Discussion Locked

A+ Certified but can't figure out this one..

0 helpful
41 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Ok, I have built a lot of PCs from scratch and fixed a lot of them but the problem I am having with this PC is just too much for me.
I got this PC to fix for someone, the PC will not boot. I wanted to reinstall windows xp from sratch but I couldn't boot from the CD-ROM for some reason.
It goes past the CD-ROM and tries to boot from the HDD instead (which is not booting).
What I did..
- Swapped IDE Cable
- Tried different DVD-ROM
- Tried another XP CD
- Yes I do see the CD-ROM in the BIOS and the boot order is set to CD-ROM first and if I reboot and go back in the CMOS it does retain the settings.
At that point I was sure it was a bad motherboard so I went and bought a combo motherboard with new ram and new CPU (a small upgrade from what she gave me in the first place to end up with a PIII 800 Mhz)
I am still having the same problem!!
Will not boot from the damn DVD-ROM, I do the same troubleshooting again, try new DVD-ROM with a new IDE Cable, unplugging everything but the DVD-ROM, if HDD is not attached and doesn't try to boot from it I get the error "Boot FailureSystem Halted". WTF? Anyone with suggestions please feel free to comment.
Remember, the Motherboard, memory and CPU has been changed..

41 replies

by jim_p

Just try this if you haven't already, I know this should be a part of the problem, as you have changed motherboards, but just to get this out of the equation.
Also have you tried to boot another PC from the XP CD you are currently using?
Can you press something like F12 at the post screen to get a boot menu where you can choose the CD-ROM to boot from?
Let us know how you go.

Kind Regards,
Jim

by nicknielsen

An older 800 MHz CPU also assumes an older BIOS that probably doesn't recognize the DVD drive as a valid device.

Try the plain CD-ROM drive.

by cdrmk5

-you're not advising the basis for, nor the sequence of steps taken prior, to THIS system response to your boot attempt... that failed.

So any attempt to resolve advisories made by U appear as... just pissin-in-the-wind... and worse.

a baseline... XP ... + prior[?] multi component replacement...

MS has a major hissi-fit regarding.

by ken.ellis

What is the hardware. Some older model motherboards like Compaq do not like DVD's on CD Rom's. Take a lookk on the web and make sure the hardware you are using is compatible or maybe there is a bios update.

Again some motherboards want you to press a key like F9 or F10 to manualy run the boot order.

Have you tried making a boot floppy and got it working that way.

You said it was an 800Mhz CPU and mother board. These are older so I would use older hardware with them.

If this still doesn't work then consider formating and loading the harddrive with the CD in another machine then transfering back to this machine. Boot with anything you can get working and install from there.

by jufarah56

For some reason I think it might be hardware you had before that you've included in the new pc and the only thing I see is the hard drive that you haven't changed.
If you have an old 3GB or any HDD on hand try it out.

by themorg56

I would try booting from a dos floppy and check to see if the DVD/cdrom is accessible this way. Although it shouldn't make a difference I would check how the DVD/cdrom is jumpered. It may need to be set to Master vs CS. Last but not least confirm that the cd is bootable. Based on the facts that have been presented I would lean towards the disk not being bootable.

by synthetic

I have systems that do this as well and it drives me nuts. I have no idea why I get an occasional unit that try as I might will not boot from the dvd/cdrom device. Just got to bootdisk.com and download a windows 98 se boot disk from a 1.44 fdd. This will have all the base cdrom drivers you need to dos over to the drive and manually start the installation.

by massiej

If you boot to a Win98SE floppy it should have drivers sufficient to operate the drive as a standard CD-ROM since all newer drives are generally backward compatible. Booting into Win98 in RAM would then allow you to click the executable on your WinXP disc to begin setup.

by hal 9000

All that will happen is when you attempt to click on the XP Setup EXE you'll get an error message telling you that this is not a DOS Compatible File.

You need to use the Windows XP Setup Floppies to do it this way.

Col

by -twitch-

have you tried a different XP disc? i have found my self in the same situation before and it turned out to be a bad cd. go figure. if you still have problems. I would boot from a floppy or even try booting from a 98 disc and start the installation manually. if for some reason you still cant start the installation i would suggest booting from a floppy and copy the cd contents on to the hard drive through dos and running the installation straight off the hard drive.

To me it sounds like you just need to try a new xp cd.

-- worse comes to worse. you can try to begin the installation with the hardrive in a completely different pc. when the installation forces the reboot, shut down the PC, remove the drive and continue the installation in the original PC.

by bemcculloch

Could try another power supply. Have had this issue before and turned out to be faulty power supply.

by reparent

I have a lot of things to try here.
Very appreciated!!
I will repost with what I have done to rectify the problem to let you all know.
Thanks again!
Remi

by ro013jo

Just for kicks, re-install the old motherboard, find the jumper for re-setting the cmos(like if you have a system password but forgot it), If no jumper exists then remove the coin battery powering the backup and leave out for 15-30 minutes. In the earlier step, you may have to re-boot with the jumper removed, then re-install it after the system boots.... Just an idea.

