Discussion Locked

Are Manufacturer's Guilty of Fraud?!

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Recently I Purchase a New DVD RW Burner that was Marketed to Operate at Burn Speeds of 20X.
After getting it, and Installing it, and putting it to the test, I found the Firmware is making the Software only detect 2X Burn Speeds.

My 16X DVD Burner only is Detected as 1x Burn Speeds. And Why does different Software Programs Detect Different Burn Speeds if the Firmware is what Determines the Burn Speeds?

The DVDR Disks I am using are rated at 16X so at the very least I should be getting the Software to detect 16X Burn Speeds, but I am not getting anywhere even CLOSE to that rate.

WHY? I just Bought the 20X DVD Burner Last Week, so I should not have to Flash the Rom in the DVD Drive just to get it to Function Properly.

WHY do these DVD Burner Drives not Operate at the Rate that is on the outside of the BOX?
The Fact that the Firmware is suppose to Determine this Rate, could make the Manufacturer's in Violation of Consumer Protection Laws, and Guilty of Fraud IF their DVD Burners do not Operate at the same Speeds they are Sold to Operate at.

Have have TWO Different DVD Burners, and Neither one of them operate at the Speeds they SAY they are suppose to Operate at. I want to know WHY, and What I can do to Correct this Problem. I should NOT have to Flash the Rom in the Drives just to get them to Operate at the Burn Speeds they are Rated at on the outside of the Box. They should function properly right out of the Box. If they Don't then they need to change the Box as well as how they Promote their Products. Otherwise I believe they are Guilty of Fraud.

If anyone can provide me with some Solutions to this Problem, please let me know.
Lawyers, please feel free to Build a Case and Sue the Shitt out of any company that produces crap to Torment us, or Deceive us.

Thank You,

Mark*

9 replies

by pgm554

Truth in advertising has long since lost any relevance in the real world.

Read the fine print.

Under ideal circumstances ,using specfic machines,OS,patch level,etc,you may get what is advertised.

That's like believing SATA II really gives you 3GB/sec throughput.

It's marketing hype that has been going on for years.

If it requires a firmware upgrade,then do the upgrade,otherwise your only legal remedy is to take it back.

Do you really believe something like Enzyte ,can improve your sex life?

Yet they continue to advertise that stuff everyday with nobody sueing them for fraud.

by hal 9000

That you want to use as the Burner obviously can not burn a Blank faster than the blank is rated to can it? So the absolute fastest that you can hope for is 16 X Burning.

Many years ago when CDR first came out we where paying $25.00 AU per Blank and thought that was cheap. Then a few years latter they started to get cheaper and then I sold a new machine to a company and told them to use good quality CDR and gave them some Verbatim Blanks and before I had got back to the office I had a service call because the CD Burner had exploded.

Apparently they didn't like the expensive CD that I left them and bought some cheap nasty ones and because the different layers of plastic had air caught between them when they where running at a High Speed Burn at 4 X the air got so hot that it caused the plastic structure of the Disc to fail. The front was blown out of the CD Drive with bits of plastic embedded into the walls office furniture and anything else in the road.

Exit 1 Burner and replace it and they then complained about needing to pay for it as it was under 1 day old. :D

Now back to the box while it may say 20 X Burning Speed for DVD what software is listed on the box and what are the system requirements listed as well? Also do they list a recommended Media?

If you are not using the recommended software on the recommended hardware or better there is no possibility of getting high burn speeds as the computer & Software is unable to deliver the data to the DVD Drive fast enough. The original CD R had their own HDD included in them and you copied the data to that HDD which in turn copied directly to the CD R and with that setup we got really high speed burns of up to 8 X but the price of the drives was quite high.

You obviously have a bottle neck somewhere that is preventing the free flow of data to the Burner/s and if you are attempting to burn 2 DVD's at the same time things are going to be slower than if you are burring 1 as the IDE Lead can only transfer so much data at any given point in time. That is something that can not be exceeded no matter what you try.

However in this case I would be looking at the software involved and see what the User Manuals recommend as Supported Hardware and the Machine Specs as well. Does your computer meet or exceed their minimum requirements by at least 100% if not more and are the DVD Burners listed as Supported Hardware in the form of Burners?

But no matter what are you looking for speed or quality of what it is you are burning? I find that when I'm making copies of my personal DVD Movies I get better picture quality when I burn the 16 X DVD Blanks on a 16 X Burner at 2 X. I'm not exactly sure what that the 16 X refers to either as it's a Dual Layer Burner and I don't know if that is for Single or Dual Layer Blanks as the paperwork only says can burn at 16 X on DVD. Even then less than 2 years ago the fastest single layer DVD Media where only 4 X and I was handed 1 Dual Layer to have a test with. Now they are available but still expensive compared to the Single Layer so I just stick to the Single Layer 16 X -R and they work well even if for some reason the 16 X Blanks burn slower than the 4 X Blanks used to. Same computer with no changes except Windows updates added as they became available and the faster the media becomes the slower that the drive burns at. But as I'm paying less that 50 cents AU per Disc I don't really care. I can afford to throw away several without loosing any real money where as a single Dual Layer is still costing me $3.50 AU per Disc. So I'll stick with the single layer for the time being till the Dual Layers get cheaper. I'll not even consider the Blue Ray as they are just plain expensive and I'm not sure that they will ever take off. Though to be fair I've found that the TDK Blanks do work and burn faster than the no name blanks but at 3 times the cost the difference in picture quality isn't worth the expense.

