Discussion Locked

DDR vs RAMBUS

0 helpful
12 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I AM BUILDING A HIGH END COMPUTER FOR RENDERING
I HAVE TWO MOTHERBOARDS IN MIND. SUPERMICRO P4DC6 DUEL XEON 2.2G P4 AND 16G DDR RAM. THE OTHER BOARD IS A SUPERMICRO P4DC6+ DUEL XEON 2.2G P4 AND 4G RD RAM. WHICH MEMORY IS THE BEST FOR THE JOB? DOES DDR RAM HAVE AN INTERFERECE PROBLEM?

12 replies

by shanghai sam

Hi,

DDR memory is just now becoming as fast as RAMBUS memory. RAMBUS is very much a dying breed, but currently better bedded in at 400Mhz bus speeds. It may be a couple of months before we see stable DDR2 at that speed.

See the following article for advancements on DDR...

http://story.news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&cid=73&u=/zd/20020321/tc_zd/5105153

(remove spaces from the above URL)

But taking two steps backwards and looking at your question... You may be going overboard on your CPU power?

Your rendering will largely be done by your graphics card unless the software you're using insists on doing the rendering itself! Make sure you spend mucho money on the graphics card!!

What software and graphics card were you goingto choose?

Either way, no matter what you buy today, in as little as one year it will be slow by comparison, so one strategy is to move away from super expensive leading edge technologies and go with slightly cheaper less powerful options, but upgrade much more frequently. If thats the case then its important to go for technologies that have a future - like DDR!

To put that into perspective, you may spend half your money now and get a very fast system, but not the fastest possible - and then in 6 months, upgrade with some of the remainder and get a system that is even faster than the one you were considering right now! Then continue to do that each 6 months!!

Of course if money is no object, the go for super expensive leading edgetechnologies AND upgrade frequently. RAMBUS is your baby. For today.

Cheers,
Tim.

by timthetoolman

Hi,

Sorry for the double post, but sometimes TechRepulic loses the ID of the answerer...

DDR memory is just now becoming as fast as RAMBUS memory. RAMBUS is very much a dying breed, but currently better bedded in at 400Mhz bus speeds. It may be a couple of months before we see stable DDR2 at that speed.

See the following article for advancements on DDR...

http://story.news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&cid=73&u=/z d/20020321/tc_zd/5105153

(remove spaces from the above URL)

But taking two steps backwards and looking at your question... You may be going overboard on your CPU power?

Your rendering will largely be done by your graphics card unless the software you're using insists on doing the rendering itself! Make sureyou spend mucho money on the graphics card!!

What software and graphics card were you going to choose?

Either way, no matter what you buy today, in as little as one year it will be slow by comparison, so one strategy is to move away from super expensive leading edge technologies and go with slightly cheaper less powerful options, but upgrade much more frequently. If thats the case then its important to go for technologies that have a future - like DDR!

To put that into perspective, you may spend half your money now and get a very fast system, but not the fastest possible - and then in 6 months, upgrade with some of the remainder and get a system that is even faster than the one you were considering right now! Then continue to do that each 6 months!!

Of course if money is no object, the go for super expensive leading edge technologies AND upgrade frequently. RAMBUS is your baby. For today.

Cheers,
Tim.

by thechas

While RAMBUS is technically faster memory, DDR based systems achieve higher performance.

Check out the DDR vs RAMBUS articles at www.viaarena.com

This has been part of why the AMD Athlon systems have been stomping on the P4 systems.
Now that Intel is giving up on RAMBUS, I am afraid that AMD will loose most of it's performance advantage.

So, even though the rated speed is slower, you will get better data throughput on the DDR system.

by the_ripper

Amd duel cpu board 2X amd athlon 2000+MP 4x512 pc2100 ddr rating 2 matrox rt2500 + matrox duel head g450 gpu 4 x 40 gig 7200 rpm drives make a duel mirror to get the transfer rate this is the main problem to over come its not the memory problem its the speed of the drives and the through put which counts 2 mirrors of 80 gig each should give you plenty of room for manipulating huge pieces of work. make 2 static drives and 2 pull outs for security purposes.Also aquire adobe premiere 6 an essential ingredient to the whole picture. ive managed to streem 8 hours of vid without dropping a single frame using a setup far inferior to this 2 p3 700 2 gig pc133 and the rest the same I now use duel 10.000rpm ultra 160 drives and a 29160 scsi disk controller My system never fails me. I make and produce video for the Northern Arts Council

by yacco

If you use a P4 for rendering and want to do it today, use RDram. It is faster with the P4 beyond 2gz. Your video card will NOT be doing the rendering as suggested, you will be creating a file during your rendering, not a realtime display. You will want a video card that is appropriate for displaying your completed content.

by timthetoolman

Hi,

Even though this is a dead question.... To address the above point about the graphic card not doing the rendering... Well that depends on whether the rendering will be done in real time or not, wont it!

You obviously have two options here...

1. Produce a AVI from video editing and image enhancement in which case the CPU does the rendering.

2. Produce a 3D simulation involving lighting effects, textures and so on. Like in a game! In this case, the GPU does the work...

This discussion is closed to new replies.