Question Locked

Estimating Workstation Specs

0 helpful
3 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Anyone have any idea on how to make a rational estimate for CPU, RAM, Graphics for a workstation that must do the following?

System Requirements

This list contains the minimum requirements necessary for PBS TeacherLine courses. You may use higher versions of software or faster internet connections, if desired.

Internet access via a 56k modem
Internet Explorer or Netscape, version 6.0 or above, Firefox, or Safari
RealPlayer 8
Windows Media Player X
Flash 5 Player
Shockwave Player
Adobe Acrobat Reader
QuickTime
Java 1.4.2.

I mean, do I add up the individual memory requirements for each individual application? And what about graphics - which is the biggest hog in this bunch?

3 replies

by mr.wiz

are not that exacting. Most any modern computer would run all of these without difficulty. I'd run at least a 256 MB graphics card, 1-2 GB of RAM and a core 2 or equivalent processor, but those are more personal preferences. Even the $599 Dell's will run all of this without problems.

by hal 9000

New Systems/hardware or building from second hand parts.

If it's new hardware any of what is currently available will meet the needs stated above though I would recommend against using Celeron CPU's and all in one M'Boards with Video on them as I've found them more unreliable than M'Boards with a separate Video Card and even then you will be pushing things to find anything below a 256 MEG Video Card. Depending on where you are there may be a few 128 MEG Video Cards available but as the difference in costs in minimal if not cheaper to go with the 256 MEG units for the sake of uniformity I would go with what you know you can get more of if required so that you have a uniform setup across the entire place.

I would also recommend to get the best performance to use 2 sticks of RAM so that the CPU's work to 100% capacity and decent Power Supplies and cases if the budget will stretch to these the PS are important and while the cases are nice they are also far more solid than the cheap no name cases that flex and bend out of shape so if you can afford these Antec Cases or something of similar quality would be a better investment and Antec or similar quality PS's will be cheap insurance for the computers as they protect the internals far better than anything else that you can buy and are much cheaper than putting in place a decent Power Filter.

As for second hand you will need to look at the minimum requirements of the OS and then go at least 50% bigger in CPU Speed and at least 100% in Memory. The rest will be limited by the M'Boards that you are using but I wouldn't be recommending anything like this as it's impossible to maintain any uniformity across the entire desktop range which makes servicing and repairing these things so much easier.

If you are looking at new systems bought premade anything that is currently available will fit the stated needs but I would avoid any systems with Celeron CPU's and get 2 sticks of RAM fitted before you buy them as this will be cheaper and save you timer & effort latter on.

The above only applies if you are planing on running XP of some description Pro would be the best and if you are building things go with a Volume License. If you are thinking of running Vista you'll meed bigger CPU's more RAM and HDD space and do not consider anything under Vista Ultimate as that has the absolute minimum OS parts necessary to be useful. If you are looking at a Volume License in Vista your bottom choice is Enterprise and you can get Software Assurance with that if required. All M$ Products have a minimum number of 5 for a Volume License and no upper limit.

Most of the listed software can also be purchased on a Volume or Site License as well to save money.

Col

This discussion is closed to new replies.