Discussion Locked

If this isn?t lunacy, I don?t know what is

0 helpful
832 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post

832 replies

by jdclyde

but this great mind beat you by 29 minutes... :p

B-)

All that and likes girls too! :D

by jdclyde

Just because there are elitists in the fed does NOT change the fact that the politicians are elitists too.

Democrats are always talking about "the rich" and how they shouldn't be trusted. Guess what, ALL of the Democrats are rich.

Sen. Obama made more last year than I will in my lifetime.

by deepsand

And, which is more easily captured and recyled; the undesirable waste products of cumbustion, or those in batteries and/or solar panels which have reached the ends of their useful lives?

by deepsand

Quite the contrary. As one trained in the sciences, I am most objective with respect to the facts. My subjectivity is reserved for those who persist in either failing to become informed as to the facts or ignoring them.

As for the variables you mention re. temperature measurements, it seems to have escaped you that, in matters of [u]climatology[/u], one is dealing with trends, employing large amounts of data, such that variations generated in the manners described by you are averaged out.

Individual place/point-in-time measurements are of interest only in meteorology.

And, those who kept such records in times past were not so ignorant of the issues you raise as you would have us believe.

by deepsand

Whatever made you think that each and every period of cooling or warming owed to the same cause?

by deepsand

in either the same direction or of the same magnitude.

The effect of such depends, at the very least, on both the volume and composition of the effluent, which determines its interaction with the state of Earth at that particular point in time.

by danlm

One of the super hazardous cleanups?

That is why I think of hazardous disposal. From everything I have read about hydride cars, the batteries do not have a long life cycle. No, I don not know what it is specifically. But, not as long as todays batteries... With that being the case, what is going to happen every say 4/5 years with these special batteries? How will they be processed? How will they be disposed of?

If this is a stupid concern, please tell me why. And I wont bring it up again.

Dan
[edited to add] God, it took me forever to find reference to this. But here is at least some information on it.
http://www.epa.gov/reg3wcmd/ca/pa/pdf/pad003041910.pdf

Thought I was losing my mind for crying out loud.

by the scummy one

Ice Ages and Warming Trends have been caused by quite a few different effects.

A large volcano or a large meteor can shoot ash into the atmosphere which can/has blanketed the Earth causing cooling trends for several years, along with mass extinctions

The constant move of continents has also cased large Ice Ages in the past (theoretically). From what I saw on the discovery or history channel last year, there was several ice ages that was caused by the shifting of the continents (Continental Drift) and the flow of the current in the oceans. These caused much longer ice ages than volcanoes/meteors.

There have also been large fires which have caused cooling for extended periods.

Aside from that, moving closer and farther from the sun is also an effect, along with the sun's current state.

Now, there has also been research indicating that Meteor hits in the ocean may have caused water to shoot into the atmosphere, which may have had a similar effect as the dirt/dust, except it also induced massive flooding worldwide for many years (and colder temps).

Other considerations may be from

by deepsand

As earlier noted, I deliberately oversimplified, for the sake of ensuring that the point re. energy density and hydorgen was not missed. In that regard, my only error was that of carelessly employing the word "exclusively."

I am well aware that, at 1 standard atmosphere, the volume energy density gasoline is far superior to that of hydrogen. However, that does not prevent us from seeking to exploit the fact that the mole energy density of hyrodgen both exceeds that of hydrocarbons and is more easily released.

Now, to return to the origin of this particular sub-thread, where you spoke re. recycling CO2 into more fuel - How do you envision the CO2 produced by combustion being captured and conveyed to the biomass being grown for fuel?

by deepsand

Personally, I'd be more concerned about today's oil spills and refinery fires/spills than about yesterday's batteries. In this regard, batteries are no different from a host of other widely used commodities.

Now, what are the hazards in solar panels?

And, which undesirable end products are more easily and properly disposed of; those of combustion, or those of solar panels and/or batteries?

by deepsand

Take, for example, volcanic eruptions.

If the effluent contained no particulates, then the most likely effect would be that its CO2 emissions would increase radiative forcing, resulting in warming.

However, given a sufficiently high amount of particulates of the right composition, their presence in the atmosphere would tend to shade Earth, resulting in cooling.

But, what happens [u]after[/u] those particulate fall to Earth?

If, at that time, Earth's average albedo is low, with little of its surface covered by ice and/or snow, quite possibly there will be no immediate affect on temperatures.

On the other hand, the covering of ice and/or snow would decrease Earth's albedo, more short wavelength radiation would be absorbed rather than being reflected, and would be re-radiated as infrared radiation. Then, given a sufficient level of CO2 in the atmosphere, radiative forcing would cause warming.

Knowing the type of event alone does not necessarily suffice for determining what its effects will be.

by deepsand

The "No Child Left Behind" program was a flawed concept form the very beginning. In order for no child to be left behind, no child can be ahead; you cannot have the latter without the former. Hence "No Child Gets Ahead."

Accusing anyone other than those responsible for foisting an intellectually bankrupt policy on the public for the ensuing failures is nothing but empty rhetoric.