by darin3

I have seen this quite a bit with older hardware. The most common solution I have seen is that the DVD drive wants to be master on it's own controller i.e. Secondary Master. This seems to have cured the problem on about 15 out of 18 machines I have tried in this category of PII-PIII vintage machines. Also sometimes you will get the blue screen of not being able to read 1 or more files. The most successful fix was to set the drive to PIO mode 3 or slower. Good luck.

by felixeh

The power supply is the base of any computer pyramid. Could be a dead rail in the PSU. If that is not it, a bad HDD bios can poison an entire system also.

by skruis

Who cares why it won't boot from the DVD drive? Find a Windows 98 SE boot disk and launch setup from there.

by jufarah56

I've had that problem in certain pc's. I didn't know you used a dvd drive.
What you do is put a cd rom drive in there to install the os and if you want the dvd drive in the pc install it after the os is in. For some reason it won't read from a dvd drive but will read from a cd rom drive. I think it might be a driver issue.

by daytech

I have seen this very problem alot recently. I keep an old cdrom drive around just for this purpose. Swap it out after the os is installed. Also I have found recently that the newer motherboards behave better with drives jumpered as cable select rather than master/slave. Shouldn't matter but it makes ghosts disappear and improves drive performance when I switch them to cs.

by jufarah56

I've had that problem in certain pc's. I didn't know you used a dvd drive.
What you do is put a cd rom drive in there to install the os and if you want the dvd drive in the pc install it after the os is in. For some reason it won't read from a dvd drive but will read from a cd rom drive. I think it might be a driver issue.

by ozzie

I notice that in all the reply's, no one mentions DIP switches. These can be the culprit also...

by nboamah1018617209

Yup just try changing the boot order on the Bios setup when the computeer first starts up, if you can get into setup then change the order and get the computer to start from the cd-rom first so giving it chance to boot the new operating systrem or create a boot disc from a floppy and run a diagnostics check.

by jimmie

Is this drive the only drive on the cable?
Are the "master/slave/cs" settings correct?
Is the drive connected to the primary or secondary IDE controler?
If connected to the secondary controller, is the secondary controller enabled in the bios?

If this does not help resolve the problem, post the findings to these questions and I will try again.

by w2ktechman

There have been several main problems for me. First, I use images, not the Win CD, so this may not apply. We used to get images on cd's, then they switched to using dvd's. I tried installing with a dvd in a cd drive (didnt work).
Other problems that I have encountered have been posted already. They include the power supply, a bad disc, and dvd driver issues with the MB/Bios. First, update the bios. Next, try replacing with a cd drive.

by reparent

Well I have tried everything that was mentioned here with no luck. I'm going crazy here, I think I got another motherboard which is defective.
I don't even have the floppy drive as a boot option on the new board I bought (well, second hand I should say). I tried to start the installation of XP on my working PC but got a blue screen, ok so maybe the HDD is bad but even if it was, it doesn't help me boot from the CD or floppy to even start an installation.
I put the old motherboad back in.
I tried different CD-ROMs (original that came with the machine and other older ones I had) with no luck. This time I was able to put the floppy as the first boot order but when I try to boot from the floppy with my Win98 boot disk it still doesn't work, I think I got an I/O disk error (The diskette booted fine in my other computer). I have tried booting with just the CD-ROM on primary master AND on primary slave making sure it is always detected in BIOS. I tried this with nothing else plugged in.
Oh and I tried all of this on a new power supply as well. I'm out of ideas and I have already spent way too much time on this. I'm sending it back to the person who brought it to me and it will not be fixed (this is the first time that happens to me). Very frustrating!

by w2ktechman

A few more things to try first.
Did you check/replace the cable for the drive?
Also, if you use another system, you can copy the source files to the HDD and then install it from booting to the HDD instead.
Another thought is that the jumpers are not correct on the cd/dvd drive. Set to C/S and place on master. If that doesnt work, make sure they are set to master.

by w2ktechman

I thought that this was already posted so I didnt add it, but going back I didnt see it. Good call.

by hal 9000

Make sure to clear it so that none of the old settings remain these can cause problems on some Chip Set M'Boards.

Col

by dirkpitt

lol..lame it is. However for the problem use a linux or dos boot disk and see.
Does it have an A:\ drive? if so do fdisk/ mbr
either of these should blow the garbage out and allow for a fresh install of XP.

by jim_p

Sorry I should have suggested this one too, I have looked all through the replies and haven't seen it suggested yet. Go to a PC that is working, with Windows already installed. Put your XP CD in, and there should be a directory containing the makeboot32.exe or something like that, it has the 32 numbers in it (Gui Version).
Have 4 newly formatted Floppies. Go through the makeboot utility which will make 4 bootable floppies. Just like the good old NT 3.51 and NT days.
Mark the boot disks 1 to 4. Then boot this trouble making PC of Floppy 1 and then when prompted, insert disk 2, 3, 4. You may have to manually add the IDE Atapi driver for your HDDs and CD-ROM too in the second screen after the first setup installation screen as well.
Let us know how you go.

Kind Regards,
Jim

by shanijgriffin

If the problem still exist..after doing this step...u have to check the power supply...try with another one....
Let us know is it got solved...

