Question Locked

How do I get Windows to boot on new, used HD from other PC?

0 helpful
10 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have a PC that had obvious signs the HD was going out. So I pulled the Hard drive out of a newer, but slower PC to put into into the PC with HD problems. Both HD are same brand and only differ in size. The old drive was 30g and the new is 40g. The new drive is from a PC that worked fine and had windows XP SP2 as well.

I get the "We appologize for the inconvenience..." message and cannot get Windows to boot up. Shouldn't it start normally? What settings do I need to check?

Thanks

10 replies

by boxfiddler Hot topic

to be one reason HD won't boot. While others here are much more knowledgeable than I am, I have yet to be able to move a hard drive containing Windows from one PC to a different PC and have Windows boot.

Data drives have been another story. Those have usually - but not always - been available without problem.

by meridenscrafts

My first concern would be why the situation arose in the first place. There are approaches to moving the operating system, but my advice is not to.

?

When you add a hard drive, it's usually designated in the BIOS as primary or secondary. Primary is of course, the boot drive, and is where Windows expects to be installed. Typically when you install a second drive it will be the secondary, and not participate in the boot process at all.

If your new drive had been installed as primary by mistake, I would have expected your first reboot thereafter to fail, because the new drive would not have an operating system on it. Unless, perhaps, your BIOS is smart enough to check all drives.

When you install Windows, it will also present you with an opportunity to upgrade in existing installation or set up a new one. In the latter case, you could certainly have selected the new drive.

But the bottom line is that why it installed on the new drive may impact the success of the suggestions to follow.

Moving an existing installation of Windows is theoretically possible, but I would consider it risky. I'd expect it would be easy for many things to go wrong, putting you back where you started, or worse.

So the ultimate answer to your question is no, I would not recommend attempting to move the operating system.

In your shoes I would try one thing: swapping the hard drives. I started by pointing out that the drives are primary and secondary, and it's apparently installed the new operating system on the wrong drive. Make that drive the primary, and see if that results in what you want. Exactly how to do this will vary on your motherboard, your bios, and your drive types. And ultimately, it may not work. Depending on the exact configuration you ended up with, I can think of several issues that might invalidate this attempt.

That brings me to what I'd expect to be required: reinstall. Or rather, re-upgrade, making sure that the upgrade happens to the drive you expect. I might even go so far as to remove the second drive, perform the upgrade, make sure it's all working and then re-install the new drive, and make sure that you're still booting form the old one with the properly upgraded operating system.

Or you can make the HD with Windows on it your master and the used one with other things on it as your slave. Then you can copy your programs onto the new hard drive. I have done this. My Windows on the new one(install windows from CD onto new hard drive. Then hook up the two hard drives as master and slave. nanse

by achristensenjohnson

Why not try ghosting the bad drive to the new? If it has bad sectors, you can "force" cloning, which may write past them. If not, you've got your info on the clone, no harm done to the original, and you can attempt a non-destructive recovery. Or you could simply reinstall Windows on the new drive and XCOPY the the contents of the old drive to a folder on the new. There are plenty of instructional pages on the web to tell you how to do that in XP. First, though, I'd hook your bad drive up to another system as a slave to see if the data is still there or not. I hope those suggestions help! EDIT: Sorry, I goofed. I meant to reply to the thread, not to an individual. Sorry!

by imonroe

I'll give this a try. If not, I guess I will try to reinstall windows.

by seanferd

If Windows came pre-installed on the drive you want to use, it is an OEM version and may never work on the other system. It is also against the EULA to do this.

For a retail copy of Windows, just reinstall the OS on the new machine.

by imonroe

Thanks for the help. I thought a clean install would be the easiest way to do this. I did make a critical error though. I didn't make sure I had the hardware driver discs at hand. Lesson Learned.

by achristensenjohnson

from the old hard drive? If you were able to hook up the original drive as a slave, you should be able to get your drivers and data from it, provided the damage isn't too bad. You probably already thought of that, I was just curious. It would save you time googling and wading through support pages.

by imonroe

Yes, that would have been a good idea. I thought we had all the original resource disks on hand. Evidently I was wrong. I did spend the majority of yesterday searching for drivers. Other than that there was no data to be transfered. We have a few programs to install, but all the data is saved to our server. That is why I decided to reformat the HD. I thought it would be easier.

Next time I will set the new drive up as a slave like you suggest.

Thanks.

This discussion is closed to new replies.