Furthermore, where in the US Constitution is the Fed empowered to regulate education?

by jamesrl

If thats what I meant thats what I would have said. I was simply challenging the notion that the US is the most scientifically ignorant of nuclear power nations.

James

by deepsand

How many hold the flawed belief that a nuclear reactor can explode like a nuclear bomb?

As for waste, again, and aside from the fact that few have ever really given it any real thought, how many have great misunderstanding here as well.

Why did we end our development of breeder reactors just as we were close to having a practical design?

Who has played on the ignorance of the American public so as to make them fearful of the atom; and, for what purpose?

by deepsand

in our schools? Why is the case?

Who is it that has played on this ignorance so as to instill such fear? Who stands to gain from such?

Why are the above not occuring in other countries?

by deepsand

in the trading of such.

What is it that so many others seem to see that so completely eludes you and me?

Why do they see 1 + 1 = 1?

by jdclyde

we should not question the methods used in collecting and processing the data? "That dog don't hunt".

Time of day doesn't effect the temp at the time of the reading?

Consistent methods don't matter?

If the methods are solid, then no one should have ANY problem with people asking about them. When people get defensive right away (like you have) then it makes me wonder why.

As for your other post about causes, what makes YOU think you can rule OUT all past causes? Nature is fairly consistent.

The alarmist attitude and the race for the money, as well as the shifting cause, all make the global cooling/warming/climate shift "experts" very suspect, and shows how lacking they are.

How is ANYONE an expert on global climate shifts? Where did they study, and under who? The person they studied under got their expertise from where? There are not ANY "experts" in this. Yeah, I know you like to knock meteorologists as not being experts as well.

by deepsand

Having realized that the days of big $$ oil are numbered, he's shifted his attention wind turbines, and the fact that Texas has a large amount of land suitable for such.

by danlm

In the US.

Deepsand, I need to apologize. I was just leaving work, which is why I didn't complete my response about the hazardous waste... I actually wanted to give more detail into why I'm not thrilled with batteries... The past is only part of it, but it is a foundation to my deslike... And I provided nothing on the solar panels, I know.

But, alas... It's the weekend... The sun is shining... And if I get lucky, this 10 minutes will be the last time I log into TR before Sunday. I will try to give more detail then.

;o), have a good weekend.

Dan

by deepsand

Regardless of office or party, the majority of my votes cast over my life time have been for those who lost.

by deepsand

but, in this case I do believe it's that I put more effort into learning about the issues and candidates before voting.

In fact, if there is a specific race about which I myself to be inadequately informed, I'll not vote in that one.

My ex-wife, with an IQ to rival mine, drove me nuts at election time. Rather than make her own informed decision, she expected me to tell her how to vote; my response was that she was more than capable of doing her own homework. She, of course, would respond that, by her following my advice, I'd be getting the equivalent of 2 votes for the price of 1; I'd tell her that I'd prefer that that extra vote be earned rather than gifted. She very quickly stopped voting.

by the scummy one

actaully, not all 7 were 'his', 2 were his wifes and each of his kids had one. But they were all paid for by him... As to the other :0 :^0 :^0 :^0

I really have no idea, but with all of those hummers around, likely he gets one for each time he buys another :^0

by deepsand

I was certain that I had a news article relating to this archived locally, one that I could easily produce; however, Google Desktop came up empty. :0

Perhaps I saved it on another machine and it failed to get transferred when I do files syncs. Just what I need, another problem, or at the least the appearance of such. :-(

No offense was taken re. the abrupt reply re. batteries, solar panels, etal.; just puzzlement, which is now abated.

Enjoy your time off, and contemplate my having to be in an office on both Sat. & Sun.. :_|

by nicknielsen

But the only way I can justify such a position to myself is if I am a smug non-user of the resource in question. Unfortunately, we in the USA are all users, either directly or indirectly, of said resource.

Our primary form of transportation is the individual motor vehicle propelled by the internal combustion engine. [b]Everything[/b] that is bought and sold at retail is delivered to its end destination by truck. Given North American topology and current technology, our current transportation system is the most efficient method. Unless and until an effective and [u]economical[/u] replacement becomes available, we are stuck with it. Research needs to continue into alternative fuels; we need to develop more efficient engines and motor vehicles, but to refuse to allow oil refining capacity to expand to ease fuel shortages and their economic impact strikes me as both shortsighted and selfish.

by deepsand

then, would it not be both more energy efficient and less costly to refine as close to the well head as possible, and ship only the refined product?

by jdclyde

so unpopular?

It IS all a popularity contest. You DO realize that, right?

Bill Clinton was young, hip, and a likeable guy. I am sure he would be the life of the party, you just can't trust him with your daughter, let alone your country. oh wait, character doesn't matter. I always forget that....

by nicknielsen

but I suspect the rest of Europe is much the same.

Most Germans own smaller cars; delivery of large or heavy items is almost a given. Gasoline is taxed at a very high rate, such that Germans are now paying $5.57/gallon.

