Discussion Locked

IDE Disk Test going nowhere fast

0 helpful
11 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hi,

First post here guys, so be gentle ;-)

My laptop (HP Omnibook XE3) crashed a horrific crash a few days ago and on attemted reboot could no longer find a hard drive.

I managed to start a diagnostic through the Hewlett Packard troubleshooting system on startup.

It is e-DiagTools, Ver 3.01r.

It read through 69% of the disk before it started to find errors, and offer to fix them.

So, at Cyl=0707, Head=150 Sec=20 it began to fix sectors with LBA IDs. It takes maybe 3 mins to fix them, then finds another new LBA ref to fix after another 3 mins. It has now repaired about 20 or so corrupt sectors after 2 days of this activity.

However, the display still tells me only 69% is tested and we are still at Cyl=0707, Head=150 Sec=20. I thought the 'Sec' value should increment at each new LBA reference?

The quandry now is, do I let the Disk Test continue for possibly many many days, or do I just push Escape, abort the test and try my luck.

The laptop is now 3 years old, but got a new motherboard 2 months ago. Are we talking a dustbin job here or should I just replace the Hard Disk if it is dead?

11 replies

by ghimpe--

Well, sorry to hear this. If you want to make sure youre harddrive is dyeing or not go to the makers webpage (you will probably have to open the laptop so you can acces the hdd and identify the maker) and download there disk utility. That should tell if it's time for a new hardrive.

GooD LucK! ;)

by softcorp.us

Hello Neil...

It is clear that you have a hard drive problem and it needs to be replaced. Getting three years out of a notebook hard drive is nominal and pretty good.

That your notebook is 3 years old is not sufficient criteria to junk it. If it is still fast enough for you and runs your apps, you might want to keep it. I personally replace them every 2-3 years, but it is a personal decision.

Be aware that notebook HDDs often require a special bracket that varies from notebook to notebook, and HDD to HDD. It is not entirely a standard physical size like in a desktop. The notebook HDDs have a standard connector though. The height and width are standard. The thickness varies from 9mm to 19mm.

A good place to find a replacement notebook HDD at a good price is www.zipzoomfly.com.

Since you're new: Be sure to rate the answers you get in Q&A and close your question when you're done.

Good luck to you.

-----Steve Jackson

CEO
Software Corporation (Softcorp)
http://www.softcorp.us

by mjd420nova

The first thing is to power down and try a restart. I experienced a similar failure,
found it to be the IDE controller on a
daughter board took a hike. As a result the
hard drive had to be reformatted after the
board was replaced. Sorry to bear bad news
but parts should be availabe still. Just
trying to give you a possiblity.

by hal 9000

Well as others have said Sorry about your problem but if it is just the HDD this is easy to replace. Most of the current crop of NB HDD's are about 9 MM thick and have been that way for quite some time now. But the really important thing to look out for is the Power that any replacement drive requires this should be on the Sticker on the top of the Drive so if you can get one that doesn't require as much power to run as the old one you'll get a longer battery life while the NB is running on its battery. But and here is the real killer if you get a drive that has a higher power requirement it may very well not work with your existing NB. So be careful ask questions and look up the different makers Web Sites for the specs of their 2.5 inch drives.

Mostly the HDD are held in a mounting rack which on the newer units is a standard fixture for that particular NB so it should just be a matter of removing the dead HDD unscrewing it from the mounting rack fitting a new one {Make sure you have it the right way around or you will be unable to actually plug it in.} Then refitting it to the NB and loading whatever OS you where using. With a lot of the Propriety NB's the Recovery Disk/s may not actually support a larger HDD {in capacity} at least but you should still be able to load Windows from the Recovery Disk/s.

Incidentally there is a bracket and adapter that you can buy very cheaply to fit a 2.5 inch drive to a 3.5 inch IDE connection to test that may be worth a try just to check out the drive first before you even consider buying a new HDD. If the drive works perfectly it has to be in the Notebook. Depending on where you live Radio Shack tends to have these adapters and mounting kits as I'm not in the US I don't know how much they sell for but I can buy them here in AU for less that $25.00 AU.

