Discussion Locked

Is anyone else tired of spyware?

0 helpful
395 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Do you want to do something about it?

I'm a network admin for a small company. While I have anti-virus on all our computers, I can't really stop spyware/adware from installing itself.
yes, I can educate users, but we know that won't stop all of it.

I'm spending probably at least 1 day a week cleaning PC's. And as soon as I find a tool that I think cleans up the systems, a new flavor comes out and I'm forced to wipe the hard drive.

I've had it! And I think some of you feel the same way. So I have an idea.

Many of these hijack programs direct browers to specific web sites. Also, popup ads that install themselves on the hard drive target specific sites and/or products.

So I'm thinking, why not bill them? If I spend 2 hours cleaning a PC, I should send them a bill for, oh, $50 an hour, or $100 for my time. Of course, they won't pay, but why not?

Could these bills, not payed, be turned over to a collection center? Could legal action be taken? By myself, I won't be able to make much of a dent. However, if we could get hundreds or thousands of techs, and maybe consumers, or businesses submitting bills to these firms, could it impact their slimy business? Could this work? Would you be willing to particapate?

I welcome your feedback!

395 replies

by tribbles

Hi

For starters, you might want to install Firefox on the users desktop, then go into Internet options and increase the security levels as well as maybe enabling content advisor. Also if you put Spywareblaster or Spywareguard and keep them up to date, they will stop most of the garbage that tries to drop in on your'e users desktops.www.wilderssecurity.com/spywareguard is the site to go to. You also might want to check out the Beta Spyware program that Microsoft is offering, keep in mind it is a Beta (Research and Development)(WinXP) and download it onto the users desktops, it has active monitoring, when surfing the net, and will protect the computer. As for billing the perps who are responsible for this, save your stamps and just try to be proactive in ensuring your companies assets are clean.

Good Luck

Jim

by trevorbax

the problem is that installing firefox is not an answer to the problem. Protection through using a more obscure product will only help in the short term as if we all do this it will gradually move to be the leader. Once everyone moves to firefox then so will the spyware developers! What do we do then move back to IE or go on to opera? In either case the spyware people will follow eventually.

Programs like MS's antispyware will help however this product is best positioned currently for homes and small businesses as currently as far as I am aware it cannot be controlled by GPO thus controll of the product on 1000's of desktops is not going to be easy. MS will add this in but probably a version or two on from this beta.

Billing these people will not stop them but some how we have to put them out of business, or learn to live with them.

by jp-dutch

Trevor Bax does make one wrong assumption.
In fact there are no longterm solutions to the spyware problem. Spyware guys were, are and will be constantly prowling for our Net behaviour, so their bosses can give us the 'right' popups, banners, etc... And their compadres, the spammers, can flood our mailboxes with their 'irresistible offers'...

Fact is, since I installed Firefox and stopped using IE, my two spyware removal tools (SpyBot and Adaware) hardly find anything to remove.
IE is and will be a leaky basket, Firefox is a much more robust Program, which obviously has been designed from a clean(er) sleet.

Conclusion: Firefox is a good short term solution. And I have more confidence in Mozilla than in Microsoft to stay abreast of events.

by liame

They will claim that users 'agree' to their sofware being installed in some way by clicking their misleading crap.

I'm all for trying to bill the gits though. Lots of small bills would be harder for them to fight I guess though. Think of 10,000 people trying to take em top court for $100 each. They'd have to send someone to court 10,000 times to defend themselves.

On a brighter note have you tried the MS antispyware beta? It might be the sort of product you are looking for to block infestation in the first place.

by awfernald

now if we could just coordinate it so that we all file in small claims court at the same time against the same companies.....

by johnmcgrew

...but at different times. Why make it convenient for them so that they only have to show on one day? Make it so that they have to be in court every single day of the week, and in every possible jurisdiction.

by jereg

I'm glad you brought that up. Yes, I expect that they may say we somehow agreed, (I don't think you always get a choice though). In a corporate environment, I am the only legal decision maker. When there is a policy that users can't load software, any 'agreement' the user might make shouldn't be valid.

I think....

by tribbles

Try setting up the users with limited accounts on their desktops, this will stop them from installing even after they have downloaded, as well as stopping them from installing off of disks. Also if you have clear guidelines on internet policies, you shouldn't have these recurring problems, unless some of the users don't subscribe to your policies, then methinks it is time to replace users.

by jdclyde

If the scumbags are in a country that can't be bothered to have a law against such behavior because they are making money off of it, the there would not be a court for them to answer to.

A mafia hit sounds good to me. Let them wake up with a horses head next to them.

But just like SPAM and Virus originators there should be a way to nail them to the wall.

by karldearnley

The mafia hit sounds good.

Personally I think it's a good idea to bill the companies and I would be willing to get involved. I'm sick of doing the same thing and wasting time doing shit I shouldn't need to.

by pgcasey

http://www.javacoolsoftware.com
This software prevents several thousand active x and java items from know spammers and other bad actors from running and installing themselves on your system. Freeware. I is the only preventitive rather than reactive software that I know of.

by oz_media

I have gone from cleaning more than 70 entries per week to 2, and they were both acceptable and set to ignore as they are just cookies from a homepage login.