The revenue from these taxes is used to subsidize the transit system. When I was last in Germany, it was possible to travel end to end using the transit system; very few homes in Germany are more than a kilometer from at least a bus stop; most are within 3 km of a train station.

Primary reason for the difference - geography and population. German is only slightly smaller than Montana, but has over 250 occupants per square kilometer. This population density supports transit systems that would not be possible in the US except after almost exorbitant subsidies.

Data from: http://www.nationmaster.com/country/gm-germany/geo-geography
http://money.cnn.com/pf/features/lists/global_gasprices/

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]How can we reconcile this difference without one person or the other feeling infringed upon?[/i]

For the other folks, of course.

by $$$$$$$$$$

I believe the enthalpy of heat of 2H2 + O2 --> 2H2O supports deepsand's claim. Shall I do the calculations?

by cactus pete

I drive a Prius. In the winter the mileage drops to about 45, but that's because my wife likes to run the heater - which only produces heat when the engine is running. So if you need more heat, it again runs the engine. kinda wasteful if you crank the heat up more than necessary.

Also, I have SUPERB gas mileage on the highway. I'd wager it's better than any non-hybrid car out there in mass production. And by far.

The scam you cite has been debunked long ago, but I suppose you latched on to the notion you preferred and never heard the corrected statement.

For the average commuter with a Prius, the savings is rather significant.

by cactus pete

I wonder how many of those trucks are used on weekends for, say, jet ski's, ATV's/Quads, and or boats?

The height of wasted fuel comes from those leisure vehicles. These vehicles are also not as tightly regulated and can be expected to not perform nearly as efficiently as they possibly could, to say the least.

by cactus pete

Sen. Obama wrote a couple of best selling books. If the money is important to you, try doing something from which you might generate it.

As for Max's elitists being environmentalists, I have to say that they don't seem to fit the role. It would be more appropriate to suggest that the elitists are the large corporation leaders who run the show, and in so doing cause the issues that concern the environmentalists.

by jdclyde

The rich people trying to tell us how to live and what to do, all the time doing something differently themselves, no, they wouldn't be elitists.....

Do you really think that the democrats are any different than the republicans?

by $$$$$$$$$$

Somebody whose income is 10x mine is wealthy. Somebody whose income is [b]thousands[/b] of times mine, and obtains special treatment from Congress via bribes ("campaign contributions" is the common euphemism, they are bribes) and nationally televised whining about the "danger to energy production and the economy" posed by environmental regulations, "shortages" of H1B visas, et al, is a vile elitist pile of crap.

by maxwell edison

..... are not necessarily one's with all the money.

Elitism (noun): The belief that certain persons or members of certain classes or groups deserve favored treatment [b]by virtue of their perceived superiority, as in intellect,[/b] social status, or financial resources.

a. The sense of entitlement enjoyed by such a group or class.

b. Control, rule, or domination by such a group or class.

Edit: However, in the case of the elitists of whom I speak, they, too, have some pretty deep pockets - not to mention the power of the dominant media behind them (evidenced, in part, by the recent Time Magazine issue).

by $$$$$$$$$$

Granted, that those definitions of "elitism" are acceptable approximations of what is normally meant by that epithet; on what basis do you apply any definition of "elitism" to [b]all[/b] news & opinion which concludes a significant likelihood that global climate destabilization [with a general trend toward incremental increase in average temperature, hence the oversimplified but on average accurate term "global warming] is real, now, and probably caused by the various [b]measured increases[/b] in atmospheric concentrations of gases which are [b]known to retain heat longer than other naturally-present elements[/b] in the atmosphere?

Arrhenius predicted exactly this result from large-scale industrial combustion of hydrocarbons, very early in the history of both modern industry & modern science [adding empiricism to the ancient Greeks' logical but hands-off analysis of observation]. I mention this fact in order to set the context for claims of doubt, beginning with the molecular basis of the phenomenon. If you honestly doubt the claims, that is the topic with which to [b]begin[/b] a rational argument. If, the first time the "global warming" hypothesis was introduced to you, you wanted to believe it false, that is the topic with which to [b]begin[/b] an investigation of the veracity of the claims. It's really difficult, despite my politically-motivated [b]wish[/b] to do so, to take you seriously when you claim there is no global warming, especially when there is so much information available that you could use to pursue a small-government argument by making the case so much better, that government is too stupid and corrupt to solve this problem as efficiently as needs be done, in light of both the consequences if global warming is real, and the cost if global warming is combated with any but the most economically efficient measures available. We cannot afford to do this wrong should be your argument, not we cannot afford to do anything.

I agree the government has no place claiming credit for helping to solve this problem, but because government is exacerbating the problem, not because the problem is not real.

