Unobtrusive employee monitoring
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Security
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by doc squidly
It sounds like you have issues with the "IT Person" at your work. If this is the case you should speak to your manager. I know I get fustrated when I see other employees not doing their jobs.
And... Some companies do exist because of IT. Such as companies that create software or provide IT services to other companies.
by dphopkins
The question was not "How do I manage the people in my office?" The question was what tools were available to see how much time employees were spending on computer resources.
Citing outside problems such as commuting time (move closer to work), day care, and scheduling as a work problem is outrageous. No one is hired with the expectation that they will get their work done as long as their spouse doesn't have anything going on that week.
Health impacts? Divorce is not a problem at/for work, that was a personal decision that was made. Raising children with little parental contact: that is a HUGE problem these days but that is a problem of the parent and decisions he/she makes rather than a supervisor (boss makes you stay late every night - switch jobs and get one closer to home!). Bad diet: learn to cook quick, healthy meals. Don't have time? This goes back to MOVE CLOSER TO WORK or switch jobs - while inconvenient at first it is a completely viable option. Won't make as much money? Well - as you have just proven: money isn't everything. Happiness should come first.
You shouldn't criticize his question based upon your beliefs of what he is looking for and all the underlying meaning you are reading into it. You should concentrate on Manage by Helping Others: get your hands dirty and offer some assistance to person, don't try to point out your perceived inequities in him/her just to give yourself a feeling of better self-worth.
by tomaaa19
You should be able to monitor log on and log off times via the servers. Do a general monitoring of total web, email and other activity and publish the gross numbers for all to see, for instance xx hours on ebay, yy hours on email zz hours on XXX sites
This should be preceded by notification of what you are doing. Most people will be careful automatically upon being notified of this tracking
the truly egregious abusers may staighten up those that don't can be isolated and dealt with
by unhappyuser
by johanv
From your response & further comments it would appear to me that you are somebody who sees a barrier between management levels (of which there are incidently three levels in the classical tier business structure) and you are obviously not in a management position and therefore feel threatned by management practises which are being used more and more across the globe. I am truly sorry that you see management in this way and can only summise that you have been a victim of bad management and now view all managerial positions with mistrust.
As for cost of monitoring software, any project these days should show a ROI (Return on Investment), and monitoring software certainly pays for itself in less than a year depending on the size of the roll-out.
While you paint a colorful image using the chainsaw analogy, please note that unless you have been in a mid/senior management position, you lack the experience & knowledge to critise managers for implementing business practices that you don't like. I can't help but wonder what you would do if one of your co-workers (who spend 2 hours a day on the Internet not working) gets a payrise because management believes he/she is a hard worker and you get no payrise. You will obviously blame management again for not "knowing" what happens in the business, but when measures such as monitoring (which can actively help management see trends) are discussed you also object to those.
In my opinion (note I said my opinion), I would never employ somebody who rebels against every decision a manager makes. Rebels are what poison the workforce and contributes more to low morale than properly implemented monitoring could ever do.
by breadtrk
by unhappyuser
by johanv
by johanv
by johanv
by mtg42
I like the idea of showing up at 11:00, and working til 2:00 & I could avoid the internet for most of that time. But I would require an hour for lunch!
:-)
by davecut
Linux make a product called flow tools (netflow) it can be configured to take net flows from cisco devices and you can then monitor ports and ip addresses
it will require work to learn it and get it configured it is not an appliance. but it will make a nice security tool
by timbstoke
"There is seldom a good technological solution to a behavioural problem"
I have no idea where I first heard that, but it's very true in this kind of situation. Your problem seems to be that the environment of your company/department is such that people feel able to slack of (assuming of course, that this is what happens). I've been there - my last job was exactly that kind of environment. There was monitoring in place, but it didn't make a bit of difference, because the work wasn't there for people to do anyway, so they just found other things to amuse them.
My current job is entirely different. There is no monitoring, but a much higher workload. Every person in my department is required to send a handover to the rest of the department at the end of each shift, detailing what they've done throughout the day, the progress of all tasks, and any work remaining to be completed on each task. This serves two purposes - those who don't pull their weight can be picked up very easily, and because we're a 24/7 shop, colleagues can pick up on unfinished tasks knowing exactly what position they're in. If there isn't a lot of work to do, we've been told the management has no issues whatsoever with us using the internet or doing personal projects. However, the working environment is such that this doesn't happen. People have enough work to do, and they get on with it.
My point is, what you want would be pointless. If your employees are meeting their targets and still have time to relax, find more work or let it slide.
Besides which, how do you propose to differentiate between 5 hours researching a problem, 5 hours personal browsing, and 5 hours leaving an auto-refresh window in the background while doing other work, if all you're doing is very high level monitoring?
by bkinsey1
You're right that it's not IT's place to motivate, build trust, create a challenging, productive environment, etc. That's on management. But management needs to know if a problem exists, and gathering the data to determine that may very well be IT's job.
