Question Locked

What is a good external harddrive? Do I need high speed USB?

0 helpful
3 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I have a Gateway Profile 3 and would like a external harddrive for backup, the computer does not have any high speed USB ports does this matter, also what about USB hubs, everything I see in the store says high speed or 2.0?

3 replies

by risques

Ove the years I have had several where I store various image files. They are nice looking 'Porsche Design' and until recently worked well (not recognised on one PC worked on all others - see one of my other posts)

How about make your own - a HD external case with any working IDE sometimes even SATA is quite cheap.

You will get a benefit of speed with USB 2 it depends on what you are transferring.

WinHEC 2008 has a a brief performance comparison sample for data transfer of 25GB HD movie:

USB 1.0: 9.3 hours
USB 2.0: 13.9 minutes
USB 3.0: 70 seconds

by captbilly1eye

In your situation (only USB 1.0), stay away from the 'portable' external hard drives - those made using notebook hard drives, since they spin at a slower rate and often require power from the USB port. You could use a USB cable with dual connectors to overcome the limitation but I would recommend against it.

Stick with the larger 'Desktop' external hard drives, for these main reasons:
1. Faster RPMs - faster read time.
typically 7,500 as apposed to 5,400
2. Larger capacity available.
3. Lower cost.
4. Increased reliability & durability.

You could add a PCI card to add USB 2.0 ports. It's called a High-Speed USB 2.0 PCI Host Controller Card, it will typically add four USB ports and cost about $25 - $35 USD.
An external hard drive with a A/C power cord will most likely work with your USB 1.0 ports but the transfer rate will be noticeably faster using 2.0.

As far as the actual drives go, I prefer and have had best success with the ones from Seagate and Western Digital.
.

This discussion is closed to new replies.