Regards,
Shanij

by hal 9000

Is that the DVD ROM is failing and will read DVDs perfectly but not CD's I've mostly seen this on Samsung Drives though it could be related to others.

There is also another possibility here and that is the actual DVD ROM is incapable of sending the correct signal to the M'Board to see a Bootable CD in the drive, this happened quite a lot with the early DVD ROM's and the only cure it to temporally replace the DVD with some type of working CD Drive and try again. I would also suggest using known good IDE leads as even new leads can be faulty particularly if they are of the 80 cable type and not the 40 way ribbon.

I think that you'll find that will cure your problem. Sometimes a Firmware Upgrade on the DVD ROM will do the trick if there is one available.

Also there where several M'Boards back in the old P3 days that where unable to read from a DVD ROM and required a CD ROM to boot from that's a problem with the BIOS as it's unable to recognise the output of the DVD for some reason.

I really would suggest changing the DVD ROM Drive to a CD ROM Drive and attempting to load XP as a clean install and see if that works which I think it will. I seem to remember some trouble with the Intel 815 Chip Set M'Boards and available BIOS that didn't allow it to recognise the data being transmitted from a DVD ROM. If I remember correctly there was something about the firmware in the DVD Drive clashing with the BIOS that caused the problem though don't quote me on that as it's been a very long time and I'm not overly sure that's the reason but I seem to remember something about it causing problems and we had to always have a CD Drive of some kind as the Secondary Master be it a burner or reader it worked but if we used a DVD Rom it never would work.

Also have you tried using a Live Linux to see if the hardware will actually work? If that will load you can rule out he M'Board and at least the IDE Controller that the CD/DVD is on though for something this old only try a CD version of Live Linux not one of the DVD Versions as they just will not work.

If you can get the system to load any form of Live Linux you can then try the Ultimate Boot CD available from http://tinyurl.com/3jnpy and run some of the Diagnostics like CPU, RAM and M'Board tester there is also a HDD tester built into the CD and as everything goes into a RAM Drive you don't have to worry about any corruption of the HDD just like any Live Linux.

If you use Knoppix you can actually read any NTFS HDD Partition and The Ultimate Boot CD has a utility that wipes and totally erases the HDD by writing 0's to every sector several times over I think from memory that it's called [b]Something Boot & Nuke.[/b] This will make certain that the HDD is really empty and not causing any problems.

With these old M'Boards you [b]Can Not[/b] use the CS option as this wasn't supported by these IDE Cables so you need to set the HDD to Master on the primary IDE Channel and the CD ROM to Master on the Secondary IDE Channel to make sure that things will actually work.

Col

by hal 9000

When they go flat you'll get all sorts of screwy problems rise their heads up that will drive you insane attempting to understand what is happening.

Col

by the admiral

Dont listen to anyone else when I say to change the power supply. You have chaned everything except the power supply, which is highly likely is the problem in the first place in which it *May* have burned out the CD-ROM and Hard Drives, or it isnt supplying enough voltage to run them (gives it enough to be seen but there is a difference is being seen and running)

by reparent

Hi, I did change the power supply actually. I thought I had indicated that on the posts later.
I am now back with the older motherboard that came with the system in the first place because I couldn't even boot from the floppy (no option to change in the boot order). I created a win 98 boot disk and didn't work at first even though it was working on my PC. Most of my floppys are old and will not work so I decided to create another one (with the win98 batch file from www.bootdisk.com) and it took me like 7 floppy before I was able to get one to work successfuly. I was then able to boot from it but I get an error from the HDD. I'm pretty sure the HDD is not working correctly so I will try with a another HDD (I had try to install XP with that HDD on my computer and it had given me a blue screen so it really looks like the HDD is toast).
Oh and I did try to boot from a XP CD on a CD-ROM instead of a DVD-ROM and it still wouldn't boot from it, weird.

by nicknielsen

Each hard drive manufacturer has a set of utilities specific to their drives. The drive tests in these utilities will almost always find problems you couldn't find otherwise.

This page (http://shrunklink.com?iec) has links to the major drive manufacturers.

Edit: spellig

by jim_p

If need be, buy another floppy drive they don't cost much these days, and also buy a box of floppy disks to put bad floppies out of the equation. Maybe as suggested a BIOS Upgrade as I haven't seen a BIOS yet that won't let you set the boot sequence, at least between the hard drive and floppy drive yet.

Regards,
Jim

by reparent

Your right, a BIOS upgrade might fix this as it is also the first time I see no option to boot from the floppy. But that was with the other combo I had bought which I am returning. I am just waiting another HDD to try to fix the one I have now as I was able to finaly boot from a floppy witht that one. I'll post again to let you all know how it went.
Thanks!

by jufarah56

Like most old computers the BIOS can only
upgrade so far. I happen to remember when I
bought my first 200GB HDD and to my surprise it
only recognized 137GB no matter how many times I
upgraded the BIOS.
Have to read up on the manufacturer's specs.

by jack

Have you tried another bootable CD? Perhaps the CD you are trying to boot from is not bootable!

This discussion is closed to new replies.