Also right about the difficulty of determining that with only high-level monitoring, though. . . .
by firstpeter
"If your employees are meeting their targets and still have time to relax, find more work or let it slide."
Well said - but there's a problem with the sentence right before it ("My point is, what you want would be pointless.").
You can't effectively manage what you can't effectively measure. Right now the poster has a problem - management is perceiving (as you pointed out it's just an assumption at this point) that something is wrong. For them to effectively manage it they need to know if there is a problem at all.
If they don't find a way to measure it then they make an assumption, and I think it's safe to say they would opt to "find more work". If the folks really aren't sandbagging and are working their tails off this "find more work" won't be well received - a lose-lose for the employee-company.
Alternatively If the decision is made to "let it slide" and in fact they are slacking off then it's a win-lose for the employee-company (I called it a "win" for the employee since there really isn't much downside to that. Those that want to take on more and learn will do so of their own accord).
Perhaps they get lucky and implement the right solution for the problem...that they only guessed actually existed. Management that way still ends up as a loss for the company (guessing is a really bad way to run a business).
Either way the company comes out on the losing end if they don't have some measurement that gives them guidance on whether or not a real problem exists. What the poster wants is NOT pointless - it's a tool to measure time spent.
To your point about the difference it may be difficult to split out research from other stuff, but it might not be. I don't believe the poster indicated what the job responsibilities entailed which would ultimately decide whether it made any sense to use the data gleaned. If it doesn't then you're right on because you're back to the "you can't effectively manage what you can't EFFECTIVELY measure", and "effectively measure" includes measuring the right thing accurately.
by willmage
We implemented a proxy server (Microsoft ISA) in our shop a couple of months back and cut our internet usage by over half. Before setting up the proxy server though, we issued a memo to all staff members reminding them that internet and e-mail usage is subject to monitoring. After setting up the proxy server and printing a few days worth of reports, the 2 or 3 worse abusers were brought in and shown the logs of their internet usage and asked to explain that usage. A simple 'slap on the wrist' was then given to each, along with a another reminder of acceptable usage. It took no time at all for this to get around to everyone in the company and now we don't even look at the logs except in cases were someone's productivity seems to drop.
The most important thing to remember though, is that you have to be proactive. Make sure you have a company policy about acceptable usage and that ALL network users are monitored. Even my (the network administrator/systems administrator) usage and all of management's usage is logged and that log is available to management/HR for viewing. Make sure everyone is aware that this monitoring can occur BEFORE you start monitoring. This will avoid the riots that you stated would occur and keep the resentment to a minimum. As others have said, if you present this as a company policy BEFORE you do it, you are no longer spying on any employee/contractor but are maintaining a healthy company network/system.
by komputec
Well Said.
David
by tpernas
by crake
Work ethics and management styles notwithstanding, you have several options to accomplish your goal of monitoring Internet/user traffic.
There are appliances from Cymphonix (http://www.cymphonix.com/) that you can scale to meet your needs.
In fact, most options will require you to scale back the detail you require.
There is also software from SurfControl (http://www.surfcontrol.com/). We use this software at my workplace. It is highly effective and easy to manage, although it does need to reside on a server for best performance.
There is also Astaro's Content Filter (http://www.astaro.com/firewall_network_security/surf_protection_content_filter).
I built and tested this Linux firewall at home (trial version) and I must say I am impressed with it... but that's just my opinion.
You could even build a *nix firewall on a PC, drop a monitor/filter in it (Nagios, Squidguard, Dan's Guardian, Webalizer) and add bridge it to your primary gateway. If bridging is not an option, you can drop it in as a border management device.
Those are just a few options. There are over a hundred different ways to get this done.
Just my two cents about the ethics and management style - yes, from a company perspective, time spent not producing is time wasted. Unfortunately, tools like these have become necessary because, as a manager, you need to have some sort of documentation to prove your point should a disgruntled ex-employee decide they were unfairly "let go" or discriminated against.
I've been through it, and having documentation in my hands to prove my point basically saved my ass.
We have implement Websence for policy assurance not for monitoring people in cunjuction with a cache engine and works really good even at branch locations.
Obviously only HR and IS manager can see the logs.
by andeanderson
Especially when you are talking about technologically savvy people.
Unless the company has a policy stating that computer usage will be monitored and that all "employees" must be "on-site" and productive for a minimum of 40 hours per week, then you are treading some very dangerous territory.
Also, are these people actual company "employees" or "consultants"? There is a world of difference in how you can treat the two different categories. If they are "consultants" and the company starts to place such requirements on them, then they are no longer "consultants" and are then considered to be "employees". Then your company is required to provide them with all of the benefits and protections required by law for compensation, such as overtime and medical benefits.
If they are actually "consultants" your company can request they provide them with a record of the time they have spent on their specific projects and their progress at a time interval you specify. You will also need some sort of written agreement or contract spelling out what their required actions are to be and what is considered as acceptable by your company.
At any rate; to just start recording computer usage without notification of such a policy opens the door for personal, against you because you are the one doing it, and coporate liability lawsuits.
Been there and done that both as a "consultant" and "employee".
