Question Locked

Computer won't boot windows after ram installation

0 helpful
16 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hello,

I recently installed Windows XP...and had a fair amount of trouble installing it with a 2.93Ghz Processor, 1024 MB PC3200 (2x 512 MB PC3200), a G4MX440-VTP graphic card, and a Samsung 80GB HDD. During the Windows XP installation, I got a few bluescreen errors (two or three different ones)...one of the three was something about being unable to write to memory (or something along those lines). At that point I took out one of my Ram Dimms. (Don't ask why...it was four in the morning) in any case, I was able to install Windows just like that. After it was done installing, I tried adding the other Dimm back in. But the Computer would never boot to Windows. I tried switching the Dimms...but the same result. What is wrong? Upgrading Ram should be the easiest of all upgrades...what am I doing wrong? Or what can I do?

Thanks

16 replies

by daveo2000

Test booting with each memory stick and see if you can repeat the problem. Label one (with tape?) as "A" and the other as "B".

If "A" alone always works and "B" alone always doesn't and "A" and "B" together don't then you probably have your answer.

If they are intermittant then it could be the second memory slot is damaged or dirty or you aren't seating the DIMMs properly.

by nikolai.hobruecker

That's definetly worth a try...as far as wrongly set DIMMs are concerned, is that even possible if Windows akwnoledges a total of 1024 MB? (in the memory test and in the bios). Or would Windows not see the second DIMM whatsoever if I've seated it wrong?

by langlier

1. Get a RAM test (microsoft has a free memory test on its website and there are many others available). Download it and verify that this is a RAM problem (could also be hd, or media (in this case your windows disc) issues. I believe you are on the correct path with the ram but its always best to eliminate everything.

2. after labeling your ram as noted above also keep track of which slot your RAM is in. sometimes slots go bad and this is more of a pain then if the RAM does.

3. Use the memory tester to verify if it is slot or ram. putting one chip at a time into one slot at a time.

by daveo2000

I have seen hardware where some pins acknowledge hardware configuration and such (PnP setting, for instance) and other (or more) pins do the actual operations. If that is the case then it could query the DIMMs for size spec but fail upon talking to the specific area of the DIMM that is faulty.

by nikolai.hobruecker

I've tried booting into safe mode...but it's exactly the same. Or rather, I get to the 'welcome screen' in safe mode (in other words the black screen with "safe mode" in each corner and the cursur in the middle) but that's as far as I get.

by yongsp01

if you can log in to the safe mode try uninstall some of the driver, if still not able to boot to normal mode, properly is the ram problem, you can try change to a new ram and see how.

by kunal.khandait

Hi,
It seems that problem is with hard disk or any other component ( including Windows CD). It would be better if you send the blue screen error message to us. It would provide us Clue about cause of problem. Primarily problem seems to be with Hard disk either it is full or damaged so that there is write error.

by nikolai.hobruecker

Alright,

I havn't run any Windows test on the ram itself as I don't have a cd/dvd-rw drive OR a floppy drive. I'll get my roommate to burn me a cd though. In the meantime, I did the DIMM/Slot test.:

DIMM-------Slot
A--------------1 (good)
A--------------2 (good)
B--------------1 (good)
B--------------2 (good)
A+B--------1+2 (respectivly) - reboots w/o showing Windows "welcome screen". (same result after 3 runs)
B+A--------1+2 (respectivly) - gets to "welcome screen" but hangs there. (same result after 3 runs)

After taking DIMM B out, I restarted, was able to load Windows, and got a popup msg saying that Windows hat to replace a file in the registry, and that the replacement was a success. (Not the exact english error msg...translated from german - so please excuse the poor translation)

Computer works fine, but why did I get the error message and why do the DIMMs respond differently when (together) in different 'formations'?

by daveo2000

Thanks for the good test info. I am asking HAL 9000 (Col) to look at this since he is better at deeper Windows questions.

This still sounds to me like a potential issue in the DIMMs with memory boundaries affecting any parity checking but that may be just my older bias.

While waiting for Col to answer, send your test results to the DIMM manufacturer and see if they have any helpful hints and let us know their answer.

Also, a more invasive memory checking program could be very useful. Check the other poster's mention of a memory checker. You can check the DIMMs one at a time by booting up with 512M each time.

by hal 9000

If this is a desktop the answer is still the same you are seeing a RAM Incompatibility. These are likely to pass static Checks A OK but when exposed to a Dynamic Test should fail. So you'll need to look at the RAM test that you are using if you had an CD Drive I would suggest The Ultimate Boot CD to do the Open Ended RAM Test with but I think that you can solve this quickly and without the time delay.

The most likely option is that if each RAM Stick works by itself but not together is that the RAM is a different speed and is running into Timing Issues which is preventing the system from loading properly and falling over in the process.

When using NB I always use the same spec & Brand RAM and replace 2 sticks at a time to prevent problems like this from happening.

If possible look for some decent Brand Name RAM I always use Corsair RAM but Kingston is good as well but I avoid the unbranded OEM RAM that is so common as it has issues with the different timing speeds and Parity Checks that the Named RAM doesn't have.

I do know that Corsair has RAM Sets for NB's that have matched Pairs of RAM that are specially made for working together not sure if Kingston does as I can not buy it where I am but it should work as well as the Corsair does.

