Discussion Locked

Why are vendors demanding WinXP?

0 helpful
115 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

What could possibly be worse than buying a product and missing the fine print about requirements? That it isn't a speed requirement, but an OS requirement.

Bought my boys each an MP3 player. Chose not to go with an Ipod.

We get up Christmas morning, and they see they each have a 512M MP3 player and are geeked!

The problems start when we try to fire this pig up. Great, they system requirements are incompatable with my boys PC. Too slow? Not enough memory? Not enough free disk space? WRONG. It HAS to have WinXPsp1 or higher. What crap is this? And what in the world would have ever made me think for a second that this piece of crap would not run as a simple USB flash drive?

Will I EVER again purchace anything from http://www.iriveramerica.com ? You can bet your LIFE I will not, and I will strongly recommend against it to anyone I see.

Got the T30 model.

What are you thinking iRiver? Locking yourself to an operating system?

Now I get to look for a hack to get this friggen pig to work on win2k or setup a XP partition just so we can do mp3's.

I wonder if linux would work with this? Have been meaning to setup a linux desktop at home after the holidays, and if it will work for these devices then that would be all the kick in the a$$ I need!

Well, off to research what it will take to get these going. Anyone got any ideas?

115 replies

by jaqui

try connectiong to a linux box and check the usb connection with usb view. :P

if it recognises the device then it will work.

it should, an mp3 player is little more than a player on a rom chip and a hard drive to store mp3s on. the only issue might be it using ntfs for the data storage.

by jdclyde

Got a PIII sitting around, so I guess it is time to load it up.

If I want a simple version to get my boys indoctrinated, which would you recommend?

Will worry about doing a "real" install for in a few months when my schedule opens up more. For now I need something to just load and go, with web and music. Would be nice if it would play Diablo2 but that isn't a requirement yet. Just need to get the MP3 players going. That is the SOLE purpose of this install to start with. Need to be up and going by next weekend when the boys come back from their female parental units place. I would HATE to have to load XP just to run MP3s. What a STUPID reason to load it. :(

by jaqui

Xandros.

debian based, has full access to the .deb package repositories, and best chance of getting drivers for most hardware.

by noyoki

I would recommend downloading a couple of versions of Knoppix. As far as I understand it, they have Knoppix versions of most (all?) of the major distros.

Knoppix is a bootable CD that installs nothing on the hard drive. Whatever OS is on the computer is unaffected (just make sure to set the bios to boot from CD first, if it isn't already). The issue is that you loose your settings each time you reboot. (But it's fine if you leave your computer on.) This will let you "taste" the different flavors before going through the actual (sometimes hour or more long) install.

by consultant-1

So....who isn't running XP now?

Man, that's sorta of like buying a frozen dinner and wondering why these #$%@ folks are wanting me to have a microwave!!!

Get with it, or be ghetto, your choice, but live with your choice!

by jdclyde

instead of toys have no need to get a new system and new OS every few years.

If I have systems running Win2kpro that do everything I need them to do, why would I put more money into them for just to get to a newer, more bloated version? (In the business world, we call that "stupid")

There was always a marketing myth about computers, and that "by the time you get it home, it is obsolete". Of course only someone that makes a living off of SELLING computers or a complete moron would believe this.

How big and bad of a computer do I NEED to have to do email, excel, word processing, browse the web and listen to some MP3's? Not much. I have a P4, an AMD1900 and a PIII800 at home, but the one I still use for all of my business functions at home is my PII400 because it still does EVERYTHING I need it to do.

When you grow up and enter the real world (and pay for your own resources) you will see that there are still lots of people running win98/winNT/winME/Win2k and they will continue to use it until they don't do the job required of them.

"Be ghetto"? Try "Be Real".

by nighthawk808

I was actually considering an iRiver product to replace my aging 256MB player, but if it won't work under Linux, then it's useless to me. Apparently some models do work, but they seem to have gone out of their way to design the T30 in as stupid a way as possible, so it _requires_ Windoesn't Media Player as of right now.

However, the nice thing about Linux is that there is always someone out there coding away to get more and more things to work, so this is likely to change in the future.

Microsoft is known to pay companies to develop products that only work with Windoesn't (or that only work with recent versions of it so users are given an "incentive" to upgrade). A slightly less monopolistic approach that they have also taken is to pay companies just to not develop drivers for alternative operating systems. It wouldn't surprise me at all to find out that the T30 is as brain-dead as it is thanks to a friendly "research partnership contribution" from M$.

by charliespencer

Manufacturers of products aimed at the home retail market specify Windows XP because that's the OS used by the majority of home users interested in multimedia.

By your own admission, you missed the OS requirement. Out of interest, what OS did you originally plan to use with these devices? And why don't you take them back and get something compatible with that OS?

by jdclyde

OS planned to use, win2k.

Why not take them back? Have you ever seen kids tear into packages with the sonic weld? Will they take it back after it has been torn into? Or will they say that isn't their problem? I would bet the second, that it is now my problem because we opened the package and the only defect was the thought process used by the manufacturer.

by chief bottle washer

With you boys returning from their female parental units, you
mp3 players not working, you now need to take time away from
your work projects and concentrate on making the boys happy.

