Discussion Locked

Is anyone else tired of spyware?

0 helpful
395 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

395 replies

by black_eyed_pea

For IT professionals that do not have the luxury of WebSense, you can still be proactive at the workstation level by using my Spyware Prevention Checklist:

Spyware Prevention Checklist

Consider using Firefox for all web browsing unless functionality of business critical web applications require Internet Explorer. If you can use Firefox exclusively, then steps 2, 3, 5-8, & 10-14 still apply.

1. Open Internet Explorer, click Internet Options, click the Security tab, and click Default Level on each Security Zone.
2. Install all Windows Critical Updates.
3. Install and update Spyware Blaster. Remember to click the link to Enable All Protection.
4. If you have Windows XP, use SP2's built-in popup blocker. Otherwise, install a valid popup blocker of your choice.
5. Either manually disable the Messenger service or run GRC's Shoot the Messenger applet.
6. Either manually disable the Universal Plug & Play service or run GRC's Unplug & Pray applet (Windows XP Only).
7. Execute DSOStop2 and click the Protect Internet Explorer button.
8. Execute HTAStop and click the Protect Internet Explorer button (WARNING: Windows XP Only - Will cause problems on Windows 2000).
9. Install IE-Spyad2.
10. Run GRC's SocketLock utility.
11. Install and update JavaCool's Spyware Guard or utilize the built-in spyware detection of MS Antispyware, Spy Sweeper, or Spybot S&D's Tea Timer.
12. Rename the default Windows Hosts file located at %windir%\system32\drivers\etc and place the Gorilla Design HOSTS file in the same directory.
13. Install eDexter to efficiently handle the new HOSTS file.
14. Educate the principal user on Internet best practices.

Utility Download Links:
Ad-Aware - http://www.lavasoftusa.com
CWShredder - http://cwshredder.net/bin/CWSInstall.exe
DSOstop2 - http://www.wilders.org/downloads.htm
eDexter - http://www.pyrenean.com/distribution/dxtr142.exe
Firefox - http://www.mozilla.org/products/firefox/
HijackThis - http://www.spychecker.com/download/download_hijackthis.html
HijackThis Log Analyzer - http://www.hijackthis.de/index.php?%20langselect=english
Hosts File - http://accs-net.com/hosts/get_hosts.html
HTAStop - http://www.wilders.org/downloads.htm
IE-Spyad2 - https://netfiles.uiuc.edu/ehowes/www/res/ie-spyad2.exe
LSPFix Utility - http://www.cexx.org/LSPFix.exe
Microsoft Antispyware Beta - http://www.microsoft.com/downloads/details.aspx?FamilyID=321cd7a2-6a57-4c57-a8bd-dbf62eda9671&displaylang=en&Hash=KX7DK75
Shoot The Messenger - http://www.grc.com/freepopular.htm
Spy Sweeper - http://www.webroot.com/shoppingcart/tryme.php?bjpc=64000&vcode=DT02
SocketLock - http://www.grc.com/freepopular.htm
Spybot Search & Destroy - http://www.safer-networking.org/en/download/
Spyware Blaster - http://www.javacoolsoftware.com/spywareblaster.html
Spyware Guard - http://www.javacoolsoftware.com/sgdownload.html
Unplug & Pray - http://www.grc.com/freepopular.htm

by tlcomp

Please don't flame me, as I haven't read all of the discussion so I don't know if this has already been mentioned. But, I didn't see it mentioned in any of the titles.

For a small business with one connection to the internet, a good firewall will block ALL of the crud. My client's network gets no spam or spyware. Sure, the logfile from the firewall gets big with all of notifications of attacks that it thwarted, but I spend very little time dealing with junk ware.

by black_eyed_pea

My friend . . . I'm incredulous. Share which firewall you're using. If that is your only protection against spam and crapware and it works . . . by all means enlighten us! You could be saving my employer countless millions of dollars a year! Your valuable information could be the means of promotion for all of us - except you.

Yes, I'm ribbing you. Forgive me. I personally think you may be experiencing temporary bliss on an obscure network with incredibly disciplined users.

I administer servers and workstations on a federal government network and I have yet to see a firewall good enough to block "ALL crud" as you described. My experience says you need many layers of security - firewalls, antivirus, cache proxies, URL filters, spam filters, secure routers, workstation templates, GPOs, appropriate use policies, etc. (Phew! The list goes on.)

by tlcomp

I'm sure that you are quite right. Yes, my client's networks are not large, thankfully obscure and the staff are generally well disciplined. At our monthly staff meetings, I have mentioned that we all need to keep up our vigilance in order to stop attacks before they start. And yes, I agree that a layered approach to security is necessary.