I know many environmentalists would be receptive to an argument for a decreased government role in emissions, given the current administration's ill-advised payments to petroleum and agriculture industry [b]elitists[/b] to continue pretending corn ethanol is a viable alternative. The data on switchgrass ethanol alone, and the Bush administration's stubborn support for corn, would sway a great many people who self-identify as "green" to a small-government position on that subject.

http://www.sciam.com/article.cfm?id=grass-makes-better-ethanol-than-corn

When you claim a particular agenda [less government involvement] and use a sub-par argument after [b]years[/b] of demonstrating to me the ability to do better, I wonder whether the agenda you claim is really the one you are pursuing at all. You used to seem too intelligent to waste your mind on this Pollyanna claim in the face of all the evidence. I've come to doubt my first impression of you.

http://www.uni-solar.com/
http://www.ovonic.com/eb_so_solar_overview.cfm

What's pushing them overseas, [b]to communist China[/b] where there is no freedom or democracy, of all places??

http://www.renewableenergyworld.com/rea/news/story?id=47377

by deepsand

Given your rejection of the legitimacy of the knowledge of certain others, whose knowledge and understanding yields a conclusion that you find unsatisfactory, you seek to recast them, and all who accept them, in an unfavorable light by employing the term "elite" as a pejorative.

by Member 25348569

I don't have to do anything other than sit back and let Nature do it.

If I grow a hundred acre field of, say, corn, ALL of its constituent carbon is derived from atmospheric carbon, lowering atmospheric CO2. When I sell the cobs for human food and process for biofuel and utilise as animal feedstuff the rest, ALL of that carbon is released back into the atmosphere as Carbon Dioxide. Next year, I grow it again. Year on year carbon footprint is zero so long as I use my some of my fuel output to power my tractor and processing plant and provide sufficient energy to offset any fertilizer that I might need.

by Member 25348569

But do it for C + O2 -> CO2 as well as his claim was that carbon doesn't contribute anything to fuel energy output.

I have done the calculations further up the thread anyway so I'm confident about MY conclusion that Hydrogen content is not the ONLY contribution - not even close.

On an energy per weight basis, Hydrogen beats Carbon, no problem, but half of that is due to the anomalous atomic structure of Hydrogen in having no neutrons.

We still get to the problem of carrying the stuff around, though.

Neil :D

by nicknielsen

The same economies of scale that created the supertankers dictate that it's more economical to ship the raw crude to a refinery close to the end-user than to ship the refined products from the well-head.

The oil refinery separates crude oil into its constituent components, including gasoline, kerosene, LP gas, heavy oil, lubricating oil and asphalt. Some components are further processed to create additional gasoline, diesel fuel, wax, and coke. Once separated, each product must then be stored and shipped separately.

Many of these products (LP gas, for example) are highly volatile and require specialized shipping and handling. The shorter the distance they are transported, the lower the shipping costs.

Link:
http://science.howstuffworks.com/oil-refining.htm/printable
http://www.edf.org/article.cfm?ContentID=1537

Edit: correction

by jamesrl

Americans experienced Three Mile Island. Canadians. Brits, French etc have not.

James

by jdclyde

While not the most flowery of language, it does get right to the heart of the matter, doesn't it?

Yeah, some will say that people don't NEED boats, jetskis, quadrunners, snowmobiles or whatever. F them.

While I don't own any of those toys, as long as the purchase and upkeep of them doesn't take away from the needs of kids in the family, rock on.

Just use them in a responsible manner.

People that tear up the woods (going off the trails) or don't keep them properly maintained (leakage) should be flogged, publicly, and often.

People that tell other people what they need and don't need, NEED to be flogged as well... ;\

by jdclyde

comes from the Feds giving funding. A simple thing, and I am sure you understand fully well before you even asked that.

Anyone that doesn't want to follow federal guidelines can simple choose to not accept federal funds.

NCLB was put in place BECAUSE the system was so corrupt and failing, someone had to finally TRY something. NCLB didn't make anything worse, and didn't hold anyone back.

Name the last Democrat solution other than to blindly throw even more (federal) money at schools and hope that some of it would help?

The public schools already spend much more than the private schools per student, yet have much lower end results. Maybe it is the METHODS, not the money? hmmmmmmm.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]The public schools already spend much more than the private schools per student, yet have much lower end results. Maybe it is the METHODS, not the money?[/i]

All by itself, partaking of a service which is described by elected representatives and distributed to future voters as primarily an entitlement, which is difficult to revoke for behavior problems up to and including crimes, and impossible to revoke on the basis of "mere" lack of performance, fosters the entitlement mentality on which we've previously [at least partially] agreed. At many private schools and some public "magnet schools" attended by friends, one's [i]alma mater[/i] tends more to serve as proof of achievement than at "regular" public high school's, attendance at which is seemingly mentioned to provide no other data than what can be obtained from a GPS device.

With the decreased total cost per student, the cost [b]to the parents[/b] probably remains about the same, while the quality increases. For a parent to favor public over private education in these circumstances, which we all know to be reality, permits no other explanation than malice toward their own offspring.

[edit: Omit a letter here, and a word there, and pretty soon it looks Absolutely like gibberish.]

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]On an energy per weight basis, Hydrogen beats Carbon, no problem, but half of that is due to the anomalous atomic structure of Hydrogen in having no neutrons.[/i]

It's an inanimate element, not a person, so I only care that it's the most efficient source of energy for my purpose, which is conversion to mechanical or electric form. I'll come back in a couple hours to do the calculations, and leave just one thought to ponder in the meantime. A balanced hydrocarbon equation which does not include CO in the products isn't telling the whole story, it's only describing the unreal ideal case of complete combustion of a hydrocarbon.