How much time have you spent trying to make this work?

Hmmm...

Should've bought the iPod!

by nighthawk808

I think the biggest point of his that you missed was that there is no valid engineering reason for a device like this not to be OS-independent. It takes special effort to make a simple thing like an MP3 player to NOT be compatible with certain operating systems. If you buy a Ford car, you don't have to drive on a special, Ford-compatible road because the basic principles behind automobiles are universal. By the same token, the basic principles behind MP3 players are universal, yet this one requires Windoesn't XP SP2 for no good reason. That's active stupidity, not passive ignorance.

by charliespencer

So I'm working from a lack of experience. Perhaps that's why I wouldn't buy anything to connect to my computer without checking the system requirements first. Being ignorant, I assume that I would have to buy a model with drivers compatible with my OS, an assumption I make with any peripheral.

I also don't blame the manufacturer for my failing to read the system requirements. If I buy a Ford (deities forbid), I make sure the accessories I buy will work with a Ford.

by skooboy

How funny, all of you complaining about this device requiring Windows XP. You're obviously not product or software developers, because when you create a software product you usually aim for the greatest market coverage, and the "market" uses Windows XP. Although I don't own any of their products, iRiver is a very successful company. Like any successful company, they got that way by making sound business decisions.
On another angle, didn't the purchaser of this product check the system requirements? Were they not conspicuously printed on the exterior packaging? If not, you've got a good argument. If so, shame shame; in any product purchase, this is always step one.
And those of you on the Linux bandwagon, I'm sure you're very talented geeks (meant respectfully). But who cares about Linux on the desktop? Your organization? Your personal customers to whom you provide technical support? Probably neither. Hang loose, you've still got many years until Linux becomes relevant.

by m_a_r_k

I understand your frustration but the iriver website does say the T30 requires SP1 or higher. http://iriveramerica.com/prod/ultra/t30/T30-512.aspx Not exactly a smart move on their part. I wonder what is so special about their software that it absolutely needs something in XP1? Did the Windows internals change that much with the XP1 release?

Actually I have two simple questions about your predicament. First, why haven't you upgraded to SP2 yet? And second, why not simply upgrade now that you "have to" for the MP3 player? I'm not a Windows XP expert, not by any means, so please educate me. Isn't SP2 a big step up from the original XP? I upgraded long ago and luckily had no problems. Concerned about breaking something else that HAS to have XP with no service packs? Yeah, that is a concern. I won't do any kind of upgrade to the Windows OS or applications software unless I absolutely have to. And then I do so only with all of my fingers crossed. And with something big and soft nearby that I can punch the hell out of when I get infuriated after the software upgrade inevitably turns into a downgrade that hoses up my whole system.

by jdclyde

I am using win2k on the home systems. Been on them for years and never had a reason to change them. Defenately have had no valid reason to upgrade to XP.

win2k runs faster on older systems, and has lower requirements.

by johnnysacks

Yeah right, top of my list of things to spend my money on. Absolutely zero cost benefit of installing XP, thanks for the iRiver tip, I've always assumed XP and 2000 to be compatible and will verify on any future fine print before purchasing.

I hear there's some DRM crap in XP but any music player company requiring it is on my blacklist.

by noyoki

Curious... Have you any idea what DRM is in XP? (Or where to look for info?) This is the first I'm hearing that and it sparked my interest. :)

by nighthawk808

I was going to recommend Xandros, too, but you beat me to it. Xandros (and Linspire) is probably as close as Linux will ever get to having a Windoesn't XP clone. It even crashes every once in a while for the "Genuine Windows Advantage".

However, I'd like to extend that recommendation a bit and suggest that in a year or two, once they gain a feel for Linux, that they graduate to the real Debian, or at least Kubuntu. Maybe I'm being snobby and elitist here, but Xandros's real purpose (and one at which it shines) is to transition people gently into the world of Linux. To me, it's a bit like a cocoon: it's where you spend your time when you're changing from an old Windows worm into a soaring Linux butterfly. It's good while you're making the metamorphosis, but if you never shed it eventually, you'll never fly either.

by jdclyde

I have been working with linux for seven years now, but it has all been server side, from a command. My start was SCO unix openserver and added in Redhat.

Been intending to do the desktop thing soon, this just pushes my hand.

As for the boys, this will be a good start just to get them used to the idea of life beyond windoze. Next would be to get them to install themselves. Then go to the next level of linux.

I see using SuSE at work, so that will be one to get loaded soon too.

Thanks.

by jmgarvin

I love xmms (a lot of people hate it) or mplayer (clunky GUI, but sweet command line interface). Grip is great for ripping (via Lame)

If (IIRC) that MP3 player uses MPA format (native on it) you should be set.

I'm not a MP3 player expert, but I do know that they are mostly plug and play USB devices that are basically USB drives that encode the data in an audio format (eg MPA)...Anyway, good luck and let us know if they work in Linux

by jaqui

that was lindows, and I really wasn't impressed with it.

