Discussion Locked

Feedback on Dell, Compaq ,Gateway PCs

0 helpful
16 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Will be undertaking a large procurement of PCs (8000+)- have been looking at Gateway,Dell and Compaq. Have all the specs on them but would like to hear from folks re: their experiences service/maintenance, negotiation strategies etc. How you rate them etc. Any input would be appreciated. Thanks.

16 replies

by eagleworker

Hello,
I am a current Gateway user and have been since 1990 when people were awed by the amazing capabilities of Windows 3.1. My experience has been very good with these machines. Gateway products are reliable and I have never had a technical problem with one. My rating for Gateway is 9 out 10.

by dcosgrove

I have to say that Gateway support has seemed to drop off quite a bit in the past year or so. Compaq, on the other hand, seems to be improving in service and quality. Just curious, any reason you didn't mention HP. I have used large quanties of HPs and was pleased with the reliability. I had about 300 vectras at one site with only about a dozen hardware problems in the first year. three years later I hear they are still using the same machines. I have never used Dell in such quantity, butI personally use there products with good success. Dell is probably the toughest negotiator, they have good stuff in high demand, and they know it.

by csmith

Have had to service all of them.
I prefer Compaq.
We have had the fewest service nightmares with them.
We have had customers who have had to dump Dell and Gateway machines because of lack of parts, etc.

We are a white box VAR.

We do not sell or represent any of these brands, so I do not have any information on the negotiation strategies of any of the brands mentioned.
May it go well.
Regards, Chris

by csmith

,
The question in Ans. #2 has some merit.
From a service tech. point of view, it becomes obvious after many repairs, that the two best manufacturers for well designed and engineered desktops are, Compaq and Hewlett Packard.
If you are on a long (5 year) upgrade cycle, these are the only two manufacturers that should be considered.
Dell has an excellent sales organization, but I think you will find most service techs have a very different opinion.

Regards, Chris

by nichomach

OK, as an end user (I don't sell the blasted things, I just have to make them work...), I currently use Dell Optiplexes, and have preferred these for some time. Robust and well designed for maintenance, with easy case access; 3yr onsite warranty, and I haven't had bad service off them yet. The last Compaq Deskpro I had shipped here had the CPU and h/sink assembly floating loose inside the case. 'Nuff said. Nothing against HP, or Gateway, except their service appeared a little "off" last time I used it.

by jpt

I've been using Dell Computers for over a year and find them quite good. Our office uses the Dimension 4100 series and the Inspiron Notebooks.

Their 3 year next business day warrenty is great. I've had to use it a couple of times,ie. boss dropped something on the keyboard of my notebook and Dell came in next day and replaced keyboard. The other time had a bad hard drive delivered with my notebook (a different notebook) and they shipped me a new hard drive next day before 7:30 am.

One other thing I like about Dell, is that they don't nit pick if you open their box, insert more ram, change the sound card. It doesn't change the warrenty. This isn't the case with some of the other companies out there.

Good luck with your choice.

by macgyver.hicks

Hi Grady,
I'm a PC Service Tech. and have had experience with the three brands you mentioned. I would have to agree with Answer 5 about Dell. They are easy to upgrade(if that is planned for later) and they are solidly built machines. Compaq is anightmare to try to upgrade. If you want more RAM, you can't just pick up some industry standard modules and pop them in. You have to get modules made specifically for
Compaq, at a premium price, of course. Gateway is similar to Dell in the build of their machines, as well, there bundled software is easy(much easier than Compaq's) to reinstall, if necessary. As I see it, your choice is between Dell and Gateway, and they are relatively equal in machine build and quality. You just need to see which offers the best service plan and price-per-unit for your needs.

by csmith

Shall we start with Dell Optiplexes.
The counter is of course: Have you ever tried to upgrade an Optiplex GL 575? After several years the case sags because of the monitor, and it takes a half an hour to get it open without destroying it. And then you have to contend with the insides.
About loose parts: I have seen it everywhere.
Most of it is shipping abuse. I have an example of here.
We have a Nokia 449E that has a cracked case. It still runs well.

On the warranty: The problems that occur after the warranty runs out are usually the most frustrating. (Unfortunately that is when they call us.)

On proprietary parts: Dell has PCs with proprietary power supplies. Well?
On RAM: If you don't want to buy RAM from Compaq, then buy it from Crucial (Micron) or others.

The point about checking the service plan is valid, when in house service is not available, but what happens after the warranty period is also important. (Particularly considering future economic conditions, etc.)

Now to the serious point:

If you look at Gartner Dataquest (Gee, doesn't that name seem familiar?) February 2001,
the server revenue figures are very revealing.
Compaq increased their sales revenues by 1.8 billion dollars yearly revenue in 2000 over their yearly revenue in 1999.
The increase for Dell was only 1.4 billion dollars.
Server sales for Compaq in 2000 were 8.6 billion dollars.
Server sales for Dell in 2000 were 3.4 billion dollars

Either there are a lot of idiots out there in IT land, or they know something and they buy Compaq.

This is something to seriously consider, considering the size of your organization. (8000 seats)

Again please note:
We are a Whitebox VAR.
(Whitebox VARs sell their own house brands, and have about 30% of the market.)

I am just trying to give you a little balance in your point of view.

Regards, Chris

This discussion is closed to new replies.