Discussion Locked

IDE drive in Firewire external case

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Has anyone tried to put a std IDE (40Gb ATA100/7200rpm WD BB400) drive in an ext. firewire case?
Testing under XP Pro, Dev mgr sees the controller as a HDD controller - but no devices listed.
Disk manager of course, does not see it.
A CD-RW is fine; but not the HDD - am I being naive in expecting it to work? does a HDD need a driver of some decription?
Its really bugging,e, as I thought I had a backup solution (using removable bays).
Rob

5 replies

by titanpcs

I have actually done the same thing as you have, with both USB and Firewire, and both read as HDD's in WinXP Pro. I believe the brand I used for the Firewire was Belkin, but I cannot be sure at this time.

The only thing I can see it needing in terms of software would be a root hub for the firewire box itself, but if a CD-RW works, I don't see why the HDD would not. Have you tried another drive? The Western Digital you have may not work that way. (I used Maxtor and Quantum)

This discussion is closed to new replies.