Discussion Locked

Internal VS. External Drives

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I was hoping someone might be able to give me some general advice about internal versus external hardware devices (e.g., hard drives, zip drives, CD-RW drives, modems, etc.). Which do you think is better to do -- buy internal or external -- any why? Personally, I tend to prefer external, for several reasons. (1) You don't have to pay to have them installed. (2) When your computer becomes obsolete, you can quickly and easily connect them to the new replacement model you buy. (3) They are mobile devices.

9 replies

by computechie

Both internal and external drives have their pro's and con's. Personally, I prefer internal drives just because they are contained inside the box and connecting them is simpler, you dont have to have external power supplies, and cuts down on the number of cables running out of your machine. External drives are nice because they are portable as you say, but most connect to parallel or USB ports, which are slower than the internal IDE or SCSI connections you have. If you don't like to tinker around inside the computer, avoid the high charges tech's require, or have multiple computers to use the device on, then definately go with external devices. I'd also check out external devices that use a FireWire port, it's very high speed for external devices. I hope this helps you make a decision.

by galahad04

Hi Troy,

Thanks for your helpful comments about the pros and cons of internal and external hardware devices. If you don't mind, I have a brief follow-up question to your last message: you mentioned that external drives are slower than internal drives b/c they connect to parallel or USB ports. Therefore, I was just wondering because of the speed issue if it is generally not a good idea to buy an external hard disk drive?

Thanks

by csmith

If you use IDE, the boot drive (C:) should be internal. For SCSI, the drive, the scanner, etc. speeds are all the same, internal or external.
The other peripherals don't matter either, except the CDRW. If the bus speed on a CDRW is too slow, buffer underruns occur and this causes bad CDs. Internal IDE for CDRW is more reliable. The best idea for CDRW is to hook it to the second IDE channel on the Mother Board.
Regards, Chris

by marence

As mentioned by csmith, SCSI devices are the only external devices that have the same speed rate internally or externally (except for firewire, otherwise known as iLink or IEEE 1394). The slower connections thru parallel, serial, or USB ports don't allow for speeds close to what an internal IDE device is capable of. If you use firewire, the speeds are blazingly fast - faster than your usual internal hard drive - but - you have to have a firewire port or buy a firewire expansion card (now we're getting into the "opening the box" area again.)
If you find yourself upgrading often, it's usually cheaper to learn how to connect devices internally yourself. That way you can use better faster devices, and when the time for a new box comes, simplybuy a bare bones system, and install them in the new place. (This also means you can use your same hard drives and not have to reload OS and programs!)

This discussion is closed to new replies.