How's it done? Firefox, free, no adware.

The only way I hav picked up ads with Firefox is from installing sharware and in that case you must agree to the license first.

by hereinoz

I run Firefox, with SpywareBlaster, and the spyware infections have almost disappeared. The occasional tracking cookie is about it.

cheers,

Alan

by jrcurry

Firefox, SpywareBlaster, and now I'm down to a cleanup once a month, only to get rid of the occassional cookie. Way to go Mozilla.

by dcperich

Can someone write an ap that will respond to requirements to "load" (but disable) a spyware program to satisfy requirements of a web page? Or...can an application be written that hands a neutral or false front set of data to the spyware program? What would be the result if the data the spyware program collects is worthless to the spys?

by mcs-1

At a meeting of a local computer club we had a round-table on 'Spyware Blame', and your idea was mentioned - it is a good idea.
Another one that raised interest is getting the ISPs involved. I guess the logistics would be staggering to this, but it might also be the most effective. If we were able to monitor our connections, add up all the junk at the end of the month, and deduct that off our Internet bills ... the ISPs would respond very quickly.
As it sits now, ISPs almost seem to encourage internet garbage, as it has become a source of revenue for many of them ... selling spam blocking, spyware control, firewalls, virus packages, ....

But, the bottom line is still education. When people stop clicking where they shouldn't, the problem will start to vanish.

by jereg

Good points. I should add that I've been useing various tools, including MS AntiSpyware.

I am testing Firefox now. I know that it will prevent many of these problems, but there are a few issues with it as well.

I do try to educate the users here, and to be honest, it's really a hard core of 10-15 people that have a problem. But the owner of the company encourages the employees to ask me for help with their home PC's, and I'm happy to do it, but they always have the same symptoms, i.e., "my PC is running slow, can you help?"

I have to say, I believe that the problem is bigger than just cleaning PC's. A number of times I've searched for something, gone to a website, and gotten hit. No subscribing and no downloading. And I know that the problem will get worse. That's why I believe that something needs to be done, and we all need to address it.

Thanks.

by jereg

It's a good idea, but when I tried limiting the desktops, I found that some of the apps we use wouldn't work.

I've been able to educate most users, but there are some hardcore ones that, well, what can you do. We're a small company and the owner are proud of the fact that we have a limited number of company 'rules'. It makes it a nice place to work, but it does cause a few problems for me....

by house

I have no problem with spyware at all (at home). I have a problem with trying to manage tech support inquiries that are attributed to spyware.

If I am infected at home, I can deal with it myself. Pity to those who do not know the ways of Windows. Pity to me who has to listen to the bickering. ;)

by jdclyde

I am sure they would just LOVE to bring the computers to you at work and have you fix them. After all, being nice and personable, people might think you were a repair shop.....

by house

I'm working on my attitude - I need to discourage people from asking me for advice. The next time that I talk to a client, it'll be with a grunt.

by thechas

I know it is a draconian tactic, but, if you lock the desktops and get serious about filtering web access you can stop most of the spy-ware coming at you.

Even if you just keep adding restricted sites to a web filter and increase the blocking level of your firewall, you can reduce spy-ware significantly.

I must be too limited in my surfing, as I don't have a spy-ware problem myself.

(At least since I forced my kids to stop using the peer to peer networks.)

The number 1 source I have that attempts to install mal-ware on my systems are the free desktop theme and screen saver sites.

One thing to keep in mind, is that spy-ware is just the latest battle in the war of people trying to make money off of their web sites.

First it was banner adds, then pop-ups, now it's mal-ware.

What will be next if we do manage to effectively stop the mal-ware?

Chas

by house

In the corporate world, you need to lock them down.

On a home support basis, there is not much you can do besides cringe. :)

by dubdays

I completely agree that the garbage screen savers and themes will slow your computer down to a speed that seems comparable to a Pentium 90 (just an illustration; don't quote me). Another source that you're right about are a lot of P2P software. And, it's not whats downloaded that's causing the problems, but the P2P software itself. If you've ever installed stuff like Kaaza or BearShare, your computer is almost invariably full of trash.

However, I'm not sure how much locking the desktop is going to help. Certainly, it will help some. However, IE is so much a built-in part of windows (this can be debated), that even a locked down user who's using patches that are only slightly out of date (which isn't unusual in the corporate world), they also have the potential to infect the entire computer, especially if a virus is installed. And, the problem with filtering the stuff at the firewall/router/you pick, is that much of it runs encrypted through the normal www port 80, which makes spyware traffic very difficult to determine without very sophisticated software. Really, what it all boils down to is having all systems patched as much as possible, even with the headaches involved. Add in a GOOD anti-sypware system, and the threat will be reduced phenominally. Unfortunately, patches can break things, so until MS decides to make patches that are fully compatible with "all" instead of "most" currently working software, you may have your hands tied.

by awade

Why doesn't this fall under the catagory of invasion of privacy. If we were being bombarded with adverisers at our front doors, You could force them to stop by law. The computers in our homes and offices are private property. If computers are not covered they should be. As far as I am concerned Adware and Spyware getting loaded on my computer without my permission is equivalent breaking and entering. We need to start a grassroots uprising or a class action suit to have it stopped.

by jcox

I couldn't agree more that Spyware qualifies as invasion of privacy. It seems many of these programs get installed whether the user chooses Yes to Install, or No to not install. I bet the perpetrators would cease if we hit them with criminal and civil penalties!

by jdclyde

If companies start to get bad press for this type of activity, then you would get their attention.

