Discussion Locked

Clean renewable energy, dispite Democratic opposition

0 helpful
75 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

The Alliance to Protect Nantucket Sound, http://www.saveoursound.org/About/Position is strongly against the wind farm going in THEIR neighborhood because "This will cause visual, noise and light pollution."

The charge has been led by Senator Ted Kennedy, who has always been an advocate of the environment and a sound energy policy, until this project came along.

More links about the case:
http://www.capewind.org/
http://www.capecodonline.com/special/windfarm/
[b]Kennedy faces fight on Cape Wind[/b]
http://tinyurl.com/kyp3y

[b]Off-Shore Wind Farm Opponents Lose Massachusetts Court Battle[/b]
http://tinyurl.com/yltnh9

[b]Ten Taxpayer Citizens Group, et al. v. Cape Wind Assocs., 373 F.3d 183 (1st Cir. 2004)[/b]
http://tinyurl.com/yahyep

[b]Massachusetts Attorney General Tom Reilly opts out of case over wind farm cables[/b]
http://tinyurl.com/ykmjzk

Do you oppose wind farms? If so, why? What would be your solution instead?

75 replies

by danlm

Talk about being two faced.

Where I just moved from 2 years, they fought for years to put wind farms on top of a mountain. This was Carbendale, Pennsylvania.

You heard every argument from spoil the view to protect the owls/birds. What a crock. All of it.

It's again, yes I support this technology. But not in my back yard.

This should be a campaign issue used against Edward Kennedy. For all his talk, he isn't willing to apply that to his own area where he lives. And if their are any Republicans opposing this, they should have the same done to them.

And they don't want us using fossil fuels, or searching for more. What do they want. God forbid if someone wanted to put up solar arrays in their area. Which in that climate, I know wouldn't work. But you get my point.

Dan

by jdclyde

not likely.

Any moron that has voted for him in the past is so completely retarded that he could kill someone again and it wouldn't matter.

He could get kicked out of college (oh yeah, he was!) and it wouldn't matter.

A real disgusting human, and anyone that WOULD vote for him has no standards in life and no brain.

by mjwx

is considerably less than the amount of birds killed by windscreens :)

My only concern about wind power is it depends on the wind, making it unreliable. But I live in a flat low lying country, I don't know what the wind is like in Pennsylvania.

by danlm

Nowhere did I read, and I followed this pretty close, anything that brought up scientific evidence why it shouldn't be placed there.

The only thing I can say for their argument against the windmills is that Pennsylvania is one of the largest old growth forest states in the US. Huge amounts of forest land, which means huge amounts of wild life. But, unlike oil rigs and other possible pollutant solutions. What harm can wind mill's do???? Noise pollution? In this area, numerous highways already detected that area.

Did it, or will it power the area. Nope, but it will contribute to the supply in a non pollutant manner.

Something else that is done in that area. There are numerous landfill's there(too many, butt ugly). They have started producing electricity with the methane gas from these landfills in old co gen plants. This has been a notable contribution to the electrical grid in that area. Taking the waste product produced by our garbage and producing electricity in a profitable manner. Wish more could be done like this.

Dan

by deepsand

The proposed windmill farms would have been [i]atop[/i] mountains. The mountains in question are world renowned for their wind currents, which are used by a great many species of birds, particularly as [i]flyways during migration[/i] seasons. These winds are so strong, reliable and far ranging that the area is a mecca for glider pilots.

Had the windmill farms been built astride the mountains, the toll on birds of prey would have been staggering.

One does not make the planet a better habitat by destroying that which gives it beauty.

by danlm

They built the windmills. You can see them from the highway.

Thats why I ask.

Dan

by benevolence

I certainly don't oppose wind farms, but I do think the locations need to be considered very carefully. People in areas that are NOT using high volumes of energy perhaps shouldn't have to be inundated with energy production technologies on their doorstep.

It would be an interesting experiment to see whether the wind effects created by sky rise developments could be harnessed within cities.

I think solar will eventually be the most useful (and renewable) source for our power needs. But we will need to refine the technologies used.

by tonythetiger

to the wind will cause the wind to slow down, maybe even stop! This could lead to increased smog (not necessarily all man-made) or even over prolonged periods a slowing down of Earth's rotation (which would, of course, lead to untold catastrophe).

