Have you added any more to this Initial Session?
If you have it is possible that Roxio has made the previous Burn Invisible as it's rewritten the Partition Tables. This is quite common with Roxio and part of the reason why I no longer use it.
When you originally burnt the Disc how has it been stored since?
If it has been exposed to direct sunlight on the Data Side it is possible that the Disc was wiped as the dye was affected.
Basically what's altered since you could last access the Data that is supposed to be on this Disc?
They are not Permanent Storage even under Ideal Conditions, Kodak recommends reburning CD media every 5 Years to prevent degradition of the Images stored on Burnable CD's and rendering them useless. Under less that Ideal conditions this 5 year can be considerably shorter and I personally had one Disc erased in under an hour because the person who took it didn't carry it in the car safely. Throwing it on the Dashboard data side up in our Summer and driving home rendered it useless by the time he got home. A trip of about 20 miles.
Granted that was a bit extreme but it can happen that quickly if not stored correctly. ;)
Col