Discussion Locked

harddrive shorting out system?

0 helpful
7 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
My PC operates in normal fashion with two harddrives. When I place a suspect harddrive (80 gig Seagate), in place of the secondary drive, the PC will not power up. Fan will attempt to move and motherboard will power back down, as if the harddrive is shorting out the system. Is there any other way to recover the data without going to expensive data recovery services?

7 replies

by thechas

Sounds like the controller card on the bad hard drive failed.

Other than a recovery service, you can try swapping the controller board from a known working drive of the same make and model.

One other thought, did you verify jumper settings?
If both drives are set as master, it might lock up the IDE controller and power down the system for an error.

Chas

by thechas

As far as drive controller revision, it depends on the manufacture. Most of the time a newer controller will be backwards compatible.

Your chances of success also depend on just how the drive failed.

If the head or spindle motor has shorted out, a new controller will NOT correct the problem.

What happens if you connect just the power connector to the drive?

If the PC shuts down with just the drive power connector plugged in, the failure is near catastrophic.

If the drive spins up at all, then you have a very good chance of success swapping the controller card.

Chas

by skidoggeruk

I agree with Chas.

Try the drive on its own. Same Result? Knackered hdd. I have done Chas's recommended controller board fix successfully, before. Make sure controller is exactly the same, to avoid corruption.

Check jumpers, sometimes these are left on cable select as well

Good Luck

by grandhighdruid

I would make one other suggestion. I have seen where two HDD's will not work together at all, even ones from the same manufacturer. I have two at home that work fine by themselves, but put them together, and all I get is a blank screen; no post, nothing...ever. I have been told that it is a compatability issue between the HDD controllers; there is NO rhyme or reason to this, no reference chart for this phenomenon or anything. It's just 'plug and pray'. Hope this helps!!!

by alee_dp

Thanks for the info. I will try swapping out the circuit board on the HD. I did try the drive alone, as well as recheck the jumpers. No luck. I heard that you need the exact same HD to make the swap (including same revision). If I purchase the exact same model, how guaranteed am I to get the same revision model? (Not sure how often manufacturers change their drive, and if so.. if they change the model# at that point).

by trident

If swapping the board doesn't help, you might consider swapping the harddrive plates from the broken drive into the working equivalant. To create a dust-free environment, you can do the swapping inside a closed ziplock bag.

This discussion is closed to new replies.