Discussion Locked

Hard Drive Failure-Can I Swap Platters?

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
My Toshiba MK4019GAX hard drive is toast. I opened it and found one of the heads is broken off. Can I simply put the platters in another Toshiba hard drive and retrieve my data? I know this sounds desperate, but that's exactly what I am right now. I'd appreciate any help on this as there is 40GB of my life on this drive and it would take me months, if not years, to recover from this. Thanks in advance.

5 replies

by thechas

Well, you can, BUT don't get your hopes up too high.

First, I assume that you do not have a clean room environment. So, the platters have become contaminated just by your opening the drive.

Close the drive back up right away.

Second, the loose head may well have damaged at least 1 side of 1 platter.

Depending on how valuable the data is to you, the less you do yourself, the easier it is (and thus lower cost) for a data recovery firm to recover the data for you.

If you desire to attempt a repair, here are some guidelines.

Short of a clean room, choose the cleanest space you have and seal off any forced air vents to the room.
Clean the work surface, ceiling, tools and nearby items with water.
Use an ionized air (anti-static) blower to help keep any free dust particles from sticking to the platters.
Wear a face mask, clean room grade latex or cotton gloves and an anti-static wrist strap. Along with the most lint free clothing you have.

Handle the platters VERY carefully so as to not bump into the heads, or touch the actual surface of the platters.

Best wishes,

Chas

by bfilmfan

Not that I am interested in points as Chas was 100% correct, but I do want to know if you had considered ever backing up any of that critical data onto a portable USB hard disk?

That would have saved you a ton of pain that I am sure you are about to experience.

by wjmcmanus

Thanks, but no I didn't back it up. I did buy a 40GB Mobile Disk today...perhaps this answer would have been acceptable had I asked, "how can I save myself a ton of pain?"

by wlbowers

Here is your current problem. That drive was assembled in at least a class 1 clean room.

This means that the contamation in the air is less than 1 particle .5 microns in diameter per cubic foot.

To put this in perspective. Pollen is 50 microns, human hair is 120 microns. Normal fresh air contains over 1 million particles that are .5 microns or larger per cubic foot.

The drive heads travel at @.05 microns above the platters. Some drive actually use a lubricant to keep the heads from crashing because the distance is so close.

Contact a recovery service.

http://www.iomegadatarecovery.com/

Tell them the story and go from there.

Good Luck

This discussion is closed to new replies.