Discussion Locked

Which Linux Distro Is More Capable of Competing With Windows?

0 helpful
30 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

In a recent blog post I brought up the touchy subject of Linux on the desktop and how desktop Linux can not compete with Windows.

Several people commented on various versions of Linux that they feel already compete or beat Microsoft Windows. I would like to know which Linux distro YOU believe is the best, and more importantly WHY? I'd like details, links, etc. that show why you feel your preferred distro is in the lead.

Just for the record: I am a Linux fan, I just don't see it winning on the desktop. I am looking for business justification and solid technical documentation to back up the use of Linux on a desktop. I have several clients looking at Linux as an option and I'd like to have more than my opinion and experience to help in providing the correct solution.

30 replies

by tony hopkinson

won't just depend on distro. Application set, interoperability within the organisation, suppliers, customers etc.

If you pick a mainstream general purpose distro, especially one aimed at the appliance user market, very few will bother to argue right or wrong. SimplyMepis is my current choice, because it installed on the hardware I had with the least problems, a far from trivial consideration. But I doubt all your clients have a Compaq A60s. :p

Support, administration, software choices etc will be far more important.

Linux is an OS for people who want choice. To make one you have to find out which aspects of windows they need, which bits they like and which bit's just came with it.

They all beat the windows OS technically, but windows is more than the OS. If you are talking about swapping inplace back and front office MS products it's going to be hard. If there are 3rd party apps, in house ones from VB CRUD apps to VBA macros....

I'd be having a look at what you want the OS to do first, windows technically inferior or not, may still be the pragmatic choice because it's already in play.

The big thing to remeber is linux is not windows, there will be some things that while being fit for purpose (possibly more so), will be different, and that's a cost.

Approach with care, you could do everything right and still get it wrong.

by jdclyde

he is here to push his website, not hold valid discussions with other members.

Take this as my opt-out.

by daileyml

Sorry guys, you got it wrong. I'm not pushing anything. I'm asking a valid question. Don't follow the link, no problem. I am asking for some honest feedback, and you can post it here on the forums.

Sorry for the confusion.

-Mike D
http://www.daileymuse.com

by forum surfer

It wasn't that long ago that he took a cheap shot at you while you were posting about losing your job.

The rest of us offered condolences and he took the opportunity to tell you that you were under prepared and irresponsible, then proceeded to link us all back to his website and postings about how to prepare yourself.

He's a troll hiding in plain sight.

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-13622-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=301020&messageID=3009535

It's one thing to shamelessly link your website repeatedly at every possible point, but another thing entirely to try and take cheap shots at someone's dignity in the process.

I have no respect for the shamelessly self promoting guy. I'd still like to hold him for you while you break his nose over a beer at the local pub.

I think he should be blacklisted until he removes his links in his signature. The rest of us come don't bother promoting our own agendas so blatantly. If we want your silly little link we'll ask for it or pm you for it. Speaking of blacklists...I just thought of a new website to add to my web filter. I gotta go to work now...

by daileyml

The major focus for the clients is on deploying something as "similar" to Windows as possible. This has always been the case in my experience as the learning curve is too great if the Linux desktop environment requires complete retraining.

There is some discussion with using a Linux desktop with a virtual terminal session back to a Citrix or similar environment to run Outlook, MS Windows, etc. Not sure how far they'll get with this.

-Mike D
http://www.daileymuse.com

by tony hopkinson

as in Gnome and KDE styles within distros like Ubuntu they are windows like. ie designed for appliance users.

Lets face it you are going to get as many if not more issues re OpenOffice or FF/Thunderbird etc than you are with the exact icons on the desktop or lack of a Start button.

That said aside from macros, VBA or OLE type stuff they should be surmountable in an office environment. A bigger problem would be receiving active documents from suppliers and customers that rely on that sort of drivel as well. Can / will they change as well.
Seriously unless you go for one of the outre distros, like those targeted for OS developers or other niche environments, or decide to do something as fatheaded as use an alpha release, distro choice isn't that much of an issue, user wise.

It will be worth looking into in terms of installation/hardware compatibility.
SimplyMepis was the fourth distro I tried, my old portable not being in anyone's compatibility list.

Terminal sessions is something any nix is much better at than windows. But they introduce their own 'erm 'feature' set.

I'd get taht working on winders first as well.

by charliespencer

From a business point of view, the apps are more important than the OS that supports them. You have to identify replacements for those mission-critical applications that no one seems to have developed open source equivalents - CAD, MRP / ERP, etc.

