Discussion Locked

Identical Drives for RAID

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I have a server with 3 Western Digital 18Gb 10k RPM hot swappable drives that are no longer being made. The drives are partitioned 2Gb/16Gb With two of the 2 gig partions being mirrored and the three 16 gig partions in a RAID 5 configuration. The hot swap bay has a 5 drive backplane and I would like to add two more drives. Can I subsitute drives from another manufacturer and add them to my RAID 5 set?

6 replies

by rawright

Assuming your server is WinNT, the drives do not have to be identical, but the partitions in the stripe set have to be the same size. The disk controller handles the hardware details, while the OS deals only with them logical drives. Install your new drives and create a partion on each identical in size to those in your existing stripe set, then add the new ones to the set. One note I found in the documentation is that the boot and system partition must not be in the stripe set, and once youhave set the configuration, be sure to commit the changes immediately, rather than simply letting the system do it in its own good time.

This only applies if you are using the OS to control the RAID set; if you are using a hardware RAID controller the specific manufacturer may have different requirements.

by rawright

Having re-read your posting for more detail, it appears that the system/boot partition isn't a concern - they're already in the mirrored set...

by computechie

In RAID configurations, they do not have to all be the same size, but from my experience, the closer they are, the less headaches. Make sure that you get at least 10K RPM drives, and they are the same size or bigger. When you go over your current 18GB setup, you'll loose the rest of the space on the drive, so don't go to much over 18GB and waste your money. Then manufacturer of the drives really isnt going to matter, just make sure you get a good brand like your current Western Digital's, IBM's, Seagates, etc. Hope this helps you out.

This discussion is closed to new replies.