Xandros is targeted at new to linux users, as is Vector, ubuntu, kubuntu and a number of others.
vector is slakware based, and has 2 issues with the install that are really show stoppers for newbies.
[ doesn't remember x-config data, and doesn't give any info about password limitations they have for root password, like they do not support pass phrases, the space character is illegal character. ]
I haven't looked at Ubuntu or Kubuntu.or yellowdog.... [ huge list here ] so I can't actually honestly suggest them.

by nighthawk808

That's why I didn't recommend Linspire, I just pointed out that it is about as close to a clone of Windoesn't XP as you're likely to get. Sorry if I was a bit confusing about it. I'm not sure being compared favorably to XP is a compliment. If it is, it's a compliment like, "Hey, tubby, you're not quite as fat as you used to be!"

I don't particularly care for Xandros, either, but it is very good at being a balance between the brain-dead simplicity of Windows and the power and functionality of Linux. That seems to be its target, and it has done a pretty good job hitting it.

Of all the Debians that aren't Debian, I think Kubuntu stands out. Ubuntu is nice, but I've grown to like KDE more and more over time. I find myself hardly ever using GNOME anymore. While Ubuntu/Kubuntu succeeds on its marketing as "Linux for humans" and all that crap, it's not as toy-like as Xandros, either. It's definitely worth a look.

by jmgarvin

Not only is it "almost" a raw data MP3 player (MPA I think it is called), but a 2gb one only costs a little over $100. It is the Sandisk m250 (http://www.bestbuy.com/site/olspage.jsp?skuId=7331149&productCategoryId=pcmcat10200050002&type=product&cmp=++&id=1118844780039)

My biggest beef with these damn MP3 players is most don't play well with Linux...the Sandisk works just fine. It is detected as a USB drive and I can just write data to it...spiffy!

Oh, the iPod is an over hyped, over priced, piece of dog poo.

by jdclyde

I was down to iRiver and Sandisk on which to buy. Not knowing anything about either as an MP3 player, I followed the advice of the guy behind the counter.

Mistake!

I called, and BestBuy said they WOULD take the players back, provided it is an exchange and not a refund. Sandisk, here I come!

I liked the idea of testing this with the linux, but I like the idea of NOT supporting a company that would make M$ only products even more.

Let you know how it goes tonight!

by jmgarvin

I love my little Sandisk. While it doesn't have a spiffy display (I could care less) where I can watch movies, it does hold plenty of music (I have about 150 songs on it right now) and it is easy to deal with.

Also with ONE AAA battery I get a ton of play time (I honestly don't know how much, but the battery lasts for about 1 week before I need a recharge...)

Let us know what happens...

by jdclyde

it is just a fancy FLASH drive!

What about a flash drive is or should be OS specific?

I am going with the sandisk that was recommended and it states it is "PC" compatable for it's requirements.

Keep in mind, this is like a digital camera. It is a device that just happens to get information from a computer, not a computer accessory.

by nighthawk808

You seem to have missed the point about there being specific system requirements in the first place. There shouldn't be. Again, the concept of a basic MP3 player is like the basic car: they all work the same way, so requiring a special road for a certain type of car is ridiculous.

The equivalent to car accessories here is included media players. There's no problem making a special, "enhanced" media player that reads MP3 data and only works with Windoesn't. That's an extraneous bell and/or whistle above basic MP3 functionality. It's not unreasonable to expect that a Ford engine computer wouldn't work in a Chevy. But that's not the issue. The issue is creating proprietary formats for no particular reason and then supporting those superfluous formats for only one particular OS.

Sure, with a road paved in a series of cycloids, Ford could create cars that ran perfectly smoothly on square tires. But that's just plain stupid and unnecessary. Creating an MP3 player that won't work in any of the several dozen media players available for Linux is just as stupid and unnecessary.

If you bought a car, brought it home, and then found out that it requires a special plutonium-based fuel that can only be bought at Ford dealers, would you be happy about that? You seem to suggest he should blame himself for not asking the salesman if it ran on gasoline like practically every other car on the road today. A question like that shouldn't be necessary.

by chief bottle washer

In an effort to dominate the computer world Microsoft continues
to develop proprietary software and insists that it is the
standard. The simplest solution always escapes Microsoft.

He should have bought the iPod.

by jmgarvin

I can't "raw" write to an iPod in Linux. How is that easier? I can get a 2gb MP3 player for around $100, where as an iPod Shuffle 512mb is $100.

Also, the iPod is also OS specific. IIRC you can't use Win 9x with an iPod.

by jdclyde

and think it is crap for what you would pay for it. I wouldn't even own THAT one if I wouldn't have got it FREE as a door prize at a Voip demo. :)

No, I would never buy one.

I want a flash drive that plays MP3's.

by chief bottle washer

In an effort to dominate the computer world Microsoft continues
to develop proprietary software and insists that it is the
standard. The simplest solution always escapes Microsoft.

He should have bought the iPod.

You guys make these things too complicated.

by jaqui

I'll stick with lfs. ]:)
I like having to compile everything from sources, gives me more control over what is on the system and how it works.

by jmgarvin

An MP3 play is just a glorified USB drive. It stores data in a VERY similar manner to USB thumb drives.