Unless you plan on replacing everything 'cold turkey', integration with Active Directory is also a requirement. I understand SUSE does this, but I haven't seen it or other distros with AD integration personally.

by daileyml

I see the same thing, Palmetto. Some reviewing Linux as a desktop alternative are looking to utilize it only where it can replace basic office functionality (word processing, email, etc.) I don't see any of the clients attempting to use Linux as a replacement for critical business application access. Some MRP/ERP systems are currently housed on AS/400 or HP UX environments so those could be accessed via Linux since terminal clients are available for those platforms.

Obviously this is part of the evaluation process for these clients. First to determine which distros offer the most Windows-like or ease in learning, and then to determine to what extent Linux could be deployed on the desktop.

Is anyone else seeing the economy pushing these types of evaluations in the enterprise?

-Mike D
http://www.daileymuse.com

by daileyml

You are correct, and that is the heart of the problem and the reason I'm asking for the input of others.

In my experience there have been so many distros that were tauted as an alternative to Windows on the desktop and few could deliver on the promise.

I understand that one single distro is not positioned to meet all needs (that's a whole other discussion...) but which distro most closely gets us there? That is what I'm trying to determine with the help of input here.

-Mike D
http://www.daileymuse.com

by the 'g-man.'

There is not one that can replace it yet.

Coming close is no good to Joe Bloggs in the street so the answer is 'none'.

by tony hopkinson

Even if we had a case study for distro X at company Y, and youi chose to trust it.
It still doesn't mean it will work for anyone of your clients, never mind more than one.

Because there is so much choice in the linux world you aren't going to get a consensus. If anyone comes back and says XXXX is the only choice for everybody, they are a f'ing idiot, you should pay no attention to whatsoever.

One of the biggest complaints windows newbies have about linux is the multiplicity of choices. The bit they don't get, is that nix proponents like that....

SimplyMepis 7.0 meets my needs, is as much as I can say in a professional manner.

by charliespencer

A member's profile is the place to put links to his / her independent web site / web log / other external content. mdailey, fill out your member profile and put your link there. Do you end everything you say verbally with, "Visit my website at www.whatever.com?" If not, why do it in conversations here?

by daileyml

I apologize if you don't like the use of a self-promoting link, but it's a signature, guys, and nothing more.

For the record, I apologized to jd for the tone of the post in the other forum. It came across wrong and I see that now. It wasn't meant to come across the way it did.

Now can we stay on-topic, please. I'm not here for the flame wars.

by jdclyde

Any relevant information should have been provided here, not linked to on an outside source of your own making.

And insulting tone aside, that was what you did in my blog that tuned me on to your game. The promoting of your own blogs. The direct insults I blow off, but seeing how someone operates isn't forgotten.

I don't care about the link after your name, but the other links are out of place. Take the information from your blog, copy/paste it here, and if people like what you have to say, they will seek you out for more. The more intelligent members here do not follow random links posted by someone they don't know.

by forum surfer

Google his posts elsewhere. They all go the same.

Here's my opinion, blah blah blah...visit my website here: blah dot com.

If he wants to have a discussion I'm fine with that. But I won't address it with my opinion while I continue to see a link in his signature and almost all of his responses linking back to one of his blogs. Half the people here have a personal website promoting a business or a blog yet none of us have a link in our sig over and over and over and over...

by charliespencer

when I asked, "Do you end everything you say verbally ..."

Specifically, you missed the key word 'verbally'. I assumed he did the same thing everywhere else on the web. Does he speak his URL at the end of every vocalization?

He has some interesting things to say, but he's missed the 'water cooler' concept of the community here. If he thinks his web log is of enough interest to the community to warranty regular mentioned here, let him contact the PTBs and see if they'll host him. If they don't think so, then his web log is probably just another burst of electrons among the background e-noise, and his repeated linking taints his posts with the odor of canned pork product.

by ernie0

I have tried various versions of linux. I always switch BACK to windows, because even though I have had some programming, I did not feel like going through all of the required steps of /user/thisthatandtheother
to get a program to work. Furthermore, when you go looking for advice on how to get a particular app to work in Linux, you get a hundred different views with a hundred different ways to get there. DUH, HELLO !
I, like many other windows users, would love it if a linux distrubution came out that it worked as well or better than windows. And when you installed a new program, it sas simple point and click to install. I do not want to take the time to go and learn how to program in linux just to use it. And until Linux gets to the point where it can be as smooth as windows (especially XP), in using/install/removing software, then linux is NOT going to dominate the computer market.

by tony hopkinson

Your time machine worked, now if you could just bog off back to the eighties...

Look up package manager for whatever distro you choose ffs.

Those instructions are for people who want to play with / change the source. Or dead, or very very new.