Col

by deadly ernest

The system is detecting and reporting what it's finding as effective operating speed. And that's at optimum conditions. Any bottle neck and you get minimum.

If the burner is sharing it's IDE cable with another device, especially what it's burning from, you will see a slow down as the cable is handling both devices. I found placing he burner on the secondary channel with the HDD I'm burning the data from on the primary channel gives me faster burn speeds.

Also does the IDE channel you're using haev a 40 pin or an 80 pin cable. Some optical devices only use 40 pin cables, some use only 80 pin, and some (read most) will use either. This will also affect the highest possible speed due to the data transfer capability.

The last two major effects are from the software itself - I have a friend who didn't realise the default burn setting in his software is 1x and did all his burning at that speed - was shocked when I got his system to burn a disc faster because I changed the setting to 'Auto' to allow auto detect. Also, the effective burn speed is often affected by the other options you set in the burn software, and the actual program used.

by the_webninja9

I DO appreciate everyone's input on this subject. First of all to answer the Hardware Configurations issue, I am running a Pentium 4, 3Ghz 800mhz FSB, 2.5GB Ram, Radeon 9550 with 256 MB Ram, Sound Blaster X-Fi Extreme, and a Firewire Card, Two- 200 GB HardDrives, one Sata,(As the Primary Dirve),and One IDE Slave HD(On the Primary). Secondary IDE I have One DVD RW 48X read 20X write Lite-On as the master, and One DVD RW 48x Read 16X Write I/O as the Slave.
Copy Data from Primary Sata 200GB HD to Primary DVD Burner at 20X (But using 16X Disks) the Detected Burn Speed is only 1X or 2X.

Software Offers no other options, however different software such as Nero will detect Higher Burn Speeds off the same drive. This is what puzzles me the most. Why one speed from one software program and a different speed from another Software Program?

The Bottleneck I could understand if I wasn't running such Highend Configurations.
I feel with the set up I am running I should at least be able to get 16X from my DVD Burners.

In response to the Guy who felt that it is an Acceptable Practice for Businesses to Misrepresent their Products, (Asking how long I have been in the Business?), I first started using Computers in 1989 with the US Military, to answer your Question.
I studied Business and Business Eithics and no where did it state that it was "OKAY" to Misrepresent your Products or Services.
On the Contrary, when Studying Business they usually teach you that Misrepresenting your Products CAN make you Liable for Fraud.

I understand that some Companies DO, but that does NOT make it Right, Nor should it make it Acceptable as the Norm.

I do not think that just because someone can get away with unjust Business Practices, that it should be made "Acceptable" for all businesses. People who accept that "That's just the way things are" are the one's who deteriorate this Country, and all the Standards it is suppose to represent.

The one's who stand up and Fight to make things right, and refuse to accept sub-standard products, are the one's who make the difference in other people's lives.
Just something for you to think about.

Once again I want to thank all of you who try to resolve these Firmware Issues I am having. Thanks again,

Mark*

by hal 9000

Give it a go. The different software is written at different times and makes best use of different hardware.

Now while the Guts of every DVD or CD Drive are literally made by one company the way that different companies assemble them and integrate the Chip Sets on the Circuit Boards makes a massive difference to how something will work.

While I personally don't agree with this practise either it's common enough and has been around for a very long time. The obvious comparisons are Stereo Equipment you'll see some cheap throw away junk rated to a 100 W RMS when actually by using the real rating system it will be more like 5 W RMS. Technically it's not illegal to use a rigged rating system particularly when many other makers are using the same Rating system. Just think what a professional Sound Amp would come out at under this rating system. :D

In Power Supplies you have two distinct types the Questionable Ratings and the Real Ratings. The ones with Questionable Power Ratings will give a Peek Value that can be maintained for short periods of time before overheating and either dieing or the protection circuitry cuts it to prevent damage. The Real Ones are rated to a Power Ratting that they can run at all day every day of the year and not so much as miss a beat so something like an Antec 350 W True Power PS would probably be considered as about 800 W under the other rating system.

Even when the same rating system is used like in Brake Horse Power developed by a car the not so great makers will measure this at the crankshaft and quote it through all their advertising while the better companies will quote the BHP created at the drive wheels which is the more useful of the 2 measurements. But as people don't ask they will generally chose the one that has the higher figure even though it actually produces less power at the drive wheels the broacher said that it had whatever so that's what it has.