BE VEERRRYYY CAREFUL!
by sjohnson175
but agree with DC Guy.
IT workers in particular are for the most part craftsmen who love their work and such micromangement will only kill morale and stifle creativity.
So the truth is, you can't really answer the original question. With all your experience, you cannot suggest any software that might be helpful.
Amazing!
-->S.
by sjohnson175
Come up with some other method to value IT product produced.
I don't have an answer, just throwing out food for thought.
by melar
by capt.brad
by ramills1
Who provides and pays for the internet connection the employees use for work? The employees or the company? Do you have an acceptable use policy?
If not, you need one.
If you've got employees that would "riot" if they thought someone was actaully checking for unacceptable web usage, I think you've got a bigger problem than you think.
If it's your company, you can put any kind of monitoring tools you want on it. If they don't like it, they can choose to be employed elsewhere.
This guy is just like I desribed. He is a tech in IT arrogant and believes he has a right to spy on employees. This is the kind of guy that should not be working in IT, or any other service job. Employees INCLUDING IT employees use company resources to benefit the company, not the egotistical needs of an IT tech. Any acceptable use of company resources must include not spying on others. Shouldnt that be common sense? not in this techies world.
Any monitoring MUST be connected to an event or a need, and MUST be made known to those being monitored. In other words, a posted sign - Warning Speed Enformced By Radar...
by capt.brad
by chaos-x
You are wrong. I am in a management position and have both the practical and educational experience to know that monitoring is not going to solve productivity problems or help worker morale. I expect more from people in IT than to just jump on a band wagon. You miss the obvious, if you feel the need to use monitoring how is it going to help? You already have a problem with employee morale and this is just going to make it worse.
Futuremore, you don't make an argument by attacking the person stating it, that does nothing to prove your point. To that end I won't spend time defending myself, don't work for, don't want to and have no plans to. And why call someone who questions things a rebel? By questioning things you find new and potential better ways of doing things or realize that the best practices are in place. Just as you seem to think that you need to be "in business" to understand the market place. Got news, every person who goes to work, either for themselves or for someone else is in business. You are seeking, or should be seeking, the best compensation that fits your needs.
by hebbeson
It sounds like the original poster in this subject was looking for some kind of monitoring tool to generally gauge online time versus productivity time. Since the machines the employees are using are probably considered company property, technically, anything they do can be scrutinized by management at will.
There are many login scripts that one can get that will allow automatic time synching and logging from the workstation to the server and track by user profile.
If the employee has a problem with being monitored, then that employer might want to re-examine their 'Acceptable Use Policy' portion of the manual and make sure the employees sign it and knows what they are signing. Management has the authority to check any computer at any time, since they are the owners of the property anyway.
It is not a 'big brother' type thing at all, and frankly, those that have a problem with it are possibly suggesting that they have something to hide....
If there is cause to examine a user's work habits, this should certainly be a tool for doing so.
by steve_it
by jonf
We use surfcontrol http://www.surfcontrol.com and it works very well at monitoring and blocking certain types of sites. There are appliance options and server based options.
I don't agree with the first post by DC Guy. With the increase in internet use and the increase in liability caused by the internet, it is imperative to monitor usage and be able to react and control it when necessary.
by ungle
...and while not liking the name (should be big brother :-D ) can agree with jasmith. I found it to be very effective.
Ignore the people berating you. The bandwidth AND the time is owned by the employer, and, just like employers will tell you email is owned by the company, so is internet usage.
Trust aside, some employees simply need monitoring.
by mhollick
Might i suggest running a tool such as ntop. being free,
mature and easy for manager types to 'understand' ntop
is a quick way to start monitoring internet useage. it will
certainly give you a clearer idea of what you really
need from a network monitoring tool. as it has a web
front end you can give selected (or even all) users read
only access to selected reports. doing so helps takes
the big brother aspect away. personaly i would rather
not give users open access to the internet. proxy
servers provide additional layers of security,
management and monitoring. using caching can (will)
cut down internet bandwidth useage. smoothwall
corporate guardian is a rather nice proxy that can also
tie into your active directory.
matthew.
by ben.hunter
I would give a strong vote for NTOP. I've used it used it regularly to monitor our traffic. I just mirror our outgoing port and let it watch. It?s free reliable non-intrusive.
I don?t consider it spying, most of the problems I have found the user was completely unaware of. It?s called network management. I?m not going to let one user or a small group bog down the network for everyone else, especially when they are completely unaware that they are doing it.
by mswanberg
Hasn't it been well-established that an organization that owns the equipment (i.e. the PCs) has the right to monitor how they are used? And if they tell the employees that they are being monitored (which I understand a lot of companies SAY they are monitoring but then don't actually do it... scare tactics) then the employees have 2 choices: deal with it or go work elsewhere.
As for the control of the home issues, I agree with the earlier post about how it would be better to lose a few minutes productivity ordering stuff online than it would be to have to miss work to take care of things.