Smooth as XP for removing applications. ROFLMAO. It has a go at running the vendor uninstall, and then if all else fails just wipes it off the list, leaving load of stuff half in and half out and probably a mass of of dead crap all over your file system and the registry.

by slayer_

I tried Ubuntu very recently, and while the system requirements are greatly exagerated, the system itself works really well. Installs and uninstall are almost litirtly two clicks, never even need to open a web browser or anything. All patches come automatically and apply automatically. It's really very simple. The interfaces for many of the control panel like items are finally starting to look similar. Every new screen isn't a new experience anymore.

About the only thing I hated was there was no 1 stop shop for running your programs, a start menu. Everything was in menus at the top of the screen, just like a Mac, and I always hated that about Macs. (Only recently did I learn that Macs are built from 'nix).

Otherwise, if there was really anything to complain about, it was that not only did I have to learn a new OS, but I also had to learn the methodology of it, like home folders, and I had to learn all new applications that often seemed infurior to the Windows versioned counterparts. Except for Apache webserver, every app I installed seemed less capable then a paid for Windows app. And that anouyed me.

by itadmin4

At work there is a SBS network and all the computers are Windows computers. Recently they bought me this computer on which I installed Mepis - I was always curious to see it. At home I have Debian. I find Linux easier to work with. The file system is not presented as My Documents C: D: etc. Yes, I know how the Windows file system works. In Linux you see just one hierarchy, irrespective of your disks, etc. There are not 150 things always popping up when you least want them to. Yes, I know some of them can be disabled. With Windows it's like the OS tries to think for me and tells me what to do. With Linux I do the thinking and telling.

Most people use Windows because 95% of people couldn't care less about computers and just follow the herd. Linux is for the thinking man who knows a bit about computers. I'm sure some use it too because they dislike pirating software. I know there are Windows installations without any pirated software, but they must be in the minority.

by daileyml

Tony:

Thanks, I understand. Knowing that there is much more to assessing a distro as a viable alternative to Windows, one of the key features IT managers are seeking is a "Windows like" usability. They are looking for which distro gets them as close to a Windows look-and-feel as possible to reduce the re-training curve.

Honestly, I am one of those people that complain about the number of distros available for Linux. It makes it an overly complex decision when evaluating Linux for a non-server use, in my opinion. I understand that Linux proponents like that, but we have to look at it from the view of the common desktop user. They don't care about the variety, they just want email/word processing/spreadsheet/etc. applications to do their jobs.

I'll look at SimplyMepis. I've personally never used it.

-Mike D

by tony hopkinson

then choice isn't an issue.
If you change the desktop image to the company wall paper, they won't know what distro they are on.
What is windows like?

You double click on the picture nd the application runs....

Not much scope in there for a difference. You need to get hold of your client's or one of their people, and get their feeling whether it's alike or not.
Your perception as a tech is vastly different to their's.
We are talking about people who if you changed the FF icon on the desktop to a blue e, and told them it was IE9 would just shrug and get browsing.

by daileyml

jd, point taken. I removed the links from both of my posts. They were meant only as a source of info, nothing more. I also modified my post on your blog to remove the abrasive tone.

I'm big enough to admit when I'm wrong, and I was. It wasn't intentional, but I can see how it appeared. Again, I apologize. I also sent you a private apology earlier today which you either ignored or didn't care to acknowledge. I just wanted you to know I had not intentionally taken a shot at you.

Beyond this, if folks remain upset and want to continue a useless dialogue it's on them. I've taken steps to correct an accidental situation and I do sincerely apologize. Accepted apology or not, it's out there.

-Mike D
http://www.daileymuse.com

by jdclyde

which is why I made a point of stating that I don't hold onto grudges over insults. It is fairly standard where many of the regulars will not reply to a peer message from someone we do not know. To much scamming/spamming of addresses, ya know?

As I said, leave the links out to your external blogs, and I have no beef with you. If the information is relevant, copy/paste it here.

As MichaelJ pointed out in my blog, you appear to be doing nothing but trying to draw people to your own blogs. Not a "troll", but not an activity I will not partake in.

Clean slate.

by tobeyllop2

My history goes from an Apple IIe through CPM, dos, Windows, with every 10th pc or so the latest Apple product just to be defiant. Now heavily reliant on XP and Vista, I want to play with linux in a virtual pc mode, which could lead to a fuller install on some old box lying around. Tell me in 100 words or less where to download what to have linux running in a vm with standard free apps I can get to know while flipping back to familiarity whenever.

by bill wilson

Whilst we tend to advise our customers to use Ubuntu on the desktop and Centos on the server I think that most Linux distros are better being more stable and giving a wider choice of applications.

This discussion is closed to new replies.