2H2 + O2 --> 2H2O2

edit: capital 'O' in chemical equations for oxygen. D'oh!

by santeewelding

Forgetting this in the press of work one day singed every hair on my dear belly in the case of O2 and C2H2.

by $$$$$$$$$$

How to set the value(s) of T, is it same before & after a chemical reaction?
...
Forget it, I found the answer ready-made in the text I was using to find the theory, so for now I'll just copy the answer from the book and understand the equations later. I did promise the answer within hours, which I think means less than half a day later, so here is the entire chart:

[pre]
Substance Energy Released [kJ/g]
hydrogen [to give H2O(liquid)] 142
gasoline 48
crude petroleum 43
typical animal fat 38
coal 29.3
charcoal 29
paper 20
dry biomass 16
air-dried wood or dung 13
[/pre]

Kotz & Treichel, [i]Chemistry & Chemical Reactivity, Fourth Edition[/i]

edit: html for Δ doesn't display correctly without an edit/submit my comments. I suppose I need to copy & paste the symbol, not its code [pre]Δ[/pre]Have I mentioned lately that I really don't like computers very much?

by deepsand

The progress bar creeps along, but the timer remains fixed at 00:002 and no video or audio are forthcoming. Not being one who frequents YouTube, is it the case, unlikely as it may seem, that it doesn't support RealPlayer?

by $$$$$$$$$$

Both petroleum & batteries involve some liquid, which [b]will[/b] leak, constituting "pollution" in some proportion of cases of use.

Are the proportions the same? Similar? I don't know. But, estimating both sources as equivalently polluting in the liquid phase, batteries are the clear winner, because we never put them into the gas phase. Whether we [b]choose[/b] to clean up after ourselves is a question to consider as secondary to the question of the relative [b]possibilities[/b] of cleaning our waste.

by deepsand

In the mean, as you've already pointed out, managing solids is much easier than managing liquids, which themselves are eminently more manageable than are gases. And, whether or not we choose to manage any wisely is an entirely different matter.

Re. solar, from the wording of his next to last post in this sub-thread, it appears that his primary objection at this point may be nothing more than the ROI.

by deepsand

At this point, I'm not ready to decide who's correct; further research and thought is required.

by $$$$$$$$$$

I want to work in the labs where better energy sources are developed, the plants where they're manufactured, or the shops where they're installed. Until that industry proceeds beyond its infancy, the chances are slim. I was also motivated by Dan's mention of shortage of time for a thorough answer. Something might come up Sunday!

by deepsand

While the Earth as whole can be taken as a closed system, individual volumes of land, sea and air cannot necessarily be considered to be part of such.

Therefore, while the total CO2 in gaseous form may remain constant over the long term, assuming that the output from combustion equals that of the intake by biota, it does not necessarily hold that such balance will will be uniformly experienced throughout the entire volume of Earth space.

Given the presence of different convection cells, is it not then possible that CO2 accumulates in the troposhere in some regions at a rate faster than it is consumed in others? And, if so, might this not result in increased radiative forcing in some regions, or increased ocean acidification in others?

by tonythetiger

have shifted their focus to the results of testing rather than the teaching of children. This has led to children being required to memorize things rather than learn them.

They have gotten away from seeking answers themselves, instead preferring to wait around for someone to teach them something. Since the opponents of nuclear energy are more vocal that's what people are hearing, thus being "taught".

Welcome to Generation G (gullible).

by deepsand

I fully expect that within a decade or two we will see batteries, supercapacitors, fuel cells, and photo-voltaic cells that by today's measure will seem miraculous.

by deepsand

It only explains that certain people had a particular experience that might give rise to fear.

I was one of those in "danger" from Three Mile Island. I heard the voices of fear. I also witnessed those who insisted that their fears were well grounded, even though thay had not the slightest clue as to the pertinent facts. They simply "knew" that things were going to start glowing in the dark, or that a mushroom cloud would appear above the Susquehanna River. For them, it was taken as article of faith.

Why were these people so irrational? Why too the same for those who were never in danger?

Why do people have an irrational fear of that which they do not understand?

Why do some succumb to fear, while others heed the voice of reason?

by deepsand

The fact remains that the Constitution provides the Fed with no authority to regulate education, along with a parcel of other areas in which the Feds meddle.

How odd that Republicans, who espouse the Doctrine of Strict Construction, rely on that of Implied Powers when it serves their purposes.

Before you go blaming politicians and/or teachers for the plight of public education, you might look to the parents, who, despite their demands for "quality" education, put little to no effort into seeing to it that their kids become [i]educated[/i].

Far too many of them are only too eager to take the easy path, allowing their kids to learn no more than their schools demand of them. The wife of my best friend, after teaching since she graduated from college over 3 decades ago, is taking early retirement; she is burned out, overwhelmed by the feeling of having accomplished very little. She is weary of trying, and almost always failing, to motivate parents to help their children realize their potential, of parents telling her that "passing" is good enough.