So the problem is that it just doesn't make sense to make the device OS dependent. It should be plug and play and transfer data in a similar manner to any other thumb drive.

by kaceyr

I'm referring to the answer to your question, not the answer to your MP3 dilema.

Manufacturers of USB devices have a few choices to make at the outset that involve the core hardware of the USB device as well as the software to drive it.

Many MP3 manufacturers go with Windows XP as a requirement because the driver software has already been written for them and the supported USB controller list is pretty comprehensive. Add to the mix that their target audience has a high probability of having a Windows XP system, and you have the formula for a quick-to-market device (just in time for the Christmas season).

In a nutshell, the Windows XP SP1 requirement that you mention just happens to be the only one that they actually tested (and perhaps even certified). Many USB devices require SP1 or better because SP1 included a major USB controller fix and a greatly expanded list of USB controller chipsets.

Now, just because they say Windows XP, doesn't mean that it's all that will work. The device software is well documented and many Linux implementations support an almost identical USB chipset. The protocols for working for the device are also well documented. If they weren't, even Windows Media Player wouldn't be able to talk to them, so finding a Linux implementation that works shouldn't be a difficult task.

It's also not impossible for your MP3 device to work with Windows 2000, but you'll probably have to hunt around for a third-party driver since Windows 2000 is no longer updated.

As I was skimming the other posts I read that you've replaced (or are going to replace) the devices with the SanDisk MP3 device. My co-worker just bought one and loves it, and she loads her MP3's from <> Windows ME (someone actually runs it, who knew?). My boss bought one for his daughter and he loads his off of XP.

I think you'll be happy with the SanDisk device because they tend to select the most prolific hardware and drivers.

Enough of this winding road.

Just my $.02 USD

by chief bottle washer

Spam is what you get in a can. The gentleman is having a
coniption due to system incompatibilities. The iPod I bought
works with Windows MP through XP. Who's wasting time and
space here? I guess you guys like to complain a lot.

"When you guys get together you're worse than a bunch of girls
at a sowing bee..." Uma Thurman, Pulp Fiction

by chief bottle washer

The choice you made was primarily based on your preferred
mode of operation. And yes it is also OS specific. iTunes has
never worked with Window9x, as far as I recall, and just plain old
works with everything else.

Face it - Cheap is cheap is cheap!

The choice is yours.

by jmgarvin

Please, tell us why the iPod is superior to every other MP3 player...I want to know.

by chief bottle washer

Now with the cussing. Wow, the Goat has been got! We are all
techno geeks or we wouldn't be here. Think about it. All the new
toys and systems to figure out. What makes this go? What doews
this do? "Look what I can do!" No bells or whistles - boring!

If I'm so wrong are you aware of Creative trying to sue Apple?
Here, oh enraged one:

Creative may sue Apple over MP3 interface design?
All is fair in love and war... and MP3s I guess. During the product
launch of Creative's Zen Vision:M MP3 player, company CEO Sim
Wong Hoo indicated that Creative is planning to "pursue
aggressively" any and all infringements on their beloved MP3's
patented interface design.

Let's review dates a bit. Creative filed for a patent regarding its
interface design for its Zen digital media players in January
2001, and was granted the patent on August 2005. Meanwhile,
Apple Computer's iPod was launched in later October 2001. Aha!
The iPod was released to the market approximately nine months
after the Zen MP3 player was out and so Creative seems to
believe that they indeed have a right to seek legal action against
Apple.

"We will pursue all manufacturers that use the same navigation
system... This is something we will pursue aggressively...
Hopefully this will be friendly, but people have to respect
intellectual property", according to Mr. Sim.

But what is Creative's real purpose for such a bold statement?
Many believe that Creative simply wants all the free publicity
such a legal suit will surely create. In the interim, talks about a
pending lawsuit will draw attention to its just released Zen
Vision:M MP3 player. Once an actual lawsuit takes place, all the
talk will bring Creative's name to the forefront, and just maybe,
they can get a bigger piece of the MP3 player market pie from
Apple."

Bells & Whistles and PROFITABILITY! Your red-in-the-face-ship.

by too old for it

... I'll be looking at iRiver shortly. I'd like an MP3 player, just don't want to get locked into iTunes-Nation.

by jdclyde

The SanDisk that garvin pointed at is 4 times the system for $30 more.
http://tinyurl.com/cvyj4

It is PC compatable. Can be used with any PC and also can be used as an external drive. 2 gig instead of 512m.

by jdclyde

As long as I have a working solution by then, I am fine.

I have an iPod. Not impressed. Sorry.

by jdclyde

I returned the iRiver mp3 non-compatable players tonight.

The SanDisk I want is sold out (BIG SALE!) so I got a rain check for two of them. They come in Friday, so I will be all set when the boys come home!

Bonus!

The SanDisk is 2 GIGS. Much better than the 512m I would have been stuck with using the iRiver and it is only $30 more.