Note, has anyone seen where some of the spyware makers are threatening the adware removers to stop removing them? The search tool bars were claiming that even though they were installed as a Media Player update that the customer agreed to it.

Scumbags.

by dubdays

I had exactly the same problem....antivirus software, but still getting tons of other garbage that took forever to clean up. Often, the user feels like your a god for being able to "fix" it, but it just feels like a TERRIBLE waste of time.

Then, I started trying different software to combat the spyware nightmare. Initially, I tested AdAware SE (the personal edition...I don't pay to only test software...sorry Lavasoft). You can download the free version or buy a commercial license at "http://lavasoft.de". It works fairly well, but it's difficult to administer.

Next, I tried Spybot Search and Destroy, which also has administration problems, but it has a ton more features to help prevent the adware in the first place. Plus, it's completely free, which is a big plus if your protecting quite a few machines. Well, it catches most stuff, but not all. So, I went on to try something different.

The last one is Spy Sweeper (http://www.webroot.com), and I have to say, this is the one to use. There is both a standalone version and an enterprise version that will allow you to monitor and set rules at a central location. You can also download a free 30-day trial (includes definition updates) at their website. Seriously, you should just try it and see what it finds. It's absolutely amazing, at least to me.

I know CA also has a spyware tool for enterprises, but I haven't had the chance to play with it. Honestly, I don't even feel I need to. Spy Sweeper will clean your computer clean as a whistle (of course, as long as you don't have any viruses festering and trying to cause chaos).

by ians

I've found that FortiGate products (FG-50, 60) have feature to filter out "grayware" (that's way they call it). It's appliance that have firewall, router and content filtering features. It's not cheap but it does the job. I am sys.admin in about a dozen organizations and two of them use FG's. They forgot what is spyware. But to configure FG and configure its VPN client is a MAJOR pain in the a$$ :))).
On PC level - Spybot + Adware + Microsoft's AntiSpyware beta (with agents enabled) does this job (and don't forget HijackThis - powerful small tool against hijackers).

Good luck.

by mostexcellent

This is what needs to happen if spyware/adware/spam is to stop: Find the CEO of the company who is spreading it. Pull him (or her) out of their house in the middle of the night or a Saturday afternoon. Make them run a gauntlet of those who have had their computer compeletly compromised or identity stolen. If they survive to the end. Lucky them. Repeat as needed with the next company and/or the same. There is NO incentive not to spread spam or spyware.

by kitg6flw

I agree with the sentiment but your solution is probably even less "legal" than "crime" we're fighting!

Until there is an enforceable law - unlikely? - We can either frustrate them by blocking their attacks on our systems (which will be an ongoing struggle)or we can identify perps and spam them back big time. Overload their setup and clog up their net access.

If you do set up a lynching party however, don't forget to invite me!

by gordon.forbes

I think that billing them is not enough. I would like to charge them for bandwidth, diskspace, processing time, Time for waiting for the download and time for cleaning up the mess. I am sick of these intrusions and raping of my computer resources. Why is there a law for breaking and entering, stealing and damage to propperty but not for syberspace?

by ngl0578

one of the power tools in spybot include a huge list (128k i believe) of sites that are added to the hosts list to redirect to local host.
127.0.0.1

basicly, when your computer gets a request to connect to one of the listed sites, you instead get a connection to remote host unavailable type message in the block where the ad or other request resides.

It has helped a lot to keep my system clean, even/especially when visiting sites that are known for banner ads, spyware, and such.

by p_tavares

But someone should ask the senate to pass a bill on that. Even more so millions of $ of productivity are lost everyday by the amount of people that has to clean up their PCs. Could we ask a senator to indulge a committee to study this?
Best regards,
Paulo Tavares

by bjcomp

I am in full agreement...however getting paid from these firms could be a pain in the arse. Would we ever receive payment?

In the meantime, our clients keep getting with with this crap, interfering with their internet access, popups and want us to clean them off the system and we have to charge them to keep in business ourselves. It's a vicious cycle.

I would be willing to participate in billing the bastards who write the shit to begin with.

by kays07

Installing Firefox is a good option, if your company like mine is more comfy with I.E. install the google toolbar, it blocks pop-ups. On machines running WINXP install MS Antispyware beta-for once something from MS actually works.

On older machines, one a week run either spybot search and destroy or SystemMechanic Pro 4 or 5, the popup blocker is quite effective.

More than that educate, educate, educate...if that doenot get results, and you want to take real drastic steps and can do so, block Internet Access for a day for the offenders...