I think we should spend several hundred billion studying these possible effects before we jump in with both feet :)

by Member 25348569

We put these things in carefully balanced sites where the prevailing wind blows in the opposite direction and they cancel each other out.

Can I have my hundred billion now, please?

:D

by jaqui

the idea, yes I support it.
the actual style of blade is where I have concerns, the old fashioned propeller style requires both more space and more wind to function than the new style tower blade system.

the tower blade system uses 6' square and is on average 65' tall.

the propellor blade system is on average 60' square and is as tall as the tower, so the "blades" clear any boats that are stupid enough to sail up to them.

the tower style, the blades are within a cage to protect anyone stupid enough to get that close.

the propellor style needs 20 mph winds minimum to generate power, the tower style 5 mph will do.

odds are that the wind farm is designed around the older style blade system.
[ utter stupidity ]

by drowningnotwaving

it's pretty funny isn't it?

You can put a wind-farm anywhere, just not in front of my view.

Hydroelectric power remains viable but we just can't build a dam anywhere any more.

Half the world's environmentalists are urging a review of nuclear, and the other half want them killed as heretics.

It's not unlike the oil companies saying that clean production and complete removal of chemical emmissions puts too much financial strain on them - like the fundamental demand will go down, or something.

We all reserve the right to be self-interested and greedy and demand compromise of the other side only.

Well I do anyway.

by jdclyde

and it shows that the farm is MILES out to sea.

It can't be seen from shore!

It isn't greed, is is hypocritical. Renewal able energy as long as THEY are not affected. Well, if THEY are the ones crying about the environment, then they should be willing to MAKE some changes for the good of the world.

But not Kennedy. Can't think of ANYONE in the US government that I respect less, past or present.

by tony hopkinson

I didn't like Ted Kennedy before I found out he was one, that he turns out to be a hypocrite on the issue as well, is barely a surprise.

by drowningnotwaving

Hypothetical . . .

You live in northern England. You've done well becuase you've studied / worked hard, got yourself a nice terrace with garage and flat-screen inside. All is good.

To cope with an ever expanding population and all the demands that entails, the local government in conjunction with Whitehall announces that a sewerage treatment and water-recycling plant is going into the parkland that just happens to abut your neighbourhood's local woods.

This will replace and update a facility that was basically built a century ago.

Anticipating complaints, the government has foreshadowed a not-totally-unreasonable buy-back scheme for houses within a 500 metre distance of the parameter or the new project.

And that line stops about 2 metres from your fence.

No complaints?

Of course, you could sell and get out. But you can't really because your house value just went down, pardon, the $hitter.

Seems to me NIMBYs come in all shapes and sizes and from pretty much any side of the political tree. And don't say you hate them too soon because given the history of government planning and foresight (in pretty much any country, century or under whatever political banner), the chances are ...

I mean, f' it, two dirty northern geordie bastards just moved in behind my place. World's really going to $hit.

by tony hopkinson

I'm going to look at what planning permission I need to get a wind turbine in my back yard. If I can get four I can sell power (1 = 30%).

So yes being green is not just pointing the finger at others it's doing what you can yourself .

Given the north south divide, it will soon be economical to build plants for treating southern $hit up here. Plenty of land about now we are a service economy instead of a manufacturing one. Given the practice we've had, we've got quite good at it. :D

You want to be up here in a hot summer when they start spreading chicken manure all over the local fields. A sewage plant would make the place smell better :D

PS I'm a yorkshireman , not all northerners are geordies.

PPS the only reason we are dirty , is because you southern monkeys used all your water up and then outbid for ours. :D

PPPS the only reason you out bid us, is because whitehall which is full of southern wusses, sold off our industry for cheap imports.

PPPPS. That hurt us badly because some southerners didn't want smelly heavy industry in their back yard. :D

by gadgetgirl

Two dirty northern geordie barstewards?

How are they dirty? Are you sure they're Geordies? Aren't you tarring all us Geordies with the same brush here?

We're normally found to be hard working, hard playing, friendly helpful folk. What have they done to you to deserve the above remark? Is it truly justified?

