Discussion Locked

HDD peculiar behaviour

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Dear All,

This is avout a 60GB Maxtor UDMA133 PATA HDD, few months old. Recently, randomly, the drive would spin down and up again, with a varied pattern of frequency and duration as much as to crash the computer by consecutive spinup/downs duirng POST or in windows. The PSU connector on the drive did not fault other drives, but other PSU connectors did not improve the situation. Same with a different PSU.

There is also a randomly recurring problem during booting. Running Win XP Pro off a SATA drive on the ICH5R or a separate PATA drive on the 1ry IDE, randomly, I would get "A disk read error occured Press Ctrl+Alt+Del to Restart" after POST. A random number of soft/hard reboots or shutdowns later the error would resolve itself. Overheating is not an issue.

At stock speeds, using 8KNXP-specific settings on motherboard monitor (MBM) 5.3.5.1, failsafe settings on BIOS and Top performance Not enabled, on an idle system reported voltages are:
CPU 1.58 (vs. 1.525 stock)
+2.58 to +2.60 (for +2.5)
+3.31 (for +3.3)
+4.99 (for +5.00)
+12.03 to +12.16 (for +12.00)
-11.99 to -12.08 (for -12.00)
-5.33 (for -5.00)

Components:
Gigabyte 8KNXP rev1.0 F9 BIOS DPS2 module installed, Intel P4 2.8c, Corsair TwinMX 2x512MB 3200LL, Antec 550 TruePower, Radeon 9700 Pro (PN# x-40) on isolated PSU connector, 1x 37GB WD Raptor SATA, 1x 80GB Maxtor UDMA133 PATA , 1x CDRW, 1x DVD-ROM.

That the 60Gb HDD only exhibits the spin down/up behaviour indicates to me it is failing. That the read error occured on either SATA or PATA indicates motherboard failure. MBM is reporting flickering voltages, the +2.5 a bit overvolted. I would welcome greatly opinions.

Kind regards,

Sterghios

6 replies

by sterghios

I will also test tonight the seond PSU for voltage levels. Would appreciate comments in the meantime!

by theohkm

It seems quite posssible that your HDD has error. Please enable SMART monitoring. You could see some message appear during boot up.

by service

Although your voltages look good, try running a current check on your power supply to ensure you have proper current coming through.

Also if you have access to another "good" hard drive, try hooking it up to the system to eliminate the motherboard question.

by csmith

There is nothing wrong with the Hard Drive.
The flickering voltages reported are usually the problem.
The common causes of this are:
BAD WALL PLUG! Emphasis intended. This is a fire hazard.
BAD POWER CORD! Another fire hazard.

The overload sensor in the power supply is failing.
Not very likely.

Fan or Temperature Sensor on motherboard failing.
Usually you will see no/re boots with these problems.

The first thing to check is the power cord and the wall plug, by changing the cord, and plugging the PC into a different wall socket.
This is also a symptom of aluminum house wiring.
Was you house built (or wiring installed) between 1967 and 1972?
Aluminum wiring, without the rated receptacles, is a severe hazard, and will burn down the building.
Regards, Chris

by sterghios

Thanks for all the answers gentlemen, mr smith yours was the best.

It is likely that I could be running too many plugs of the socket - I'm gonna try and sort this out, but dont worry, the house wont go up in flames, there's relay switches and everything, a bit of a spike and the juice's cut everywhere. Even if I stuck a hairdrier in a full bath with me in it I would be safe - but I am not gonna try to get a Darwin award ;-)

Gigabyte siad that the design of 875P's and APIC required that IRQ's also control voltage distribution. In other words a component with lower IRQ will have even power priority over another with a higher IRQ. So that can cause alot of havoc, especially if one is IRQ sharing too (as in my case).

My problems occured because my USB controllers share the same IRQ with the GFX card. And as I got USB stick drives, webcams and stuff I plug in and out all the time... It dont get pretty.

Also, removal of a card from a PCI slot and replacement in another makes the board think that both slots are occupied, unless you reset CMOS by removing the battery. A bit of an inconvenience, but the best way to setup a system on such boards is to build, install the OS and then not add or remove anything from it. Not really useful for them USB stick drives now is it? Then again this was never a desktop board, but a workstation solution....

This discussion is closed to new replies.