Discussion Locked

If this isn?t lunacy, I don?t know what is

0 helpful
832 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 6 of the discussion. Read the opening post

832 replies

by tonythetiger

[i]Is the reason for the recording an observation germane to the data gathered?[/i]

So why even mention:

[i]100 years ago man's population was significantly smaller, and his effect on the biosphere dramatically less, than today,[/i]

"Cooler ground will cool the air above it, just as urban heat islands heat the air above them."

[i]That's a gross over-simplification [/i]

Well, we can't have that, can we?

[i]with regards to climate, one that is of import only to local weather.[/i]

is it not many of these "local weathers" which make up a climate?

[i]That you remained unconvinced owes to your lack of knowledge and understanding, not to a dearth of empirical data and the application of well understood laws of physics.[/i]

Are you sure that's the only possible explanation?

[i]As for "bankrupting a country," such not only assumes facts not in evidence, but also demonstrates a bias towards being more concerned for ones own creature comforts of the moment than for the necessities of all for the future.[/i]

You know nothing about my level of comfort, nor anything of my own personal efforts, freely and voluntarily made for the betterment of my, and therefore your environment. What you DO know, but rarely, if ever, acknowledge, is that those squawking the loudest about the need for ME to reduce my footprint upon the planet are among the biggest wasters of resources on the planet.

If I were truly as self-centered as you seem to think, I would be blatantly wasteful on the theory of "Why should I economize simply so Al Gore can get his fat ass on another plane to jet around the world telling everyone how bad they are?"

You really don't know me... you assume that because I espouse conservative views, that I hate the poor, or illegal immigrants, etc., when nothing could be further from the truth. I want the very best for each and every human being on this planet, and I believe that the best way to bring that about is to allow everyone to realize their own potential, and that is not accomplished by talking over peoples' heads, or excluding or belittling their ideas or dismissing their questions because they don't understand all the $20 words some would throw around to try to impress them.

by spam.mailbox

Might I chime in here for just a bit?

[i]Palmetto[/i] hit it right on the head in this quote:

[i]I don't want to hear about the record profits the oil companies are making. Companies are in business to make money; why should they oil companies be treated any differently? No, they shouldn't get additional tax breaks, but you don't see Kellogg's being dragged before Congress regarding the cost of breakfast cereal.[/i]

[b]My 2 cents:[/b]
Oil companies have ALWAYS made an average profit [u]margin[/u] of around 10-12%, except for a short stint from 1979-82 when the "oil boom" hit and it inched up to around 18-20% for a short while.

The "big profit" number that the liberal media keeps throwing around is the [b][i]overall grand total "after-tax" profits[/i][/b] that the oil companies made, but the Liberal media make [u]no mention[/u] of the profit [u]MARGIN[/u]. Before you go crying that they made $35 Billion or something like that, let me outline a hypothetical example:

Let's say that XYZ Company (a car maker in Detroit) decided to build a car for $100 and only retain a 10% profit ($10) on each car. During the first year XYZ sold 1 Million cars, thus made a $10 Million [u]profit[/u] for the year. Not too bad...

Let's now say that the following year, our economy was just sizzling (Parallel example: China's annual GNP growth is currently around 13%, while our economy is considered "red-hot" when it is only around 3% annually...), and XYZ sold 200 Million cars that year, thus making an [u]overall[/u] profit of $2 Billion, a whopping increase of 2,000%! The Liberals would automatically scream "Windfall Profits Tax!!!", and demand that some of that "extra" money go to the Government because XYZ made "too much money". (Classic Socialism- re-distribute the wealth...)

The fact is that XYZ still only making a measly $10 per car, so their profit [i][b][u]MARGIN[/u][/b][/i] remained the same. The same is true for the "Big" Oil companies.

They are not making bigger profit [u]MARGINS[/u], they are simply selling a [u]BIGGER VOLUME[/u] of their product worldwide. China's sizzling economy (and India's) needs huge amounts of previously unused worldwide fuel to sustain their current astronomical economic growth. They are simply buying a lot [u]more[/u] fuel than they were just a mere 8 or 10 years ago.

If Liberals in Congress decide to increase the tax oil companies pay, then every one of you will suffer [u][i]twice[/i][/u]. [b]

First, [/b]because YOU are an owner of an oil company! You probably just don't realize it. Check your 401(k) plan to see if any of your stock or mutual fund holdings in your retirement plan are oil-related. I'd bet you have some oil holdings in there somwhere. They are all PUBLICLY-OWNED comnpanies... People own them! Teachers. Pilots. Truck Drivers. Firefighters. Nurses. Ordinary People...

[b]Secondly[/b], the "Windfall Profits Tax" tax will just be passed on to (guess who???...) YOU! Liberals in Congress will increase your taxes twice! Once on the Windfall/Increased Capital Gains Tax, and once again at the pump when the oil company passes this tax on to [u]YOU[/u].

I don't want to write a book on economics here, so I'd better close for now. I just want to end with a question:

Why aren't Liberals making a big stink about the massive profit [b][u][i]MARGINS[/i][/u][/b] that the credit card companies make. 18%? 20%? 22%? Plus "other" charges...? Hmm...

Leave the Oil Companies alone, and let the free market flow! Some of them are currently investing research money into alternative sources of energy. If Congress taxes the heck out of them, their investment money that they have been using will disappear, and so will our hopes of developing alternative sources of energy, or building new, VERY EXPENSIVE refineries.

Thanks to the stiff laws that the environmental whacko's lobbyists insisted our Congress pass, there are now so many restrictions that is it not economically feasable to build any new refineries. That is the main reason that there hasn't been a new refinery built in 25 years. Thus the bottle-neck at the refinery level grows.

One last statement to initiate a short-term solution for our domestic problem. (This is so simple that it actually hurts...)

In the US, there are currently 22 different "cocktail blends" of gasoline (for many different states, regions, or even counties) and 4 different blends of diesel fuel created in order to comply with local air quality regulations. Refineries should only take the top 3 cleanest blends of Gas, and the top 2 blends of diesel and just produce [u]those[/u]! That would make much more productive use of our very limited refinery time we currently have available.

What say the rest of you???...

by tonythetiger

profit is not bad. In particular, oil profit is a not inconsequential portion of most people's pensions. Do you really want to cut your parents or grandparents standard of living? That's what increasing the tax on profits will do (that and raise the cost of the product for everyone because you know as well as I that the oil companies aren't going to just 'eat it').

by deepsand

Rather than go on and on about auto manufacturers, why not conjure up some data re. US refineries, the tax incentives for exploration that they continue to gulp down, despite the fact that such were predicated on certain price levels, long since surpassed, but, unfortunately (by design?), never stipulated in a legally binding manner, etal., and then come back and demonstrate how narrow the margin is and has been for Big Oil over the recent past.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]Why aren't Liberals making a big stink about the massive profit MARGINS that the credit card companies make. 18%? 20%? 22%? Plus "other" charges...? Hmm...[/i]

Let's talk about the rates that are presently common on credit accounts, and the rates that have historically been defined as "usury." If you don't, I will.

by tonythetiger

[i]Why aren't Liberals making a big stink about the massive profit MARGINS that the credit card companies make. 18%? 20%? 22%?[/i]

Interest is not all profit. It is the COST of borrowing money. That interest also pays the employees, operating costs for their buildings, legal costs of going after deadbeats, etc. And it's voluntary... if you pay your balance in full every month, you don't pay ANY interest. A helluva deal if used correctly.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]There you go again...
TonytheTiger - 04/22/08 your claim of improper measurements? ... saying I said something I didn't say.[/i]

Your claim about improper measurements may at one point have been implicit, but to cast doubt on the conclusions, it is required that you find [b]specific[/b] fault with either the measurements or the calculations based on them. In this sub-thread, you have certainly focused on the measurements, calling those taken "100 years ago...not comparable to current data."