I worked for a company that was firmly of the mindset that it didn't matter what you do, it only matters how you look doing it. I think it's obvious why I chose to leave.
There is nothing like the feeling of freedom a self-motivated person like myself gets from being task-oriented. Somedays I don't feel as productive, and it's nice to know that my boss isn't going to crucify me because my 8 hours today wasn't as productive as my 8 hours yesterday. It's nice to know that I can make up for the lost productivity on another day when I'm feeling better.
On the other hand, an organization cannot be 100% task-oriented. Imagine if I got paid for each project I completed. Heck, I would skip every meeting because they would just get in the way of me finishing the next project. Meetings are important (most of the time) but get in the way of measurable progress.
Just my $0.02
by oside-mike
Seems to me that the people that cry the loudest are generally the ones that have the most to lose.
Not only is monitoring prudent but in some cases really required. Baseline traffic monitoring to establish trends and patterns is a good start so when I start getting complaints about Internet speed being slow I can look to see the 30 plus GB FTP traffic from one machine downloading porn now. It didn't effect his performance but it sure hit the rest of us. Or a little finer detail may be required such as to catch an employee running an outside business from inside our network.
Both have occurred in our office. We have a very open attitude and policy towards internet usage but always within the framework that company computers and networks are not private and all data on the network is company property (from a liability stand point any court in the US would go with that position).
So get off the high horses and answer the question!
I'd start at firewall logs for a good overview of where and when your traffic is. Emails are another story, if it's on an internal server firewall logs won't show who but Exchange SMTP logs will get a little closer. Your spam & virus firewall may let you define a little more granular logging of outbound mail without logging actual emails.
Hope this is more helpful than some of the other blather spewed here.
by sjohnson175
is getting the employees to "buy in" to the concept everyone is on the same team. What's good for the company is good for them and vice versa.
So long as manager and employee is an adversarial relationship overall productivity will suffer.
Why did the Japanese beat the US in manufacturing so badly in the 80's? Because the employees believed in the company as if their personal investment capital were on the line.
Apologies to the original poster for continuing this thread hijack.
by sheeva
Your submission is exactly how I handle any staff who are on an "off-site" basis. Traditional 40 hour weeks are not nor have ever been the staple of an IT pro's life. We've always put in 50 to 60 plus hours and if we're lucky, work for organizations that recognize this as over time or banked time or lieu time, etc.
As a manager, you should know how long an objective will take, you negotiate it with your "off-site" staffer and then you review and measure the quality/substance of the stated objective's outcome. Many off-site staff will work evenings or weekends or what have you and not the traditional daily 9 to 5.
So for my staff we've found a better way to "negotiate" their production rather than watch the clock. This process takes more management but is far more rewarding that giving them a pink slip for being 15 minutes late 3 mornings in a row.
by bkinsey1
Employees have the right to a reasonable expectation of privacy when it comes to using company resources. (i.e. no reading of someone's personal e-mail) Not a complete right of privacy, notification or not. (As in privacy to visit child porn sites, participate in terrorist chats, whatever.)
What the original poster actually said, though, was that he wanted to monitor time spent, not content (which I assume means not specific sites visited, either). Being able to tell the employee A was on the web for 4 hours is not even monitoring in the same sense.
Having said that, it is still pretty much mandatory to have a written policy regarding not only acceptable use, but procedures used to verify that use, triggers for more specific monitoring,actions taken in the event of breach, etc.
by kraken_
Hi!
The fact is, monitoring "time spent on the net" is irrelevant in many jobs today; an accountant might spend a lot of time doing research on federal/state/provincial websites. A consultant spends most of it's time searching for answers in tech sites (either Microsoft, IBM, Oracle, HP to name a few) or on tech forums. A translator might need to use a terminologic dictionnary (www.granddictionnaire.com) as a work tool.
To be of any use, you have to do content monitoring/content filtering, which leads to the uncertain and often misunderstood grounds of the legal terms regarding privacy.
by ickesk
"But who will guard the guardians themselves?"
Juvenal
So - who watchers the watchers? It's a concept as old as the hills and as controversial as we'd like it to be. As we increase our ability to watch and monitor, we are faced with options and burdens that new technologies bring. Of course, it also means all manner of ethical disruptions and challenges we may not be prepared to face or cope with. Like it or not, though, there will be times when monitoring is wanted/needed. For instance, there may be a legal issue brewing or harrassment occuring in which case a company may have to defend itself and need to do so via monitoring. Who among us would want to know that a failure to monitor resulted in a stalking tragedy or situation that went unwatched, or ignored because of a resistance to monitoring? The question is: The tools are available - do we use them? More importantly though, in this forum, the questioner has taken it further and is not looking for a sanctioning of the activity, but rather suggestions on how to do it. There are many good tools that can do the job. Hardware and software for monitoring, spending time reviewing logs and providing data and exist and can be used. My preference is not to advise on one tool versus another since many of you have already. What I would advise, however, is that if your company reserves the right to monitor, that you do it with checks and balances so that there is some ownership of not just the technology and the tools, but also of the actions. Policies that allows a company to reserve the right to monitor are a good place to start. Giving employees the ability to know and understand that monitoring might need to happen are informed. Then, when the decision is made to monitor, it should be done with two approvals and not one - so for instance, HR and a Department head might approve IT employing a monitoring tool. That takes the ethical and legal issues and places decision making on management and HR. That way, if there is a real reason to oppose the decision, higher level people can raise the challenges and set the guidelins and everyone involved can take ownership for the legal and moral liability.
by marvngardn
by firstpeter
I think you're right on with your post (for the most part, anyway). The organization that owns the equipment has a right to determine its use, and if the employees don't like it...tough. It's the company's asset, not yours.
