Discussion Locked

Unobtrusive employee monitoring

0 helpful
218 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

218 replies

by vltiii

My experience with meetings are very similar to yours. They are unproductive and negative. Even when the foundation of a meeting is productive, they tend to erode into something unproductive. It's really quite horrible.

by vltiii

Salaries are priviledged information that only the employee, HR, and the employees manager are privey to. I would be careful with posting this information, but then since it is priviledged, where would he get the info anyway. If these guys are consultants, I would guess they're under contract and the customer certainly woudn't have access to their salary info.

by kshaurette

If employees are using company equipment legal precedent supports that this is not spying nor invasion of privacy, however I would be sure you have a policy that outlines monitoring is approved and that employees have not come because of other corporeate culture, statements by executive, hr etc.. to expect privacy in their use of company equipment.

I also don't believe you can get much accurate information without something installed at the workstation level unless you are only looking for some very specific statistics such as use of the Web, the something like a Websense or other similar tool with that kind of reporting capability will work.

If you truly need to monitor to compliance there are very very few robust and adequate solutions to do that.

There is a product that is the best solution that I've seen in my 20 years in secuirty that meets this on a commercial basis without all the mystery and sneeking around. Doing monitoring should be done up front and not in some black magic/hidene way.

The ELEVATOR SPEECH that I would make is as follows:

Proof of control over your network sometimes means an organization must track employee?s personal computer usage. An unpleasant, undesirable and time consuming task with potentially negative repercussions for the company.. The proper solution can automate the process, helps protect employee?s privacy and their dignity while protecting the company assets. It can help meet compliance requirements for monitoring and auditing activity against Corporate data without the heavy administrative burden or any application modifications.

Contact me for more information on the solution if you are interested in knowing more: kmshaurette@buympc.com

by kshaurette

If employees are using company equipment legal precedent supports that this is not spying nor invasion of privacy, however I would be sure you have a policy that outlines monitoring is approved and that employees have not come because of other corporeate culture, statements by executive, hr etc.. to expect privacy in their use of company equipment.

I also don't believe you can get much accurate information without something installed at the workstation level unless you are only looking for some very specific statistics such as use of the Web, the something like a Websense or other similar tool with that kind of reporting capability will work.

If you truly need to monitor to compliance there are very very few robust and adequate solutions to do that.

There is a product that is the best solution that I've seen in my 20 years in secuirty that meets this on a commercial basis without all the mystery and sneeking around. Doing monitoring should be done up front and not in some black magic/hidene way.

The ELEVATOR SPEECH that I would make is as follows:

Proof of control over your network sometimes means an organization must track employee?s personal computer usage. An unpleasant, undesirable and time consuming task with potentially negative repercussions for the company.. The proper solution can automate the process, helps protect employee?s privacy and their dignity while protecting the company assets. It can help meet compliance requirements for monitoring and auditing activity against Corporate data without the heavy administrative burden or any application modifications.

Contact me for more information on the solution if you are interested in knowing more: kmshaurette@buympc.com

by technicalmumbojumbo

A simple vb script can report on logon and logoff success audits. This will tell you when people are coming and going anyway. If they're surfing the web the whole day, while they're there, that's another story.

I say trust no-one

by vltiii

Im my place of employment it is written into our user agreement that everyone must sign-that is it ok to do personal business using company resources as long as it doesn't impact network performance (This is a very broad statement), is not illegal, work performance is not impacted, and the user is not running their own business using the companies resources. There is monitoring here and everything gets logged. Anyone that runs afoul of the policy does so at their own peril. I consider this to be a very liberal policy so a user would have to be extremely foolish to go outside of the boundaries.

by vltiii

And it must makes sense to have a general policy that applies to all users as well as have them sign a user agreement acknowledging that they are aware of the monitoring policy. I think this covers the company from a legal perspective and at the same time gives them carte blanche when they do need to follow up on suspicous activity when needed.

by vltiii

You couldn't be more wrong. Privacy is not guaranteed absolutely! You are only guaranteed privacy in situations where a reasonable person would expect privacy. Your place of work is not one of those places. In your place of employment you have no right to privacy (with exceptions such as using the restroom) since your employer owns and operates the premises and all of the tools you use to do your job. Your employer has a right to ensure their property is not being misused, especially when it can become a legal liability to the company. This has been upheld by the courts time and time again, and the Sarbanes Oxley Act requires monitoring. It amazes me everytime I hear of someone trying to sue their employer because they got caught doing something they weren't supposed to be doing and claiming their privacy was violated.