[i]4.1.2.1.1.1.30. "sufficiently well distributed."
TonytheTiger - 04/22/08 Which wasn't the case 100 years ago, so that data is [sic] not comparable to current data.[/i]

[i]Is that how science is supposed to work?[/i]

Oh, spare me your whining. Science did not single you out to raise your gas taxes and I did not single you out for critique of your debate tactics. You just aren't right, and I'm not helping you pretend that you are. That's not my job. Science is supposed to work on evidence, and all you've provided is speculation without basis in fact. Describing a system in mere words to argue that some measurements might be wrong, or could have been wrong doesn't cut the mustard. Until you bring some specific numbers, cite your sources, and explain, with calculations of your own, what's wrong with the researchers' methods, you're contributing nothing, and wasting everybody's time.

[i]You reply with fiction: Art imitates life. I was going to add that Darth Vader eventually redeemed himself, but now I'm starting to think ...[/i]

That would be a welcome improvement.

Do you have a serious argument, a quantified argument that the uncertainty in the data used in climate science eclipses the identified mean temperature increase? Then name the study!! I get tired of asking you this, Pr-r-rincess, so it'll be the last time: What is the basis of your claim that these data are "not comparable"?

by deepsand

Is the reason for the recording an observation germane to the data gathered?

"[i]So why even mention:[/i]"

[b]Because [u]you[/u] implied that the data was biased owing to it's having been collected for a particular purpose.[/b]

100 years ago man's population was significantly smaller, and his effect on the biosphere dramatically less, than today,

"[i]Cooler ground will cool the air above it, just as urban heat islands heat the air above them.[/i]"

That's a gross over-simplification

"[i]Well, we can't have that, can we?[/i]"

[b]When it leads to a fallacious conclusion, no, we cannot.[/b]

with regards to climate, one that is of import only to local weather.

"[i]is it not many of these "local weathers" which make up a climate?[/i]"

[b]No. In fact, it is the case that climate drives weather, not the other way around. "Local" weather is merely an expression of a particular weather system at a particular place and time.[/b]

That you remained unconvinced owes to your lack of knowledge and understanding, not to a dearth of empirical data and the application of well understood laws of physics.

"[i]Are you sure that's the only possible explanation?[/i]

[b]Would you have me, instead, accuse you of being a dolt, or worse. Ignorance of the facts is the kindest reason within reach.[/b]

As for "bankrupting a country," such not only assumes facts not in evidence, but also demonstrates a bias towards being more concerned for ones own creature comforts of the moment than for the necessities of all for the future.

"[i]You know nothing about my level of comfort, nor anything of my own personal efforts, freely and voluntarily made for the betterment of my, and therefore your environment. What you DO know, but rarely, if ever, acknowledge, is that those squawking the loudest about the need for ME to reduce my footprint upon the planet are among the biggest wasters of resources on the planet. [/i]"

[b]I need know nothing of your particular personal circumstances in order to observe what you here most dearly defend and the methods employed in such defense.[/b]

"[i]If I were truly as self-centered as you seem to think, I would be blatantly wasteful on the theory of "Why should I economize simply so Al Gore can get his fat ass on another plane to jet around the world telling everyone how bad they are?"[/i]"

[b]I make no such judgement. Rather, I point out that your priorities are skewed, as are those of most people in some fashion or another, in a manner that here biases you against being sufficiently open-minded in the matter at hand. Should you wish to label that bias "self-centeredness," so be it.[/b]

"[i]You really don't know me... you assume that because I espouse conservative views, that I hate the poor, or illegal immigrants, etc., when nothing could be further from the truth. I want the very best for each and every human being on this planet, and I believe that the best way to bring that about is to allow everyone to realize their own potential, and that is not accomplished by talking over peoples' heads, or excluding or belittling their ideas or dismissing their questions because they don't understand all the $20 words some would throw around to try to impress them. [/i]"

[b]Firstly I do not categorically label you a "conservative;" and, though you may so label yourself, I do not concur. As one who cleaves to no party, and who has here engaged you on many occasions, I have observed far too many statements from you that do not, from my observations, well comport with the characteristics of those presently described as "conservative."

Furthermore, and again from personal experience here, I have never had cause to doubt your good intentions.

That having been said, though, what I have repeatedly seen is a strong tendency to reject scientific facts which do not well comport with your beliefs or opinions, coupled with a great reluctance to advance your admittedly weak knowledge of the sciences or give credence to the statements of those who do possess such knowledge and understanding. This, to the degree that you repeatedly look for a reason, any reason, to disagree, so as to not have to give up you preconceptions.

I long ago pointed you to several online sources re. radiative forcing, etal.. Have you yet read them? If so, do you understand them? If not read, why not? If read but not fully understood, why no request for amplification and/or explanation? In short, why have you turned away from that which serves to refute your belief?[/b]

by $$$$$$$$$$

The idea that converting foodstock into fuel is a case of priorities out of order is still correct.

[i]And, do you suppose that he'll ever acknowledge that we do not categorically disagree with all that he says, that he will ever acknowledge those points of agreement?[/i]

My guess is, no. Only time can tell, but so far I'm disappointed in his level of participation in this thread. I intentionally threw him a couple bones, direct replies to the topics he identified in the opening post, and he hasn't replied. I haven't counted his replies after the opening post, but they're fewer than mine, yours, or Neil's for sure. It isn't absolute proof of an edisonian cooling trend on this topic, but my best hypothesis for now is that he didn't get the openings he wanted for portraying climate science as a collectivist conspiracy.

by deepsand

What are they going to do?

Raise the price of their product, thereby increasing the their taxable income, thereby increasing their tax liability, [i]ad infinitum[/i]?

Or, do you expect that they'll simply be allowed to pass along such to the consumer as a non-taxable line item, i.e that they'll be able to treat their Federal Tax as a deductible expense?

by deepsand

We've enough distractions and attempted mis-direction here without our helping the logically challenged derail the train.

by deepsand

If you're not aware of it, registration brings with it the opportunity to receive daily alerts of items of your selected interest(s).

I've no intent on being the only one swamped by too much to read!

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]Not all hydrocarbon bonds are C-H; some are C-C, some C=C, etc.
Could one not, therefore, do a differential comparison between, for example, different straight-chained aliphatics, between a given straight-chained aliphatic and aromatics with the same number of C, between alkanes, alkenes and alkynes with the same number of C, etc.?[/i]

Probably as readily available as the last data I started to calculate.

