I need to tone down.
"I can understand your dislike for distributions aimed at neophytes (like me) that do a lot of hand-holding and "installation by default". "
Its not that I dislike easy distros, on the contrary, what I dislike is the lack of control durring the install process. Example. I love Debian, but when you install Gnome in Debian, you get a monolithic package, unlike the Gentoo builds, which range from spartan to monolithic (choice). But, I just do not have the patients to install Gentoo anymore(pain in the @$$). Most of my complaints are not more then trivial to fix once the distro is installed, except for some file system options in Ubuntu (LVM, McryptFS, which need to be "finagled" at install time). The trend in installs is going more towards "5 clicks and done," which is fine, but please leave me some way to customize, and at MINIMUM ask me if I want beryl/compriz installed/enabled by default. Sigh. Its as bad as google toolbar. (Don't ask). Windows does not have the sheer number of options as a Linux install, as all of the Windows "options" are third party products and drivers (MS is trying to change that though, (Looking at you Media Center XP, Vista Ultimate). And while install routines do let you customize the Desktop installs, there is still something to be desired in the way they tie in to other bits.
Sometimes their choices are "more complete" then you may want.
" As a newbie screwing with drivers is too much work for not enough reward."
I completely agree. I hate driver issues, and lets be honest, a driver is only a few bits of code. Even "old" hard drives are 40+Gb now.
My concern is not with drivers, that seems to be a Jaqui thing :p but with services enabled at boot by default. Bluetooth, bittorrent, cups, hplip...
Really my complaint is that I have to do some minor work to secure my box... thats it really. Each of those enabled services not being used is an open source of attack, and consumes resources (even if tiny) while doing nothing for me. Its much like on Windows, you disable every service you can for security. And even XP does not come with bittorrent by default (im looking at you Debian/Ubuntu).
"it's not going to go away just because yet another distro pops up. Unlike Windows upgrades, no one is trying to make you switch."
No they won't go away, but the character is changing. And not all of it for the good. The trend is there to make Linux easy. Fine. But that ALWAYS means a compromise in security. IUt can be easy, it can be secure, but it can not be both (maybe this will change one day).
Mostly though, Im just dern grumpy. And was hoping to get some lively debate going here with some loaded terms. So take me witha grain of salt. Mostly it was just me moaning in much the same way everyone complains about their jobs. They aren't really unhappy, they (we/I) just like to bit*h.
"Bloated" or not, linux still runs as well as XP or better on the same hardware, and much, much faster then Vista (in my experiences). And even "Dumbed Down" it is a superior platform to Windows (In my opinion). And honestly, some dumbing down was required, to avoid those messy xfree configs and driver issues. I use XP and Ubuntu daily, and hade several web proxies built on Debian that i check out weekly or so. I look into other distros a smuch as I can, usually at least one a month, and try to give them a few weeks of use at home.
I would be happy to see everyone use linux, or at least try linux. I have had my dad on ubuntu for 2 years now. He loves it. After years and years of Windows, he is actually getting interested in computers as fun, not just work. He has even rebuilt his own computer, which he uses daily now :)
And on that note, I will take some more asprin, triple check our spam filter (crashed 2 times today), and drive out to get an estiamte on replacing the trunk lid, rear bumper, and driverside rear quarter panel and lenses.