Which firewall? That depends on the installation. The original question was regarding a small business, and my response was based on that perspective. Clearly, your networks are a different breed which will require a different solution.

For small business networks, I have found SonicWall to be extremely effective in keeping out the crud. They're not horribly expensive, but they're not a cheap home network model, either. And they're a whole lot cheaper than repeatedly rebuilding machines that have been infected.

I hope that there will be some more discussion. I'd like to find out about other firewalls and the layered approach that we should implement in order to keep our small business networks crud free.

by mostexcellent

kitg6flw,

Yes, I do have to agree with you that it is currently illegal. We should change that. What is needed and needed NOW is an inforcable law that makes spyware/adware illegal, and with painful consequences. Be they financial or other wise. Corporal punishment for propigating/distributing spyware/adware? There is caning in Malaysia. The real point is that the spammers/spyware/adware perps are getting away with it. For them to stop, they must be hurt. Ok, legally. I have spoken with so many people whose systems are so overrun with spyware/adware that the only way to fix it is to wipe the hard drive clean and reload, OS et al. Yes, they loose all of their data.

You will be invited, but it won't be a lynching (too fast!).

by cjfuller_61

You are not the only one who has thought about billing these companys for this. Now these slimy companys are getting worst and the average person would have no clue on how to rid there computers of the problem. I am at the point of suggesting that our goverment step in and make it a real crime with REAL punishment for these offending companys. Enough is enough, if it keeps up peaple are not going to want to use the internet for fear it may cost them money to get there systems fixed. Then where would we be?

by kompudok

I also run IT for a small corporation and have a consulting business. And it is so unnerving to spend so much time eliminating malware from machines. It is insidious and so extremely counter productive. The mere fact that someone thinks that is such a good thing is beyond me. For them it is all about money and there are times when I won't charge for my services because it is not the way I like to make my money. But, I would like for these net advertising companies to foot my bill for services rendered for their intrusive way of business.
So if there is a way to do this, sign me up.

by g.brown

Quote:
"Fix the cause, not the sypmtom
Using other browsers will help until someone find a security hole somewhere and continue their sinister actions. This i see as fixing the symptom while we should be fixing the root cause - people producing spam in the first place."

THE ROOT CAUSE PEOPLE PRODUCING SPAM IN THE FIRST PLACE

Not all spyware/adware is just to get your email address.

Google is adware, and to some extent spyware.

There's also Alexia (which comes bundled with windows).

They record demographic, browser, your searches etc.

What do you think they do with that - they don't sell your email address (well, not that I've seen so far), they make money from spying on what you're doing.

by chasster

Try a fresh install and run Ad-Aware.

What do you find - ALEXIA for virtually every vendor software that is installed.

Start with the vendors and have then remove their spyware.

cheers,
cs

by dusterman

We [ the folks that the public and companies rely on ] need to take a stand .
I personally have several friends who are more than capable of either slowing this down or stopping it all together.
It would seem that we have over thought all of this.
It comes down to a simple solution ......... as a teenager [ very computer smart ] told me .
Write a program that reverse's the flow and in return disables the offending computer.
Ok .... I know it not quite that simple , but with all of the "brain power" we have just in this group , we should be able to come up with a realistic "fix" !
Disabling of the offender's system in not a new concept or method of control , so why are we not using it ?
Me thinks ........... I wonder ..........
who is benefiting from all of this crap ?
Hit them where it hurts ...... not only don't buy their product but demand that they cease and desist immediately.
At a local "coffee" we talked about the fact the several free .... checking services have went to full pay now ~ !
My oh my oh my .......... this stinks of corruption .............period !
After all ..........who's checking the checkers ???????
Now go ahead and tell me how wrong I am ......prove me wrong ...........
If you are a programmer ...... prove to me that a program can't be designed to disable to offending sender ..........
If you design/sell anti-virus software .... prove to me that you aren't complacent in the known glitches and don't ..... pre-design a fix , because every time a new "bug" comes around it makes you money ......... period .
.
I made this same challenge to our "coffee group" and am waiting to see if anyone will pick up the challenge ..........
.
Sorry ... I'm not that smart or I would do it myself [ giving you an answer before you ask ]!
.
I will however help anyone , anywhere and anytime to execute this plan !

by jtw-saintjoehigh

Write a program that reverse's the flow and in return disables the offending computer

if memory is right than the above which you said is hacking. and that is still illegal right? and 2 wrongs don't make a right (but 3 lefts do).

i guess i am just concerned. thats all.

by g.brown

Nah, I don't believe that, they're just going to be pushing for the less intrusive and probably coming up with stuff along the lines of "as long as you don't see it what harms it gonna do, I mean it's just data, if you've got nothing to hide .....", if you don't want them spying on you then you must be some sort of terrorist.