:)

by $$$$$$$$$$

To be exact, in 11 days, 3 hours, 19 minutes, a BOINC* project will complete, after which time no more will be downloaded in the currently-active operating system. The same computer will then be re-booted into Linux, hopefully never to return to Windows, and if so, only for the shortest possible intervals. After proving both BOINC & video rendering in general [DVD, YouTube, TV] to be fully functional in Linux on the same hardware, I'm finishing one last computation I signed up for, ironically in the climateprediction.net project! In the meantime, for my convenience, no new online accounts, or computing projects of any kind.

*
http://boinc.berkeley.edu/

by deepsand

Grid computing.

It's been on my list of things to do for more than a little time now; but, given that the alligators only take brief times-out from biting me in the ass, its not had a chance to yet get anywhere close to even being on the stove, let alone a front burner.

Not that your reminder will change any of that; only that it gives me one more regret of the moment, the like of which I've a more than ample supply.

by tonythetiger

[i]Raise the price of their product, thereby increasing the their taxable income, thereby increasing their tax liability, ad infinitum?[/i]

Where does the money to pay corporate tax come from????

Cut profit (and all that the profit does), cut costs (wages among them), or increase prices are the only choices. Which would YOU choose?

by $$$$$$$$$$

It's pretty easy to set up the BOINC client, and equally so to add each project, both in Windows and Linux (with the exception of 64-bit operating systems, which I'd call only moderately challenging for projects that have 64-bit applications at all).

by Member 25348569

As you say, we know the bond energies of C-H and C-C - and, for that matter C=C and the triple bond in acetylene. It would be a fairly trivial comparison between, say, ethane and acetylene to see what the Hydrogen contributed between C2H6 and C2H2. Compare C2H6 and progressively longer chains, propane, octane and the ratio of the number of Carbon atoms to the number of Hydrogen atoms changes. Easy Math for you.

The key word in the paragraph above is "you" because I'm still not sure what you're trying to prove or calculate.

:D

by Member 25348569

They key point about burning ethanol derived from plant material is that the carbon dioxide released into the atmosphere was atmospheric carbon dioxide when the plants were grown a year or so ago. The carbon dioxide released into the atmosphere when gasoline is burned was last atmospheric carbon dioxide around 100 million years ago.

Lack of sulphur is just a bonus - as is the fact that you can drink your fuel if the bastards didn't put poison in it. And you can easily make your own. Moonshine, anyone?

Neil :D

by tonythetiger

God told me.

You don't have to believe in mine, and I don't have to believe in yours. The only difference? Mine loves you.

by tonythetiger

kindness.

[i]"Are you sure that's the only possible explanation?

Would you have me, instead, accuse you of being a dolt, or worse. Ignorance of the facts is the kindest reason within reach.[/i]

But that wasn't what I was getting at. Scientists have been wrong before, and they'll undoubtedly be wrong again. This could very well be one of those times.

[i]Ignorance of the facts[/i]

And I thought it was a theory. When did it become fact?

by delbertpgh

instead of finding excuses and loopholes that apply only to oil and gas companies. Tax revenues have to come from somewhere; it's best for a dynamic economy to work out a rule for taxation that applies to everybody evenly, and let the chips fall. Prices will adjust as they must, and economic activity will adjust to meet the prices.

Energy-related activities don't deserve a permanent tax favor. It means that some other activity, like the hardware or construction businesses or individual taxpayers, is picking up the bill that an oil company walks away from. It's not as if a tax gift to a private business is a gift to everybody large and small who buys from that business. It's collusion, and it's trying to game the system, and it's un-capitalistic.

The only time a tax break or a tariff makes sense is when it's in the national economic interest to build some new industry, or in the security interest to preserve an existing one. Otherwise, it's just a giveaway, usually to politically connected people. Like this whole ethanol fiasco is primarily a giveaway to Archer Daniels.

by tonythetiger

Tax breaks given to companies will ultimately be made up somewhere else, sometimes even more so. A state can for example, exempt a company from tax in exchange for moving there, but the sales tax on the produced product, and the income taxes paid by the employees may well more than make up for it.

by $$$$$$$$$$

Increasing [b]my[/b] rates as the cost of doing business with [b]them[/b] is subsidizing deadbeats, exactly.

[i]Interest is not all profit. It is the COST of borrowing money. That interest also pays the employees, operating costs for their buildings, [i]legal costs of going after deadbeats[/i], etc. And it's voluntary... if you pay your balance in full every month, you don't pay ANY interest. A helluva deal if used correctly.[/i]

As-is, the credit card industry is too fundamentally flawed. No "correct" use exists. Unable to profit without charging me ~20% interest? Then, you're extending credit to too many bad credit risks, period.

by $$$$$$$$$$

Unexpected this is ... and unfortunate.

[i]re:What is the basis of your claim that these data are "not comparable"?
TonytheTiger - 04/23/08 God told me. You don't have to believe in mine, and I don't have to believe in yours. The only difference? Mine loves you.[/i]
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=260852&messageID=2482256

Aw, that's sweet. I look out for you only as a by-product of looking out for me. Did you check the credentials of that guy who says always believe there is no danger of global warming, and never delve into the data? I don't believe he's a good guy.

by dr dij

Max, you're all for independence from foreign sources and these help. And as I mentioned in my previous post, biofuels are not the sole cause of increase in grain prices as developing countries like India and China develop a taste for beef that takes 8x the grain per pound to produce when not grass fed.

One alternative to cattle would be the strange 'meat mountain' vat produced meat:
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=261612

but on a local level they help: the farmers who use alot of energy are not as dependent (and could become totally independent of) fuels trucked in long distances. In the end this both helps ensure reliability of crops and reduces fuel use since not trucked long distances.

And if you know anything about the US power grid, you know that some power plants, when shut down CANNOT START THEMSELVES! many plants, strange as it seems, need a supply of electricity from elsewhere to be able to restart, so in blackouts restart can be complicated.

This same principle means that farmers who have liquid fuel production co-op or plant nearby are alot less reliant in an emergency or fuel embargo, natural disaster, etc.

Secondly even tho biofuels emit carbon (to max that's not a problem) the carbon they emit CAME FROM the atmosphere so not adding new carbon. Whereas if we dig up all the fossil fuels and burn them (from the atmosphere of 70 million years ago) we'd be ADDING 7X the CO2 of today, and at 1000 times the rate of previous natural climate changes.

CO2 then is a leading indicator / cause of change as opposed to previous times when climate melting poles caused release of methane deposits in ocean and tundra CO2 for example, which were lagging indicators.

Max, you're for (I hope) energy independence so this, when fully played out will help with that. I agree it should not be subsidized.

Also, while raising the price of food, it is NOT the primary cause. And frankly food prices have been too low, causing farming to be a 'non-profit' occupation in many countries.

This of course leads to reduced food production by them. Many can't at previous prices even afford fertilizer. And the prices are often kept low by govt subsidies of agriculture in those countries, severely distorting the market and reducing food production at times.