I'm a Geordie and proud of it. Yes, I'm northern, no, I'm not dirty (only in mind, and that's more raunchy type dirty) and my parents were most definitely married, and still are.

If you have problems with them, sort it, but don't tar us all with the same brush. You don't know us.

GG

by maxwell edison

...what "the issue", but they never want the solution. They don't want environmental solutions, because they'd lose the issue. It's not unlike their desire to keep people oppressed and victimized. They present themselves as the champions of the oppressed; and without oppressed victims, they have no issue.

by deepsand

You know that, as well as I do.

Yes, it may make for good press, but not for sound logic.

by jdclyde

The Dems had control for a long time, and nothing was ever done to lift people up, only to bring others down, so the people at the bottom won't feel as jealous.

We saw the poorest of the poor when New Orleans went under, in a CITY controlled by Dems, in a STATE controlled by Dems. How is this possible? doesn't that show you when Dems have their way, you only end up with the lowest of the low?

Actually, yes. It does.

And then there is always the old race card.....

by deadly ernest

NOT designed to suit the area. The plans I've seen for such set ups have been based on 'We've found a design and size we like, we'll set up to make that and put it in everywhere' process, when each should be designed from scratch for the environment in which it is. Also, where going up in populated areas, they should be designed to supply energy to the local population, not people hundreds of kilometres away. If set up right, you could greatly reduce the power on the grid, maybe even remove part of the grid as each region becomes independent.

If the devices make any noise, they will have an effect on the local wildlife and population, thus affecting the environment as they force changes in wildlife patterns.

If they want to put up wind farms as commercial operations, then let them do it as commercial operations. They buy the land at full commercial rate, and only use land available for sale for commercial usage. No tax subsidies either.

-----------

I've not been to Nantucket, but from what I've seen and read, it strikes me they would be better off using some sort of sea based electricity generators, either wave generators, or thermal variance units. No sounds, they just sit there doing their job, out of sight.

by benevolence

In Nantucket there may even be a place for tidal power generation.

"Unlike wind turbines, tidal turbines produce a constant, unpausing supply of clean, green electricity because they harness the tide in both directions.

They are in the sea and so do not produce an eyesore. There is virtually no limit to the number of turbines we can float."
- http://www.foe.co.uk/forum/index.php?topic=2581.0

also -
http://www.hie.co.uk/argyll/tidal_power.html

and -
http://www.environment-agency.gov.uk/aboutus/512398/289428/930386/?lang=_e

by Member 25348569

I don't think that they have a very large range from low to high - less than 10ft.

In the UK - the Bristol channel - we have up to 45ft tidal range and [b]still[/b] we're ignoring tidal and going for nuclear. Mad.

by delbertpgh

The WSJ, that famous anti-socialist rag, opposed this very project because the only way it was economical was by the huge tax breaks and subsidized rates it was entitled to collect. The Journal blamed the liberals, of course, for structuring the whole mess.

It is a plan to put money into private pockets by pulling it out of the taxpayers' pockets. Although JD sounds to me like a man who favors privatization, I'm guessing this is probably not in line with his principles.

by jdclyde

It was not long ago we heard people screaming because the government in America was not doing enough to clean up the environment.

Investing in the infrastructure and getting off of coal and such at any point is good for the country.

If investors get a return on their investment, they will actually INVEST. No one is going to do this for free, and any new structures take years to pay for themselves.

Are you saying we should not be going to clean energy just because someone might make a profit in the process?

If you still have a link to that article, can you post it?

For the record, I favor windfarms and tidal generators, and think they should be supported and encouraged. Even if the end user breaks even on their bill, it is about a cleaner way to generate the energy, not the end users cost savings that should be first concern here. Or did I miss the boat on the whole Environmental issue? Or was that just talking points that were not suppose to be taken seriously?

I won't stop driving, but I am as economical as possible. Same for electricity. After a few of these farms go up, it would be nice to see the coal plants get shut down, even though we would then have to deal with an entire industry possibly going under.

Question, if the WSJ is such an anti-socialist RAG, why are you reading it? And if you don't agree with the paper, why are you quoting it? Just wondering.

by delbertpgh

The author of the editorial in the WSJ, William Koch, is a one-time mechanical engineer, rich, and an investment manager. He wrote a guest editorial in the Wall Street Journal on May 22nd, but you have to pay to read it at WSJ.COM, so here's a link to a reprint on some save-our-beautiful-harbor website:
http://www.saveoursound.org/node/471

When the guy from Cape Wind replied to the article, he didn't dispute the economics; he simply ignored that part of the argument.