See where this is heading.

We have our freedom and liberties to gain, and also not to be treated like a criminal, but they have money to make, and a massive control complex what do you think they care about?

by jshotsky

I think the problem should be tackled by Microsoft, and handled via the operating system. It is the operating system that they are targeting.

First off, we have learned how to use blacklists and whitelists for our email.The same should be true of anything that attempts to install *anything* on your operating system, or make any changes to it.

The white list would allow all legit companies to run properly. It should be on the internet, so anyone encountering an install, overt or on the sly, would have to pass the whitelist test. Every legit company would happily join this list.

Everything else would have to be manually approved. The OS should keep a record of everything that gets installed, or uninstalled for tracking purposes.

by bywhatnow

YES!!!! And as acomputer repair center we make a lot of money from spyware/malware removal. Yet I am so tired of these programs being put on a computer without the owners knowledge or permission. Yes, I know, you download & install another program, (one that you think you want) and these things "piggy back" into your system, and they will argue that you "agreed" to allow it when you installed the other program. Blah, Blah, Blah, blah!!! Bottom line is this, if we fight back by billing them, will be just be tying up a lot of our (already very limited) resources? Will we find ourselves just constantly sending bills that just get ignored? If we sue them for payment, will that just tie up our paper work, time and or money. So, having said all that, let me pose a question, would it be better if we banded together and brought a class action suite against them? I'm willing to do my part in helping to get rid of spyware and malware.

by tonia5555

I did not think of sending a bill, but I sure sent one of these annoying companies an e-mail telling them that I would NEVER purchase anything from them, and pointing out a spelling error on their site!

by kenmikaze

While Removing IE is a novel Idea, you would still have to worry about IE only sites. We sure do hope that FireFox could work out with that. For you to resolve your spyware issues, and would like to contribute ways on how to troubleshoot those buggers, here's a third-party site which I could suggest... www.hijackthislogs.com

by mmaserati

Let see,

I use Symantec AV Corp version so users cannot mess with the settings, I update virus def's once a night and scan HD nightly on all pc's

I also use Astaro firewall w/intrusion protection, Spam, Virus and surf protection. I get updates all day long from them. I log every packet. Then back it up off site every hour.

All automated.

I have a very low intrusion problem. The worst is having USB on a pc and someone brings in the keychain storage devices.

I use AD to protect drive access.

So do we sue ? - not worth my time. I am from the school of be the black hat for a week and learn to protect yourself. Proactive not reactive.

If you deflect it soon you fall off the radar screen of wanna be hacks. Real hacks will see my protection and turn away fast. Real Fast.

It is that simple. Spenmd the money know your $hit and you will be fine. Oh and do preventative maintence. If it catches you off guard - You were asleep.

by dr dij

Problem is you'll hit innocent sites. So soon as it is known people retaliate with DDos attacks, spammers will put legitimate sites into spam so that they trick you into taking out a valid business or a competitor. Its called 'framing' someone.

by black_eyed_pea

You misunderstand. I am a proponent of user education before, during, and after spyware cleanup. I just always make sure to do it before I leave a user with their cleaned up computer. Doing so leaves a final impression as to the importance of computer security.

by dr dij

Problem is you'll hit innocent sites. So soon as it is known people retaliate with DDos attacks, spammers will put legitimate sites into spam so that they trick you into taking out a valid business or a competitor. Its called 'framing' someone, and you would be the one tricked into being the 'executioner', doing the illegal act.

by the docman

Youe employees may not be able to enter into legal agreements, but if they let the spyware in against your policies, they have personal responsibility for the outcome... Unfortunately, responsibility wouldn't likely lie with spyware producers unless they used deceptive tactics to get your users to install it.

by kathleenmuro

I am all in favor of your suggestion, although I am sure that there is a legal loophole for the spyware/adbot companies. I run a public access lab, and I have wasted way too much time cleaning computers.
I will be installing Deep Freeze, plus I use Spybot and anti-virus software. As a public access center, i am in a constant battle with bots of all kinds, because many of our users are children and virtually all are computer-naive. I can't tell you how many times someone comes to me and says that they computer they are using has a virus based on an adbot message.

by dr dij

Tracking cookies do not execute anything on your system. Why spyware includes them is beyond me. They are simply a way to store persistent data.