Finally, there is not god given mandate that farmland needs to be dedicated to food. in the end, biofuels help make farming more reliable due to ready energy supply nearby. The global economy needs diverse energy supplies. Having developed countries such as US flooding the markets with cheap (subsidized by US agriculture handouts also) grain as we previously did can be prone to disruption via logistics problems, climate, economic factors, etc.

It is our right and a good idea to dedicate part of our croplands to biofuels. Happily some or all of it will most likely soon be switched to non-food crops (cellulosic crops) for ethanol and these can sometimes be grown on more marginal lands.

The down side is that some will still be grown on lands that could have produced crops. And sometimes unhappily it will cause more clearing of habitats for farming. But as I said we and individual farmers don't have an obligation to sell any crop at any particular price.

One more thing to realize is that US OIL PRODUCTION HAS BEEN SUBSIDIZE FOR YEARS thru various direct and indirect methods. In fact we encouraged for 40 years the pumping of US oil out of the ground meaning we don't have much left in easy to pump reserves as tax subsidies caused us to use this over cheaper to produce oil from elsewhere. Whether this could then have caused probs due to lack of US oil infrastructure I don't know.

Another good idea on the way, oil companies are now injecting CO2 capture from power plants into the ground as this allows vast amounts of previously unobtainable residual oil to be freed from sticking to the rock formations and allows it to be pumped out, much more so than injecting water does. This is of course also good just for the carbon sequestration. One company in N. US built a 200 mile pipeline from power plant to oil fields just for this purpose and has vastly increased oil production at the fields.

by maxwell edison

I won?t disagree that the rise in ethanol production isn?t the only factor in increased food prices, nor did I say it was the only factor. It is, however, a significant factor. (And one I predicted over a year ago in a different discussion on the lunacy of ethanol production.)

I won?t debate whether or not the production of ethanol causes more or less greenhouse gas emissions, because, as you correctly stated, I think it?s much ado about nothing. However, for those of you who do believe it?s destroying the planet, perhaps you care to debate these experts:

http://blogs.wsj.com/environmentalcapital/2008/01/23/more-bad-news-for-ethanol/

(The link to the full story at Science Magazine requires a free registration.)

What makes you right and them wrong?

Or Britain's chief environment scientist?

http://www.pr-inside.com/britain-s-chief-environment-scientist-says-r499796.htm

What makes you right and him wrong?

And the Ding-Dongs at Berkeley have also suggested that producing ethanol causes more greenhouse gasses. (As does the hot-air they spew!)

Am I in favor of total energy independence, you ask? Yes I am, but in today?s global market, I?m not sure it?s either possible or practical. I do think it?s silly to buy oil on the open market (from whatever foreign source) when we could be using oil from our own fields. We have so much untapped oil in this country it?s ridiculous; and it could be tapped in environmental friendly ways. It's the radical environmentalists who are blocking the production of our own oil - in essence, keeping us more dependent on foreign sources.

My solution to reducing our dependence on foreign oil? Produce more oil domestically and, at the same time, encourage the private development of alternative energy sources.

The point of my initial message was that the ethanol route is, to a large degree, counterproductive ? its production uses as much oil as it saves; AND it's contributing to an increase in food prices and contributing to food shortages. That sounds like lunacy to me! (Especially when one believes, as I do, that the whole global warming / climate change hysteria is bogus!)

It truly is a mad, mad, mad, mad world we live in! (A very funny movie, by the way - circa 1960s.)

by dr dij

when they do these calculations they 'assume' that the farmers are using OIL from fossil fuels to produce the ethanol or biodiesel but when they can produce their own fuel they ARE NOT USING OIL or as much oil or significantly less.

And as I said, we don't ALLOCATE farmland requiring it to produce food. I say they should produce whatever gives them the best return. Not produce food because Max is ticked off that they should be a slave to him and produce food for his benefit or that he doesn't want to pay $.50 more for a bagel.

Again, there is no RIGHT price for food. Higher prices will stimulate more production and are good. The subsidies will probably go away shortly and as you admit are not theh only cause. But like I pointed out we were and are still subsidizing US oil production via various incentive and tax break plans that other industries don't get.

And if we do tap all our own oil we'll use it up like the texas oil fields, which just now are reviving due to new extraction methods and high oil prices encouraging more expensive harder to get oil to be tapped.

I've said previously that while I'll hand you that subsidies are bad, you seem to have a serious disconnect from reality and evidence that 1) we are emitting massive amounts of CO2, equivalent to 10% or more of the naturally present amounts yearly, 2) that the CO2 affects climate seriously, 3) that we will then be affected by the warming. even if you don't admit that warming cause the current food shortages & corresponding high prices you have to admit they are causing instability around the world: Riots, regime changes, actions by stupid regimes to freeze prices to mollify the populace, only to have this cut back on future production.

by $$$$$$$$$$

Dingbat.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pXyJrFKwjrc&feature=related

[i]My solution to reducing our dependence on foreign oil? Produce more oil domestically and, at the same time, encourage the private development of alternative energy sources.[/i]

Why not [i]get the government out of the way[/i] of this social problem, as with redistribution of wealth when the recipients are the poor? Why should only the oil industry receive preferential treatment from the government?

by $$$$$$$$$$

Why [b]your[/b] experts are wrong: lack of both.

The [i]Wall Street Journal[/i] may have been a prestigious subscription before Rupert Murdoch got his grubby mitts on it, but you really need to read beyond the headlines! The article you posted says that "[b]corn[/b] ethanol" and "land use change" (from forest to farmland) are the CO2 costs they just started including in their calculations.

[i]"Simply said, ethanol production today using U.S. [b]corn[/b] contributes to the [b]conversion[/b] of grasslands and rainforest to agriculture, causing very large GHG emissions," wrote Berkeley profs Alex Farrell and Michael O?Hare in a January 12 memo to California regulators. "Even if only a small fraction of the emissions calculated in this crude way [through [b]land use change[/b]] are added to estimates of direct emissions for [b]corn[/b] ethanol, total emissions for [b]corn[/b] ethanol are higher than for fossil fuels."
ethanol_plant_art_200_20080123131315.jpg
Out of LUC. (Wikipedia)

The Berkeley team warned about the [b]land-use-change bogeyman ("LUC" in shorthand)[/b] in a pair of lengthy reports submitted to California authorities last year. But only this month did the team report the startling, if preliminary, numbers. Current wisdom in California says gasoline produces about 92 grams of carbon dioxide for every megajoule of energy produced; ethanol is reckoned to be slightly cleaner at 75.9 grams. But the land-use penalty alone from growing more biofuel crops could add as much as 140 grams/MJ?a "really enormous" number, professors Farrell and O?Hare wrote.

And the problem isn?t just corn. Any [b]land-use change[/b], be it to soy or sugarcane, carries a GHG pricetag that shows up somewhere in the world. If these "crude upper limit estimates" are right, California?s current fuel mix is already 3% to 33% more carbon-intensive than the state thought. That doesn?t bode well for the state?s plans to cut the carbon content of its fuel 10% by 2020.

