Discussion Locked

Hub/Switch Too Weak for Network

0 helpful
3 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I hava small network of 50-60 nodes that interface with a larger network via a T1 line and Cisco router. My network is a Cat 5 star network with a fiber-optic backbone. Recently I tried to add a D-Link 8-port hub to a department (to keep from running additional Cat5 from the main hub. I could not get the network to interface with the hub. I tried a Siemens 8-port switch, also to no avail. Finally, I resorted to a 3Com 8-port hub I use in my office. The 3Com worked where the other 2 units would not.

Is there a quality issue (either internal programming or electronics) that allows the 3Com hub to be recognized where the D-Link and Siemens do not? In essence, are the latter 2 units built for smaller networks with fewer node communications, where the 3Com is built to handle larger communications activities?

3 replies

by paulp

Some hubs require you to use a crossover cable when cascading hubs. Other hubs have a port that is designated for connecting to another hub. Did you take that into consideration?
A few years ago when I used 3Com switches, they had a feature built into the last port number which allowed you to choose, via hardware switch, whether that port will be a crossover or straight through. Perhaps you luckily choose that port when you connected it to the other hub?

by bob.ellis

I tried crossover cables and swapped to all ports to attempt appropriate interfacing. I finally acquired another 3Com hub and got a hit to the network. I can only assume the 3Com hubs are better or that I needed a 3Com hub to interface with the other 3Com hubs in my network. Thanks for your feedback.

This discussion is closed to new replies.