Thanks Garvin for pointing that one out!
Thanks to everyone for the linux Ideas! Will still do this, but not for a few weeks. Selling my house right now, so doing all that last minute stuff to it.
[b]
And no, getting an iPod is not a good idea. :D

by chief bottle washer

Ahhhh the pungent flavors of Indian Curry. With a robust
Cabernet or a luscious Merlot ones palette experiences many
different flavors. The same may be said of ones taste in all
mundane pursuits. Be it intellectual or commodity, but to start a
debate of pros or cons - someone has to light the fire!

I expect a 2000 word or less dissertation pointing out the pros
and cons between a Windows based product versus an Apple
product. Convince me that the product you have chosen
deserves the attention you warrant it. And please be specific.

As a graphic artist working in Hollywood if one platform can't
complete the job - use the other one! For doG sake...

How's that for a challenge?

by jdclyde

The system I am getting is not platform OR OS specific.

That makes it much superior as I can use this with my existing Win2k systems, my furture Linux systme, and if "Toys-R-US" has a good sale, my future MAC. :D

Why would I EVER limit myself to ANY of them? If is just a friggen usb flash drive with a few buttons! I can use this to carry around utilities for work as well as music to escape from work!

by mjwx

and a wine-o no less, that explains a lot. doing tech support for a graphic design company has taught me that the 4% of the world (fair enough 5% in the US) who use Mac?s generally don?t use their heads. People M$ bash a lot there is not nearly enough Mac bashing, so please allow me. I spend more time per machine trying to integrate Mac?s into network than I do trying to piece together broken windows machines (also to be fair we are using Small Business Server 2003). I can integrate a Linux server into this domain (using Samba) but I can?t even get a Mac to get through ISA server without putting in a password 10 times and put the wrong password in once and it will lock you out because it keeps trying to authenticate when it fails once.

I get no end of grief from our graphic designers that they always need to put in their passwords (to keep it in perspective they are also referring to logging on as well as having to put their password in each time they want to access their email or internet).

In conclusion I think Apple should spend a little time on actual functionality and less time on presentation. Crap in a pretty ribbon is still crap.

Mike

P.S. we did get a Macspert (I try not to use Mac and expert in the same sentence) in and he suggested we redesign our entire network just to accommodate two of those infernal machines (10-15 K $AU in software alone, not to mention man hours and downtime for the rest of the company). Note: our network services about 30-40 workstations and 14 servers.

P.P.S. I own an ipod shuffle and it is the worst P.O.S I have ever bought. If you want to give me $220 Australian for it you can have the damn thing.

by jdclyde

The "web design experts" that gave our corporate web site a "face lift" made a page a right and it didn't look bad at all. Problem was when it was time for them to deliver that site.

First, I HAD to ftp into their server. Do they have a zip file for me? Nooooo. They have one directory with a few thousand files in it (yes, ONE directory! OH, thats "folders" to newer Windows users). In this single directory were the graphics, labeled "picture01.jpg", "picture01.jpg" (you catch my drift here).

The MAC users could use DreamWeaver to make a pretty page, but because they knew NOTHING about computers they couldn't even DELIVER it to ME. They couldn't organize the files with a directory structure, and couldn't provide meaningful names for the files.

ipod shuffle. Got one free as a door prize, AND they are only $99 USD here.

I offered to trade my boys it for their new Samsung players but they weren't falling for it! (DRAT)

by chief bottle washer

And another thing I want to know - "Where the heck is
'Longhorn?'" Why is it taking Microsoft so bloody long to develop
their next great OS? Also, what portion of the code are they
willing to release to their developer base? How much time will I
be expected to invest just to get one of my machines running
the damn thing? And at what price tag? For the software only? Or
does the price include what my employer needs to pay me in
overtime hours?

Computer systems can be difficult at times but please... give me
something better than base (dribble) code to make all my
periphrial work with the damn thing. And why should my
employer pay for the extra time and expense to upgrade? If I
spend $800.00 to upgrade my OS then find out I have upgrade
this that, that and the other thing to get it all to work - I ain't
giving up the money!

Do it right the first time and you won't have to fix it when you're
done.

Pish posh! Take my time and money you "Blah blah blahhdy
blah blah!"

Perhaps you chuckled - all the better.

by jdclyde

Didn't say anything on the web page about it, but there it was on the package! XP! XP THIS!!!!

We got 1gig samsung. win98 and up.

Wasn't on sale, but the sandisk NEVER CAME IN and they were not going to get anymore. (now I remember why I stopped going to Best Buy to buy anything!) I get the "area manager" to transfer the sale price AS STATED on the rain check in the small print that he didn't think I would have seen. He tried to start the sob story that a rain check is not saying the product will EVER be back in, just if it is then you get it at that price. Rain check states that if they can't provide that product, they can make a deal on an equal product.

Will see how I like these ones in about an hour!

boys are happy. I gave them the choice between these or the iPod shuffle. (hmm, 1 gig or 512?) Surprise! Neither of them wanted the iPod... ;\ Guess even 13 year olds can see through the hype!

by kenneth

Now I too know that I don't need the hype of an Ipod, and if I wanna get an MP3 player. . .SanDisk is my friend!

KB

by jdclyde

I got two of these by Samsung.

http://tinyurl.com/92p5q

Only 1 gig, but will run on just about any platform and doesn't requre software to "sync" your music. Just Windows exploiter or your favorite file management software.

