If this isn?t lunacy, I don?t know what is
This is page 5 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Software
This is page 5 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by jdclyde
amusimasumaswhocaresamus?
:p
by $$$$$$$$$$
by $$$$$$$$$$
Although an important & interesting topic, this is a sidetrack from the thread, so I'm going to make this my last post in this sub-thread. (I might still refer to the education system while commenting on Americans' irrational fear of nuclear energy, but only in that context.) I want to pose one question to you, as I get off the topic of education (in general) and back to energy.
[i]a. If I implied that only 15% of parents are involved in their children's education, I did not intend to. My comment was intended more to justify my feeling that too many parents are not as involved as they should be. The vast majority of successful students, regardless of school, have parents active in their education.[/i]
Do you think, overall, parents would be more, less, or equally (un)involved in their children's education, if the State (that is local, state, [b]and[/b] federal jurisdictions of government) ceased all involvement in education? Whether the overall effect would be for the better or worse I'd like to ignore for the moment, and instead analyze each discreet change in isolation so as to discuss each with the assumption "other things being equal."
I think dictators come to power in all sorts of bureaucracies from school boards on up, by falsely conflating unrelated topics into convenient fallacies for crass scare tactics, which nobody has the time to effectively watchdog. Instead, we have to look closely at the arguments, introducing one datum at a time.
by $$$$$$$$$$
by danlm
Hazardous waste Batteries(Solar Panels to be addressed in second post)
My Assumptions about batteries and hydrides
1). If you look at the original post I made to deepsand, you will notice that I reference Thrope Pennsylvania and a battery plant hazardous waste cleanup. This was caused by, I believe lead. I lived from 5 to 15 miles from there for over 20 years, and that is the primary reason I thought hydride batteries contained hazardous materials.
2). Life cycle of Hydride batteries. I have always been under the impression that the current Hydride batteries had a very short life cycle. Ie: 3 to 4 years. This was because of conversations I have had with people and the comments that ?people do not realize they will have to replace these batteries in ? years? at several thousand dollars.
3). Weight of hydride batteries. Due to these type of vehicles acquiring their propulsion from electrical power stored in batteries. These type of vehicles would contain a couple hundred pounds worth of batteries. Much more then your current conventional cars. For every hydride car, you would have a multiplier of what would be required for recycling and disposal of the batteries versus what you do today.
Facts about batteries and hydrides.
Assumptions 1 and 2). Hazardous waste and life cycle.
First using http://www.hybridcars.com/battery-toxicity.html(Hybrid Battery Toxicity) as a reference which is as of 04/2006.
It address's something that was at the core of my first assumption. Car batteries are pretty much alike.
[i]After all, aren't all car batteries ?conventional lead acid and hybrid batteries alike?filled with the same nasty corrosive carcinogenic ooze?
According to environmental researchers, that's not the case. Jim Kliesch, author of the "Green Book: The Environmental Guide to Cars and Trucks" told HybridCars.com, "There are many types of batteries. Some are far more toxic than others. While batteries like lead acid or nickel cadmium are incredibly bad for the environment, the toxicity levels and environmental impact of nickel metal hydride batteries?the type currently used in hybrids?are much lower."[/i]
When reading further down into that specific article, you will see that they do address the environmental impacts. Lead being used in most cars today, but because of the weight it carries other types of materials are being explored.... [i]"Lead is so heavy. You can't just add more or larger lead-acid batteries to accommodate the increased electrical demands. Some say lead is at its limit."[/i]
Damn, good article... What they do is list out the toxicity of the various types of batteries from worse to best. Lead, Nickel, then lithium.
This article also notes that [i]Hybrid batteries are under warranty for eight to 10 years, depending on the manufacturer and your location, most likely won't fail for several years beyond the warranty.[/i] which address's my second assumption.
Assumption 3... I don't seem to be able to find the amount of batteries or the weight of batteries which would be found in a hydride.
What my conclusions were from the above.
1). Different materials used in these batteries, but they still are toxic. Because of the price of raw materials(, recycling these batteries will most be a high priority.
2). The life cycle of these batteries is more then acceptable, 10 year warranty... Probably the same as what is found in conventional cars.
3). Couldn't find anything that said how many battery packs were in a hydride, how much each pack weighed. I still think the amount of batteries in a hydride will be heavier and greater then conventional vehicles which will multiply out recycling and disposal of the batteries... But I can't prove it.
I was wrong... From everything I read, I don't see any greater disposal risks then what we face now. The types of batteries that are/will be used are also used in other applications... This in my mind, will insure that there is sufficient resources allocated for the disposal of these batteries. I also think that hydride cars will be expensive, and will not be affordable to the common citizen for a long time. Again, less vehicles on the road to worry about disposal.
Bloody department of energy web site sucked for research into this one.
Hey deepsand, I was wrong.. Chuckle, what else is new. hu?
Dan
[edited to add] I did read other sources other then the one link I provided. But this link seemed to be the most comprehensive and said the same thing as the other sources.
by deepsand
As long a your heart responds to a defibrillator or other stimuli, you're deemed alive enough to serve in office.
And, the fact that you continue to bring home the pork ensures that there are plenty to step in to pound on your chest if need be.
by deepsand
hazardess if handled improperly, but that in that respect they differ not from so very many commonplace commodities yet are more amenable to being properly handled.