And, of those parents who do envision their children attending college, it's not for the purpose of furthering their education, but of getting a "good job." For the most part, colleges have therefore ceased to be seats of learning, having become little more than expensive institutes of vocational training.

by deepsand

Far too many of them are only too eager to take the easy path, allowing their kids to learn no more than their schools demand of them. The wife of my best friend, after teaching since she graduated from college over 3 decades ago, is taking early retirement; she is burned out, overwhelmed by the feeling of having accomplished very little. She is weary of trying, and almost always failing, to motivate parents to help their children realize their potential, of parents telling her that "passing" is good enough.

Of course, placing an emphasis on passing a standardized test results in teaching to the lowest common denominator.

And, of those parents who do envision their children attending college, it's not for the purpose of furthering their education, but of getting a "good job." For the most part, colleges have therefore ceased to be seats of learning, having become little more than expensive institutes of vocational training.

by deepsand

Surely you know this.

Are you suggesting that the populace generally prefers the lessor qualified candidates?

My own take is that the average voter is simply too damn lazy to put any more effort into voting than the bare minimum required, and simply votes for the candidate that he thinks will give him what he wants at the moment, as opposed to what we all need for the long term.

by tonythetiger

Yes, parents, by and large, are responsible for their children's failure to teach their children to be discerning. But then you have those who take advantage of the ignorance of others (I wonder where they learned THAT?), which is also not OK, in my eyes.

An anecdote: While I was helping out at my daughter's school, I overheard a kid complaining to the principal. He related his story: "I got up to go sharpen a pencil. On my way up the aisle, another kid stuck his foot out and tried to trip me. I yelled "Hey!" and immediately got reprimanded for disrupting the class."

The principal told him "You're going to have to learn to be slicker."

That didn't set well with me and I asked the principal if that's what children should be taught. He said "It is if you want them to get ahead in the world."

I think it's sad.

by deepsand

as to whether or not the kid told his parents; and, if so, whether or not they tried to have the teacher reprimanded.

Not that I'm saying that they would find an easy success in that effort; school administrators are no different than those in any other business sector, with far too many willing to take the path of least resistance in most regards. Still, if not the parents, then who will lead?

by jdclyde

When we go into the candidate selection process, it is strictly a popularity contest. [b]Yes, it isn't suppose to be[/b], but the "average" citizen is a retard. look at what is popular in the likes of Madonna and Britney. please.

Barak can talk good, and sounds good saying a lot without saying a thing. We hear constantly how, even though he has surounded himself with America hating racists, how HE will bring us change. We are in deep trouble.

by nicknielsen

The basic assumption of NCLB, simply stated, is that all children, regardless of ability or disability, can learn to the same level at the same rate. Yeah, right.

The second major flaw in NCLB is that states were allowed to set their levels of "competence." Mississippi may have more students meeting standards than Massachusetts or South Carolina, but there's a reason.
USA Today article - http://tinyurl.com/3bpe2r
Study - http://tinyurl.com/3bokee

This is anecdotal, but it speaks to the standards issue. My niece recently graduated from high school in Michigan after moving there from South Carolina. She aced her senior year. She says she already knew everything the Michigan school taught her, she had learned it as a junior in South Carolina. In the linked study, South Carolina received a B- for the rigor of its standards; Michigan received a D.

Edit: speling

by nicknielsen

[i]The public schools already spend much more than the private schools per student, yet have much lower end results. Maybe it is the METHODS, not the money?[/i]

Comparing results between public and private schools is like comparing apples and oranges. Private schools have advantages over public schools:
1. Parental involvement. If a parent has gone to the trouble of paying for a private school, it is usually because that parent is active in the child's education. I actually met the parents of less than 15% of my students in five years of teaching in public school.
2. Cherry-picking. Most private schools do not accept students with learning disabilities unless the schools is specifically intended for such students. These students thus attend public school; their test results are included in the overall ratings of the school they attend.

And the academic superiority of private schools is also in question: http://tinyurl.com/db2lp

by $$$$$$$$$$

the first President ever to be elected to office with a pre-existing criminal record in 2000, then [b]re-electing him[/b] in 2004 after the Downing Street Memo had come to light, can be seen as anything other than monstrous hypocrisy?

by $$$$$$$$$$

I'm fairly new to that source of "data" myself, but my understanding is that it requires Macromedia(Adobe?) Flash. I could not get it working in Linux, with any but the Macromedia product, which I did despite my preference for Free & Open software. Like some other sites I've noticed recently and subsequently bypassed, I believe it also [b]requires[/b] the "Newest version of Flash."

Bah!

by deepsand

It's one that was crippled by Symantec NAV, and is only partially rehabilitated. After witnessing several other instances of odd behavior, including another involving Real Player and an application that had previously been ok, I rebooted.