Corporates using Norton should install its firewall, too.

by info

We've had a real problem with certain malware with customers that deal with websites in Eastern Europe and China. Our solution is Firefox (which is much less susceptible to malware) and AdAware Plus which can actually block Malware on the way in (as opposed to trying to get rid of it once you have it already). This combo works amazingly. If you need to use IE then AdAware Plus also does the trick as it stops malware on the way in. Be aware you will have to teach users to use AdAware (particularly the AdWatch part) and that it will aggressively stop popups - including legitimate ones but it is easy to temporarily disable (right click on icon) but your users will have to be shown this.
Also if anyone is fighting with the IEFeats malware and it is particularly tenacious I found the only way to find the files is with a Linux boot CD with NTFS access. Try http://ebcd.pcministry.com for a the bootCD. (by the way the USB boot device ($25) is also amazing) Then look for unknown dlls logs and dats. (I had qaawf.dll, dfaqv.dll, n_zfayhs.log, n_napbaa.dat, n_lkwxuc - you get the idea). The dlls were around 64kb and the some of the dats and logs had HTML code in them which was the home page that came up once infected.
I hope this helps someone save the hours it took to figure it out!!!

by phasers

Sign me up. Something has got to be done to put a halt to these scumbags that think it is ok to invade a persons personal possesion and load it full of their garbage. I have heard of so many unfortunate folks that lost so much information because they did'nt know how to get rid of this invasion of privacy. Their lack of computer knowledge led them to believe that all data was destroyed because of the direct actions of these morons that install this garbage. If anyone has a better idea well now is the time to speak up. But for now....I'm on board.

by xmatelot

That's a great idea; I bought a new vehicle and the dealership was most interested in my having to also purchase their plate frame with their logo. My direct question to the salesman was how much was the company going to pay me for advertising for them; needless to say, no plastic licence plate frame was put onto the vehicle, just the plates. The same principle should hold with spammers and ISPs who don't pay attention to how their resources are employed and since they've allowed their subscribers to take up space on my hard drive and if it's like the crap from Millennium Digital Media in Charlotte, Mich by sending Trojans and to try to use my machine as a proxy of some sort, they SOBs should pay very dearly.

by gpower

It's a wonderful idea but it should have a legal aspect to back it up. If there's a law that would state that, then anyone can claim for damages resulting from spyware. Then maybe that would deter spyware development and eventually phase it out. But is there such a law for that?

by coach

Now, we just need to find a sleezy lawyer that will take on the case and sue the perps for our money. BTW, this needs to include all of the money for the damaged hard drives, sometime loss of data and even operating systems in some cases...

by justsean

I total agree that there should be a law against these SPYWARE and ADWARE companies, but these companies are shell companies over sea. Those governments do not care about any internet /computers issues in the USA. The only thing they want from USA is money to rebuild the countries or destroy another country. The programmers are just doing there job to be paid just like you and me so, I cannot knock them for trying to make a living. This is cycle that can never be broken that?s my two cents

by g.brown

Please show me some specific independent stats to say where the spyware is coming from before coming up with BROAD statements like that that you don't back up with any facts at all.

by d.sorrell1

I work from home as a IT Tech for a few small businesses and some private customers. I can remeber the times when if I got called out it was something technical or a major glitch, now most of the calls I get are to correct peoples computers who have been invaded by spyware and such forth. Not that i'm complaining about the extra work, but I am getting sick and tired of the same kind of work over and over. Thankfully one of the customers wants a rackmount server and network, something else to do, ......... Untill the spyware etc gets it.

by budgie11

Why not bill them for instances of Spam
an Idea back along was to bill the spammer ?1 for each e-mail recived

so one could have an automatic account(for Billing purposes) so he/she pays you ?1
To recive the e-mail

The Same should go for spyware Browser Highjacking
for every instance found on one computer the company individal pay you ?1

Ie I found 780 instances of spyware,browser highjacking scumware etc etc on a computer

so their woudl be a total of ?780 for having it on your machine

by brianaaa8

Most of what has been said I concur with, but I don't think we need a new law, we just need to apply some that are around already in new ways. In the US there is a law about stealing electricity as in the UK. Effectively, these guys are stealing electricity - the difference between a machine on standby and active - not much difference you might say, but add that difference up for 200 installs and removal procedures and it starts to add up. Being a federal offence if enough reports hit the authorities they will act.

Worth a try.

by mek804

This is a nice idea, but how do you find out who they *really* are
and even if you do, how do you make them pay?

These people are scumbags--they won't pay up : (

by stan20

I have identified a few of them so far, and sent bills for my time and for the use of my computer. I don't really expect them to pay without a fight, but next month I will be sending them the third notice, and then I intend to turn it over to a collection agency.

I think I'm on firm legal ground, and would be more than happy to join any class action suit. By
clearly posting my rates on my computer (use of my computer and/or my time implies acceptance) and by sending bills, etc, I have a paper trail, etc for use in any court case against them.

by stan20

My time is valuable, and CPU time, memory usage and disk space are valuable resources. My computer is my property, and if anyone wants to use my time or my property, I will bill them. My standard (confiscatory) rates are posted in a text file on my computer. Use of my computer implies acceptance of my terms and rates.