My point with the "riot" comment was more along the lines of being micro-managed at that level. I think there are other potential ways to handle it, but there's nothing wrong with monitoring the employees. The riot wouldn't necessarily be a justified riot, but given the environment that the poster outlined I can see why it would happen.
In terms of the control of the home issues I can't disagree there, either. And as an employer I would rather give folks the leeway to handle issues here at work when they have a chance instead of not being here at all. However that would presumably be included in what the poster was after. Since they were looking for a guide as to how much times was spent on what I got the impression it was to gauge if that time spent on work activities was "realistic", not "100%".
And tell me where you work - my corporate experience has not lent itself well to the impression that "meetings are important" - I can safely say that the majority of the meetings I ended up attending in a corporate environment were absolute wastes of my time and could have been handled (from my perspective, anyway) with an e-mail explaining the situation instead.
by rbarnhardt
by mustang221
by firstpeter
And keep in mind the poster wasn't necessarily looking for something to completely cut out all "personal use" of the COMPANY ASSET, but rather to see if it was being used excessively for non-business stuff.
The company certainly has the RIGHT to require 100% use of the asset for company business, but that's not always the best management approach.
by jmschattke9
Did the programming for this task for UAL in '99. It also did a keyword search fr naughty words on URLs & blocked site requests, for internal investigations of harrassment. Web front end, tied into LDAP to see who managed whom. Raw data was from the procy server logs.
All told, only took a couple weeks, so ROI was really sweet if it saved even one lawsuit.
by jmschattke9
Um, hello!!!???
What side of the world are you living in, because it sure as heck isn't reality.
A single lawsuit for sexual harrassment can break a small company, or seriously mess the bottom line of a mid-sized. Tracking internet usage is the only way a company can say "not our responnsibility" and make it stick.
As for the raw volume, its not about the internet usage, its about having the figures to back you up for a little chat with the employee who has suddenly had his productivity tank.
by catadmin
Implement biometric security on your network.
There are a couple of pros for this approach. 1) the user has to be presnt to log in and you can audit both log in and log outs. 2) increases general network security so it is harder for outside hackers to get inside.
The con is, you really can't track *what* they are doing with their time. Just that they came in, logged into the network and then logged out at the end of the day. Plus *MAJOR* upfront expense.
But it's a start.
by aa8vs
I spent some time as a consultant and here are some criteria we used:
Estimated time to do a job tracked by project ID
Logging actual hours charged to job by employe to project ID
Was work being done in a timely manner?
Were there milestones and were they being met?
The person managing having some idea [high level] of work being done.
In the VAX environment you could randomly see what processes were being ran (circa 70s)
Did the processes being ran make sense with the work to be done.
If there were unusual circumstances take employee aside and find out if he is having a problem with finding references, resources, etc.
I guess in a way it could be contrived as spying but your trying to get work done [don't assume the worst] and the manager should assist and remove road blocks.
IMHO
Chuck
by go43
by dfarrich9
by amused...
1. What prompted your boss to feel this monitoring was needed?
2. We all have to work and sometimes that means we work for jerks. That is how we know when we find a decent employer or give up and employ ourselves.
3. Hire an outside firm to perform a Client Satisfaction Survey on your clients. Easier to implement and far more telling.
a. Let the clients (internal or external) know the Survey is completely confidential. I.E. The outside firm will know how they are but will only forward comments and suggestions to you along with the Consultant concerned or, if they cannot remember, then the client info and dates of service.
b. Ask how long the Consultant works with them and are they satisfied with the work performed.
c. Will they continue, refer and or look forward to your future business.
d. Are we meeting your goals?
e. What would you change?
f. When have you been dissatisfied and what was the cause and resolution?
These are just a few suggestions. No 'Riots' needed. You and even the Surveyor may have great additional questions specific to your market segment.
The point is, this doesn't spy. It tells you very quickly what the clients think of each consultant and allows you to correct the issue before it spirals.
This can be presented as a positive to the customers and the staff for the firm. Calling a client site to see if a Consultant was there when they said they were would only raise serious questions to a client and damage the Consultants credibility. Hard to recover from that for all involved.
Treat you people like adults, set expectations and follow through. Don't be mean, remember, unless you are a church or health care provider "it ain't personal if you have to whack a disruptive employee, its business" Do it cleanly and with respect and don't spy, that is a dirty business and you find out things you aren't prepared to know.
