10 replies
by thechas
There are a LOT of variables involved.
Performance differences are VERY dependant on the task being performed.
Raw math tasks will be close to the CPU speed difference.
Tasks that transfer a lot of data on the ISA and PCI busses will not bevery different at all.
(ISA = 4.7MHz PCI = 33MHz)
Programs that take advantage of new commands in the P4 will execute a lot faster on the P4 than they will on the P1. (If they run at all on the P1)
Generally speaking, doubleing CPU speed results in a 15% to 25% increase in performance.
The largest mathmatical difference between the 2 CPUs is in the BUSS speeds.
This is the speed that all the external tasks run at.
With the 533MHz on the P4 versus the 60MHz of the P1 90MHz, you get nearly 9X the data transfer rates to the system buss and memory.
Here is a link for some CPU benchmark comparisons
http://www.cpuscorecard.com/index.htm
Of course, between systems with a P 90 and P4 2.4G there will be a number of other differences that come into play:
HDD data rates: 15MB vs. 133MB
Video data rates: 33MHz (PCI) vs. 120MHz (AGP)
Bottom line, yes you could come up with a formula, but accounting for ALL the variables would be a major task.
Chas
by thechas
A couple more thoughts:
RAM will make a big difference.
W95 can slow down with over 196MB of RAM.
XP is just getting started with 256MB.
W95 will not even load on many P4 motherboards.
Chas
by radford.mark
by authorship
Perhaps the more important question is why justify it at all? If your workload is getting by now on such an old CPU and upgrade justification IS necessary, why take the budget hit? How about a smaller step up and save money, such as an Athlon 2000+ system. It will come with a far larger disk and more memory, not to mention a supported OS and should last even longer than the P90 lifecycle at your shop.
You didn't mention if you are replacing hundreds of PC's or just a couple. Or if some new application is driving the upgrade, in which case justification will be self apparent. If only a handful you can probably justify upgrading a few powerusers and retask the displaced PC's to replace the P90-based system.
by radford.mark
by djent
by radford.mark
by guruofdos
by radford.mark
by radford.mark
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending Hardware posts
Sort by Trending