The [b]solution[/b], according to Berkeley? Newer technologies to squeeze more ethanol out of every acre of food crop, or, better yet, ethanol from non-food cellulose such as [b]switchgrass[/b], which [b]wouldn?t require a land-use change[/b]. In the meantime, the burning question is how to juggle this hot potato.[/i]

Here's how:
http://www.sciam.com/article.cfm?id=grass-makes-better-ethanol-than-corn
http://www.wired.com/cars/energy/news/2008/01/ethanol23

Although these specific more efficient sources of ethanol are new to me in the past couple months, I have known for [b]years, without a doubt[/b], that corn is a crappy source. Why has it remained a part of the public debate on energy?

http://www.cato.org/pubs/pas/pa-241.html

We do [b]not[/b] need more domestic petroleum [i]anything[/i] -- mining or refining -- either.

by deepsand

agree with Max's conclusion re. bio-generated ethanol [u]not[/u] being the god-send that many believed it to be.

If you review the posts here by Neil, Absolutely and myself, all of whom hold quite different views from Max re. global warming, as well as others whose position on that issue vary, we have, collectively, addressed the problems inherent in bio-fuels, in particular, and the continued reliance on combustion as a source of energy on demand in general.

In particular, I would note that the point re. the "re-cycling" of CO2 [i]vis-a-vis[/i] bio-fuels assumes, as I've above pointed out, assumes uniform mixing of the exhaust products, and re-distribution of such so as to balance the input of CO2 at point of fuel production, something that cannot be achieved owing to the presence of distinct and relatively isolated atmospheric and oceanic convection cells.

Combustion of any carbon based fuel is a dead end. Both energy independence and a sustainable biosphere can be achieved only by moving away from such practice.

by Member 25348569

The recycling of CO2 in biofuels assumes NOTHING.

OK, Jackanory time (Brit joke). Are you sitting comfortably? Then I'll begin...

If you burn a gallon of "ordinary" diesel, the carbon dioxide emitted as a product of that consumption is derived from fossil carbon laid down 100 million years ago. The carbon dioxide - ALL of it - serves to increase the atmospheric concentration of that gas.

When you grow the necessary feedstock for a gallon of bio-diesel, the complex carbon compounds that make up the plants are created from [b]atmospheric carbon dioxide[/b] and water by the action of photosynthesis using sunlight as the energy source. This [b]decreases[/b] the atmospheric CO2 concentration when compared with NOT growing the feedstock. When the bio-diesel is burnt, the carbon dioxide product of the reaction is released BACK into the atmosphere from whence it came.

If I got any simpler, I'd be dribbling and saying "ga-ga pooh". I don't do that.

Neil :)

by $$$$$$$$$$

Go straight to the last sentence in this article.

http://i208.photobucket.com/albums/bb27/Absolutely_photos/nature20030123p325001.png

This is from a journal dedicated to research in science. The mainstream media over-simplifies and sensationalizes to sell copies. Such does not constitute a conspiracy [b]by scientists[/b] nor a failure [b]of science[/b]. Maybe your sources of scientific data are liars. In fact, I don't think they're telling you much worth "knowing" about geopolitics, either.

Message was edited by: Beth Blakely

by deepsand

Did Max complain about someone else engaging in what was previously his favorite and most practiced activity?

I strongly doubt that Beth is reading this thread at all, let alone in its entirety, so as to have herself come across anything "objectional."

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]I strongly doubt that Beth is reading this thread at all, let alone in its entirety, so as to have herself come across anything "objectional."[/i]

I think she maybe a woman of sophisticated enough tastes to enjoy this discussion for many of the same reasons we do. I honestly don't remember that particular message well enough to know what she removed, but I am aware of having repeatedly used a certain gimmick for escaping censorship of a foul word for excrement, which depends upon repetition of a letter which is frequently silent. I reckon that's what was removed here. If she asks nicely, I'll alter the other instances of same to "equine excrement" on my own time.

by $$$$$$$$$$

Week after next, I'll pick a fight about finance. I want to give Bernanke enough rope to hang himself, thus the fortnight.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]Easy Math for you. The key word in the paragraph above is "you" because I'm still not sure what you're trying to prove or calculate.[/i]

The suggestion of those comparisons, in the context of this thread, suggests to me a comprehensive chart of the energy derived from all commonly-available combustible hydrocarbons, but I don't know that deepsand doesn't have something completely different in mind.

[i]As you say, we know the bond energies of C-H and C-C - and, for that matter C=C and the triple bond in acetylene. It would be a fairly trivial comparison between, say, ethane and acetylene to see what the Hydrogen contributed between C2H6 and C2H2. Compare C2H6 and progressively longer chains, propane, octane and the ratio of the number of Carbon atoms to the number of Hydrogen atoms changes.[/i]

Tedious.

by tonythetiger

[i]a bit of a conversation-stopper[/i]

commanded to PROVE one is an expert (the definition of which is apparently "one who agrees with the so-called consensus") in the field or trying to learn to be one (the definition of which is apparently "coming around to your way of thinking") in order to have one's questions considered seriously, or to be worthy of having a say in the outcome what do you expect?

by tonythetiger

obtain and use a no annual fee (lots of them do that) credit card, paying off the balance each month, what IS your rate? and who exactly are you subsidizing with that rate?

by jdclyde

don't bother drilling for our own oil because we will just use it up?

How does the threat of using up something you would not have us use in the first place pose a problem? (assuming your correct that we would run out in the first place, of course)

I do recall hearing that we were going to run out of oil in 10 to 20 years, but that was 30 years ago....

by dr dij

I.e. after using up allthe texas oil (that is easly obtainable at hte current market price) we are then dependent on foreign oil for that portion that used to be supplied by domestic crude. That 's the idea. It isn't quite that simple but generally correct: if we are using the foreign oil to begin with then less infra in place to get the texas oil and anything that takes ramping up takes serious investment and takes time.

I'm not saying we should not drill, I was saying we should not have subsidized the oil companies to deplete our oil then become even MORE dependent on foreign oil and the foreigh govts that control them. Like the lovely works of art Hugo Chavez who claims to be for the people but instead pays off his cronies to stay in power at the cost of helping his people like he promised, and nationalizes oil assests and spews socialist vitriol. (even tho I admire that he doesn't kowtow to US govt which is currently in a particulary stupid policy-wise era).

As an aside and possible solution to Max's objection to the using farmland for bio-fuels, it is now possible (and practical, pilot plants are being built) to capture CO2 from fossil fuel power plant exhaust, funnel it thru algae growing beds in sunlight exposed tubes where the algae convert it to long chain carbon compounds that can be either sold as cattle feed protein or recycled into new carbon fuels to burn again and produce more electricity.

While it requires alot of space for the algae acting as solar collectors around the plant, it can be arid lands, not farmlands being used.

It may be viable without subsidies. I see that carbon emissions should be taxed, without carbon trading. Then if they could reduce the emissions would cost less.

This would help account for the spewing of toxic gases and CO2 that come from coal fired plants. They would quickly recycle the carbon via ideas like this or sequestration that also helps produce oil.