Rather it is that batteries do have their reactive components neatly encased so as to make their being well managed eminently more easy and convenient than that of managing gases and uncontained liquids. And, with ongoing technological advances, we should expect to see batteries that are both more benign and of higher energy densities and lifetimes.
by nicknielsen
by jdclyde
You do not think that having someone that hates America and Whites specifically be the adviser to the President is something to be concerned with?
Him being a racist git is more of a concern to me than the people worried about if he is a closet Muslim.
It isn't about God, it is about hate. Lots of hate surrounding Obama.
by nicknielsen
[i]Do you think, overall, parents would be more, less, or equally (un)involved in their children's education, if the State (that is local, state, and federal jurisdictions of government) ceased all involvement in education? [/i]
I don't know. There would be a significant change, but in which direction, I have no idea. I would hope that parents would step up and take the responsibility they have been ceding to the schools, but in our society today, there's no telling. Many parents may step in, but many may also issue that classic line from Blazing Saddles: "Son...you're on your own!"
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
by seabee69m
The slow removal of the earth's minority,
they shall have their wealthy elite in control.
by danlm
was shown on HBO.
If you watched that mini series, you will notice that the first congress was pretty heavily saturated of people with money. Hell, Thomas Jefferson, John Adams, and George Washington were rich.
Well, John Adams not so rich. But his parents were well off enough to put him through college to start his law business. Chuckle, that's right... Lawyers were in abundance then just like they are now in this nations capitol. The rich were making the decisions then just like they are now.
In other words, what's different now then what was before? Kings and queens made the decisions in Europe The wealthy were in the majority of who was our leaders at this nations beginning.
I'm going to stop now before I begin to flame. My final words are... Everyone thinks things are so different and worse then they were before. Take the time to read some history.
Dan
[Edited to add] Hell, I can't resist this. Page 117 from John Adams written by David McCullough. Second paragraph where they are describing some of the difference between Jefferson and Adams: [i]Jefferson was devoted to the idea of improving mankind but had comparatively little interest in people in particular.[/i]
Now tell me that isn't an elitist.. Just do as I say, I know best type of attitude. No kidding. Don't get me wrong, Jefferson was a great man with regard to this nations beginnings. But that is just one example where people need to start reading history to learn that government and people are not so much different now then they were at the beginning. Disputes, dislikes, high opinions of ones self. My way or no way.
by deepsand
Yes, when it comes to money and power, men are little different now from what they were at the dawn of civilization. The only thing that has changed is the ways and means at his disposal for controlling that and those around him.
It is not by accident that Our Founding Fathers were not the great unwashed poor, but rather the privileged well endowed of the times.
by danlm
Hazardous materials and Solar Panels
Again, with the battery post I put forth my position on solar panels was an assumption. Pretty much it fell under this assumption. I just assumed that various materials used in making them would be hazardous. No other reason then that.
Because I'm a dumb yuck, I had no idea what PV stood for.. Here is the definition that I found.
http://www.yourdictionary.com/photovoltaic
Photovoltaic Definition
photo?vol?taic (fōt′ō v?l tā′ik)
adjective
of or having to do with the generation of an electromotive force at the junction of two different materials in response to visible or other radiation
Etymology: photo- + voltaic
Bottom line for this from the department of energy. http://www1.eere.energy.gov/solar/panel_disposal.html
[i]PV products are generally safe for landfills, because PV materials are usually encased in glass or plastic, and many are insoluble. Some modules, however, could be classified as hazardous waste, a situation that is prompting the PV industry to develop recycling processes for modules.[/i]
I wasn?t even close this time.
Dan
by $$$$$$$$$$
[i]AB and the office running for
You do not think that having someone that hates America and Whites specifically be the adviser to the President is something to be concerned with?[/i]
Well, I know you're not talking about Rev. Wright, because I read Obama's speech about that smear job. He made it very clear that he can listen to an overly-emotive pastor [b]rant[/b] about real, historical and current racism, appreciate the validity of the complaints and how they contribute to real, valid concerns of the congregation (and voters) without agreeing with every vengeful word. Both of us have done more than our fair share of ranting, and know how much salt to take with anybody else's rants, so don't bring that guilt by association crap to me.
So, who [b]are[/b] you talking about?
by jdclyde
As you well know AB, there is a big difference between having someone around that continually says stupid things, and you ignore it.
If you have someone that you hold up as your spiritual guide, then that means they GUIDE YOUR SPIRIT. If the guide is a racist pig, then you will follow your guide into pigdome.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=36T1fnIafC0
hardly a right-wing source.
Yeah, whites in America invented AIDS so they could give it to the blacks.
Run along and make another excuse for this, but make it to someone that doesn't pay attention.
by $$$$$$$$$$
OK, what about being a "spiritual guide"? Rev. Jeremiah Wright certainly spoke some angry words in that video montage. So what? What actions set the context of those words? Is he a violent, underground terrorist the FBI has put in prison for illegal actions that caused real harm to real people? Or were the few phrases quoted out of context? It sounds like he's critical of the character of prominent, famous people (My favorite was "Conned/Amnesia." You?), and exhorting his congregation to choose more positive role models than the most convenient ones on the idiot box. I'd think you'd understand all that, particularly with all you say about your own kids' role models. How often do you say about somebody, "not good enough role model for my boys," or similar?