But for best value I find that the Corsair Value Select works the best for everything and is a reasonable price as well. The only time that I don't use this type of RAM is when I'm using Parity Checked EEC RAM and then I use the slightly more expensive Corsair RAM which just works without a second thought.

I've seen people spend days attempting to get incompatibility issues worked out and they eventually buy a matched set of Corsair RAM and they never have a problem again once it is fitted so it tends to work out better and faster to just replace both sticks with the same Brand, Speed RAM and allow the system to work without any issues creeping in to cause problems. The Life Time Guarantee doesn't hurt one little bit either.

Col

by nikolai.hobruecker

Alright, I want to clear one thing up first. Although it's (I'm pretty sure about this) unbranded OEM RAM, both DIMMs are 512 MB PC3200, both from the same company and they DID once work together. I still havn't done a RAM test, which is going to be my next step, but if the test still comes up with the same results as I've had until now...what could possibly be the issue? All I've changed since both DIMMs worked together is the power source (400 W from 350 W - got it for free, otherwise I would have got myself a 550), graphic card, and optical drives. Motherboard, CPU, Harddrive (although newly formated) are all the same.

I'll do the RAM test, and posted the results back up here, but please let me know if there is something else that could possibly do to solve the problem (other than buying new RAM).

Thanks.

by hal 9000

You didn't say previously that this was working only that when you added the second RAM Stick it didn't work.

If all you changed was the Power Supply try changing back to the older one if it's still working and see if it now works and check the Optical Drives are actually listed in My Computer or Explorer when Windows is running with the 1 X 512 MEG of RAM installed.

If you are at all concerned by the ability of the power supply to supply enough power disconnect one of the Optical Drives and try it like that but as you have said previously that you had no optical drives it sounds as if they are either not working at all or you have not as yet tried to get them working.

With any IDE drive you need to set them to Master or Slave on the Jumper beside the IDE Lead this is generally a green piece of Plastic that shorts out 2 pins and gives the drive different settings the Master always goes on the end of the IDE Lead and the Slave goes on the Middle connector.

It would help here if you where to list all the problems that you are actually having and what you have done as from your original question it sounded as if you have just attempted to add a second stick of RAM and the system was now not working. That along with the no Optical Drives or Floppy tended to make it sound like a NB that you where having a problem with.

Now what you need to do is tell us what you have and what it is you have done so that it is possible to answer your question properly or at least have some idea as to what is happening.

Col

by nikolai.hobruecker

Alright, sorry that it took this long to respond, but here it is.

My computer:

2.93 Ghz Intel Celeron Processor, MSI P4MAM2-V Motherboard Socket 478, 2 x 512MB Samsung PC3200 DDR RAM (only one installed), Samsung 80GB Hard Drive ATA, Maxtor DiamondMax Plus 9 160GB Hard Drive ATA, Samsung SD-608 DVD-ROM (currently seen from Windows as a CD-ROM...I don't know why) an ATI Radeon 9550 256MB DDR, an NEC OHCI-konformer IEEE 1394-Hostcontroller and a VIA VT6421 RAID Controller (not working like it should either). Power supply is a P4-400W DY01-400W-XDL.

Current Problems:
a) I can only use one of the 2 RAM DIMMs at a time.
b) DVD-ROM drive seen as a CD-ROM drive.
c) RAID Controller won't acknowledge any IDE devices attachted to it. (I don't have any S-ATA drives to test the S-ATA ports). Message in RAID utility: "No stand-alone disk and No usable disk array attached, please check if any disk arra is broken."

What I've done:
a) For the RAM problem:
Booted the system with each DIMM in every possible configuration. Results: Windows will boot with each DIMM alone, regardless of slot. Together, Windows will never start, also regardless of which DIMM is in which slot. Temporary solution: Only using one DIMM.

b) For the optical drive problem:
Re-installed the drivers from the Samsung website. But nothing changed.

c) For the RAID Controller:
Updated and installed the newest drivers and utility tool for the card, attached both hard drives, and the one optical drive to the IDE port on the controller. No acknoledgement of an attached device.

Hopefully this will help you guys help me better. Thanks.

by hal 9000

http://tinyurl.com/2cg28q

[i]Due to the High Performance Memory design, motherboards or system configurations may or may not operate smoothly at the JEDEC (Joint Electron Device Engineering Council) standard settings (BIOS Default on the motherboard) such as DDR voltage, memory speeds and memory timing. Please confirm and adjust your memory setting in the BIOS accordingly for better system stability.
Example: Kingston HyperX DDR500 PC4000 operates at 2.65V, 3-4-4-8, CL=3.
For more information about specification of high performance memory modules, please check with your Memory Manufactures for more details.[/i]

This is fairly straight forward and you need to look up the RAM specs and set them in BIOS to have them work correctly.

As for the DVD Drive being seen as a CD Drive forget about this as it is unimportant sometimes windows does this till a DVD or several are placed into the drive or the necessary patches are applied. When all is said and done an optical drive is an optical drive an the DVD Drive no matter how Windows is seeing it will play/record either CD or DVD.

Now I don't know if you have given me the correct M'Board Number as the MSI P4MAM2-V doesn't support SATA Drives according to the Makers Web Site and it will only be on SATA Drives that you can configure the RAID setup. You really need to read the manual for this M'Board.

Col

This discussion is closed to new replies.