Discussion Locked

AMD or Intel for SOHO sever

0 helpful
7 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Hi all. I am currently running a celeron 366Mhz and win2k with IIS 5.0. I'm running a personal web server and a ftp server. Now, I'm planning to upgrade to a 1Ghz proc but undecided which to go; AMD or Intel. I'm not sure of running an AMD as a server is reliable due to the fact of excessive heat and long running hours. Any suggestions?

7 replies

by vertex

If cost is a factor, AMD is the answer. At this present stage of development for AMD, they should be stable by now. AS for heat, this can easily be overcome with additional cooling fans and good ventilation casing. An AMD system would need plently of TLC, if you think you can't afford the TLC, opt for Intel's chip.

by csmith

Actually right now the AMD is more stable. The major revision of the P4 still has some issues. We use both, but right now I would recommend AMD. The biggest cooling problem with 24/7 SOHO servers is to keep the insides from turning into a giant dustball.
Regards, Chris

by txtopgun

I would strongly recommend going with AMD. I actually work with an Intel PIII 866 SOHO server (not my choice, it was there before I was)and question its stability. I have had much better luck with AMD and besides the price difference is considerable. All things considered, unless you have money to just throw away on something that will be totally obsolete by this time next year, AMD gives you much more for your money and at least as far as I can see is just as stable in a SOHO setting.

Good luck. Hope this helps.

This discussion is closed to new replies.