I'm persuaded that the Nantucket floating wind farm is a boondoggle that will only be profitable with public subsidies. That is, it will never earn a return on its own; it will only be profitable if tax money is turned into profits as some sort of gift. That isn't capitalism.

There are better ways to invest in new energy development than by subsidizing bad business ideas. This plan is like the subsidy of corn-based alcohol, which makes a taxpayer gift to Archer Daniels Midland, in return for a fuel that takes more petroleum to grow than it actually displaces.

I read the Wall Street Journal because they have great stories on the front page, and good reporting on business trends. Sometimes the editorial page has very good pieces by guest authors, and the pro-Bush screeds by the Journal editorial staff are always hilarious, and sometimes cleverly argued.

by gadgetgirl

says she knowing full well that you can't get to me by tomorrow! :p

And no, dear, I can't get to you, either.....

Why? 'cos of this.....

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/6198917.stm

You missed your chance again, Max.

]:)

Hey - when's this Scout Jamboree? August? I just bet it's when I'm taking Ma and Pa on holiday..... odds on bet, that one!

Never mind, Max, you can pop me an orgasmatron in the post instead...I'll think of you while I'm using it.....

;)

]:)

GG

Hmm. Fridayitis on a Thursday. Gawd help this place tomorrow... :D

by benevolence

Going back generations I do...

But one of my very favorite people in the world is a Geordie: Ross Noble!!! I am such a HUGE fan of his work. We have to share him nowadays, as he lives half in the UK and half in Oz.

by gadgetgirl

he's not a Geordie.

He's a Northumbrian! (Ok, my day to be pedant) But he's probably more conversant in Pitmatic, being from Cramlington, than Geordie.

(The school he went to there, btw, was about 400 yards from where I used to live!)

If he goes off on Ashingtonian and you can't understand it, let me know - I lived in Cram [he's right - dull, boring, blah] for five years when I was married.

If there's anything of his you can't get over there, let me know and I can send it over to you - the local Newcastle store constantly stocks all his DVDs!

He is brill, isn't he?!

GG

by florida_kes

Or are you simply trying to make something non-partisan into a partisan issue?

As far as if I support wind power or not, I support it.

But then again, I don't have ocean front property worth seven or eight figures that would be negatively affected by it either.

by danlm

Because it is on his ocean front lawn. What we, or least I am saying is that he promotes environmental issues... But, it's not good enough if it is where he lives.

Dan

by jdclyde

are all opposed to it.

Kenney as one of the highest ranking Democrats is a major voice for the democratic party.

When it goes for funding, he has already stated he is going to oppose this on procedural matters because it is the only loop hole left for him to exploit for his personal gain.

And it is MILES off the coast, so they will not even be seen from the shore.

Just wait to see who jumps on Teddy boys band wagon and decide for yourself if Democrats are really interesting in a clean environment of just keeping it as a campaign issue.

by Member 25348569

that he was playing a "what if" game with Tony H and chose badly for the example of "undesirables" moving in next door. He probably shouldn't have started the comparison at all but given that he couldn't go with a different race or colour he was a bit stuck.

As you are still the reigning Queen of TR, let's give him the chance to offer you a craven, crawling apology before you get Your Faithful Retainers (such as me) to rip him a spare orifice...

He'd probably have been safe to use Pikeys - or maybe Chavs - but I don't know if you've got as many of either of them up north as we have. There's sure as hell none of them posting on TR as I doubt either group can read...

No computers for a while as I'm off for a few days to see My Old Ma tomorrow morning - back after Boxing Day - so if I don't post before then, you have a great Christmas! :D

Neil :x

by gadgetgirl

just took umbrage at the Geordie reference, as I'm sure you well know and understand!

(not normally shoot first and ask questions later, but question my heritage and I go off on one! ;) )

Thankfully, you have most of the Pikeys and Chavs at your end of the country. This is not a hint - please keep 'em! Keep 'em all!