If anyone thinks my rates are too high (and they are outrageously high), then they can stay out of my computer.

by g.brown

All those people with annoying gif images that take up your CPU and drive space ... I mean you didn't ask to see the picture.

Some people just think a little too simple me thinks :)

by gordon.forbes

Using other browsers will help until someone find a security hole somewhere and continue their sinister actions. This i see as fixing the symptom while we should be fixing the root cause - people producing spam in the first place.

by g.brown

SPYWARE IS NOT SPAM!!!

Spyware collects info on you .... SPAM is Unsolicited Commercial Email.

Maybe the problem is idiot programmers who don't do any/enough research.

by gordon.forbes

Using other browsers will help until someone find a security hole somewhere and continue their sinister actions. This i see as fixing the symptom while we should be fixing the root cause - people producing spam in the first place.

by stan20

Firefox helps, but its not always an option. Some sites that my business must use only work with IE. And even when its a viable option, its a short term solution at best.

If the music industry can get the names and addresses of music downloaders, it should be easy for the justice department to track down the people who produce this crap and put them out of business.

by perses_1

I think that bill to the sites is not a good idea because as you may know a adware tool developer could also include visits to your site company and in this case you must to pay for it.

by alanchcc2000

This sounds a good solution provided you can actually trace the scum who are doing this I,m into it It really bugs me too

by ngage-online

I actually think that it's not a bad idea at all. Maybe not directly, but there should be a way for charging these companies for the work and time you spend cleaning up their shit. The problem is, that most spyware which does install stuff onto your system to redirect you to their site, is generally been given permission by the user prior to this. So in otherwords you can't really hold them responsible anylonger. The user would become the one to receive the bill.
What I think should happen; is a new law, inwhich spyware that is installed to your system, would first have to CLEARLY identify itself and present the user with a warning, other than a general ARGREEMENT. Pleople just don't read that stuff when surfing. They just click the box they have to click to go on with whatever they intend to find.
Of course there also is a lot of spyware that is being introduced to your system without any prior authorization. Unfortunately these tools come from sources yet to be identified. There are tons of sites out there that don't have owners, so it seems. Which makes it hard too. Try to bill a ghost! The bill will come right back at ya!
Companies like Microsoft should work a lot harder on training their support-staff in means of helping improve communication between getting input from the outside and their research departments.

I recently replied to an artikle about Trojans, Viruses and Spyware, by sending an e-mail to Microsoft.
One of the things I had found in my system was a file I still don't know where it's from and it hasn't returned yet (Luckily). But it does cause for enormous bandwidth drop for LAN/Internet.
At the time my Norton AntiVirus didn't recognize the WEBDLG32.DLL file as an Ad-Aware/Spyware file. Now it does. I think Ad-Aware still doesn't recognize this file as Ad-Aware/Spyware. It also includes a file with extension .INF

Here's what's in it:
---------------------------------------------
[Version]
Signature="$CHICAGO$"
AdvancedINF=2.0

[Add.Code]
webdlg32.dll=webdlg32.dll

[webdlg32.dll]
file-win32-x86=thiscab
clsid={0E1230F8-EA50-42A9-983C-D22ABC2EED3B}
FileVersion=1,0,0,1
RegisterServer=yes
---------------------------------------------
The CLSID can be found in four places in the registry. It doesn't give me any clues.
- HKEY_CURRENT_USER\Software\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\Ext\Settings\
- HKEY_CURRENT_USER\Software\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\Ext\Stats\
- HKEY_USERS\...\Software\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\Ext\Settings\
- HKEY_USERS\...\Software\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\Ext\Stats\

But anyways, the main reason for sending an e-mail to microsoft were the InternetExplorer ADD-ONs. Such an ADD-ON can change the way a user surfs, for sure. This is what I found:

Explorer Class - (Not Verified) - Browser Helper Object - DSMAN~1.DLL

When this Internet Explorer ADD-ON is Enabled, search engines like google will come up with very weird results. I don't know what else it does and where it comes from yet, but I don't surf sites like ADULT FRIEND FINDER and know for sure that I didn't get it from any site of this type. I simply DO NOT visit SEX & PORN sites. They are a huge problem and welcome startout places for spyware.
When I enable it, and search for anything in for example google, i ALWAYS get some; "Adult Friend Finder Sex-bla..bla...bla" within the top 3 and more in the list below it.

This is what I inquiered about with microsoft. Cause I wanted to be able to remove the ADD-ONs causing this, instaid of DISABLING them, so I could search for where it originated from by having it re?nstalled while surfing.
That way I could block those sites from ever causing any damage again on systems I build.
I'm on the verge of stepping out of private computer-business into starting my own little firm. I'll be building computer-systems on which I want max performance for a limited type of customers. The elite type of user, that demands only max performance high-end and visually attractive systems. I can't afford to have stuff like a stupied piece of spyware drop system performance by 20%. That's not good for my line of business. I'm not cheap... but people know what they get is good.
Oh, yeah... Microsoft's answer (in short) was: YOU LIVE IN GERMANY, CONTACT MICROSOFT GERMANY FOR KNOWLEDGE OF YOUR LOCAL OS-version.
Well... I don't have GERMAN-version, but US-version.
No matter!

