That's kind of like saying "is Honda more reliable than Toyota?" - It depends on the model of the system (particularly its components) and the specific PC in question. In fact, the software you install and the computing practices you employ will make a great difference as well (maybe the greatest difference)...so there is no hard and fast answer to the question.
That said, Dell is riding pretty high these days and I know a lot of people swear by them. I don't dislike them, but am not overly impressed. In fact, I'm not *especially* impressed with any of the major manufacturer's PCs today. The trend seems to be for cranking out the least expensive box you can (for volume) rather than using robust high-quality components. Until I see a manufacturer that really impresses me again (the last one was Digital), I'll build my own PCs. That way I can choose the components I want and tailor the machine to my needs (OS, software, etc).
If you don't want to build your machine (or have a pro build one for you) then Dell or Gateway are pretty good choices.
Here is a good link to comparisons, reports, etc on Dell, Gateway and others. Hope this helps!
http://computers.cnet.com/hardware/0-1017.html?tag=st.re.9870989.dir.1017
(delete any spaces in the URL)
Good luck....