Discussion Locked

You know what, I've had it with TR. I'm done, bu bye.

0 helpful
26 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I joined this site for one reason only. Technical information. I belong to numerous other sites for the same reasons. The difference being, the other sites I belong to I never went off topic... I.e., non-technical conversations.

Even though I have found some technical information on this site, it's not enough to make up for the crap that I see in off topic threads here. Everyone is of strong opinion here, myself included. But, the focus of this site has been totally lost because of its off topic threads. I no longer come here to learn something new; I now only come here to argue crap that doesn't advance my career.

It?s not worth it, the arguments aren?t worth it. And the knowledge gained be it on topic or not isn?t worth it.

Don?t worry, I won?t let the door hit me in the a$$.

dan

26 replies

by w2ktechman

There are a lot of topics, and many areas here. The off-topic discussions are amusing, and abundant. But there are plenty of technical items as well.

However, I think many off-topics came from you as well. I seem to remember a 'socks and dryer' thread....lol
Hey, going on that, what do you think when the dryer does not stop at socks? I mean, I am missing quite a few shirts lately!!!

oops, off topic.

ok Dan, try this. Hang out in the questions area a bit more. Even without posting, others will add responses. These can often help for reviewing and or learning.
My first few years at TR I never left Q&A and articles. Never really came over to discussions or much else.

by michael jay

You will be missed, here is hoping that your just havin a bad day and you you will be back.

Just loved your special brand of humor, and your rants..

O well, life goes on.

by w2ktechman

as I was busting up when he was going off on BOJ the other day!!!

ahh, many a times I read Dans posts and dont comment, but, he will be missed.

by dr dij

TR seems to have lost focus.

there used to be category trees for topics.
long gone.

I'd watch certain ones I was interested in.

However, Dan, those off topic threads may be useful in saving the world. Discussing what should be done is relevant to the future of humankind. Ok, won't immediately make you any more money.

But if the right solutions to our problems are not done, we don't have much future. So those who simply want to earn a living then go home and get blasted are contributing to the problem in a way.

by locolobo

That doen't worry me as much as not being able to find tech answers.

Guess I'm slow but sometimes when I use the search feature in forums/questions I can't find something that I saw a couple of days previously.

by dr dij

I'd like to see the forums arranged in a branched tree form. e.g. software->anti-viruses->[specific vendors] | [specific problems] > responses..

then people could come along and check immediately instead of searching or re-answering the same question again and again.

by jaqui

the questions and forums so they merged, TR KILLED the search.
when they added tagging, they destroyed the remains of the search.
[ tags do not supply on topic results, since sh!t for brains have tagged posts with everything but what the topic is. ]

by thechas

Years ago, the TR forums, both Q&A and Discussions were branched forums under each of the major technology categories of the newsletters.

This had 2 problems from how it was structured.
1. Peers would start multiple new threads on the topic they needed and answer to under every related heading.
2. It was difficult to find new threads to look at. There was a new threads link, but the server load of the search function was too costly for TR after they became part of CNET.

Back then, TR used a points system to reward answers and limit questions. The points never really amounted to anything other than a way to keep score.

While I think there would be at least as much of an uproar if TR tried to do away with the off-topic threads as there was when they attempted to drop Geek Trivia, I do think that the off-topic threads should be a separate forum.

Call it the water cooler or the debate room, the off-topic threads should be isolated from the technical threads. At the same time, except for those threads that deserve a flame response, TR peers need to show more restraint and not take technical threads off-topic.

Keep in mind, that the off-topic and near topic threads tend to get the most posts and site traffic. The most recent example being the "Are you a Wi-Fi Thief" thread.

Chas

by neil higgins

it is informative,funny,too the point,and the humour,or is that humor? is appreciated.All that leave,apart from the down right rude,will be missed.We are a happy family,who some times go awol,but hey,TR does inform,help,and tries it's best.

See ya.

by thechas

Dan,

You will be missed.

As you stated, there is some valuable content on the site.

How about just looking at the new articles and avoiding the threads?

I've gotten frustrated with some off-topic threads and peers who spend all of their time there. I only drop in on discussions when I feel like it, and get very selective as to which threads I post to. For that matter, I've been getting more selective on what questions I attempt to answer.

I am sadly observing a changing of the guard here as I see fewer and fewer posts from the peers who used to answer a lot of questions.

I don't blame that so much on the off-topic threads as I do the fact that TR seems to be used as the tech support hot-line for India.

I had some hope that Vista might invigorate the Questions again. But, that has not happened.

Best wishes to you, and I hope you find an online community you enjoy being part of.

Chas

by tony hopkinson

FFS man get a spine transplant.

You post in off topic, no one made you.

If you aren't getting what you want from TR, then by all means leave.

If you think it will make a difference, then you need a brain transplant as well.

by charliespencer

The content in the Questions forum is almost completely technical, even when it wanders off-topic. While there are members who participate in both, there are some who are only active in Questions, and the tone and flavor are completely different from Discussions.

You can also read the editorial content (articles, blogs, how-to's, trivia, etc.) and ignore the forums entirely. I seem to recall there are actually more passive members than active ones, but I've only got 64K of RAM and it takes me 56 to run Heart-Lung OS 1.0.

I'm not going to beg you stay, but I feel most of your contributions have been worthwhile.

by shellbot

Sorry to see you go..its your choice, but like everyone else says..stick with the technical stuff if your tired of off topic.

As pointed out, i remember you joining in a lot of the off topic stuff..so I'm not quite sure whats got you p!ssy?

Hopefully you'll pop in now and then.

Shell

by dadspad

The off topic area is sort of addictive. Some people here have admitted they should be studying, working on a project, etc. when on (but that did not stop them from succeeding).

I first came to TR to get technical information, then one day I found the Friday Yuk! then found many interesting folks here with interesting opinions. Most of it is good stuff. I like to get away from the technical side sometimes. The relief seems to help me work better.

No it will not make me more money or, usually, increase my technical knowledge. But it does make me a better person.

I hope you will change your mind and come back when you need friends to talk to or an issue you want to B!tch about.

If not, it has been a fine thing that I got to see some of your personality brighten up TR.

May your future be filled with happiness.

by armstrongb

You are doing with this post exactly what you say is driving you away. Useless posts with no information or even semblance of relevance. Thanks for that and may spread your useless negativity far and wide this Holiday season.

by itgirli

I come back after being gone a year and see that some things never change. Wow, people sure do like to get worked up, don't they. And I do so love that they act like they are above such things when there real problem is that they let themselves be pulled into the arguements. I usually came here for the arguments, it gave me a chance to think about things and let off some steam. Blaming an site and the people on it for your own lack of will power is something that never ceases to amuse me. Oh, woe is me, I cannot keep myself on-topic and must blame those that lure me in with their wanton cruelty. This ignorant self pity is so common. Bwah-ha-ha!
Okay. I'm done like. I just like to see people to the door.

by av .

... There were voices down the corridor,
I thought I heard them say...

Welcome to the Hotel California
Such a lovely place
Such a lovely face
Plenty of room at the Hotel California
Any time of year, you can find it here . . .

AV

This discussion is closed to new replies.