Offline? Prepared for withdrawal symptoms? Never mind, catch up when you can. Say hi to Ma for me, and give her all my good wishes for the season.

Merry Mithras babz, have a good time but watch out for low flying hangovers!

GG
:x

Watch out for a pm when you get back - my job is safe!

by drowningnotwaving

ha ha heheh ha - (thank you god) In this case a couple of northerners HAVE moved into the terrace behind us. They are dirty. They have empty boddys cans all over the place and a union jack in the back window. Disgusting.

Don't really know if they are actually Geordies. Could be scousers. All the same innit?

You surely couldn't have been thinking that I'd just be taking the pi$$ would you? :)

I mean, we haven't yet once mentioned the cricket ...

GG your paranoia, given this is how 3/4 of your own countryfolk refer to those of your general area, is understandable. I've seen the documentaries - The Bill, Eastenders etc. In this case, it's not the case.

Now, can we explore your own explanation of the 'dirty' bit in more detail? ]:)

And before you throw any other documentaries back at me I will get in first: Home and Away is exactly how we are - we all live on a beach, all the girls are cute, they all put out and any guy (no matter what he looks like) gets heaps.

by benevolence

Yeah, I have heard the Bristol Channel mentioned for potential tidal technology before. 45ft !!! That is huge!!! It would be PERFECT! and the systems tend to be so unobtrusive!

Hope your lobbying!

by benevolence

Surprisingly, the company I buy my electricity from often sends out information on how to REDUCE energy consumption.

This week, in a newsletter from this particular company (Energex Australia) we have been informed that:

1- you can choose to source your electricity from renewable sources for an extra $40.00aud a year, and this will be equivalent to NOT dumping 3545 'wheelie bins' (large flip-top, wheeled waste bins).

2- Walking or Cycling once a week instead of driving a car (averaged equivalent) reduces the burden on our planet by 893 bins.

3- Switching to energy efficient light bulbs reduces by the equivalent of 2172 bin loads.

4- Insulation to an 'R' value of 2.5 could reduce by an equivalent of 2307 bins.

5- Solar Hot Water instead of electrical... 6934 bins!

Those are significant reduction without any real hassles!

Interestingly, now in my city you HAVE to install solar if you are building a new house!

by jdmercha

There is no such thing. Any and all means of power generation will adversly affect the environment in one way or another.

by jdclyde

Environmental impact is almost nothing other than that it takes to MAKE the towers in the first place.

by deepsand

Just as dams alter the flow of water, resulting in changes in temperature and sedimentation rates, which, along with the physical impediment, impede the passage of animal life, as well as affecting aquatic plant life, etc., so too do windmills have their non-obvious and unintended consequences.

One [b]cannot[/b] remove energy from any system without altering the system as a whole.

There's no such thing as a free lunch.

by deepsand

Well, place them in birds' major flyways, and the harm will become evident soon enough.

A look at what ill placed dams have down to fish populations will serve to provide an example of how "harmless" human activities can have far ranging unintended consequences.

Remember the adage that "you cannot do just one thing."

by danlm

With congestion, noise pollution, and all the ill's that go with populated area's. I do not think that was an issue. Also, the elevation was not that high.

I've seen articles where the death's from bird's flying into high rise's were discussed.... Ie, NY. I would venture that these bird death's are much higher.

Dan

by deepsand

While the mountain peaks there may not tower above the valleys, the valleys themselves are a considerable height above sea level; the entire state of PA in increase in altitude as one moves from the Delaware Bay northward into New York.

Furthermore, that an area may be populated and "polluted" is of little consequence to migrating birds, as they are using the prevailing and favorable wind currents to transit over such areas, not to get to such areas.

by tony hopkinson

the amount of energy we took out of the system would have an impact.
Exactly what it's hard to say.

Just think we could end up having wars because the nation up wind sucked up all the moving air. :D

by deepsand

The amount of power available to be extracted is orders of magnitude greater than that of wind power; and, it is energy that would otherwise be dissipated ashore.

Harnessing tidal power would merely extract "waste" energy from the waves, and transfer it ashore for beneficial purposes, rather than have it do little more that erode beaches. Of course, one would have to ensure that a sufficient amount of wave energy remained for the natural replenishment of beaches, etc.; but, considering the gross inefficiencies involved, it would probably be unlikely that we could ever come close to overreaching.

by jdclyde

where are we going for lunch then?

