Discussion Locked

ATX and Swapable Hard Disk problem

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have a situation where a user has an Inclose MobileDock IDE hard disk bay in his PC and he uses it to go between different OS's for testing.
The other day he powered down as usual and switched the drives to go from Win98 to Win2K but when he wentback to Win98 the drive was completely dead (bios couldn't even find it!) We even tried it outside of the dock and it still was completely dead. I replaced the drive with a new on and it works just fine.
My theory is that it was fried because ATX still has "power" to the mother board even when the system is off. Does that sound right?

Therefore, I feel, he should turn the powerstrip that the pc is connected to off and cut ALL power to the PC before he swaps.

Any ideas would be greatly appreciated.

5 replies

by computechie

On most ATX computers, the motherboard still does have power, but the drives do not. The power connectors to the hard disks run right from the power supply, and are only on when the computer is switched on. Most likely, the drive just died. I've hadseveral hard drives that worked fine, and a then I just rebooted them (warm boot), and the drive was dead. Having him switch the power strip off won't hurt anything, but I doubt having power to the motherboard killed the drive. Hope this helps you out.

by nitehawk

Hello there,

In answer to your question, when you swap like that you can easily fry a drive. Chances are, you got attacked by the old static electricity bug or a little left over charge. My suggestion is that you shut down not only your power strip, but additionally, consider the addition of a rubber floor mat to quell any static charge if wrist bands are not used. As a final note, just to be on the safe side, always make sure that the drive being removed is allowed to stop spinning after shutdown before the other drive is loaded in. This may again create a source of left over charge that could repeat the problem.

by scott horvath

It ended up being user error. They SWORE to me that they waited till it was off but I CAUGHT them later almost pulling it out with the "Windows is shutdown" screen still on the monitor

This discussion is closed to new replies.