Col

by binky.glindmeyer

First, call HP and make sure there is no warranty left on the laptop or hard-drive, then, if there is none left, shop for a new H/D.

phil

by glastron

Hello

I agree with a previous poster if you have a hard drive enclosure try that and see if it a controller. If you don't have any critical data on it then stop it and try a reformat. Good Luck!

by hmcomptrs

Hi,

First find out the manufacturer of the HD and go to their webpage and download the HD diagnostic software and run the disk utilities. If it is under a warranty it may give you an RMA# and you can send it in for replacement. I my self have seen programs that come with some desktops/laptops not really fix the issue so i always use the HD manufactures disk utilities. If the HD is dying then look at Computergeeks.com and Compuplus.com or newegg.com. Hope this helps and good luck :)

by bob wya

Simple answer mate... Spinrite 6.0. (www.grc.com)

If that don't work then its time to sort yourself out with a new HD. Boot into Knoppix off a CD and copy all your important files onto a USB disc drive. Then get yourself a decent HD!! I replace my laptop HD with a Hitachi Travelstar 7,200rpm 60Gb 2.5"... Its much faster!! They aren't that pricey now (about 90 quid in the UK)... Cheaper than a new laptop and easy to install.

Hope that helps.

Robert

by roger

From all the postings you have received it appears that you have the correct solution in these pages. From experience with HP equipment, I would expect to find a Travelstar 2.5 hard disk in your laptop. Spinrite is very good at recovering damaged disks (if possible) and Knoppix will allow you to access the data if the drive is at all usable. If your system has a writable CD drive in it Knoppix should be able to detect the drive and allow you to copy files from the damaged disk to a CD. Even if you can get a damaged disk to work, you should copy the files and replace the drive. You might also get 2 of the drive adapters that allow you to access laptop drives in PC systems and use Norton Ghost to clone the damaged drive to a new drive. This should be very quick, and keep you from reinstalling all the software you have already installed on the damaged disk. If portions of the old disk are unreadable, you might try this (it has worked for me in the past): Put the defective disk in a ZIPLOCK plastic bag and put it in your FREEZER overnight. In the morning, open the freezer and remove the drive. Wrap it in a DRY cloth (to absorb moisture from the outside air), open the ziplock bag and plug in the drive adapter. Last, connect the drive connecter into an IDE cable on a desktop computer and attempt to recover data. Sometimes a FROZEN drive will allow you to read the data and ceases to function normally when it warms up. I purchased 2 adapters over the internet a few years ago, and paid $9.00 + shipping for each. Good Luck

by wlbowers

Got news for you. Good recovery software will churn on a drive attempting to recover until you call a halt to it.

If you have something you need. Carry on Dude.

If you attempting to fix the drive to reload, Don't.

Your drive has experiened a head crash. This is where the head has come in contact with the platter. Kind of like the "bugs" ship in MIB when it hit the ground.

Crater, lots of trash floating around. Even if you got it to format, every time the head passes that area, well you get my point.

As others have said if that laptop gets it done replace the drive and carry on.

By the way if recovery is a necessity, go the 2.5" adapter to put it in a desktop.

Good Luck Lee

by sgt_shultz

boy that is a toughy. i guess you need the data or you wouldn't be posting. think if my drive i would stop chkdsk and buy Spinrite. if dust is grinding around in there seems like best idea to write to hd minimally as possible. spinright best you can get probably...
you can get cheap usb laptop drive enclosures if you think it might be a good idea to get it out of laptop. i belive spinrite will read data off drive and place on *another* drive which sounds like what you might need. so you could take out laptop hd and put in this little usb drive enclosure about 15 or 20 dollars and run spinrite on say your desktop with the usb laptop drive plugged in. would spinrite find a usb drive with invalid stuff on it? not sure.
my ears perked up at others with sim experience suggestin controller problem. i would definitely vist tech support siets for laptop and hd to see if maybe known issue.
but most likely you jiggled laptop or had hard power failure maybe or just bad luck and drive is hosed...

This discussion is closed to new replies.