12 replies
by westdodge
I've never used Cable Select because I've never had that type of cable. It seems to be a concept that hasn't taken off. I always do it the old master/slave way with the jumpers and a normal 40 opin cable. Here are a couple links that better explain it:
http://www.firmware.com/support/bios/cablesel.htm
http://www.gsi-inc.com/products/gsicsel.html
by westdodge
(That should read: "40 pin cable." Here's another explanation site:
http://users.netropolis.net/djsmith/cable.htm
by getclyde
by pschuvie
I really think this is a topic that is very much misunderstood and how it is/can be of benefit in the growing data storage on PC arena. That said here are some very good resources that I think can give you a FULL feeling regarding this subject area.
Enjoy the reading and the potential excitement from really knowing what it going on.
http://www.gsi-inc.com
http://www.gsi-inc.com/products/gsicsel.html
http://www.gsi-inc.com/products/csel.html
http://www.firmware.com/support/bios/cablesel.htm
http://www.storagereview.com/guide2000/ref/hdd/if/ide/confCS.html
http://thef-nym.sci.kun.nl/cgi-pieterh/atazip/atafq.html
note: as always all links were tested good before posting but wrapping stuff happens.
by getclyde
by dirk.deprest
All newer IDE/EIDE hard drives can be jumpered as Cable Select (CS or CSEL). This is an alternate way to indicate which drive is master and which drive is slave (instead of jumpering one drive as master and one drive as slave). Cable Select jumpering requires a special IDE cable with pin 28 not connected to one of the drive connectors, which would configure the drive attached to that connector as the slave drive.
Cable Select jumpering is not widely used now, but may become more common as things move more towards Plug and Play, as this is part of the ATA PnP standard and Microsoft's PC97 standard. The idea is that drives can be installed easily without having to change jumpers on two drives anytime a drive is installed or removed. Cable Select is defined in the ATA-2 and ATA-3 specifications.
In order to use Cable Select jumpering, several conditions must be met. Both drives on a channel must support CSEL, both drives must be jumpered as CSEL, a CSEL cable must be used, and the host interface connector must support CSEL. For the host interface to support Cable Select, pin 28 must be grounded.
Although the Cable Select specification may simplify things in the future, there will probably be lots of confusion, especiallyon legacy systems, as this starts to be introduced. One problem will be in selecting the correct cable. Supposedly, the cables used for Cable Select will be clearly marked, with each connector labeled as Device 0 (or Master) or Device 1 (or Slave). If not clearly marked, it may not be easy to identify a CSEL cable visually. Pin 28 can be checked for continuity.
by getclyde
by dirk.deprest
CONT. ANSW 1
A Cable Select cable can be constructed in various ways. Pin 28 may be nonconnected to the connector at the end of the cable or to the connector in the middle of the cable. Another design would have the host interface connector in the middle and the two drives would plug into each end of the cable, with the connector at one of the ends not connected to pin 28.
If both drives are set for CSEL and the host interface supports CSEL, but a regular cable is used, both drives will be seen as master.
A Cable Select cable can be used with master/slave drive jumpering.
Another problem will be with host interfaces on legacy motherboards and controller cards. If pin 28 is not grounded on the host interface, drives connectedto either connector on the CSEL cable will be seen as slave. It will be common to find that pin 28 is open or high on many older IDE interfaces. This can be checked with a voltmeter.
by getclyde
by dmiles
Cable Select
The Cable Select (CSEL) Feature has been in the ATA/IDE specification quite some time,yet never implemented.It boils down to the original definition of cable select which created confusion over drive letters when a second drive was added
Concerns was that a user added a second drive,the drive that used to be known to the software as Drive C:,would now be known as Drive D:The new drive would take the Drive C: position of the cable,but this would leave an empty data cable position at the end that could create noise and cause data integrity concerns.
The goal of cable select is to eliminate the master/slave jumpers.
CSEL is a special cable-To use cable select,both devices on the channel are set to the cable select (CS) setting usually by a special jumper,The cable is similar in most respects to the regular IDE/ATA cable,except for the CSEL signal.CSEL is carried on wire #28 of the stanard IDE/ATA cable,and is grounded at the host's connector.
On a cable select cable,oneof the connectors (the master connector)has pin #28 connected through to the cable,but the other (the slave connector)has an open circuit on that pin.
Unfortunately,regular 40-conductor IDE/ATA cables don't support cable select.
More info can be read at the following sites
www.pcguide.com/ref/hdd/if/ide/conf_CS.html
www.gsi-inc.com/products/gsicel.html
by getclyde
by getclyde
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending Hardware posts
Sort by Trending