Oh, my favorite part, 2:50!
"Reverend Wright retired last month, but members of the church say, he made a lasting impression on them, and Senator Obama."
1. Other members' words are essentially attributed to Senator Obama there.
2. Which members of the church, the paparazzi won't say.
3. The paparazzi are paraphrasing, not quoting. Go stand in the corner, and think about how weak a quote has to be for the paparazzi to prefer to paraphrase.
Finally, do you have any spiritual guides yourself? Do they determine all your actions, or are they just people whose views you consider, before making your own independent choices?
edits: brevity; OK, finished editing, sorry JD.
...wild fantasy calling itself vision.
But go ahead, keep waiving your magic wand.
by jdclyde
And all three are going to be horrible for the country and the world.
Lets slap a bigger tax on "the rich" (make over 100K) and see how much MORE of the good paying jobs can be sent overseas.
It has been shown over and over, that lower taxes STIMULATE an economy. Just look at the BI_PARTISAN "stimulus" package. Give people back their money to spend themselves goes against everything Democrats have been saying all along.
STOP THE DAMN SPENDING is how you fix the economy.
I think McCain will be horrible, because he IS way to "liberal" in his spending of other peoples money, and will make the Republican party get all the blame for things getting WORSE, pushing people back to the Dems the next time around.
Obama is horrible in his ideas and will either bankrupt the nation or will have congress (if it is shifted back to Republicans) will not be able to get anything through (best case for ANY president).
Clinton, where do you start? Change by more of the same? And I still laugh at the morons that are going to vote for Bill, through her. Like that b1tch will listen to Bill or anyone else.
Of the three, I am looking for a third party to give my symbolic vote for. I don't see myself voting for the lesser of evils. or at worse case, become a "suicide voter" and vote for the Dems, so they can screw things up REALLY bad, to shake up the country.
In the mean time, I am paying off all debt and NOT buying anything new for a while, because things are going to get worse before they get better. Keeping my cost of living as low as I can.
by delbertpgh
The Three Mile Island accident was close to being a disaster. It really stretches credulity to try to recast it as a demonstration of our expertise and cunning, ignoring the screwup that started it and the risks that were present at the time. Remember, there was a gas bubble (hydrogen, no less) in the reactor that left the core uncovered, and if chance had played us wrong and not allowed us to bleed away that gas, we could have seen an explosion and a couple of tons of radioactive fuel scattered over the capitol of Pennsylvania.
What happened at TMI followed the rule, "If it can go wrong, it will go wrong." With enough plants and enough years of operation, there will sooner or later be a combination of mechanical and human error that makes for a near catastrophe, like TMI, or worse, like Chernobyl.
Newer reactor designs are laid out to be inherently safe, even in cases of total coolant loss. Nuclear power has a better future than ever.
by mallardtooxx
Girls should not be allowed to do things...Box :) I was being a little tongue in cheek cause I am just as accident prone as my beautiful wife! I just often hide it until I either bleed through my clothing or I have to ask her if something is infected! On the other hand I have not ever tried to take my toe off with the weed eater then in a mad panic thrown it to the ground and nearly decapitate my son ;) As for the taking my wife out shooting...forget about it! She is like Anne Oakley and I am sure I could not remember what it was I had done to tick her off the day before. Try explaining that to a Dr. "Well see I was shot in the Buttocks!"
-duck
by $$$$$$$$$$
I was about to say "good enough for me," but that would be a [b]completely[/b] irrelevant statement, as I believe you'd eagerly agree. I would, however, be interested in a sub-thread comparing the 3 mainstream media candidates' respective energy policies, and/or lack thereof, as the case may actually be.
edit: "JD" is a proper noun
by $$$$$$$$$$
by $$$$$$$$$$
by danlm
Freight on railroads is booming... Seems that railroads have some preferred treatment with regard to anti-trust laws... But, hopefully... Railroads will become bigger(long as it becomes more competitive), which help slow the rising cost of goods... In other words, if it wasn't for different forms of transportation other then trucks. our costs would be much higher.
Dan
by tonythetiger
it's the value of the dollar that's going down!
And THAT's happening because some people are demanding more of it without offering more work in exchange. They don't realize the self-defeating nature of what they're doing.
Not only do their gains get quickly eaten up by rising prices, they devalued the dollars of the people who were providing them with employment. And THAT reduces opportunity.
by deepsand
In terms of local currencies, the cost of producing the great quantities of everything that the US imports are going up.
At the same time, the value of the dollar is declining relative to other currencies as a result of the above, coupled with the fact that US exports have sharply declined relative to past levels as measured globally.
The dollar has not fallen in value simply owing to the "printing" of money.
On the bright side, a cheaper dollar has brought an influx of foreign toursism.
by deepsand
While such is now present in most markets, a look at the commodity grains market will serve to illustrate.
See http://www.nytimes.com/2008/04/22/business/22commodity.html
Also, view the graph at http://www.nytimes.com/imagepages/2008/04/22/business/20080422_COMMODITY_GRAPHIC.html
by deepsand
isn't necessarily better.
