Question Locked

Corrupted External HD...how to recover data?

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I properly ejected my Western Digital Passport (120GB SILVER USB 2.0) from my mac so that I could plug it into my friend's computer (also a Mac). However, upon insertion of the usb, the message "Disk Insertion: The disk you inserted was not readable by this computer." I tried it on my friend's pc, but although it recognized that the harddrive was inserted, I wasn't able to access it.

If my drive is somehow corrupted, is there any way to recover the files and fix my harddrive? I have many important file that I would not like to lose.

Please help!! Thanks!

5 replies

by jszivos

I'd buy a new enclosure for an external usb drive and put the old hard drive into the new case OR I'd remove the hard drive and physically connect it to the inside of your computer into the slave connection. Hopefully the hardware that modulates the connection from ATA/SATA to USB broke or is malfunctioning. I come across a lot of external USB harddrives that have this problem.

IF the hard drive is actually corrupted then you are fucked. Unless, you want to spend the $100s to pay some company to restore your data, or invest the money in data recovery software (that usually sucks). I hope that if it's broken then it didn't have important information AND that it's still warrantied. GL.

by mdhealy

Stop right now. This disk drive should not be connected to power again before it is in the hands of a technician at a data recovery company, because at this point attempts to fix the problem by a person who is not a data recovery specialist have a severe risk of making matters worse and destroying data that could have been recovered.

Your friends and local computer shops are not data recovery specialists, no matter how good they are technically, because if there is a hardware problem the drive must be opened up and that can only be done in a special "clean room." Ordinary environmental dust will instantly destroy the drive if it is opened up in an ordinary room. Unfortunately, these special filtered "clean rooms" can cost more than most houses cost, so only specialized data recovery companies can afford them.

I fear I cannot give specific recommendations for data recovery companies because I've always made regular backups so have never needed one -- when a disk dies I simply get a new disk and restore from backups.

Good luck.

by jszivos

Data recoveries are EXPENSIVE. I don't recommend you invest your time and money in data recovery unless you harddrive contains extremely important data. As I said, I highly recommend that you attempt to troubleshoot the problem if you don't want to spend the $100s. We encounter corrupted harddrives on a weekly basis at my job and RARELY do we send the drives away to get recovered. It's typically not worth the investment for the company. Also, sometimes a data recovery specialist cannot retrieve all data from a faulty harddrive.

This discussion is closed to new replies.