1.5 ounce, it is TINY yet it rocks. HALF the size of an iPod Shuffle and twice the memory.

One thing I don't like, is you need their special cable to plug into your computer. (uses same port as the headphone jack.

The Sandisk would be fine if you don't mind the idea of a vendor wrapping itself around a single OS like that.

by jmgarvin

Go away, or I shall taunt you a second time!*

*Uh...ok Creative is suing, but that still doesn't mean bells and whistles imply profitability. Please provide me with a solid example where bells and whistles ALWAYS win out over anything else...I bet you can't.

by jdclyde

[b]Sent iRiver this email, got no response after a week. So much for customer service. I laughed at a friend that bought himself one! (he has bought into that whole MS only "thing") :D[/b]

[12/27/05]
My boys each got a t30 512m iRiver mp3 player for Christmas.

I was shocked to discover that the systems would not work unless you have a computer running Windows XP. Is there a driver available to run these devices off of Windows 2000 or linux?

They look like nice little boxes, and I would hate to have to go with someone else's product because of tieing yourself to a single operating system.

Thank you for your time and consideration.

by sit ubu, sit.........good dog!

Hello all:

I am in the market for an MP3 player (under $120), and I've been shopping around for a while. The one question I can't seem to get answered on any of the companies websites is if a normal flash MP3 player can use playlists, where we can divide our music into generes, and still have the titles of each song show on the screen.

This would come in handy for me, since I have MP3s of songs as well as albums (well, CDs). I see that you all have recommended Samsung and Sandisk, and was wondering if you have the info that the websites are lacking.

Thanks
Geoff

BTW: I also have a 20GB iPod. Haven't listened to the radio in months!

Suggestion: Download (and possibly buy) iFill from http://www.griffintechnology.com. Records internet radio stations and loads them up on your iPod (NOT your computer) AND divides the stream up and stores them song by song (with track info). I'm addicted!

by jaqui

Digital Rights Management.

you haven't heard about sony and the rootkit?
that is the DRM issue for windows being bandied around right now.

by noyoki

I'm not a *complete* idiot. Or not yet at least. I was referring to the DRM included in Windows XP. I hadn't heard there was any natively included.

by jaqui

the digitally signed thing that activex had added, for "trustworthy" activex?
or the windows genuaine advantage that tells eveyone they have a pirated copy of windows.

just about everything where ms is trying to protect corporate interests is thier drm

by jamesrl

One of my staff had a really rotten experience with Samsung MP3 players. They had a technical issue, sent it in for repair, it got lost, and took in the end 3 months and many phone calls, including escalated calls to the President of Samsung Canada to resolve. At the end of the day it worked for a few weeks and died again.

Hope yours work out better.

James

by jdclyde

hope it carries over to these.

they seem like nice little boxes and the boys LOVE them.

Hearing this, I will have to make special care that I save the receipts!

by jdclyde

How could I "break" it if it never installs? Where is the fun in that?

Time? It just will be going on a system that is not in use now anyways, and will be next to my gaming system. Let that disk roll, I can amuse myself while it loads! :D

And I do have SOME linux desktop experience, just not much. Like I said earlier, mostly a server from the promt kind of guy and now I just need to use that "new fangled technology"! B-)

I would LOVE to make a linux gaming system. After my house sells, there will be a new computer in the family!

by noyoki

As far as fun in crashing, lol, I meant it would give you a taste of how the OS handled itself before spending hours on one and realizing you didn't like it and having to install another. :P

Honestly, the only thing keeping me on Windummy for my main computer is the fact that 85% of the games I routinely play are Windummy only. I honestly don't know how good WINE is anymore, but years ago it was sluggish, crashy and didn't work with 75% of Windows apps.

(One of the games I play even had a coder working on a Linux-based client, she (I think it was a girl anwyay) had gotten the client to the point where it would connect to the central server but no farther when it got put to an end by the Korean-based company that has no plans on writing a Mac/Linux client themselves! Grr.)

Anyhow, best wishes when you get your system up and may MOST of your "breaks" be minor! :)

by jdclyde

there are many games now that are making a linux version, which is cool.

also, I remember reading garvins blog that he is running games on linux, but I don't recall the package he was using. (wasn't wine)

Will have to get back over there and see what he did.

I am on Win simply because I haven't had the time to just sit down and do it. (between the divorce, fixing the house and getting ready to sell it) Been just a little bit too busy to spend the time to replace what I already have "kind of" working.

by nzamparello9

I honestly would not reccomend linux for gaming... There really aren't that many games for it and let's face it.... There really aren't very many financial incentives for companies to port games to linux.. Just look at loki software... Some companies such as Id, bioware, and activision have come up with the best linux gaming solution so far... Buy the windows version and then if you run linux they give you a linux client version for free... The only other problem is that there also hasn't been a huge demand for linux gaming.. The ultimate hypocrisy in pc gaming is that blizzard co developed SDL but still will not port ANY of thier software to ANY other platform then win/mac.. That frustrates me the most.. Companies will make mac games which is essentially bsd but won't make some minute code changes to run on linux...

by jdclyde

As for "the market", there are still plenty of systems out there running windows 98 and win2k in the home market, not to mention WAY too many ME systems.