Aside from perishables, getting a product across country more quickly does nothing except increase the costs of transportation.
by danlm
happening for the last couple years? That rail is being used more and more. It just seems to be hitting the news now... Also, they are adding track, not decommissioning it.
I can attest to this very easily. The trains run alongside the major highway I use to take(before the back roads) to work. There was always trains running, and they were always stacked with those metal box's that can also fit on trucks.
Which is what I think is happening... Transport the long distance via train, and then short haul from the rail spur to market via truck.
Dan
by tonythetiger
by $$$$$$$$$$
[i]When someone says
... "averages out" or "should be assumed to be", I get the distinct impression that science is taking a back seat to politics.[/i]
Apparently, you've somehow found out about the time machine that was used to select locations that 100 years later would be logged, so we could fake the global warming data. You better not tell, or I'll scare the next hurricane at YOU.
http://www.livfilms.com/2008/03/13/how-to-make-a-tinfoil-hat/
by deepsand
are actively seeking out knowledge, rather than waiting for others to feed you their own versions of the truth. In this I commend you, wishing that others would do the same.
As for solar power & hazardous materials, there will undoubtedly be the potential for some such being present; but, given that the state of the art is changing so rapidly, as the quest for increased conversion efficiency continues, it's difficult to know with any reasonable degree of certainty what elements will eventually be use in PV cells.
As for the framing materials themselves, which are the least likely to change with the passage of time, I would say that the main concern in that area would be the use of certain plastics, which can be easily removed for separate handing if need be.
by tonythetiger
by deepsand
That there are various kinds of averages, e.g. arithmetic mean, geometric mean, median, mode, is not to say that they lack for precision; rather, it is the case that the word "average" is frequently used in an ill-defined manner, frequently because the specific type is either irrelevant or that it is assumed to be understood by all, and sometimes to mean a particular kind of average, of an undisclosed type, that was especially chosen so as to best serve the purpose of the speaker.
It is the latter usage that is oft times employed in debate, whether of a political nature or other. That such is sometimes the case, though, does not mean that one can and should disregard all or any particular average.
As for the "consistency" of temperature measurements vis-a-vis the characteristics of the locale, consider the following. If a given location is consistently used, and the surrounds do become, for whatever reason, warmer in the long term, does such either require or even suggest that an other area has experienced a corresponding cooling; i.e., does heating at a given point require that cooling occur at another? Clearly the answer is "no."
And, if a given point and its surrounds remained in a warmer state, while those elsewhere do not cool, then is it not the case that, on average, by whatever measure chosen, temperatures have increased? Here, the answer is clearly "yes."
by deepsand
by deepsand
It's only neutral if the CO2 output uniformly returns to the input stream.
By way of analogy, consider the effects of various forms of savings of currencies on the that in circulation and therefore available for use. Currency that is physically stored outside the circulation clearly has an effect different from that which is transferred to a financial institution.
With CO2, that produced at a distance from its source, and then sequested in the oceans and/or atmosphere, so that it is not immediately returned to the input stream, alters the balance.
by deepsand
by danlm
what can I say... Same thing, different way of saying it.
I really like this book though... It characterizes both Thomas Jefferson and Benjamin Franklin as being very sedate in congress... Mr. Franklin doing more behind the scenes is what I gather. Mr. Jefferson, I get the impression. Making his view points through his written word. And Mr. Adams, the fiery debater. I don't know what I want to read next after this.. Thomas Jefferson or Benjamin Franklin.
By the way, I take it that Mr. Franklin was dirt poor before he started his printing business. He wealth came after he started his business.
Lol, and to this point... John Adams doesn't have a very high opinion with Thomas Pane.. But, that is because of his idea's of what the government should be. And I swear, he called him a racist...
God, I love this book. A makes these people much more close to the heart finding they are just as human as the rest of us in all their glory, and all their faults.
And I mean that in the best possible way. Because, for all the differences. All the egos. They worked things out to give us the nation we live in. And they did a great job at it.
Dan
by deepsand
Of course, they did not envision their creation becoming so large, as measured by any standard, as it has. Nor did they forsee the likelihood of the need for a large standing armed force, the need for a large Federal government to oversee such a great expanse, or that such would give rise to the professional politician.
One can but speculate as to what counsel they might now give.
by nicknielsen
by deepsand
However, locally (South East PA) there's no evidence of old lines being reclaimed. Many, if not most, were abandoned, reclaimed by state and/or local government, and transformed in biking and hiking trails.
I do understand, though, that north of here some lines are returning to life.
I would expect the latter to be more probable in less densely populated areas, and the former in those more densely populated, owing to the different needs with regards to preserving open spaces and access to nature preserves.
Still, I don't expect to hear the old steam whistles unless I venture to places like the Strasburg Rail Road or the East Broad Top RR & Coal Co. at Orbisonia. [insert emoticon for wistful sigh here]
by tonythetiger
[i]As for the "consistency" of temperature measurements vis-a-vis the characteristics of the locale, consider the following. If a given location is consistently used, and the surrounds do become, for whatever reason, warmer in the long term, does such either require or even suggest that an other area has experienced a corresponding cooling; i.e., does heating at a given point require that cooling occur at another? Clearly the answer is "no."