Sure, it harnesses energy, but not releasing a harmful byproduct does have an appeal.

The option to do nothing because everything does something is not an option. Next option.

by benevolence

...but hey, I couldn't be stuffed figuring out that algorithm either!

By the way, that continually increasing resistance idea is not really an issue. For one, the wind does NOT make the world spin around! I am assuming you were being sarcastic?

by tonythetiger

but not entirely. If you remove energy from the wind, the wind obviously will be less able to do whatever it does, which could certainly affect something.

by jamesrl

I hear 50% of people are of below average intelligence. Horrors!

I heard that 50% of people are of below average incomes. Say it isn't so!

James

by delbertpgh

Way more than 50% of people earn "below average" incomes, because the average spreads the incomes of the very rich over everybody.

When Bill Gates walks into a tavern, the average butt on a barstool just got $200 million richer.

by benevolence

Yeah OK... but he calls himself a sort of Geordie.

In my opinion, he is the worlds best comedian by far... ever! His ability to free flow funny ideas is phenomenal (quite savant-ish)!

I may have to take you up on the sourcing of his DVDs some time... there aren't many available here.

Cheers GG!

by maxwell edison

Do you advocate taking the dollars that one group of people earned and give them to the people who earned less so you can make the outcome more equal?

by delbertpgh

Like, I don't believe in using nonsensical mathematical statements to support a point. The idea that "half of all people make less than the average" is foolishness. If nine people in a room have one dollar and one person has two dollars, then they all have an average $1.10 (eleven bucks divided by ten people). However, 90% of them have less than average, right?

Anybody who throws a number like that around like it means something deep about income distribution is perpetrating a fraud, right? And what about somebody who thinks that given an uneven distribution, the average divides the sample set exactly in half?

I hate fallacious reasoning, whether on the right or left.

by danlm

Ok, I know I'm straying off topic here a bit. But, we have seen alternate methods of energy being discussed. Perpetual wave action, solar, windmills, nucular. What about this article I just found:

[b]The technology dates to the 1920s, but today's prices make liquid coal for cars a live option. The result is an investment boom.[/b]
[url]http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/16299632/site/newsweek/[/url]

What I did not see in that article is if any conversion needs to be done to cars/planes/trains. Or, if the end product of liquid coal is suitable with the current combustion engines as we know them now. Chuckle, but then you would have the extremist tree huggers that want us back to rubbing sticks together not agreeing to this self reliance no matter how much eco friendly the extraction process is. And please read that this is addressed in the article. And also I am specifically leveling that statement at extremist eco individuals, not ones that look for a valid solution and insure that their concerns are addressed.

You know, kind of a side note to another topic going. Not being at the mercy of other nations for energy needs would go along way for this world to be a much safer place. We could step back from volatile Middle Eastern nations and tell them to get their act together without fear of our economy grinding to a halt over an energy crisis. Is that isolating ourselves, to a certain extent. But I think it is more of an economic pressure by just not needing their products which would cause them to come more in align with world opinion and practices.

Dan

by delbertpgh

As you say, gasoline from coal would improve our strategic position, not being at the mercy of bad luck or hostile regimes who could jeapordize our oil supply.

Germany in World War 2 used this process to make gasoline and aviation gas. It works, but it's a lot more expensive than refining petroleum. WW2 Germany and later South Africa used this technology because they were forcibly cut off from oil.

The article makes an odd statement that a car could run 30% "cleaner" using coal-sourced gasoline than with petroleum-sourced gasoline. (The "liquid coal" and gasoline are chemically the same.) This makes no sense to me, since the car and the gasoline are the same in both cases. It must be that they mean capturing the CO2 produced by the coal-to-liquid factory and storing it underground, as opposed to oil refineries that just vent it up the smokestack. Which is what the coal-to-liquid people do now, by the way; they just vent it into the atmosphere. The whole technology of storing carbon dioxide underground forever is still on the drawing boards, and not part of any actually existing factory process.

by danlm

With the price of a barrel of oil being as high as it is, this process is now comparable in cost.

