Discussion Locked

ATA133 HD vs. ATA100 HD - speed ?

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Which is faster on an ATA133 IDE controller? an ATA133 HD with 2Mb of Cache or an ATA100 with 8Mb of cache?

6 replies

by thechas

There are more factors at play here then given.

The drive seek and access speed will have an equal if not greater impact on the overall data transfer rate.

As will the size of files transfered.

If the read speeds of the drives are equal, the ATA133 will be faster.

If the ATA133 drive has a slower access speed, then the ATA100 drive will have a potential edge.

Chas

by akula

Personally, I would go with the 8MB ATA100 drive. The 100 or 133 MB/sec only applies when the disk cache is full- the HD can't read fast enough to transfer at even the old 66MB/sec spec. So, with an 8MB drive, you can burst more information over the ATA bus.

by akula

The latest Maximum PC (April 2003) tested an ATA133 Maxtor drive on both a Promise ATA100 and ATA133 controller. There was almost no speed difference- not even a single percentage point difference in speed, and on a couple things the ATA100 was even faster (although by that miniscule difference).

This discussion is closed to new replies.