And, if a given point and its surrounds remained in a warmer state, while those elsewhere do not cool, then is it not the case that, on average, by whatever measure chosen, temperatures have increased? Here, the answer is clearly "yes"[/i]
... you actually measured all of those "elsewhere" points 100 years ago, but since they WEREN'T being measured then, you don't know if they cooled or not.
by sleepin'dawg
There's more energy in the gasoline, ergo; you would need to burn more ethanol, thus further adding to polution, to obtain the same energy that you would from gasoline.
Ethanol:- The GWB solution to air polution and Global Warming. Enough said.
[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)
by deepsand
While both the mass and volume energy densities of gasoline are greater than that of ethanol, that does not mean that the combustion of ethanol yields more CO2 than gasoline for the release of the same amount of energy.
Ethanol, C2H5OH, has a higher mole energy density that does gasoline, by virtue of its having a higher ration of hydrogen to non-hydrogen molecules than does gasoline. Gasoline, with generally between 5 and 12 carbon molecules can therefore, in a straight chain so as to maximize the bonds available for such, carry from 12 to 26 hydrogen molecules; the max. ratio of H to C in gasoline is therefore 12 to 5, or 2.4, less than the 6 to 2, or 3, of ethanol.
Thus, a greater portion of its combustion products is H2O than is the case for gasoline.
Additionally, ethanol, unlike gasoline, contains no sulfur or nitrogen.
I leave it to Neil to provide any needed energy calculations.
by $$$$$$$$$$
[i]That would be correct, if...
... you actually measured all of those "elsewhere" points 100 years ago, but since they WEREN'T being measured then, you don't know if they cooled or not. [/i]
OK, what mechanism do you suggest is causing that? Anthrophobic global cooling midichlorions?
edit: Since I described Tony's imaginary midichlorions as anthro[b]phobic[/b], I had to change "warming" to "cooling" in my closing jest, so that the cooling daemons would move away from the humans and our measuring devices, lowering the real average temperature while the measured average increases. "Anthrophilic global warming faeries" would also have served the same purpose, but I mixed my prefixes. Durn it.
by $$$$$$$$$$
by danlm
for a response on Hydride batteries... If the price of a hydride is comparable to my E85, that might be my next lease... Thats in 3 years now, but yes. I am doing something.
I'm burning ethanol every day, every week... Because I will do everything in my power to insure my energy dollars stay in the US.
Dan
by jdclyde
by $$$$$$$$$$
are pollution.
:p
by $$$$$$$$$$
Although I disagree with him about global warming science, I agree with maxwell's underlying premise in starting this thread, that knowing or believing something contrary to the mainstream logically implies discussion, either to inform others or detect one's own error. For deepsand, for example, to know that batteries are less toxic than Dan (and, by assumption, some population of citiznes with similar levels of knowledge of the same topic) believes, and that they are making both economic and political decisions on the basis of errors, and furthermore that those poor decisions will harm the economy in which he earns his living and the livability of the planet, the lunacy would be to silently decrease his own consumption only, and let ignorance spread of its own inertia. I think I'm less informed than deepsand, but participate for the same reason. If that bothers you, go slap yourself. Not all threads are the Friday Yuk, nor should be.
I also bike & bus & train to work, except for emergency calls requiring me to cover the same distance in a time possible only by personal motor vehicle.
by deepsand
by tonythetiger
I don't know ... but more importantly, I don't CLAIM to know (that which is impossible for me to know).
One hundred years ago, the measuring point at Columbus was at the edge of a clearing in a meadow. That spot is now an urban area. The average temperature of that spot is 4.5F degrees higher than what it was a hundred years ago.
They put new stations in meadows in Pickaway county (about 35 miles south), and Fayette county (about 40 miles southwest) 4 years ago. Neither of these areas have significantly urbanized in the last hundred years.
Can they claim that Pickaway and Fayette counties have also warmed up in the last hundred years? Can they claim those areas haven't cooled? If so, what is the basis of this claim? They weren't being measured 100 years ago!
And how many other measurement points that existed 100 years ago have had significant urbanization?
by deepsand
You know quite well that warming at one point is [b]not[/b] dependent on cooling a another.
When, for example, you turn on your stove or range, does its warmth cool down another area in your house? In your neighborhood? In the world?
Does it suck heat from [u]any[/u] other point in the universe?
by deepsand
one includes each and every possible data point within the universe of those being studied? That [b]no[/b] sampling method is valid?
In that case, virtually every decision that you have made in your lifetime was empirically flawed to the point of being no more that a wild-assed guess.
by deepsand
by $$$$$$$$$$
Comment on the laws of conservation of energy and mass and the first law of thermodynamics to prove you have a fraction of a clue what you're talking about. From there, develop an explanation of your hypothesis that urbanization of measurement locations is somehow distorting estimates of global mean temperature changes.
[i]Causing what?
I don't know ... but more importantly, I don't CLAIM to know (that which is impossible for me to know).[/i]
Impossible? Can you prove that?
[i]One hundred years ago, the measuring point at Columbus was at the edge of a clearing in a meadow. That spot is now an urban area. The average temperature of that spot is 4.5F degrees higher than what it was a hundred years ago.