Looks likes it may be a series worth viewing in its entirety; nice find.

by $$$$$$$$$$

I myself posted the info to which I believe he's referring, but my enthusiasm for this position is little. I just happened to hear Pickens on C-SPAN.org (com?) while composing a reply to this discussion, and as old & rich as he already is, I'm inclined to believe his claims of detachment, and of course he knows the facts of manufacturing well enough to have enjoyed not-inconsiderable success in the field we're discussing. Still, he has some vested interests, including wind power in Texas. It's quite possible that, deprived of government favoritism shown to one of his competitors, he's recommending against building new refineries more out of spite than practicality.

It's that kind of crap that keeps me more interested in the cutting edge of science & technology than the government policy of the moment. I'd probably be more useful to the world if I could stomach staying up-to-date on both.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]elitism is an attitude,
It's someone who thinks their $hit don't stink, but want someone else to clean it up anyway.[/i]

Sure, fine, but why re-state the definition maxwell already posted, with which I already agreed? I don't see anything your comment added to the previously-agreed definition of "elitism" so why did you post that comment at all? Second, why to me? It looks like you're trying to say something, without actually saying it.

by $$$$$$$$$$

If, by Harry Potter magic, public schools disappeared tomorrow, you can't really believe that only 15% of parents would find a way to finance their children's ongoing education, although it may have seemed that way [b]at times[/b] as a teacher.

[i]1. Parental involvement. If a parent has gone to the trouble of paying for a private school, it is usually because that parent is active in the child's education. I actually met the parents of less than 15% of my students in five years of teaching in public school.[/i]

It's my contention that in the absence of the option of having a (co-called) education, free of the trouble of selecting & paying for it as a discreet, volitional expense (as opposed to a coerced expense, lumped together with a plethora of other expenditures of our obligatory taxes), parents would not only go to the necessary "trouble" of seeing to their children's education, they would find it to be more rewarding and less trouble than they now suppose, even if -- perhaps, especially if -- their finances require home-schooling.

[i]2. Cherry-picking. Most private schools do not accept students with learning disabilities unless the schools is specifically intended for such students. These students thus attend public school; their test results are included in the overall ratings of the school they attend.[/i]

While self-selection undoubtedly skews some measurements, the amount of such skew is difficult or impossible to determine. Also, is it truly the case that "special needs" students are included in the "grading" of schools? If not, it would render the "cherry-picking" complaint meaningless. If so, that failure to measure accurately would seem to further impugn the quality of public education, turning your complaint to further support for privatization!

[i]And the academic superiority of private schools is also in question:[/i] http://tinyurl.com/db2lp

There are two basic reasons, in my experience, that students are sent to private schools:

1. academic and/or ideological (usually xian) preference

2. discipline cases

"Analyzing raw data from the 2000 National Assessment of Educational Progress for 28,000 fourth- and eighth-graders representing more than 1,300 public and private schools, Mrs. Lubienski, whose research focuses on equity issues in math education, was surprised by what she was seeing. When children of similar socioeconomic status were compared, the public school children scored higher. She called in her husband, who studies school choice and privatization, to help interpret the results."

That's weird. I doubt they're telling us about all the correlations they identified. I strongly suspect there is something else more strongly related than income, but I don't have the raw data to prove it. In any case, this is but a single claimed exception to a phenomenon that remains generally true. Also, if the math test in question was geared to the national public school curriculum, which is likely as both are federal projects, we should further discount its apparent significance.

by $$$$$$$$$$

Zero. Nobody. Not one person was even harmed by the Three Mile Island non-event, which was, properly understood, a demonstration of the skill and wisdom of nuclear engineering, not "close call" averted by Divine Providence, nor even dumb luck. Like the small damage of Chernobyl (compare to a nuclear bomb, and the amount of energy Chernobyl produced during its operation!), despite the horribly incompetent, politics-over-fact story behind that meltdown, both show that nuclear energy can be harnessed safely. Even the worst reactor designs ever implemented were designed with the magnitude of the risks carefully considered. I'm with deepsand on this, the American fear of nuclear energy is mostly irrational.

by $$$$$$$$$$

I'd call active encouragement of dishonesty grounds for dismissal, on the first documented instance. Hop to it!

by delbertpgh

The learning disabled are, Abs, included in the NCLB evaluations. In fact, they are a separate-but-equal category of student, and if a school does not show sufficient progress in improving the test scores of these guys, it can be ranked as a failed school, eligible to have its federal subsidy dollars sidetracked to another school, should parents of any child (not just the learning disabled ones) decide they would like to move.

by $$$$$$$$$$

did George, Jr. attend any public schools? If so, another BIG mark against public education!!

by nicknielsen

[i]It's my contention that in the absence of the option of having a (co-called) education, free of the trouble of selecting & paying for it as a discreet, volitional expense (as opposed to a coerced expense, lumped together with a plethora of other expenditures of our obligatory taxes), parents would not only go to the necessary "trouble" of seeing to their children's education, they would find it to be more rewarding and less trouble than they now suppose, even if -- perhaps, especially if -- their finances require home-schooling.[/i]

