Discussion Locked

Determining if a card is bad.

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

How could I check for a bad card.
ex. If a computer has been exposed to a surge, I want to find out which boards have been fried. Besides trying to configure each board in another PC, is there a way (using software, equipment or tools) complete this check? I am not and electical engineer, so using some sort of HIGH END equipment is not in my buget.
Thanks for any help.

5 replies

by pcjockey2000

If it was a serious surge you can look at the card carefully and see if there are any blown circuits. We got a serious surge on our phone system and it fried the capaciters on the cards. You could see the burn marks.
For lesser surges it dependson the card. The cheapest way if you have other computers and cards to play with, is to test components by either putting a known good card into a potentially bad PC, or putting a possibly bad card into a known compatible PC and see if they work. Your choice depends on which you think is bad, the computer or the card. Most cards are so complex that using a mulitmeter would not be beneficial unless you really knew what you were looking for. One thing to check is that there may be diagnostics for each card on the software installation disk that came with it. Network and sound cards are especially good about diagnostics.

Hope this helps.

by geroxx

I have to agree with the above post.

It has been my experience that it is easier to test the cards in a known good system. I have also used (or tried to use) some of the diagnostic cards/software. Most of the time I find that they were not worth the hundreds of dollars that they cost. And, I mean HUNDREDS of dollars. I think that if you are looking at a system that will boot up you might have some luck using regular old Norton System Works. It has a diagnostic program. Unfortunatly, when I really need it I find that my system will not even boot or get past POST. Another problem with using diagnostic programs are that they don't tell you what is wrong with a card but only that it is failing.

I find that the simplest way to T.S. a problem is with a known good system.

Gary

This discussion is closed to new replies.