They [/i]
Who is "They"? Exactly what type of research are "they" doing?
[i]... put new stations in meadows in Pickaway county (about 35 miles south), and Fayette county (about 40 miles southwest) 4 years ago. Neither of these areas have significantly urbanized in the last hundred years.
Can they claim that Pickaway and Fayette counties have also warmed up in the last hundred years?[/i]
More importantly, [b]do[/b] they claim that?
[i]Can they claim those areas haven't cooled? If so, what is the basis of this claim? They weren't being measured 100 years ago!
And how many other measurement points that existed 100 years ago have had significant urbanization?[/i]
That doesn't matter. Assuming, as you seem to do, that urbanization is the single cause of measurements of higher temperature, is such urbanization a local exception to a general ruralification trend, or is urbanization in fact the global trend? If previous measurement locations have become urban, are they [b]disproportionately[/b] located in subsequently-urbanized locations in comparison to the global average? And if so, that too can be taken into account, and would not justify discarding [b]any[/b] data. It is always up to you to quantify your claims, even if your claim is only of other researchers' errors. You must prove your claim or withdraw it in science.
edit: punctuation & minor improvement in manners
by deepsand
by $$$$$$$$$$
by $$$$$$$$$$
by $$$$$$$$$$
by deepsand
by deepsand
by $$$$$$$$$$
by w2ktechman
by deepsand
I was responding to Neil's post, at https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=260852&messageID=2480533 , in which he employed the phrase "carbon neutral" to describe the cyclical nature of a bio-fuel based system.
As I'd elsewhere carelessly over-simplified re. the contribution of the various components of hydrocarbons to the energy released by combustion, and was justifiably taken to task for such, I felt it important to not here leave any doubt as to my precise meaning.
by $$$$$$$$$$
Neil, what if you subtract from each calculation of energy released from hydrocarbon combustion, the energy derived from whatever numbers of O2, 2H2, and 2H2O are required in the balanced chemical equations? Would you say that gives a reasonable estimate of the [b]net[/b] contribution of carbon atoms to combustion?
Also, what would you [b]guess[/b] is the gain or loss of diverting some of a car's battery output to electrolysis of water, then adding the hydrogen to the combustion, which still includes some petrol? [I'm going to have to do the calculations myself, before deciding whether to start hacking on my car, but for sake of discussion I'm interested in your guess. Or, if you already know, I suppose it's OK to just give me the answer.]
He says it improves his mileage:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fc3mUwx8BAw&feature=related
If the electric energy necessary for electrolysis is more than what's released by the subsequent combustion of hydrogen, is it possible that combining just a little hydrogen with petroleum helps "crack" the hydrocarbons faster than occurs when only petroleum and oxygen contribute, accounting for a real increase in efficiency, claimed above?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KUGX0bq9vUs
(go straight to 2:10 for a more thorough discussion of hydrocarbon cracking, etc.)
In the second video, he makes an argument that hydrogen is more efficient based on Carnot engine equations:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hFifFR-4C28
... but for this and other general discussions (ie, not "preaching to choir," not "greenie" audiences) I think a chemical equation argument is also necessary. Anyway, the Carnot engine equations are best-case scenario limits, and using the chemical equations will be necessary at some point to pick the right amount of hydrogen. I don't like chemical equations very much, but I like the petrochemical industry even less, so I'm going to get to work on those equations. I'll select octane, btw, since that's supposedly the most prevalent type of "-ane" in gasolane.
:)
by jdclyde
that I beat you to posting that....
B-)
by $$$$$$$$$$
B-)
That was, in fact, the first draft of that reply.
by tonythetiger
[i]You know quite well that warming at one point is not dependent on cooling a another.[/i]
I have not claimed or implied any such thing!
All I am saying is that (of the points that weren't being measured 100 years ago) we [b]don't know[/b] whether they have warmed, cooled, or stayed the same during that 100 years.
by $$$$$$$$$$
by tonythetiger
[i]Are you saying, Tony, that no average is meaningful unless ...
one includes each and every possible data point within the universe of those being studied?[/i]
[edit formatting on this one too]
Each average is valid for the conditions under which it was taken. What I am saying is that a [b]comparison[/b] of an average using one set of points with an average using a different set of points (including when the second is a superset of the first) is flawed.
An equivalent would be comparing the grade average of a particular 8th grade class with the grade average of a 9th grade class the following year, when that 9th grade class is made up not only from last years 8th graders from that particular schools, but last years 8th graders from other schools, and some last years 9th graders who didn't pass last year as well.
by $$$$$$$$$$
by tonythetiger
[i]Tony, define "system" or "closed system" scientifcally.
Comment on the laws of conservation of energy and mass and the first law of thermodynamics to prove you have a fraction of a clue what you're talking about.[/i]
[edit formatting above]
Attempt to disgrace or sidetrack or squelch anyone who would dare question them, rather than answer the honest questions raised.
Apparently you have given in to the dark side.