Huh? It took me close to ten minutes to parse what I think you said, so I'll answer that.
a. If I implied that only 15% of parents are involved in their children's education, I did not intend to. My comment was intended more to justify my feeling that too many parents are not as involved as they should be. The vast majority of successful students, regardless of school, have parents active in their education.
b. Under law, parents have the option to avail themselves of the public education system or not, as long as their child receives the education required by state standards. However, economics often eliminates choice for many parents, particularly single parents. They cannot afford private school, nor do their finances [u]allow[/u] home-schooling.
c. Contrary to your indicated belief, homeschooling is not an inexpensive choice. The homeschooling parent must meet legal requirements (in SC, http://ed.sc.gov/agency/offices/sq/Homeschooling/statutes.html). There is also the cost of textbooks and course materials, not to mention the usual supplies. Some estimates are that homeschoolers can pay as much for instructional materials as public schools pay. The homeschooling family is also giving up the income potential of the parent doing the schooling. http://tinyurl.com/68ql3x

[i]Also, is it truly the case that "special needs" students are included in the "grading" of schools? If not, it would render the "cherry-picking" complaint meaningless. If so, that failure to measure accurately would seem to further impugn the quality of public education, turning your complaint to further support for privatization![/i]

Your ?failure to measure accurately? is required by law. The Americans with Disabilities Act and Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 protect the rights of students with learning disabilities. Accordingly, no public school is allowed to deny attendance to a student that meets attendance qualifications, nor can a public school deny a student any publicly available opportunity. When a student takes a test, the results are included in the overall results for that school.

Educational cherry-picking by both public and private schools is very real; witness the college application process. Do you really think a private high school won't do the same thing? How many public schools require that you pass an entrance examination? http://tinyurl.com/6adl2c

[i]That's weird. I doubt they're telling us about all the correlations they identified. I strongly suspect there is something else more strongly related than income, but I don't have the raw data to prove it. In any case, this is but a single claimed exception to a phenomenon that remains generally true.[/i]

That's as may be, but the main reason it got my attention is that he is described as one ?who studies school choice and privatization.? Here in South Carolina, those are code words for ?school choice advocate.? The last thing a school choice advocate here would willingly admit is that public schools might be doing better in any area except possibly sports. And do you have a link documenting that "phenomenon that remains generally true?"

I am not saying there aren't problems with our public education system; if you've even paid the remotest attention to my previous posts on the subject, you are aware of that. Our education system with its summer break is configured around an agrarian economy that no longer exists. Today's students have so many more distractions (and options) than were possible even 15 years ago. ?Privatizing? is not [u]the[/u] cure. ?Competition? is not [u]the[/u] cure. I have no idea what the cure might be beyond setting national standards and making them stick, but it will not be a single magic bullet, nor will it be buzzwords and catchphrases.

Edit: format

by deepsand

the need for changing between different fractionalizations at local refineries as demand requires, particulary those seasonal changes induced by increased demand for heating oil during winter & diesel/gasoline for transporting fall harvests, various formulations so as to meet clean air standards, etc..

by deepsand

in the US, with the result that we're now beholden to Big Oil and the attendant consequences.

It's time for American's to get their collective head out of their ass, face the facts and deal with them logically.

by deepsand

While there is truth in the adage that it takes a village to raise a child, too many take that to mean that the acts of any one individual are insufficient for the task; and, by extension, that their own acts are of no consequence and therefore unnecessary.

The error here is to not recognize that there are acts of commission and acts of omission, and that doing nothing can have an effect equal to that of doing something.

When I was a child, it was most commonplace for adults to discipline children not their own; not only was this accepted, it was in fact expected. Then, the village acted so as to guide the child toward the right path.

Today is so very different. Parents take offense at the efforts of others in this regard, with the result that everyone other than the parents is too fearful of reprisals to make the effort.

The village stands by, while the parents do nothing.

"The only thing required for evil to succeed is for good men to do nothing."

by deepsand

"[i]... the "average" citizen is a retard.[/i]"

Now Max will be calling both of us "elitists!"

If so, it's a label that I'll proudly wear, knowing that, in this case, it really means "cognoscenti."

by jdclyde

AB = DUI 30 years ago, hardly something I am going to lose any sleep over.

If you want an example, if a Republican says anything that could even be MISUNDERSTOOD to be racist, they are done. "nigerdly" anyone? But if your a Democart (ex-KKK) you get a red carpet into congress.

Obama's spiritual adviser AND wife (and others in his mob) are very anti-america and racist, he looks the other way. When Amis (amis in the morning) made his "knappy haired hoes" comment, Obama was right there for the kill. Oh, Amis has done more for childrens charities and such than the racist "spiritual corruptor" of Obamas ever has? So?

=========================

Deep. yes.

by nicknielsen

[i]But if your a Democart [/i][sic][i] (ex-KKK) you get a red carpet into congress. [/i]

You are inaccurate for two reasons:

1. Most ex-KKK members are no longer Democrats, but have switched parties and are now Republicans. Something to be proud of there...or not.
2. There may be a Democratic red carpet in Michigan, but I don't see one down here. In a state that 40 years ago was solidly Democratic, we now have two Republican senators and four of six representatives are Republicans.

And I think that might have been ?Imus in the Morning.? Just to quibble.