by vltiii

Working in the legal arena in no way makes you an expert. What exactly does that mean anyway? A janitor at a law firm can claim to work in the legal arena. I still contend that you are wrong about privacy expectations!

by emersonmf

visionGATEWAY with its INTERScepter solution provides a different approach that is more than monitoring, but provides full detail of all usage of all 65,000 plus ports by bandwidth, by port, by date, by time, by location, by ...., etc. Depends on the parameters you create. This can be looked at in summary form or drill down to lower level as and when required. If you wish to provide to end users the intranet application includes a "My account" information page that facilitates a "self-management" approach. This does not have to be used though.
For more information contact emersonmf@visiongateway.net

by archie_cunanan

Currently, I'm using SARG which generates an HTML report of SQUID server use. You may try it if you are using Linux as internet gateway. I don't know if there's a equivalent software under windows.

You may also try WEBANALYZER also under Linux.

I hope this could help you in anyway.

by earl.voorhis

Check out Packeteer.com

They have a solution that will give you a high level view. Their application will count the number of hits per classs of traffic.

You can also get connectivity data on single IP addresses if you need that level of information.

by baal

Looks like everyone has an opinion on this and I'm not going to read them all, but DC was pretty spot on with his reply except you all missed the main point. 'Your' boss wants to monitor 'Your' department - that means he doesn't believe he is getting value for money from your department. You must stand by your department (and prove you are the right person for the job). IT has always been a thorn in the companies budget and non IT people will always question the value they are getting (You will notice your boss brings his home computer to you to repair - because it is too expensive to go to a pc shop. But how much did that little repair actually cost the company!). Your department has a workload and you can calculate how many man hours each task should take. You can therefore make a pretty good guess at who is underperforming and this can be handled (hopefully you know how to increase a persons performance by now). But what happens when outside influences cause your stats to drop. You are the one that has to keep your users and boss informed of how things are going and it is this ability that demonstrates the value of you in your role. If you keep all informed and you deliver the goods within budget and explain any fluctuations your boss will realize you do know your job and you are in control - So forget about 'unobtrusive monitoring'.

by papawhiskey

Okay DC Guy, here's a no-brainer. If an employee is a hacker (or more appropriately, a cracker), it doesn't take much time to do some damage in the technology age. If sensitive information exists somewhere on the network, no matter how secure, it is still vulnerable. Sure, we have intrusion detection tools, but there is no such thing as a secure network. To make a network more secure, costs more money, and some company's don't want to, or can't invest in that sort of infrastructure. Productivity rather than security appears to be the compelling reason to monitor in this particular case, but security is always a concern in any company, when you have personal information stored somewhere. Consequently, your no-brainer management style is not perfect, and should be used in conjunction with monitoring tools.

Remember what President Reagen told Soviet Premier Mikhail Gorbachev in 1987?

doveryay, no proveryay......trust but verify

by shawn_w

on the part of management. I know all of my employees are working because I know exactly how long the tasks I assign should take. I measure productivity by their output. I don't need to check their email or web usage. A manager who needs those tools is probably not qualified to judge who is and isn't productive.

by luckyleatherneck

Your concern, and directive from higher-up, is valid. Your vision of using a covert tool is sound. While employed as a first level manager of programmers and systems analysts, I used many techniques to make sure they were not only on track with their assigned tasks but working on the right tasks. Many of those techniques were not secret but they weren't visible either. A very important part of delegating work to others is to check up on them with Hows-it-going check points.

While a consultant for a couple decades, I was very aware that misreporing billable time was (and is now) a crime, whether overbilling or underbilling.

Logon-logoff records can help but someone can always do that for others even though they're not supposed to know each others passwords. Some applications have intrinsic recording of employee time on the job like help desk applications that show date-time-stamps on notes, contact initiation, time-sent for technicians, and time-resolved. Well integrated project management tools can provide a level of proving hours worked without getting into in-punch and out-punch scenarios. If you don't have the project management tools to correlate project hours to billable hours maybe your boss will see the need and you can more easily manage the work and the people. Of course, if you assign 12 hours to modify a program module and the person logs 18 hours of actual time to finish it you can always ask why. That's also a function of management. But at least you have some basis for justifying those hours to upper management.

Lucky

by mon_selis

I understand your sentiments, but it's just a matter of who you hire in these positions. But monitoring employees should also be applied by the employers themselves. The system is there for a reason, to monitor employees internet use and it's useless if no one is there to fully monitor it's effectiveness.

This discussion is closed to new replies.