A simple exercise though:
A damp air mass is dumping light precipitation along its path. When the air mass crosses a large city, it is heated up, able to hold more moisture, and it doesn't rain on the city. As the airmass proceeds, it is cooled again, and starts to precipitate, not only the precipitation that it would have had the city not been there, but also the precipitation that would have fallen on the city had it been cooler. In other words, just "alee" of the city got more precipitation than it should have, and since the rain is colder than the ground, that area cools. So you see it IS possible for something warming up causing something else to cool down.
by tonythetiger
are the weather service, who want more points of reference so that they can better track weather systems so as to better predict rain amounts, give advanced warnings of potential high winds, flooding, etc. and even though the equipment is theirs (ours), they share the data with whoever asks.
[i]You must prove your claim or withdraw it in science.[/i]
he he he
"Luke! I am your father."
by deepsand
All that is required is a sufficiently large number of sample points, sufficiently well distributed.
No matter what is being measured, this basic principle holds.
by deepsand
The former deals with atmospheric conditions at the micro level; the latter, at the macro level.
To say that more accurate weather forecasting requires more data points than presently available does not mean such is the case for the study of climate.
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
[i]To say that more accurate weather forecasting requires more data points than presently available does not mean such is the case for the study of climate.[/i]
Abs only asked me who put the weather stations in and why. I didn't see anything in my reply that would prompt the above statement.
by $$$$$$$$$$
[i]You must prove your claim or withdraw it in science.[/i]
You reply with fiction:
[i]he he he
"Luke! I am your father."[/i]
Fine. Is that your final answer? Is that, without a single datum or researcher, your best defense of your claim of improper measurements?
by $$$$$$$$$$
"I must be speaking in a different language.
[i] To say that more accurate weather forecasting requires more data points than presently available does not mean such is the case for the study of climate.[/i]
Abs only asked me who put the weather stations in and why. I didn't see anything in my reply that would prompt the above statement."
I asked you that in the context of your claims that climate science is somehow inadequate, or inaccurate. You still have not done [b]one thing to quantify[/b] that claim.
by deepsand
100 years ago man's population was significantly smaller, and his effect on the biosphere dramatically less, than today, with the result that fewer measuring points would suffice.
More importantly, with respect to climatology, it is not the ground temperatures at any particular point which are of import, but rather those of the atmosphere and oceans, both of which are and have been well studied for time sufficient for noting the trends that you rail against.
by $$$$$$$$$$
Had the question been, "is it possible that one local increase in temperature [b]can[/b] be the direct cause of a local increase in temperature elsewhere?" your reply would have addressed it adequately. But deepsand challenged you to comment, not on whether that is [b]possible[/b], but whether it is [b]necessary[/b].
"You know quite well that warming at one point is not [b]dependent[/b] on cooling at another."
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=260852&messageID=2481676
[i]A simple exercise though:
A damp air mass is dumping light precipitation along its path. When the air mass crosses a large city, it is heated up, able to hold more moisture, and it doesn't rain on the city. As the airmass proceeds, it is cooled again, and starts to precipitate, not only the precipitation that it would have had the city not been there, but also the precipitation that would have fallen on the city had it been cooler. In other words, just "alee" of the city got more precipitation than it should have, and since the rain is colder than the ground, that area cools. So you see it IS possible for something warming up causing something else to cool down.[/i]
That was not responsive, and does not suggest any reason for us to expect in general that a temperature change at one point must be accompanied by an [b]equal and opposite[/b] temperature change at some other point.
[i]The global warming advocates do this too.
Tony, define "system" or "closed system" scientifcally.
Comment on the laws of conservation of energy and mass and the first law of thermodynamics to prove you have a fraction of a clue what you're talking about.
[edit formatting above]
Attempt to disgrace or sidetrack or squelch anyone who would dare question them, [b]rather than answer the honest questions raised[/b].[/i]
I'm sorry if you feel "disgraced or sidetracked or squelched," but even with fellow small-government types, my patience is not infinite. And as far as "answering questions" goes, science does not operate Inquisition-style. Scientists do not routinely* stand before a row of interrogators, with a requirement to answer to the interrogators satisfaction, any and all questions they can dream up. Rather, all parties who wish to be considered must contribute, and their input is considered according to their contribution. Your expectation of asking all the questions is arrogant in the extreme.
Now, having taken the position of a minuscule minority of the general population of scientists does not grant you the privilege of merely asking questions for me to answer, doing all the research and all the calculations. If you, or any scientists working on behalf of you and your interest to discredit the consensus on global climate destabilization, want to make your case scientifically, you need to do a lot more than just "ask questions." That's an important first step in science, but it doesn't permit skipping the laborious tasks of collecting and analyzing data. You've shown no follow-through so far, and I'm not a bit apologetic for confronting you with your responsibility to support your claims, or withdraw them.
[i] Apparently you have given in to the dark side.[/i]
No, [u]I[/u] haven't decided to pretend that what would be most convenient is what I "believe," contrary to the evidence. That's you, and jdclyde and maxwell edison on the dark side.
* PhD candidates have to defend their thesis, and some describe it like this. Others prepare better for the event, pick a less contentious thesis, or just get along better with the committee. I don't know, I haven't done that yet. It sounds like it can be pretty fun, or pretty "fun," depending.
edit: formatting, emphasis, one new sentence
I'd vaguely heard of it before but never quite cared to work out how it increased the overall efficiency of the engine. I'd always thought that the energy to perform the electrolysis is derived from that relatively inefficient engine in the first place. A case of TANSTAAFL, as Heinlein so eloquently put it.
