Discussion Locked

Dual Pentium 4 vs Single Xeon

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I am looking to upgrade some CAD workstations that use processor intensive 3D apps. We are a small org so cost is a large factor. I am considering a dual P4 or a single Xeon config but can't find any info on which is better. Can anyone help?

5 replies

by freetech

a lot depends on how your software is coded.
if it is older (pre p4) then it will probably run on the xeon better.
if the software is VERY new, then it may be optimized for the p4. in that case, you'd want to go with the p4's.
the last item to consider is whether the software can use both processors. it has to be written specifically to use dual processors, otherwise it just uses one cpu and ignores the other.
most cad software is written for dual processor support but only the newest software is coded take advantage of the p4.
check with your software vendor or support site to see if it is optimized for p3, p4 or dual p4's.
rule of thumb is to get the best hardware that you can afford, especially if you're paying someone to operate it.
time is money.
hope this helps.

by csmith

The memory on the Video Card, the Video Card Chip, and the amount of memory are as important, if not more important than the CPU.
The Video Card should have a minimum of 64 Meg, and system RAM should be at least 512 Meg for ProE.
A good Video CardChip can outrender any PC CPU.
We still set up most workstations with a single CPU, because putting the money into the Video Card is more cost effective, where there are tight budget restraints.
Regards, Chris

This discussion is closed to new replies.