A bad sector is an indication of a problem with the magnetic media on the hard disk platter.
In my experience, 90% of bad sectors return after they have been recovered.
If you format the drives, the bad sectors will be marked as bad, and skipped, they will no longer show up as bad sectors when running scandisk or defrag.
The best way to attempt recovery of bad sectors, is to use the drive manufactures low level format utility.
CAUTION: ALL DATA ON THE DRIVE WILL BE LOST!!!
Alternately, you can try things like Disk Doctor in Norton Utilities.
Chas