I'm not normally for taxes of any kind but in this case we have 'socialized poisoning' where we allow the power plants to spew despite their crud emissions in exchange for the benefits (power). This would encourage the reductions in emissions instead of sleight of hand carbon trading.

by tonythetiger

we're waiting till all of 'theirs' is used up then we can charge them even more than they are charging us :)

by Member 25348569

you'll only burn the damn stuff. Oil is a limited resource and just too damn valuable to burn to to get your lazy arse down to the shops and back!

Keep it for what you really need it for - industry, plastics, things with value.

When it's gone, it's gone.

Neil :)

Just my two barrel's worth

by jdclyde

don't you know it doesn't break down so it will sit in a landfill for a trillionbillion years....

by deepsand

Secondly, most concur that production has peaked or is near to peaking.

In short, sooner or later the supply of oil [b]will be exhausted[/b].

Given that there are so many others products that rely on oil as their base, and that energy can be produced by various self-sustaining means other than the burning of oil, does it not logically follow that we not burn oil?

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]Secondly, most concur that production has peaked or is near to peaking.[/i]

To debate the relative proximity of this peak, with intent of treating it as a comparatively distant or minor concern, is next of kin to endorsing cannibalism, provided that victims of such crimes be at least two generations hence.

Not a shadow of a doubt remains at this point in this discussion that we all know that corn ethanol is ADM propaganda, petroleum is Texan/corporatist/Alaskan/Arab propaganda, and coal is nostalgia. These, like preemptive military action against Iran, are off the table of honest, benevolent, well-informed people.

[i]Given that there are so many other products that rely on oil as their base, and that energy can be produced by various self-sustaining means other than the burning of oil, does it not logically follow that we not burn oil?[/i]

Beyond a shadow of a doubt.

Energy, nutrients, water, a narrow range of ambient temperature and a couple dozen hours of sleep per week suffice for human survival. The utility of petroleum and its by-products for energy is so vastly overstated, and for widgets supporting other human needs so understated, it's indescribable in mere words. Only charts or numerical comparisons will do.

by tonythetiger

economically for the US to wait until the rest of the world is out before tapping our supplies, so we can REALLY gouge them? :)

by $$$$$$$$$$

I said that to take part in the scientific process requires that participants make [b]some[/b] contribution, you were [b]Absolutely! not[/b] "commanded to PROVE one is an expert."

[i]When one is

commanded to PROVE one is an expert (the definition of which is apparently "one who agrees with the so-called consensus") in the field or trying to learn to be one (the definition of which is apparently "coming around to your way of thinking") in order to have one's questions considered seriously, or to be worthy of having a say in the outcome what do you expect?[/i]

I don't remember you being this whiny. Have you been practicing while I was away? Great balls of fire!!

by $$$$$$$$$$

Der.

[i]So, if you
obtain and use a no annual fee (lots of them do that) credit card, paying off the balance each month, what IS your rate? and who exactly are you subsidizing with that rate?[/i]

by $$$$$$$$$$

What Republicans did right, Libertarians hold as ideals. What Republicans are ashamed to admit, Libertarians proudly announce "None of my business, nor yours, nor anybody's!"

by $$$$$$$$$$

Democrats also accept ADM's money, and hum their tunes with respect to corn ethanol. But, the traditional Democrat ideology, thus the previous records of many Democrats, are not as easily adjusted to [b]advocating[/b] for Archer Daniels Midland's corrupt agenda. Thus, while they are complicit, they are less active participants in the scam.

Republicans are proven wrong in their arguments that market forces are taking care of this problem, [b]and[/b] wrong in the portrayal of their own actions with respect to the market as compatible with their assertions of [b]free[/b] market "core values". Those are not errors. Those are lies.

by tonythetiger

[i]Corporate welfare is driving up the price of food.[/i]

What is the mechanism?

I would presume that any corporate tax would be passed down to the consumer, thus raising the cost. So wouldn't [b]not[/b] taxing the corporation [b]not[/b] raise the prices?

[Scratch that - I replied before I read the link. Subsidies and protectionist practices are different than [b]not[/b] taxing.]

by $$$$$$$$$$

It's decent of you to add your revision below you original comments, rather than typing over them.

by deepsand

"[i]God told me.

You don't have to believe in mine, and I don't have to believe in yours. The only difference? Mine loves you.[/i]"

Surely you jest.

If not, then there can be no common understanding, and therefore no rational discourse.

by deepsand

"[i]I appreciate your kindness.[/i]"

[b]Good; it was never my intent to engage in personal speculation as to your abilities to understand, only your desire.[/b]

"[i]Are you sure that's the only possible explanation?[/i]"

Would you have me, instead, accuse you of being a dolt, or worse. Ignorance of the facts is the kindest reason within reach.

[b]"Ignorance" is here used in the strict sense, i.e. ignorance of facts or understanding. It is abundently clear from your many posts, both here and elsewhere, that you understanding of science requires expansion. In fact, your below statement serves as example.[/b]

"[i]But that wasn't what I was getting at. Scientists have been wrong before, and they'll undoubtedly be wrong again. This could very well be one of those times.[/i]"

[b]Yes; [u]but[/u], the scientific method includes the ongoing refining of understanding, of modifying conclusions and or theories when new data which does not well comport with such presents itself, [u]and[/u] the ongoing search for data to confirm or deny the plausibility of said conclusions or theories.

Science is, by definition, [u]not static[/u], but most dynamic.[/b]

Ignorance of the facts

"[i]And I thought it was a theory. When did it become fact?[/i]"

[b]Were you not present at any of the many previous occasions when the differences between Scientific Theory and theory, conjecture or speculation were explained? Scientific Theory is much more than the latter; it is a complete rational construct, which sets forth premises which are well grounded in empirical fact, and, by way of logic, arrives at an unavoidable conclusion. I.e., if the premises are indeed true, then so must be the conclusion.

I have, by way of example, personally pointed out to you that radiative forcing is a long known and well understand physical mechanism, one that requires little more than a basic understanding of but a few laws of nature for its comprehension. And that, regardless of any changes in [u]any[/u] other inputs, increased atmospheric levels of certain gases, CO2 included, [u]must[/u] increase radiative forcing; i.e., increased CO2 [u]cannot not[/u] result in increased temperatures.

This conclusion [u]cannot logically be avoided[/u]. It is not mere conjecture or speculation, but an unavoidable consequence of the Laws of Nature; i.e., it is a Scientific Theory.

by deepsand

There needs to be a physical mechanism for such; I have suggested 2.

The 1st is infinitely recursive, and therefore physically impossible.

The 2nd relies on an as yet non-existent tax deduction, one that would require Congressional action and Presidential approval, one that would surely result in almost all, if not all, who voted for such to be impeached by their constituents.

What mechanism do you propose that would allow for the recapture of any additional tax in a manner that would [b]not further increase the tax liabilities[/b] of the affected companies?

by deepsand

beneficial to the populace as a whole?

I'm not sure in what universe you dwell, but, if you look at the profit levels enjoyed by the card issuers in this one since they were freed from State regulation, it's hard to believe that you'd not find them obscene.

