Discussion Locked

Home network options

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have cable modem access and my main objective is shared internet between my desktop, another desktop, and a notebook. Having read some reviews, I am confused by the various home networking options now available. The choice appears to be between Home PNA 2.0 and a wireless 802.11 , but I can?t figure out what?s best for me.

1. On one hand, my house has 3 floors and a lot of concrete in the structure; so I suspect Home PNA 2.0 with USB is the way to go rather than run the risk of poor reception using 802.11

2. On the other hand, I?m not clear on if a gateway is needed for both options, and what advantage that provides. (I already have the cable modem)

3. And does anyone have experience with the true speed of a 10-MB Home PNA2.0 network? How does it compare with the 10MB 802.11?

I?d like to know the pros / cons of the two options, and what hardware (gateways, adapters, etc) I need using each. Slots are an issue so in either case I'm looking for USB. Brand recommendations are optional.

Thanks!

5 replies

by ebob

1 - PNA OR Wireless? How about both? PNA for the desktops/towers/servers and wireless for the laptops? A typical solution would be an DSL router that is also a wireless "hub". If you need more hard-wired ports just use an add-on switch/hub from the same manufacturer. And of course the wireless NIC for the laptops.

2 - You will need a gateway for either solution. You could use a PC with 2 NICS, running MS' Internet Connection Sharing (ICS). I personally prefer any of several hardware solutions ("DSL Router") such as from Asante, 3Com, LinkSYS, etc. All of these also have wireless capability. They all have built-in DHCP servers, address translation and so on. I also like the units with print server and back-up analogue modem options.

3- I have used a competitor to PNA and found that the experience was "similar" to being on a 10Mbps CAT3 Ethernet, which I generally feel is actually faster than 802.11. (I attribute to the overhead in 802.11.)

3a - While you're at it, for your DSL router, make sure it has a print server option.

by buffalodan

Also, with a permanent connection to the internet, shared amogst all home computers, make sure you are implementing Firewall/Packet filter protection to help prevent yopur home systems being hacked and/or hijacked.

Some choices...

zonealarm...very good and free for home use, simple to implement.

BlackIce...very good, a bit complicated for the novice

Norton Internet Security......pretty good, relatively easy to use, good support.

This discussion is closed to new replies.