Anyways. I think there really should be a new law, which prevents things from being installed to your system that easily. Simply make them include a big huge window with a warning that more then the customer bargains for is being installed. And then... if a company does not do that... simply bill them with a law that cancles out the notifications in an agreement if this warning window is NOT available!
Right now they're probably covered by one or two lines in an agreement that a user doesn't read, but agrees to. This must be changed.
Sigarettes also must carry HEALTH WARNINGs. So WHY NOT SPYWARE! They are a great thread to a SYSTEMS HEALTH.

Anybody wanna reply go post, please also send a copy to my e-mail address, as I usually don't have time to keep checking with all forums all the time and i'm really insterested to know if anybody things we can do something about that!

PS; sorry for the long reply... needed to let of some steam! this spyware is a real pain in any administrators's bottom.

by wiznilly

I would definitely be onboard with the idea that jereg has,there's no better place to strike back at the Spyware generator than their wallet,that always get the attention and action where it's most effective.

I say let's get the ball rolling with this idea.

J.Cummings

by corporatelackie

Given that these scum TRY to be anonymous, and even when found will claim they did no wrong it seems in many cases an alternative to sending a bill will be needed. Since in most cases the objective of the spyware is to get you to visit a web site and buy somethig here are two suggestions:

1) This one may infact not be legal (fighting fire with fire) Mount a DDOS attack on their web sites. If even 0.01% of everyone spammed started pinging their website or requesting page after page or "whatever" perhaps their servers could be overloaded causing them to be unable to take people's money.

2) Use roboform or similar tool to fill out MANY bogus orders on their website for whatever they are selling. This would cause there costs to rise dramatically as they would have to sift thru all the bogus orders to find the "real" orders. This could potentially cause their scheme to become non-profitable if enough people submitted enough bogus orders.

by admin

As a Systems Administrator for a North London College and a Freelance I.T. Support Technician, I spend a considerable amount of time removing Spyware, not so much from the college network, but from private users and small business owners who do not have their own in-house I.T. Support.

I tend to use about 4 Anti-Spyware packages namely: Spybot 1.4B2, Spyware Blaster 3.3, Adware SE, Microsoft's New Anti-Spyware software, and of course Norton's Anti-Virus Packages.

I find that when building a system from scratch, and all the above packages are installed after Service Pack 2 (WinXP)and then immediately updated from their respective Websites, I not my customers tend not to be infected with Spyware infections.

However, when attempting to deal with a computer that has already been infected the story is not so positive. Despite several scanning operations you never seem to beable to clean a machine completely, and inevitably requires a system re-build just be sure that the system is in fact cleaned.

In conclusion my policy is build the Anti-Spyware in at system build stage and keep it up to date, something many users seem to ignore.

Brian King
Computech 2000 Computer Services (UK)

by gashworth

I agree. if anyone is goin to serriously take this up then I am behind you. keep posting and lets find a lawyer that is prepaired to take this case. (I'm rather sure that there are at least one or two lawyers in the wild that have been adversly affected by spyware)
Whether it is the responsibility of the Advertising Companies or the advertised companies, I don't care, Swift penalties need to be implimented Immediately for such invasive action as spam and spyware.

I DEMAND JUSTICE - feelmypain@hotmail.com

by g.brown

There is a flaw in firefox that enables a malicious user to infect you.

The funny thing is ....

It infects IE ...

Anyone know how to uninstall IE completely?

by g.brown

I'll have to give it a go.

I used to have IE as a backup for some people that couldn't be arsed to write their webpages properly, but actually, recently I can't remember launching it at all.

So, I think it's goodbye IE.

by noorman

you can uninstall it with 2000lite / XPlite.

the only disadvantage; you can't do Windowsupdate anymore because that will only work with IE, what did you expect ?!!!

by capnpauly

Even though you can't do 'WindowsUpdate' you can still download each individual update by their corresponding MSKB article; it can just get tedious trying to find all of them.

by eingram1

I already have thought of that. The reasoning is logical. If someone send something un-ordered to my house, I have the legal right to charge for storage. My computer is my property, and if someone uses it's resources without my permission, I have a right to charge them. I'd like to hear from any "legal eagles" on this. Perhaps an attorney?

by g.brown

Well, if you picked it up from their website, or installing a program (without researching whether that prog has any spyware in) for instance, then surely couldn't you equate it to walking through someone else's house and picking up a bit of extra baggage.

by dmambo

Firefox, by virtue of being open source, has all those folks out there helping to make it more robust. It's still fixing the symptom, but so far it's a pretty damn good fix!!!!

by g.brown

I really do want to hear what the outcome of that is.