By not making this a generic flash drive, they have just alienated all of these people as potential customers.

As for knowing better, I sure do now. I have worked with many flash drives for home and work, but never saw one that required MORE than WinME to use it.

Why should I expect that Win2kpro would not run this? They have lost me as a customer, as well as any and everyone I talk to about mp3 players. (and that is a lot of people, even before this discussion!) Note their level of customer service as they never even replied to my email that I sent them on the 27th. (posted at end of discussion)

And it was not in a section for "System Requirements", it was a sentence at the end of a long list of "features".

The linux was only brought into the mix as a possible work around, not as the original goal.
[b]
Maybe WINDOWS people need to learn to read better? :O

Gotcha! :D

by noyoki

Killed the cat. lol. I looked up lmgarvin and in his profile, found this:

"If you want to play Microsoft platform games in Linux then check out Transgaming and see if your game is on the list Transgaming Games db. I'm playing World of Warcraft, Counter Strike: Source, Half-Life 2, Warcraft III, and VtM: Bloodlines in Linux! I refuse to pay for any more MS OSs and I just won't beforced to jump through hoops when those that have illegal copies have a very easy time with updates and maintenence."

http://www.transgaming.com/cedega_faq.php#12
It's $5 a month, however, though I'm not sure you need to subscribe to play. I haven't really looked at it yet.

by dirtclod

I-Pod - another in a long list of overpriced empty promises by individuals whose talent is designing computer cases that work and look like toaster ovens. (See Sellout)

Yet another trap - kind of like marketing heroin to kids. Geez, wrap something in silver, lime green or purple, get posers to dance with it on a commercial, who cares if it works? - it's the fashion statement that's important.

About as stupid as the "game boxes." Buy one - a year later they "upgrade" it, forcing you to buy another fix. Meanwhile, the music pirates thrive on. (And more power to them)

Remember? They told us that I-pod and I-tunes were going to end all of that - yeah...right chief, I'll get on that right away!

by noyoki

Just sort of took all that for granted as "it's Windummy" and never really thought about it. Lol.

by noyoki

Part idiot, part genius... They sort of cancel each other out and make me somewhere on about "Average"...

by coyotenm

...Trying to find drivers for old OS's with new equipment...new computers come with XP. I update old computers to XP if possible. If not possible, then the computer is too old to be worth fighting with. I don't have time to screw with finding drivers and fighting with old OS's that can't handle new equipment and programs. I have too much work to do. In business, that's called s-m-a-r-t.

by jdclyde

Unless your a thief waiting for the software police to come knocking on your door, it is expensive to just start throwing a copy of XP on every old system, even before you look at having to add memory to handle the new OS.

(Anyone remember when Win95 was as small as a 20 meg footprint?)

Old drivers for new equipment? Why do you need some special driver for a FLASH DRIVE? They have been making them for YEARS, and just now are STOPPING adding the driver for 98/me/2k? This can ONLY be because they are getting a kickback from MS to stop including the support to get people to upgrade to a new OS that gives them NO benifits for their current business needs.

When do I upgrade users to XP? When their computer dies and costs more to fix than it is worth, they get a new system with XPpro. Anything else woule be stupid and wasteful.

Remember, if you spend all the money, it is the same as if it was never earned and you are out of business.

Nothing "s-m-a-r-t" about wasting money, even if it isn't your own.

by coyotenm

Well, I'm thinking strictly business, and also the places where I volunteer work. Now that the really old computers have mostly passed on and I don't have to fight with trying to get modems, printers, etc to work with old 450's running Win98, life is SO much easier! Networking is easier...everything :-)

And if a business has many computers, paying an IT person to keep old relics running is considerably more expensive than upgrading.

But also both places get the licenses on a great discount because of being education or non-profit. I buy extra licenses for people who do the organization's work at home, and to cover donated computers.

So when I see an older OS having serious problems, I try to upgrade it to XP, not re-install the original. It saves alot of grief.

I agree, it is strange and annoying to have an mp3 player dependent on your computer's OS, whatever OS that may be.

by jdclyde

I have heard both sides of this.

The logical thing is to see how much time is spent on old systems just because they are old and add in replacement parts and get a cost.

The other side that I have heard and is more common in smaller organizations is that you as a tech are getting paid anyways, so it doesn't MATTER if your spending time on this or waiting for something to go wrong.

If less things are going down, they don't NEED as many support people, thus you get IT layoffs. (this is in who's benifit? Sure not the techs.)

When you get new systems, have to reload all the apps and settings and then take it out into the field and replace the old system (after transfering all the data) where is the time savings?

Run a computer until it doesn't run or it doesn't do the job it was intended for, and THEN replace it is our chosen route to follow, and I agree with it. Then we get a new PC based on the needs, not the ego.

How much time are you spending with XP now? Everytime there is a new service pack to fix the new secure OS by MS, requires time.

How many times do you have to reload an XP system because of the user picking up a trojan/malware/virus?

How much time is wasted fighting with all the new MS registration and copy protection involved with XP?