Perhaps you've heard the name for such - [b]usury[/b].

by deepsand

You give the appearance of holding that any and all businesses have an absolute right to do as they damned well please, all in the name of profit.

by deepsand

try doing a search for "oil incentive," and reading about how Big Oil continues to reap the benefits of exploration incentives that were enacted when oil was very much cheaper, how Big Oil continues to reap the benefits of such owing to the fact that the language in the enabling contracts of adhesion failed to stipulate an enforceable price cap above which such incentives would cease to be active, how those contracts cannot, as a basic principle of Contract Law re. Contracts of Adhesion, be unilaterally altered by the Federal Government, how Big Oil refuses to agree to these faulty contracts being changed, prefering instead to continue to use them to avoid paying Billions of dollars in royalties on oil extracted from leased Federal properties, i.e., those that are held in common by the US Government for the benefit of its Citizens, to the US Treasury, and then tell us, with a straight face, that Big Oil is not subsidized by US taxpayers.

by deepsand

Neil is spot on as to the comparisons that I suggest.

Absolutely is also dead on with regards to such being tedious.

Had I a sufficiently uninterruptable amount of time at my disposal, I both could and would unertake such myself. However, the fact that I have (temporarily) re-appeared here does not mean that I have more than a few relatively brief moments at my disposal. In fact, tackling such at the moment would require that I either do but small portions at a time, or ignore all other discretionary activities for its being completed forewith.

As I am loath to begin that which I cannot resaonable expect to finish within a foreseeable period of time, and am equally loath to ignore all else, if such comparisons are to be promptly made, it will be by another. For the moment, I'm merely the "idea guy."

by deepsand

which itself is but one of many "To Be Addressed" folders.

I sometimes wonder what my survivors may make of my many and obvious endeavors begun but uncompleted and those intended to have been begun.

by deepsand

The issue is whether burning ethanol so as to produce a given amount of energy yields more or less CO2 than burning an energy equivalent amount of gasoline.

by Member 25348569

I'm so puzzled as to why you can't see it! The key fact about ethanol derived from plant source is that the carbon that you release by burning it was removed from the atmosphere the previous year. THAT is what carbon-neutral actually means!

So long as you get more energy from burning the biofuel than you have to put into the process of growing, processing and extracting the fuel, it's worth it - even if CO2 emissions are your only justification for doing it. Unless, of course, too many people die of starvation...

If we stopped extracting fossil fuels tomorrow and used other energy sources - including as much biofuel as we cared to - the atmospheric CO2 level would return to pre-industrial revolution levels within a very few years as the excess CO2 was sequestrated into the oceanic sinks.

I'm not sure how much clearer I can be...

Neil :)

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]If we stopped extracting fossil fuels tomorrow and used other energy sources - including as much biofuel as we cared to - the atmospheric CO2 level would return to pre-industrial revolution levels within a very few years as the excess CO2 was sequestrated into the oceanic sinks.[/i]

At what rate could the remaining biomass absorb carbon dioxide? For starters, rate of global CO2 output from vehicle combustion less increase of atmospheric concentration of CO2 puts an upper bound on that ability. If that rate is too low, maybe switching to biofuels would simply not achieve the same thing fast enough for deepsand?

I agree you have the concept absolutely right, but the expected rate of change is not something I have ever seen calculated.

One more for my to-do list?

by deepsand

folks.

According to them, burning oil is not and cannot increase Earth's thermal energy; it's the Sun that's solely responsible for that.

Well, then, why not simply harvest all of the energy that the Sun sends our way today, rather than tapping into that which was sent our way eons ago and stored underground, from which it must be extracted at great effort.

If the Sun is now sending us so much energy over and above the amount required for a stable climate, why not simply put that excess to use?

by $$$$$$$$$$

A second time can possibly be somewhat easier, or at worst, no worse. And this time, I'll keep digital records!

by tonythetiger

Go for too much profit, and another business will steal your customers. Airplanes unsafe? Insurance companies will refuse to underwrite. It's government inefficiency which is driving costs higher, not profit, and he bigger government gets, the more inefficiency and the higher the costs.

Make no mistake, I am pro business.... without them most people would be unemployed, and most of our lives would be pretty damned miserable!

I'm even in favor of legalizing prostitution and 'illegal' drugs!

by tonythetiger

[i]So, any rate of interest, fees, etal. is socially acceptable and .. beneficial to the populace as a whole?[/i]

... warn against borrowing, so yes, they are beneficial. That some people refuse to heed the warning is their stupidity.

[i] I'm not sure in what universe you dwell, but, if you look at the profit levels enjoyed by the card issuers in this one since they were freed from State regulation, it's hard to believe that you'd not find them obscene.[/i]

It's no different than any other business. If I don't like the way they treat me, I won't do business with them ... there's another one up the street.

by jdclyde

There is more than one problem, and each problem will require more than one solution.

Short term is the issue of sending our money to the middle east or to chavez. We have oil HERE, so it is clearly stupid to be buying it from overseas.

Long term is to find other sources, as in the video. sources that do not polute our environment is good for everyone, regardless of if you believe in man-made global warming or not.

Should we not be looking to solve both long and short term problems? Or do we ignore the short term because of politics?

by tonythetiger

[i]and for widgets supporting other human needs so understated[/i]

What widgets made from petroleum do you think are a "need"?

by jardinier

Hi Max. Getting a bit carried away there aren't we, with the use of the superlative?

Do you know of any people who have died as a result of belief in man-caused global warming?

As this discussion is specifically about reducing dependency on foreign oil, I would like to draw your attention to a much more serious scam that has cost tens of thousands of lives or more.

This scam was the false reasons given for the invasion of Iraq.

Although the falseness of these reasons has now been revealed and admitted, the war rages and people continue to die or be maimed. That is what I call a serious scam.

I have my opinions on the veracity of who was responsible for 9/11, but we will not open that can of worms.

by $$$$$$$$$$

Various facts have come to my attention over the course of considerable time regarding what was known about Iraq, when, and by whom. Despite an active dislike of the over-privileged bumpkin, I was reluctant to accept each new datum. I'm sure others are still. It took quite a few headlines & Google searches to assemble the various scandals and "mistakes" into my current view, that Bush/Cheney committed pre-meditated murder of Saddam Hussein, and any "collateral damage" unfortunate enough to have been employed in his defense. Now would be an opportune time to assemble all available evidence, and review publicly. Obviously, approval of Bush is low, but I'm not satisfied with that. He needs to be tried for crimes against humanity.

[i]Do you know of any people who have died as a result of belief in man-caused global warming?[/i]

Thanks for the reminder of the true insanity of maxwell's hyperbole, and for the excellent choice of counterexample to his vicious context-dropping.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]It usually happens when ... one person decides to narrow the definition of "rational".[/i]

I frequently lose patience when one or more persons decide to broaden, for themselves only, the definition of "merit."

by $$$$$$$$$$

I'm not "alarmed" by it, but was disappointed, some time ago, when I first began to detect it.