My final comment: If everything is going well and the firm is happy and the clients are happy, commit the boss and force him to take a MMPI exam, he may be a sociopath.
by jpaullanier
by amused...
by proud member of vast right wing majority
MBatty has it right - a combination of time sheets (if they are really needed), and a measure of Project Deliverables. In our profession, either you are on-track, and delivering what you were assigned to do, or you are not.
If the project is being completed, on time and within the specified budget, other factors would seem not to be an issue.
by bjordan
by mmelvis
When I say resources available I am speaking of, budget, hardware, staff to implement the solution.
What operating system is being used on the workstations and servers? What information is management looking for? Much of the information you are seeking can be gathered from built in tools of the operating system.
On windows platforms you can gather information from history files in Internet explorer, you can setup the system the person can not clear the history from the computers you can also gather information from the cache files used in Internet Explorer. Using folder redirection place the files in shared location on a server. Using this method you can gather data from time stamps on files and get a general idea of how much time is spent on the Internet. You can also use login and logout information to see when people log in and logout of the system or domain.
On Unix systems you can use the accounting system built in to most systems. There are also log files that can be check to see when people log in and log out the system
Monitoring can be done without being big brother. Have the users in question submit weekly reports giving high level status of what they are working on and the progress that has been made. Speak with the users to get a feel for how they are progressing. This discussion only needs to be a couple of minutes if even that, Drop by the users work area and asking how things are going.
These are just a few options, hope some of this information helps/
by proud member of vast right wing majority
A combination of time sheets (if they are really needed), and a measure of Project Deliverables. In our profession, either you are on-track, and delivering what you were assigned to do, or you are not.
If the project is being completed, on time and within the specified budget, other factors would seem not to be an issue
by proud member of vast right wing majority
A combination of time sheets (if they are really needed), and a measure of Project Deliverables will really give you a measure of productivity.
In our profession, either you are on-track, and delivering what you were assigned to do, or you are not.
If the project is being completed on-time and within the specified budget, other factors would seem not to be an issue
by steve_it
If they really are consultants and not employees, you may be on very thin ice. Your manager should check with a business attorney in your city/county to determine the difference between employees and consultants. If he accidentally converts consultants to employees, that would be very costly. At a minimum, your company would have to pay payroll taxes, worker's comp and unemployment insurance.
Craig Herberg
by stan20
"If the employees found it (technology company) there would be a riot." That tells you all you need to know.
Why do you feel the need to monitor employees? If they aren't doing the job, fire the ones that aren't. If they are, why do you need to monitor them?
If you just want to know when they come in and when they leave, have them sign in and out.
by ak1967p
Cyberoam provides comprehensive web and email security with content filtering and firewall as well as anti-virus and anti-spam integration. It is the complete Internet Management Solution that lets enterprises solve their Internet-related problems.
It also manages bandwidth, ensures multiple link load balancing and gateway failover, mail and printer management in addition to providing extensive graphical reports.
visit www.cyberoam.com
and download the evaluation copy from http://www.cyberoam.com/cyberoam/jsp/trialversion/TrialVersion.jsp
by meneer r
by mfisher
Download a trial version of SurfControl, the software installs server side. You can then enforce the AUP (Acceptable User policy) should you have one. The software will give you the ability to monitor what sites the user, users are accessing, reports can be detailed or summarised.
Rules can be created to enforce the user policy, should the user attempt to visit blocked sites within a certain catergory then the user will be presented with a SurfControl HTTP deny page, should you not want to make use of the HTTP deny page then you can put a redirector withn the default http deny page that will take the user to a customised hhtp page that has been designed by you reminding the user of the company policies.
The software is also useful when running a cost analsys for bandwith usage.
Mark.
by m_sauga100
The original quesion was a technical question. It deserves a technical answer. Who is anyone here to judge the reason or merit of the gentlemans's reason. I personally have monitored employee's surfing habits - and have used the internet logs as one of the reasons why I dismissed them.
In one case I had a salaried employee surf the net the ENTIRE DAY. There is a word for this I call it THEFT! I dont want to employee thieves and the employee was fired.
I am gratefull that my infratstucture had a logging feature.
I simply used the outbound log in my linksys router and parsed it using an access database. I regularly warn employees that misuse the internet.
by shorne
by bfilmfan
Not to mention that the consultants might not agree to said monitoring, which means it is wiretapping, which moves right to The Martha Stewart experience...
If the client is requirning consutlants to be on site and settign work hours, he has already converted them to employees under current IRS rules. And the IRS will check this out if it is reported and start the fines on the company.
by paymeister
Level with the employees, and by so doing, empower instead of emasculate.