The current problem that you are facing is that you are using some high class professional burning software which was specifically written for the Professional Burners which are quite a lot more expensive than the no name stuff that you are currently using. Believe it or not but companies like Bose, B&O and Nad make DVD Burners though not many are sold because why should you buy one when you could by a few hundred of the cheap ones for less money and have a far longer life expediency?

But if you where to try a NAD, B&O or BOSE DVD Burner I'm sure that the burning speeds on the software that you are currently using would show a massive difference.

Basically it boils down to getting what you pay for and the cheap No Name DVD Burners that are so common in Computer Equipment are just that cheap & Nasty with the minimum set of IC embedded into the circuit board to do the job in a reasonable fashion where as the High End Equipment would have a frequency response from well below the audible audio range to well above the audible audio range to prevent any distortion occurring in the audible Audio Range that most people can hear at.

If I remember correctly the AR Speakers that I have are rated from zero Hertz to 800 Kilohertz which covers both way below the audible to way above the Audible audio range but even they would produce a really crummy sound if you plugged them into a Ghetto Blaster with Bugger all power behind it to drive real speaker enclosures.

Quite a lot of the Japanese Makers baffle the buyers with [b]BS[/b] in an attempt to gain sales. Several years ago one of the audio companies was charging a premium price for their amps because they had special coper wire in the transformer windings so they just had to be better. The company in question was pushing the idea that they where using Long Crystal Oxygen Free Copper Wire to make the transformer windings and claiming that if normal copper was used the impurities in it formed PN junctions so you effectively had a lot of unpolarised Didoes in the copper so it prevented the free flow of electrons. They totally ignored the Skin Effect of Electron Flow and insisted that as they had something better it was worth more. The sales people didn't know any more than what they had been taught to sell this crap and they went to great lengths to sell the more expensive stuff because they thought that it was better.

Well here with DVD & CD Burners the Digital to Analog Converters are much better on the high end stuff that you buy and while the cheap no name stuff will work sufficiently well enough it does allow some distortion to creep in at the ranges that it starts to Clip at so this alone could very well explain the slow burning speeds on the cheap Burners as the software recognises the limitations of these burners and acts accordingly. This is just one example of why this is probably right and then the associated circuitry will not be to the same specifications as the high end stuff so if anything this should slow down the Professional Software even more as the burners that it is driving are so far below their minimum specifications that the software is incapable of driving them any faster for fear of distortion creeping in and the faster that you burn the more likely there is to be distortion particularly when there is Video concerned.

While the makers may claim a 20 X Burning speed what amount of distortion do they claim at that burning speed? Remember that you'll get a lot more distortion with Video than Audio so the Video here is the real problem and the faster that you burn at, the harder the circuitry will be working at and the chances of distortion will increase.

The run of the mill software doesn't see this as a problem as it's designed for throughput not quality, where as the better software will burn slower to get a better outcome and attempt to decrease the distortion that is burnt onto the Blank.

Is that a Better Explanation for you?

Col

by the_webninja9

Thanks Hal, yeah, I understand what you are saying, and you are right all the way down the line, I completely agree with you all the way.

Incidentally, yesterday after I got through posting on TechRepublic, I started editing Video, got finished and Burned my Movie, and mysteriously the Software Recognized the Burning Speed Correctly this time.
I'm still not sure how that managed to happen when it would NOT detect the Correct Burning Speed three times before. But whatever the problem was it is Fixed now.

But I AM going take your advice and Buy some Better Quality Burners. I had my heart set on Yamaha, then they discontinued making Yamaha DVD Burners.
So I will have to Shop around.
I guess if I am going to do this Stuff I should start focusing on doing it RIGHT. :)

Thanks for your Help.

Mark*

by deadly ernest

I used to own a car that was advertised as capable of doing 240 kph (about 150 mph), yet I never met anyone who was able to get it up that high. The company even had a film of the thing being radar measured at that speed, a close examination of the advertisement shows the driver would weight around the 40 kilo or 90 pounds mark. No accessories, and I doubt they even had the spare in the boot, to save weight.

Essential, for a lot of this type of stuff they do test them and do have them deliver the advertised performance, BUT UNDER EXTREMELY OPTIMAL CONDITIONS ONLY.

As Col mentioned, good recording of video is slower than straight data, so you can bet their bench test was straight, simple data with nothing else on that IDE channel.

The software probably uses different algorithms to work out the actual burn speed, thus getting different answers, or it could be just a matter of closer compatibility with the hardware.

What is worthwhile knowing, is all the hardware does get bench tested by the manufacturers, magazine reviewers, and some governmental consumer watchdog agencies. The people making hardware have to be able to prove their advertised capabilities to the government agencies, even if it's only in a rigged bench test. Do the companies that are around a while can prove what they're saying, and those that can't aren't around long enough to make a warranty worth trying to claim on.

This discussion is closed to new replies.