However as it's a retune of the engine to take into account the increased flame propagation speed courtesy of the Hydrogen then it makes perfect sense. The closer to top dead centre that you can perform the ignition, the better so there isn't ignition while the piston is still coming up as there is in a standard petrol engine.
Your other question... The energy produced by combustion (or any other exothermic reaction) is, as I remember from my dim and very distant schooldays, the sum of the energy required to break all of the chemical bonds in the original reactants and reform them in the reaction products. I'm not sure how you could calculate the contribution of Hydrogen when all of the bonds to be broken in the fuel when burning hydrocarbons are C-H bonds.
Neil :)
I want a Hydrogen Injector for my car!
by $$$$$$$$$$
[i]I want a Hydrogen Injector for my car![/i]
I want to build you one! It looks like about a ?50 - ?100 project to do adequately, at least on an old enough car that the timing can be "easily" adjusted.
by tonythetiger
[i]100 years ago man's population was significantly smaller, and his effect on the biosphere dramatically less, than today, with the result that fewer measuring points would suffice.[/i]
that statement illustrates a bias toward the outcome? (unless, of course, you are suggesting that weather stations were put into place 100 years ago to prove human caused climate change.)
[i]More importantly, with respect to climatology, it is not the ground temperatures at any particular point which are of import, but rather those of the atmosphere and oceans, both of which are and have been well studied for time sufficient for noting the trends that you rail against.[/i]
Cooler ground will cool the air above it, just as urban heat islands heat the air above them. And I'm not "against" anything. I just think a greater amount and quality of evidence is required in order to mandate the changes that will bankrupt a country.
by tonythetiger
[i]your claim of improper measurements?[/i]
... saying I said something I didn't say. Is that how science is supposed to work?
[i]You reply with fiction:[/i]
Art imitates life. I was going to add that Darth Vader eventually redeemed himself, but now I'm starting to think I should be glad I didn't.
May your dog eat 5 pounds of prunes then poop in your shoes!
by tonythetiger
[i]
I'm sorry if you feel "disgraced or sidetracked or squelched,"[/i]
But I DO feel that the "attempt" is being made.
[i]Now, having taken the position of a minuscule minority of the general population of scientists[/i]
and what "position" is that? I am but one of the jurors. The charge is that humans are a causing a significant portion of our planet's climate change. Is it unnatural for me to want a great deal of proof, explained sufficiently well, before I decide guilty or not guilty?
[edit: wasn't done yet]
Or do you expect me to not have a mind of my own... and just blindly accept what I'm being told without question?
by tonythetiger
[i]I asked you that in the context of your claims that climate science is somehow inadequate, or inaccurate.[/i]
I asked.
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=260852&messageID=2479039
Like I said, I must be speaking a different language.
by deepsand
by deepsand
100 years ago man's population was significantly smaller, and his effect on the biosphere dramatically less, than today, with the result that fewer measuring points would suffice.
"[i]that statement illustrates a bias toward the outcome? (unless, of course, you are suggesting that weather stations were put into place 100 years ago to prove human caused climate change.)[/i]"
[b]Bias? Of what sort? Is the [u]reason[/u] for the recording an observation germane to the data gathered?
Furthermore, you've obviously ignored the fact that, the more uniform the system being observed, the fewer sampling points needed.[/b]
More importantly, with respect to climatology, it is not the ground temperatures at any particular point which are of import, but rather those of the atmosphere and oceans, both of which are and have been well studied for time sufficient for noting the trends that you rail against.
"[i]Cooler ground will cool the air above it, just as urban heat islands heat the air above them.[/i]"
[b]That's a gross over-simplification with regards to [u]climate[/u], one that is of import only to local [u]weather[/u].[/b]
"[i]And I'm not "against" anything. I just think a greater amount and quality of evidence is required in order to mandate the changes that will bankrupt a country.[/i]"
[b]That you remained unconvinced owes to your lack of knowledge and understanding, not to a dearth of empirical data and the application of well understood laws of physics.
As for "bankrupting a country," such not only assumes facts not in evidence, but also demonstrates a bias towards being more concerned for ones own creature comforts of the moment than for the necessities of all for the future.[/b]
by deepsand
"[i]I am but one of the jurors. The charge is that humans are a causing a significant portion of our planet's climate change. Is it unnatural for me to want a great deal of proof, explained sufficiently well, before I decide guilty or not guilty?
Or do you expect me to not have a mind of my own... and just blindly accept what I'm being told without question?[/i]"
[b]But[/b], you are [b]not[/b] being an [b]unbiased[/b] juror. To the contrary, you have [u]arbitrarily[/u] rejected all of the prosecutions evidence and explanations of that evidence, choosing to hold out for, as you yourself said in an earlier discussion, "absolute proof."
And, why is this so? Because, unlike a true juror, [u]you have a vested interest[/u] in the verdict. Rather than being a juror, you have cast yourself in the position of being the defendant.
by deepsand
by deepsand
Does it really count, given that he arrived at such by way of a fallacious argument?
And, do you suppose that he'll ever acknowledge that we do not categorically disagree with all that he says, that he will ever acknowledge those points of agreement?
Sort by Trending