Tell them that the Sarbanes-Oxley Act requires improved auditing, and the company has hitherto been unable to determine if the hours paid are supported by the hours being worked (don't lie, of course... but I'll bet if you asked you would find that this really is the reason for the auditing - we're doing much of the same type of thing here). The task at hand, then, is to demonstrate to the auditors that employees are indeed earning their pay. Ask for suggestions on the best way to do that, and tell them that one of the solutions under consideration is to examine login/out times, net useage, and the like. Assure them that you're NOT interested in what the wife wants them to buy at WalMart on the way home, but that the law now requires better accountability for company money. Cast your memo it in the tone that you assume that they're big boys and girls and are indeed giving the company plenty of value, but that we have a group of bean counters that, together, we must reassure.
If you're fortunate, they'll give you an easier solution. If a good employee is "getting away with something" now, he or she will get the idea that the easy ride is over, and will probably change. The REAL offenders will keep on being jerks and you'll catch them easily enough later.
Or make them all Salaried, and if the job gets done, who cares if they're out golfing? A salaried employee promises to get the job done for X amount of money, and the time it takes is irrelevant.
Another presentation of the same point: When several families moved here, the local sheriff paid a call (we live in Mayberry, more or less). After a half-hour of pleasant conversation, he said, "I notice some folks who move here haven't gotten their state tags... you might mention to them that they only have 30 days to do that." I replied, "Why, yes, sir! In fact, I know of one fellow in particular who could use to hear that!" I got my state tags the next day. No Federal case, no newspaper photo with me hiding behind my hat, just good ol' fashioned police work. Maybe something like that would work for you.
by bjordan
by jvstog
DC guy evidently lives in Washingtom DC where there is no sense of reality.
He envisions a utopic society in which everyone does just as they should. I am sorry to inform him that most people barely perform to the level of expectation presented by their management team.
Managers achieve those expectations by consistent inspection and reinforcment of good performance no matter where the employee physically is located! You seldom get what you expect, you can only hope to get what you inspect. (see the Navy for that quote).
Don't get bogged down with that post industrial line. That is psycho babble from an isolated political hack with no real world experience in getting a job done right and on time the FIRST time.
People DO need guidelines; people DO need to be monitored and they DO need to know that there is a RIGHT and a WRONG way to provide service and work in this 'post industrial' age. They also need to know that there are consequences for WRONG behaviors.
So Flannigan, I don't know what type of monitoring software is out there, but keep looking because you do NEED the security it brings and the deterence factor it offers.
Do not be deterred by overeducated, underemployed and incoherent people like DCguy. He lives in a world all his own while you and I must live and work in the one everyone else lives in.
Large words and fancy sentence structures are no match for good employees with good managers.
by bfelts
If you need a high-level overview of internet access, consider a reasonable firewall solution. I am familliar with Watchguard, and it's logging is perfect for this. Several times I have been able to identify downloads that defy company policy regarding employees installing unauthorized software. This doesn't allow me to see specific details of e-mail as an example, but it does provide usable info on what I CHOOSE to log.
HTH
by bfelts
Wow, you have breakfast AND sex at work??! You are in the minority then. Don't confuse the workplace with your PRIVATE life. You are entitled to draw a sharp distinction between the two. Your work life is fraught with issues like having to provide a return for your compensation. And other issues like a company in the U.S. can get it's butt kicked in court for NOT having controls and policies in place regarding sexual harassment, threats of physical violence, and the like. Kind of like your "...I would kick your ass... and fire you..." comment. Your lack of professionalism is startling. Does your entire management team work on the premise of physical violence to accomplish corporate goals, or just your IT department?
Must be quite fun to work there...
by jennyn
This gives you much stronger legal auditing. The timesheet is a signed doc. If it turns out they don't spend their time on what they signed off on, they have committed a fraud. If someones productivity doesn't match their timesheet claims, THEN monitor online activity.
Not so clear cut to say "fraud" if they were found to be online.
Monitoring is a bit like making people clock in/out. When I was made to clock in I just rebeled - couldn't help myself! - like clock in and then spend first 1/2hr on a personal call (yup - internet is not the only way to waste time!). But treat me like an adult and you'll get 110%. I bet I'm not the only one with this psychology ... admit it y'all!
by vltiii
by jakcap
by ntewfik
We have SurfControl (www.surfcontrol.com), the program is installed on a server or a computer close to the internet gateway and nothing is installed at the user?s computer,
You can control who is allowed to go where or not to go where, it has a wide range of rules you can create. Also they have IM filter. You can also see live demo on the web.
Nassef
There are a whole mess of people who 'toss it off' unproductively from the toilet cleaner to the MD. The thing about general monitoring systems is as soon as you implement one, you are saying you don't trust any of your employees because either you have evidence that some can't be trusted, or management itself feels that were they in a similar position they would abuse any trust they were given.
The latter is the case far more often in my experience.