Why don't you try and sue MS too - for making your system so insecure.

by george

If enough people participate I am sure we can generate a voice for these embedding spy-ware companies to back off or at least gain some ground with legal authorities to combat this problem ... I currently use "Spy-bot" and Lavasoft's "Ad-ware SE6" as well as Yahoo's "Anti-Spy" to monitor activity on my system - at least it prevents me from re-formatting my hard drive ( that's a pain for a solution!)

by david.deleon

Hi Jereg... Yes !!! I would be willing to do my "BIT" that was unintentional I think, anyway you get my drift.
allis "dyspyware"

by Former member

I am all for it! And $50/hour sounds CHEAP! If you made the mess, then you should be responsible for it's cleanup. (Most) polluters pay, and 'guilty' auto accident purpetrators pay, why not the damaging spammer/spyware source? It seems to be a similar context of action: careless affects with some level of malition.
Problem is, there needs to be some sort of legal mechanism in place to more easily facilitate execution of legitimate complaints. Perhaps even some sort of certification for and by servicers to serve as concrete proof of damage. This way, spammers will have little recourse in defense and (potentially) be dis-incented to even start spamming (et al...). Of course, it will be necessary for victims to take full action when they get 'infected'; thus the need for incentive for their pro-active participation (e.g. easy to initiate the victims recourse).
This will provide a two-fold protection: potentially deter spammers, and pseudo-'insure' potential victims against the impending financial costs.

by g.brown

Have a read of this ..... Adware maker joins federal privacy board
Most of you here seem to be from the US, so do something about it.

Instead you just seem to be legitimising spyware/adware.

Anyone remember Gator .... well read on ....

Published: February 23, 2005
By Declan McCullagh
Staff Writer, CNET News.com

http://news.com.com/Adware+maker+joins+federal+privacy+board/2100-1028_3-5587653.html

The Department of Homeland Security has named Claria, an adware maker that online publishers once dubbed a "parasite," to a federal privacy advisory board.

An executive from Claria, formerly called Gator, will be one of 20 members of the committee, the department said Wednesday.

"This committee will provide the department with important recommendations on how to further the department's mission while protecting the privacy of personally identifiable information of citizens and visitors of the United States," Nuala O'Connor Kelly, the department's chief privacy officer, said in a statement.

Claria bundles its pop-up advertising software with ad-supported networks such as Kazaa. Recently, the privately held company has been trying to seek credibility by following stricter privacy guidelines and offering behavioral profiling services to its partners.

Ouch.

And you think sueing the smalll fry is gonna be a solution when you've got some of the worst offenders making policy, that really makes me laugh.

Hmmm. makes you wonder what kind of agenda these people really have.

I can just imagine "no, it's not spyware, it's just a commercial tool for data mining"

They just need to think up some sort of Orwellian slogan or two now!!

by samuel.custer

I think this is an excellent idea. Another method would be to set up a legal defense fund and take these people to court. It would take so much time and cost so much for defense that even if we don't win, we could bankrupt some of these schmucks.

by philchil

I love it!! I have a hard time billing my customers (mostly elderly from a retirement village) for all the hours I spend cleaning their systems, usually just a service call fee or something minimal, and I would love to be able to turn that around on these guys! You are right, just about the time you get a good cleaning system down, here they come with something else. Anyway, I'mm willing - where do we start?

by g.brown

Install any anti-spyware to start with then?

Surely you wouldn't have to keep going back.

Or maybe another OS that isn't as prone??

by www.hansencc.net

I'm all for a special operations team to hold a D.O.S. virus for these "special" companies. Release it on them to offset IT time expense for clean-ups!

by g.brown

Go on I dare you ... oh yeah ... isn't DOS ILLEGAL??

... insert witty comment about "special" users :)

by escull

I think this is a great idea! It's not as important to me as it is for any business but it's a pain in the you know what!
How would you go about the billing procedure?
This is a chore(not needed)for a busy person but it would have to be someone that is knowledgible
about the procedure. I'll pass the on.
Ed

by rick.boyd

Billing them, while offering a measurement for the amount of time that they waste, seems like a good way to get these peope. However, they are probably not running an above board operation in the first place and the bills would go uncollected.

I think that we should target the sites with a "denial of service" or other such attack so that their sites crash and cause them to have to fight the hacker.

Revenge is the best retaliation!

by itissues

I am also spending an inordinate amount of time as well as lost productivity on machines that become so bogged down that they crawl along and cause drain on resources of my IT department. If anyone knows of any recourse let us know. I would join any class action suit or whatever, this is turning into a real cost drain on our business.

by dksatti

Hi,

I suspect a guy who is trying to redirect me to a MS download and say he is installing a new patch to stop hacker every day. Dont know how to kill him. spy-blaster,spybot - none of them are really of help.

I am located in Canada. Are there any cops or agencies/somebody like that who I can talk to?
Everyday my browser hangs when I start it. I have to kill a couple of exes to start my internet work. I am in job search and it is a pain.

I suspect I can get more details over time about this guy.