As far as us not being at the mercy of hostile regions, I really do not see this as this completely removing our reliance on oil. I see this as just once peace of the removing our reliance on oil. Ie: Alternate fuels, electric, Liquid coal, and oil. If you have all of these factors coming into play for the same market then you now have competition instead of a monopolistic grip on your energy needs. Competitiveness would do a reality check on a lot of people. Hostile nations and oil companies come to mind first.

Dan

by deepsand

Many sites in the Applachian (PA) & Adirondack (NY) mountains, which are major flyways for migrating birds, had been selected as being ideal for windmill farms, with little or no envirnmental impact studies having been done.

Having grown up in Centre County, and having well traveled the surounding counties, including those between Centre County and New York, I am quite familiar with the avian species that populate the areas. The same winds that are favorable for glider planes are those which are used by the birds for long range soaring; and, it is these winds which are also quite amenable to generating wind power.

by deepsand

I am not one who can be described by the name of any political party.

But then, you already know that, and chose to ignore such.

by danlm

I read that from end to end due to another article I found the previous night.

[b]Russia Proves 'Peak Oil' is a Misleading Zionist Scam
While Moscow invests heavily in unlimited oil production for the future, New
York squanders America's dwindling oil profits on fast cars and fast women[/b]
[url]http://www.vialls.com/wecontrolamerica/peakoil.html[/url]

What interested me about this article, which is in contrast to one of the points that was raised in your article dealt with deep drilling.

What I found interesting about this article is they are saying that Russia feels that oil is manufactured in the mantle of the earth and slowly migrates up 75 to 150 miles. This article goes to say that the Russians have 300 wells to prove this theory.

Quote:
[i]The theory underlying how oil is formed at such enormous depths in the mantle of the earth is not central to this report, because the Russians have already proved its point of origin in absolute drilling terms more than 300 times. Those interested in the exact process should research the archives, where there are more than two hundred Russian papers on the subject. Probably a good place to start would be "The Role of Methane in the Formation of Mineral Fuels", written by by A.D. Bondar in 1967. What is central to this report is the massive advantage that Russia's ultra-deep drilling discoveries and technical achievements give it over the western nations.[/i]

Tell me what you think of this please, skip the political bashing of the report. That has nothing to do with why I read it.

Dan

by deepsand

It's interesting to note that the author, at several places, goes out of his way to state that proof need not be provided, as the Russians' alleged results constitute proof-of-concept. However, the author offers no proof of the claimed results either.

Had such results been attained, to the result of any meaningful production volumes, where did such oil go? Why has there been no evidence of such in the marketplace? Are we to believe that the Russians are simply hiding it all? And, if so, to what end?

Furthermore, even if such deep drilling did produce the claimed results, such does not, in and of itself, prove that oil is continuously and perpetually created.

Setting aside the obvious political bent, this has all the appearances of yet another claim to the discovery of an infinite energy source, not unlike the numerous claims to the invention of a perpetual motion machine.

Lastly, despite the author's claims that the "Peak Theory" conspirators suddenly appeared in 2000, a time most convenient for the author's purposes, the concept of an oil production peak had already been around for quite some time prior to 2000.

by danlm

But, I'm off to get my daughter tomorrow in PA so it wont happen. She will be with me for a week, so I can't see me being online for anything in that period of time. At least not much.

But, I did want a second opinion deepsand. And after watching your discussion with DE with regard to the Geneva Convention, I respect your opinion. Might not always agree, but I respect it.

I do remember reading where Russia said there was no such thing as an oil shortage, and this was recently in a news article. I also would like to follow up on the field they found in Vietnam that was referenced in this article, and see if what is claimed here is true.

His political rant was just not worthy of consideration. But, I try to listen/read with an open mind to the fact there may be some truth buried in what is being talked about. Most political ravings have some truth buried in them, if for no other reason then to lend credence to their warped logic.

Thanks for reading that though, and giving me your opinion.

I also remember reading in an article where well's that were thought to be finished were still producing quantities of oil, and they felt that it was due to it being replentished in some manner. This I seen in a news article and not some postings on the web. Point being though, it does lend some validity to this article.

Do I think there is a conspiracy, no. But, would I be surprised that due to penny pinching or long held mind set that not all avenues have been explored. That would not surprize me.