Set reasonable deadlines, monitor whether you are on schedule. elapsed hours vs available hours vs hours booked will soon tell you where you are at and identify problem areas. Investigate them and don't assume it's becuase they are on TR all day or they aren't here all day.
by rmariott
William, at the school district where I worked in the past we use Aristotle, not sure if you're familiar with it. It's a very good tool for monitoring what your users are doing on the network. I understand you didn't want details but you can get some pretty deep ones if you want to (it drills down to the keystrokes), and also the interface is very easy to use and straigh forward. It runs on a Unix box and it's very stable, however it does a little piece of software that goes on the client machine but you don't have to touch each individual host, you can install if from one host by netbios or ip address (specify a range). The client is invisible to the user, you can see it only if you look at the processes running on the client computer (through task manager). http://www.sgtlabs.com/
Rossella
by carnahan
I an the Network Administrator in one of the most conservative businesses in the country, banking. I am responsible for maintaining Websense. Upper Management has instructed me to lock down the internet entirely and only open up sites that the employees need to get their job done. This translates into about 1-8 hours each week of my time to maintain the program that I could be spending on more important things. This doesn't even take into account reviewing the logs every day. That is done by both the IT Manager and myself so there goes 2-3 hours a week for each of us.
Don't get me wrong, the program is wonderful if you use it as intended. Block sites based on the content. This will not block all sites in the catagory because you are relying on the "black list" that Websense creates/updates.
by plaintom
I'm the Director of IT at a rural hospital and I understand your position. I'm not a fan of "snooping" on employees and being a one person department doesn't really give me the time to monitor logs BUT...
Here is what we do: We use Secure Computing Sentian software (N2H2) which integrates with your firewall - we use a Cisco PIX. Read about it here:
http://www.securecomputing.com/index.cfm?skey=1316
This software tracks all activity - and allows you to block sites, etc. just like Websense and others but I like what I read about this better. I performed 30 day trials on a couple of these packages and felt this worked best in our environment.
Anyway, let me continue...We chose to monitor employees for a different reason than 'false time reporting' or 'inappropriate billing.' We chose to monitor because about 9 months ago 'someone' downloaded 'something' which caused our network to come to a stand still - even with the latest version of Corporate SAV...
We found the ?culprit? and action was taken: We talked to this person, explained the situation and requested they common sense and caution next time. The result: no more incidents (the person is still employed and the incident is history).
While nobody in Administration has any desire to limit what an employee may do or where they may go on the internet (that isn't what this is about for us), we decided it important to be able to track where a potential 'virus' or 'worm' may have come from (who's PC). For this reason we chose to put unobtrusive monitoring in place (the users do not realize they are monitored because the authentication is transparent to them - they know we monitor because we informed them, they just don't see it).
If someone complains about their PC performance or popups, etc. I clean the PC and IF what is found warrants further investigation I consult N2H2 logs on a specific user to see their online habits. If their habits warrant disciplinary actions appropriate ones are taken (based on our employee policies/handbook). Since implementing this software I?ve been investigated (1) person and no action was taken. Monitoring can work both ways ? it can ?exonerate? as well as ?condemn? an employee.
I have no desire to be big brother and neither do our Administrators but I must protect the network and Patient data ? this is most critical because Patient data cannot be compromised.
I don?t really care if employees do online shopping, bill paying or whatever (heck, we all do it) as long as work gets done and nothing is ?unleashed? on the network.
The two most regulated industries, banking and healthcare, have an obligation to their customers to insure confidentiality and I plan to do whatever is necessary to make sure this happens in my facility. To wflanagan and his ?boss?, I say: Don?t abuse the software by ?spying? on employees, use it only when necessary for backup documentation when you already know someone needs disciplinary action.
Anyway, this is just my 2 cents and you can take it or leave as you see fit.
by pav1
I have two neighbors; one just retired from one of our local
hospitals as a dietician, the other managed workers for a local
landscaping company. Here is part of the dialogues:
Hospital: The new grads don't want to work. They want to arrive,
get their check and not do anything in between.
Landscape team manager: I gave up hiring caucasions because
they don't want to work...first time it is too hot, they can't
believe that they actually have to work outside. They didn't care
about working their way up. Finally due to the time and expense
of training, I just gave up and didn't consider caucasions for the
work.
Seems to be a thread going on here. Have we lost our "hungry"
drive?
by cdstewart
by dschuster
by djameson
by rayg314
Every employee, you and the CEO included, needs to be aware that their activity can and may be monitored. They need to know what will be monitored, whether it's their Internet surfing, their logon and logoff times, their incoming and outgoing email. They also ought to be informed as to why these montioring actions are necessary, including for their own protection, to protect the corporate network, and deter DoS and other external threats.
That's just the way it is.
Simultaneously, the employees need to know that you or whoever does the monitoring will use the information gained by that monitoring only for clearly-stated specified reasons, whether that includes for time and billing or for corporate protection (no corporate espionage or slandering)
by neildsouza
Version 6.0 allows you to...
1. Log individual website visits
2. Log file downloads
3. customize what is blocked
4. detail individual download and bandwidth used on a daily basis
5. customize who can get access to what
6. Log in and log out timings to firewall
I would advise you to inform via memo that you've implemented this service. Unless you have an IT policy that enforces such activity on your part, it is a breach of privacy although a day in court will be more of a pain-in-the-neck than result to anything else.
As again, don't quote me on that, har har!
by vltiii
by vltiii
by vltiii
by vltiii
Sort by Trending