Friend - any help is greatly appreciated.
Regards,
Satya

by rb scott

I agree with you 100% jereq, also, maybe there should be a fine for all spyware companies, sponsors, and any entity that knows that there software and/or website allows spyware/hijackers to be installed without the owner's permission. For example, if you download and install the weatherbug it is loaded with hijack and spyware software, however, they don't tell you what those additional software installations really are and they should pay a price for that. I know if I was to send out a software product that installed on someones computer and I was able to gain access without their permission, I would be sued. So it is with spyware, hijack, and any other software that is installed secrectly. We should be allowed to bill the ISP and/or the companies that sponsors these aggrevating programs. It will take a loud outcry from the people to make this work. So far it seems to me that most people are content to purchase the spyware remover software and any other software offered. What they don't understand is that they are spending money they really wouldn't have to if they could bill someone for their work cleaning their computers. I like the idea of billing the ISP/company.

by timmycb

I manage a web site for a small, non-profit group. Natually within a few weeks of going live with the site, anything resembling an email address was receiving all the crap we are all seeing. So I added a BIG ugly looking disclaimer right on the front page saying that anyone found sending anything other than legitimate organizational email would be charged a proofreading fee of $500, and if the charge was left unpaid, would be turned over to the local authorities on the grounds of harassment. So far, I have been able to glean enough information from email headers and logs to send official invoices for $500 to two different organizations. Naturally, neither responded. After 30 days, I forwarded the invoices along with a letter of complaint to their ISPs. Both ISPs responded that the accounts had been deactivated and thanked me for my efforts. Now granted, most of the crap we fight with comes from offshore where nothing like this would ever work. For all that, you can argue about IE vs Firefox and Spybot vs AdAware and all the other tricks and programs we have to use to combat this crap. You cannot force someone to use Firefox any more than you can force them to not open a particular email.

This problem cannot be stopped any more that you can stop homeless people on the street begging for spare change. So change to Firefox if you have the option - but be aware that next year you will be in the same boat as IE is in now. Keep current with whatever products you choose to use to try and keep your systems clean. There isn't really much else that can be done.

Well, actually, there is one thing. Next time someone actually catches someone responsible for spewing this crap out on the internet, I'd like to see each and every one of their fingers cut off, publicly - like they cut off the hands of theives in the middle east. If that is the intellectual level of the individuals who propagate this garbage, let's really stop it at the source!!!

by jakeshangout

I clean a lot of computers for friends and famialy and could work up a pretty big bill for the each month myself. I think its would be a great move towards the offensive, instead of the defensive that we're used to.

by jason

These are some of the steps I have taken and have had a very positive success rate with this nuisance.

1. Implement an IT policy ( stating software allowed)
2. Group Policy on software install
3. Browser Security ( I know that is a scare thought)
4. Educate the end-user on how an infection occurs, plus warnings signs of infections.
5. Firefox for now..

by breadtrk

Why are we discussing this on a site that tries to install its own spyware on every page refresh?

ad.doubleclick.net that tries to register itself in my windows system folder. Is that not a tracking cookie?

by breadtrk

Why are we discussing this on a site that tries to install its own spyware on every page refresh?

ad.doubleclick.net that tries to register itself in my windows system folder. Is that not a tracking cookie?

by afhavemann9

I?m tired of it as well but I have pretty good protection that works reasonably well.

First, of course if the AV/Firewall ? I use the ZoneAlarm Suite and turn off ActiveX. I also control what?s allowed in Java.

Next are the spyware blockers, they can help. I use all three major ones.

And last, but not certainly not least, is the host file. I have assembled a host file with over 19000 URL?s and routed them to 127.0.0.1. Every time I get a new POP-UP, Banner or spyware site, it goes in that file. The users have no access to the host file and it is set to R/O by the administrator. I maintain the file on a network server and workstations check (via the login script) for date and size. If there has been an update to the file, the file is copied to the workstation (run as administrator).

Any time the CRC of the host file changes, the low level routines responsible for DNS lookup flush the resolver cache and reload it from the updated host file automatically.

This works quite well. You can also re-route specific IP address with this technique, thwarting those who would use a direct IP address instead of DNS lookup of a URL. IP ranges can also be directly blocked by the firewall when you need to block a whole subnet, as is often the case. Since DNS is an IP stack operation, it can?t be subverted by spyware. Sure, it blocks everything from that address, but so what?

Al

by mr. tinker

I am sick and tired of the garbage. I no longer care that; "...clicking the OK button constitutes a binding agreement..." defense. The general public is generaly uneducated and it should be against the law to take advatage of that knowledge! I think its time to start billing the sleazeball racketeers who are extorting money from the public just to target a machine with ads, toolbars, and their sleazy search engines! I'M WILLING, AND READY! I'm sure alot of us have links to the known sites that list these companies. Lets start a web page and make it publicly known how many techs have legitimatley found "their garbage", the hours to remove it x $50.00 an hour so we all can show how much it's costing (though $50 an hour IS low) the general public. If people complain about it, pay to have it removed, then we should be able to list those identifiable companies publicly, and the time taken to remove their software/garbage and the reasons why the removal took place. (Talk about a major money matrix!)

by ron

I would love to bill for my time in removing spyware from my computer. Just tell me how and I will start sending invoices to the writes.