[i]If the interest ... is at or below the legal maximum, it's by definition not usury.[/i]

What is the definition? What trend, if any, is identifiable over the past 10 years? 20? 30? 100? Who has driven changes in that definition? Whose "professional opinions" have any potential impact on such definition, and whose is never considered? In other words, who [b]owns usury law[/b]?

by $$$$$$$$$$

Have you any solutions to advocate, other than by denying their existence? Will you [b]contribute[/b] anything to this conversation?

by jdclyde

I have already stated my opinion on what we should and shouldn't be doing.

Short term:

We SHOULD be drilling, refining, and using, our own oil rather than making some of the worlds craziest people also the richest.

We should NOT be using FOOD for fuel. There are three main things we need and all are getting in short supply. energy, food, and water. States like Arizona are in a world of hurt right now because of lack of water.

We should open the way for people to change our energy usage to cleaner technology, by stop over-regulating wind/tidal/solar/atomic plants. Stop ALLOWING econuts to prevent us from moving away from coal and natural gas. As stated before, they are looking to build new coal plants here in Michigan. Why? Because they can't trust the Democratic congress to not change the rules of the game half way through, so they stay with coal instead of atomic.

People have a taste of blood in their mouths now over the "gas-guzzlers", and many are looking for new soltuions. Solutions that have been in Europe for a long time, but never ALLOWED over hear because of the "big three" not begin able to compete on a level playing field when it comes to auto sales. Protectionism and lobbiests have kept us from seeing alternatives for people looking for them.

This makes a new nitch in the market, and people will be falling all over themselves trying to fill it, if the government will get out of the way. Should the government really be paying for THEIR profits any more than they are currently with the oil companies?

Companies like GE are pushing hard on the global warming issues, because they stand to make a fortune, because THEY are the ones that MAKE the wind farms. fox/hen house?

Does the hysteria about global warming change the benefits to us if we follow what I have put down here?

Does the hysteria and fear mean it is ok for people to lose their rights? Remember, there is talk about charging people with crimes for being a GW denier.

We should lose our RIGHT to believe as we choose?

We should lose our RIGHT to have a snowmobile or a jetski? [i](no, I don't have either)[/i]

How about the energy taxes that the leaches in congress are proposing now? Can we really handle them taking MORE of our money while the costs of everything rise?

What do I personally do?
Keep my thermostat low.
I drive slower, and almost never go over 70.
I plan out my errands to optimise my travel.
I drive a car that gets about 35mpg.
I winterize my house.
I don't fly in planes more than twice a decade, on average.
I vote against people that would raise my taxes.
I vote against people like Hilary Clinton who stated she would "TAKE the winfall revenues" from the oil companies. Remove their tax breaks, fine, but she has no rights to go after ANYONES revenues.

No, I do not believe NY City will be underwater in 100 years because of global warming, regardless of what noble piece wh0re Al Gore says.

by $$$$$$$$$$

Stupidity heats my temper. That warming trend, and its primary cause, are as evident as those which are the primary topics of this thread. Have you anything to [b]contribute[/b] to that?

by $$$$$$$$$$

... after a [brief?] hiatus as CO2 in the atmosphere. I still think you're implicitly assuming that if the thing burned is derived from plant instead of from ancient plant, the rate of plant re-absorption is [b]therefore[/b] equal to or greater than rate of combustion, and I don't assume that's necessarily so. In fact, I don't see how a decreased total living biomass can possibly be [b]better[/b] able to process an equal or greater quantity of atmospheric CO2.

by Member 25348569

Ok...

Repeat {

We grow a field of plants and formation of the complex carbon compounds removes X tons of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere.

Where we derive this carbon from originally does not matter at all.

We burn the plants down to ash - we don't piss about with making alcohol because you guys seem to get confused to the point that I think you're drinking it - and that releases X tons of carbon dioxide back into the atmosphere and warms our house during the Winter.

It is the same carbon that we sequestrated during the growing season.

}(until fusion is developed)

Neil :D

by $$$$$$$$$$

I see from another reply that you acknowledge [b]merely[/b] switching what we burn from petroleum- to biomatter-sourced [b]might[/b] not be quite as helpful as some make it out to be. That's good enough for me. I grok the concept, and I completely agree it's somewhat better than burning petroleum, provided the cost [input Joule/output Joule] can be made comparable. Just how much better doesn't really matter to me. Its magnitude is clearly somewhere between petroleum [horrible] and solar [very good].

I'm more interested in emphasizing other things like hydrogen vs. hydrocarbons for combustion, and solar instead of hydroelectricity and coal plants and other silly stuff for the Grid.

I am a bit thrown by your closing comment, "until fusion is developed." I say, why bother? Decades of Cold War research pretty well established a practical upper bound slightly less than unity. Screw fusion, solar [i]is[/i] viable, [i]now[/i].

while ( c_proven_solar > var_reasonable_expectation of_fusion)
do
{
Ask: Why bother with fusion? It's a remnant of Cold War ideology, and not efficient.
}

by Member 25348569

If we stopped using fossil fuels then then any increase in carbon dioxide would come from "natural" sources, rotting vegetation and other sources, and there would be an uptake of CO2 by the ocean sinks. I've found quite a few differing values for the half-life of CO2 in the atmosphere but the majority seem to come out around 20-40 years. So, around 20-40 years for half of the anthropogenic contribution of CO2 to be removed.

Maybe...

:D

http://www.agu.org/pubs/crossref/1994.../93GB03392.shtml

by nicknielsen

From http://tinyurl.com/42x5ot:

Fact: The Earth is getting warmer and has done so since the end of the last Ice Age.

Fact: Science has demonstrated an association between human activity and such warming.

Fact: Theories attempting to show a causal relationship between human activities and the rate of global warming make assumptions based on demonstrably inadequate climate models that, given actual data, yield results different from those observed. http://www.worldclimatereport.com/index.php/2006/11/02/messy-models/#more-183
http://www.cicero.uio.no/fulltext/index_e.aspx?id=3277

Fact: Instead of using the entire range of outputs from these models, global warming zealots often ignore the lower limits of climate projections in order to present a worst case scenario and justify "immediate action."
http://www.worldclimatereport.com/index.php/2004/03/11/scorched-truth/

Conclusion: The Earth is getting warmer. Humans are probably contributing, as they are part of the ecosystem. The extent of that contribution and the effects on climate are undetermined at this time and may remain so for the foreseeable future.

Should we do what we can? Yes.

Should what we do be at the expense of the world economy, driving companies and countries into bankruptcy on the altar of Global Warming? No.

There it is. You don't like it, that's [u]your[/u] problem. Pissant.

by deepsand

Deliberately evades the issue.

Are you ignorant of the fact that the [b]Fed does not regulate[/b] interest rates or related fees? Or, that the [b]States no longer can[/b]?

The rates in question [b]do exceed[/b] those allowed by many States.

The Fed, however, stripped the States of their ability to enforce such, thus giving the companies in question a free rein; i.e., the sky's the limit.

And, usury is [b]not[/b] merely a [i]legal[/i] term; look it up.

[b]Nobody's minding the store[/b].