Volunteer work, yes you want to minimize your hands on time. Been there, done that.

by jmgarvin

It is a recuring fee that you only MUST pay once for three months. ($15 ain't bad for any software).

If you choose to update or download, they will simply charge you $5, if you aren't paying for it anymore. A pretty good deal all around.

I recently updated to cedega 5.0.1 and the cedega engine 5.0.3 (so I could still play WoW, the 1.9 patch did some crazy things and some of it is NOT good...Windows and Mac users are having issues out the wazzu (and I had a few, but at least I could FIX them))

Cedega is basically WineX (and wine) that is more specific and better able to deal with the crazy needs of gaming.

Keep in mind the 5.0.3 engine broke Gothic 2, so I had to back up to 4.4.1 (which is no big deal, just a profile setting for each game...which is nice).

If anyone has any questions on Linux gaming, transgaming (cedega), or native linux games I'd be happy to answer.

by jmgarvin

Many years until Linux becomes relevant? You do know that *nix makes up over 50% of the server market, right? You also know that the Linux desktop market has about 50 million users (some estimates go as high as 100 million), right?

You also know that Microsoft makes more than just Win XP. What about Win2k? What about those using Win 9x?

iRiver will probably not be very successful for long if they remain so short sighted. Any company that makes a MTP transfer into something that is OS specific, won't stay in business. Mac users, *nix users, and those that don't use Win XP will NOT buy their product and therefor they are losing revenue.

by coyotenm

Every office and situation is different...we do what is most practical to do given our circumstances.

It's true you don't want to efficient yourself out of a job. But in some cases, being freed from the mundane repetitious jobs lets you work on more advanced and interesting projects, and gives you a chance to forge ahead in your field.

I have the computers do automatic updates, keep the virus and spyware guards up-to-date, automate the maintenance as far as possible. Plus because of the work we do, our equipment budget is pretty generous. The machines get replaced before they start breaking down or getting obsolete.

So maybe I'm not looking at it from a typical situation. But I have to say being able to keep things up-to-date and automated is a big advantage in our office, and has made me look good, since I did the automation. Lots better than when I spent much of my time running around trying to keep cranky machines and software running, and applying patches manually. In fact, the virus problem was a big part of why I began to automate everything. I couldn't keep up, otherwise.

by jdclyde

if not, you should be.

Any place that turns over computers that quickly, why would you buy them?

That is just a fantasy world that many of us just won't see.

And yes, since I went around and applied all the updated software and moved everyone onto FireFox, my running around putting out fires has gone from 80% of what I was doing to about 10% over the last year.

Kissing IE goodby was the single biggest time freer I have done in years.

by 3xp3rt

You?re right. I know company (little one) where all the IT works are done by a PI computer with Windows 95 and all the applications are mudded in Clipper for DOS.
So all the applications work in DOS mode, there are fast and stable and can do anything what this company need.

by jdclyde

when it doesn't do what you need it to do.

Must be hard to find someone to support this setup though.

I got the last of our 486's off the network 4 years ago, and the last P1 is just about ready to be phased out. (finally)

Problem with old hardware. Replacement parts.

by 3xp3rt

You?re right the problems are the replacement parts.
But I kept a lot of interesting things like 8? floppy, my first program in magnetic band,
My first program in punched tape?. And so on

by 3xp3rt

You?re right. I know company (little one) where all the IT works are done by a PI computer with Windows 95 and all the applications are mudded in Clipper for DOS.
So all the applications work in DOS mode, there are fast and stable and can do anything what this company need.

by noyoki

Yeah, $15 for initial downloading of the version and $5 for an update if needed is awsome. It sounded like (upon skimming the faq, as I really don't have the time to even PLAY games atm.. lol) you needed to pay $5/month to use the software and the moment you stopped paying, you couldn't use it anymore. (I dunno, thought maybe you had to log in and it 'phoned home' or somethin... M$ makes ppl too suspicious... lol)

Ragnarok & Diablo II on Linux... Here I come!
(among others... lol)

Question, is it easy to switch between Cedega versions? (ie: install them in seperate places and you can choose which to run, or some such? Or do you need to re-install/edit a config file each time you want to switch versions for games...?)

by jmgarvin

"Yeah, $15 for initial downloading of the version and $5 for an update if needed is awsome. It sounded like (upon skimming the faq, as I really don't have the time to even PLAY games atm.. lol) you needed to pay $5/month to use the software and the moment you stopped paying, you couldn't use it anymore. (I dunno, thought maybe you had to log in and it 'phoned home' or somethin... M$ makes ppl too suspicious... lol)"

Na. It isn't that bad. If you expire, you just can't update. If you decide to update, they automatically charge you. Not a bad deal when you think about it. Also it is pretty cool that cedega is a single package now (more or less) and you can just go with the flow.

"Question, is it easy to switch between Cedega versions? (ie: install them in seperate places and you can choose which to run, or some such? Or do you need to re-install/edit a config file each time you want to switch versions for games...?)"

Yes. Each game has their own specific profile where you can set various options, including the cedega version. For instance, CS is running under 4.4.3, while WoW has to run under 5.0.3. Not a big deal...