Discussion Locked

How does it all work together?

0 helpful
7 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
What is the bottleneck in a standard system besides the RAM? Say I was going to increase processor speed, had a HD that was 5400rpm, motherboard with a 100mh FSB, and 256 Mg of RAM. Would there be a limit on the processor speed that (i.e. a waste of money going faster) given the above specs? HOw do you deside which component would do you the most good, and would you get the maximum value given all the other parameters. How dows it all work together? Any articles out there that address this topic?

7 replies

by geroxx

You ask a loaded question. The answer will vary from person to person. But my direct answer is... The bigger the processor step the bigger the gain in performance.

If you are going form a 450Mhz to a 500Mhz you will not see as great an increase as going from 450Mhz to 800Mhz. I would consider it a waste to buy a processor only 1 step above my current processor. If you get it for free or dirt cheap then go for it.

It has been my experience that the overall speed of a system is made up by all of its parts. But, weaknesses in one area will not effect the performance of the machine in some tasks but will cause it to die in others or visa versa.

Typically, the faster the processor the better for most applications... BUT... If Ihad a 700Mhz 100Mhz FSB Processor with 256 MB PC100 Ram going against a 700Mhz 133Mhz FSB Processor with 256MB PC133 Ram then the Higher FSB rate will come out on top. But if you have the processor with the 133 FSB uses an ATA33 HD, and the 100 FSBprocessor have and use ATA66 controller and HD then they will probably even out when doing something that is disk intensive but the 133 FSB system will kick butt when doing thing that are really processor/ram intensive.

Something that is interesting though. It has been found that when doing Video converting or WAV to MP3 conversion that the raw processor clock rate is the biggest factor to speed of conversion.

If you could add some information, like what do you mainly use your computer for, I might be able to offer you better suggestions.

My short answer... all things being equal... the faster the processor the better.

HTH
Gary

by bv2

Bus speed, bus speed, bus speed. There is no limit on processor speed except your wallet and available processors. You may not see a noticeable difference on some apps, but a huge difference on others (Adobe products spring to mind). Where you'resitting I would go with the processor, because if you upped the mobo FSB, you'd have to replace the processor and the RAM for any benefit.

by wlbowers

Your sence of performance will depend on what your doing. If you piddle with word processor and spread sheets, you don't need blaze. If as in one of the other answers you dabble in high intense games or Photoshop or other Adobe products then this isthe rule.
Processor intense apps, Photoshop, heavy games, ect, benefit from Ram, cpu speed and fsb speed first, then from i/o or drive input output. AMD currently has intel beat in system performance. The high end Athlon with its 200mhz fsb is still edging the p4. Go figure. I run an 800mhz Athlon with 512 meg of pc133 ram, and a 7200rpm hard drive. I just put a 1 gig together for a customer with 128meg or ram and a 5200rpm hard drive. I noticed an improvement in most operations. Photoshop still runs faster on my machine with large images just because of the ram allocation of photoshop (it works with multiple copies of the image open at once).

The 100meg fsb is a bottleneck. Not enough ram is a bottleneck. a slow hard drive is a bottleneck.

You can put a system together with capabilities of going to the top end processor but start with say an 800meg instead of a 1.5gig then upgrade the processor later and save a ton of money.

You didn't say what you wanted to do with the machine. List your applications and I will spec it out for you and list why.

Good Luck Lee

This discussion is closed to new replies.