Dan

by deepsand

That deep drilling may be productive has nothing to do with how much oil is available at such depths. And, more importantly, how much is available is a question quite apart from how oil comes to exist.

With respect to deep drilling, keep in mind that Russia's economy is increasing becoming a command one, as it was during the existence of the Soviet Union. Oil production is one area in particular which is now very much so. And, that the government decides how much to spend on a program, and where, when and how, does not speak as to the advisability of such. It's a whole lot easier to waste monies collecting through taxes and extortion than it is to waste that of a corporation's shareholders.

As for the issue re. a limitless supply of oil, consider the following:

1) Oil is useful because we can easily extract thermal energy from it by reducing it to smaller chemical constituents, thereby releasing the energy that bound them together;
2) The creation of oil therefore requires energy as an input, so as to bind other molecules together into those chains of which oil is comprised;
3) There must be a source of energy to supply the input required per 2); and, therefore,
4) If the supply of oil is endless then so must be the supply of energy

An infinite energy source within the Earth? Perhaps, but highly improbable, given that the mass equivalent would then also be infinite, in which case the Earth would be traveling though space unaffected by the gravitational field of any other body, including the Sun; i.e., Earth would not be in orbit around Sol, but a solitary and barren voyager, accreting the masses of other bodies until it became a black hole.

On the other hand, perhaps black holes have a white hole counterpart, which acts as a quantum tunnel between sub-luminal and supra-luminal universea, with photonic energy therefore flowing from outside of our visible universe into ours, and such a white hole resides at the center of Earth. While that makes for good science fiction, it presently does'nt make good science fact. Still, ...

by deepsand

That deep drilling may be productive has nothing to do with how much oil is available at such depths. And, more importantly, how much is available is a question quite apart from how oil comes to exist.

With respect to deep drilling, keep in mind that Russia's economy is increasing becoming a command one, as it was during the existence of the Soviet Union. Oil production is one area in particular which is now very much so. And, that the government decides how much to spend on a program, and where, when and how, does not speak as to the advisability of such. It's a whole lot easier to waste monies collecting through taxes and extortion than it is to waste that of a corporation's shareholders.

As for the issue re. a limitless supply of oil, consider the following:

1) Oil is useful because we can easily extract thermal energy from it by reducing it to smaller chemical constituents, thereby releasing the energy that bound them together;
2) The creation of oil therefore requires energy as an input, so as to bind other molecules together into those chains of which oil is comprised;
3) There must be a source of energy to supply the input required per 2); and, therefore,
4) If the supply of oil is endless then so must be the supply of energy

An infinite energy source within the Earth? Perhaps, but highly improbable, given that the mass equivalent would then also be infinite, in which case the Earth would be traveling though space unaffected by the gravitational field of any other body, including the Sun; i.e., Earth would not be in orbit around Sol, but a solitary and barren voyager, accreting the masses of other bodies until it became a black hole.

On the other hand, perhaps black holes have a white hole counterpart, which acts as a quantum tunnel between sub-luminal and supra-luminal universea, with photonic energy therefore flowing from outside of our visible universe into ours, and such a white hole resides at the center of Earth. While that makes for good science fiction, it presently does'nt make good science fact. Still, ...

by bhel.rocks

Found a cool article online
thought maybe you guys will be ineterested

While the world is trying to offset its carbon emissions, many businesses are stuck in the trendiness of transporting their people around for unsubstantiated reasons now that the virtual office is a reality.

The change we need as a society needs to start at the top with the CEO's. Not only would it save our environment, but it could help our businesses in this tricky economy get a bit more cashflow. Often a consultant or travelling manager's monthly travel bill can be anywhere from $5,000 to an easy $20,000 a month. Imagine the carbon emissions just to make an appearance in a cube and do a few face to face meetings! As the big three get turned down for their handout because they took their private jets.... it would be beneficial and a good cost cutting measure if they might think twice about a few things:

1. Can this business be established over the internet or a conference call?

2. What really is the reason why we're sending our people on a plane?

3. Could we use the money we use travelling for other things the business needs?

http://www.findgreenstuff.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=1776:companies-need-to-redefine-travel-needs&catid=10:green-business&Itemid=46

This discussion is closed to new replies.