Discussion Locked

CDRW IDE vs SCSI Driver

0 helpful
7 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

What is the difference betwen the CDRW IDE and SCSI Driver ? If I got enough money I'd like to but it one. Which is the good cdrw ?

Thanks..

7 replies

by timthetoolman

Hi,

Essentially you're asking the difference between SCSI and IDE.

There is a very good article at...

http://www.acc.umu.se/~sagge/scsi_ide/

(remove spaces from the above URL)

Look at the bottom of that page for a comparison between the two.

BUT... a couple of comments from me.

You wont need the power offered by the SCSI technology. Especially for a CDRW. Neither SCSI nor IDE will have their bus speeds pushed for a CDRW and SCSI really only shines when you have multiple devices anyway - like a bunch of disks.

Furthermore SCSIs complex internal logic means that a SCSI controller can handle many simultaneous disk requests at once - far better than IDE, but not really useful for just the one device attached...

So, in your case all that will be wasted for one CDRW drive that doesnt require a high data throughput anyway.

Also, you'll need to buy a SCSI card for the PC to use the SCSI CDRW drive. Extra expense.

If you want it for gloat value, then SCSI is the way to go, though.

Cheers,
Tim.

by douglas_debow

there are alot of good reasons to go scsi
1 larger bus (more data moves faster)
2 scsi card's handle a lot more devices (ie: scaners or tape drives...)
3 scsi setup's data transfer speed's for each device (ide channels set speed to slowest device)
4 future up grades ( make your next purchase a scsi hard disk) probally the single fastest up grade available! pc's bottle neck with data transfer around the hd.
5 better software and support ( disk managment software and scsi driver for any OS

reasons to go ide
1 price ide is much cheaper than scsi
scsi really dents the wallet!

hope this helps you

by ebob

You are really asking about the difference between IDE and SCSI. You already have some references on that.

So some comments from me:
On a practical level, you probably do not have a SCSI controller in your system, but you likely do have the usual array of IDE. Your motherboard likely has 2 IDE (or EIDE) connections. In a typical setup, you have a ribbon cable coming out of the one labelled "Primary". On the end of that cable (in the "Master" position) is your hard drive. The other cable is plugged into "Secondary" on your motherboard. In the "master" position (at the end of the cable) is your current CD-ROM.

You might have a second hard drive. It's plugged in near the middle of the "Primary" ribbon cable. It is the "Slave" device.
You can add a CD-RW to this setup pretty easily.
1 - buy one with an IDE (or EIDE) interface
2 - set it's jumpers to "Slave" (these are little pins on the back of the unit, near where the power and IDE cable pug in - RTFM for more info)
3 - with the PC powered down, install the CD-RW in your frame, attach the "middle" (or "slave") connector to the IDE interface (there is a right and wrong way - so be careful), and attach a spare power connector
4 - boot up your PC, your BIOS should find it and just carry on after a brief message
5 - assuming one of the current "Windoze(r)" operating systems, you should see the usual plug and play dialogues
6 - you may need to insert your O/S CD, and/or locate the drivers from the CD-RW drive manufacturer's CD or website

You will also want to use the drive. You will need an application to do this. The most common is Roxio (formerly Adaptec) Easy Cd Creator 5. It is not without its flaws, but on most systems, it works well. Or check out CNET and ZDNET download sites.

Good Luck

This discussion is closed to new replies.