Spyware blocker software shows them to scare you.
Many are actually necessary for some websites that you WANT to use.

by dr dij

so why does your company do nothing to prevent it?
there are lots of almost completely effective steps outlined in other posts. And on the upside you'll probably be blocking keyloggers in addition to spyware, the difference being that keyloggers are not by a company but by thieves trying to steal passwords/ pins. As others have pointed out very unlikely to collect. Instead bill user depts at your company and see if mgmt will spring for anti-spyware measures, including personnel time to implement security measures to prevent this. It's more satisfying to whine but more practical to fix your leaky network.

by jtw-saintjoehigh

i absolutly agree with you. billing for the time will do nothing except tell them that we are willing to fight them to the bitter end. but we (my father and i) have been using TTC (Total Traffic Control by http://lightspeedsystems.com) for several months now and have recieved less and less spyware and spam. last week he only recieved 5 spam message out of approx 350 messages which includes his account that intentionally recieves spam to populate the filter. With the right security and filters in place we have had only to worry about the servers themselvs. the local workstations are frozen at his place (faronics deepfreeze enterprise http://faronics.com/html/deepfreeze.asp)call me silly but i am happy at the moment with where we stand. although there is something to be said about my home machine.....oh well

by black_eyed_pea

I absolutely agree that this problem is an international issue. A lot of it is obviously coming from Eastern Europe, Asia, and the Pacific Rim. Consequently, there is very little that domestic authorities can do to combat the problem. Indeed, international law would probably have very little effect.

I suspect there is is an organized crime, perhaps even a terrorist element to some of this. The U.S. Department of Homeland Security agrees as is evident from recent advisories. If this is the case, we would all be hard pressed to figure out how to bill the bad guys, let alone collect money from them. They also do not respond well to domestic or international law.

In addition, the lines between spyware, adware, spam, viruses, Trojans, phishing, etc. has become blurred. Presently, many of those can lead to the others. Most of these irritants are also motivated by money. It follows that the principle targets are computer users in the most prosperous nations.

Fellow IT Professionals, it is going to take much more than some Tech Republic anti-spyware threads to solve these problems. We can share ideas about how to combat them at various points within the ISO stack and that is good . . . but, we're basically a bunch of impotent peons or we wouldn't be visiting this site. The big players are the large tech companies and the governments of the industrialized world, all of which need to cooperate. Due to their power, money, and culpability, Microsoft should be at the forefront of this effort.

by g.brown

Quote:
"Then if their stupid enought to try again an attack program of some sort goes out and takes 'em out."

Basically, what you,re asking for IS actually just a Denial Of Service, a Distributed Denial Of Service just means that there's more than one system trying to crash the PC (which may well just be another infected user like yourself).

So what you ARE ASKING for IS a DOS or DDOS, just by another name.

Lycs tried it, it was called http://www.makelovenotspam.com/

erm, I really don't give a monkeys about a few dots.............

After all, this is about technology, and not a writing contest.

;)

by mc68000

Gee, if Mr. Gates and Mr. Jobs thought that way we'd still be using mainframes and we wouldn't need to be having this conversation. Perhaps a kinder, gentler, way is being called for here. We just ask them nicely to stop and if they don't we won't "take 'em out" we'll just stick a banana up their...tailpipe.

BTW Do you work for Lycos or something? If Lycos can't come up with an inovative way to stop these malcontents no one can?

And just what do you mean by "(which may well just be another infected user like yourself)." How would you know if I'm an infected user???

by dale.oliver

lets find a way to bill back, then we could put financial liens on the corporations, and also the persons house.
Fight back
plus we need to recoup our lost wages by being in the now low paid IT fields

by dr dij

instead of depending on slime to honor a dont call list somehow, how about end users create a "don't visit this website list". It could be created automatically from anti-spyware programs. Any site that edited the registry (cookies do not edit registry) could be added to a list like the anti-spam RBL (realtime Blackhole List).

Any subscribing anti-spyware program could look at this list before letting end user visit the site. settings could either warn the end user that the site is a known source of spyware, or block it totally.

This would have advantage of catching all sites that did bad stuff, including ones that had been hacked. Site owners could look at list as early warning their site had been hacked if they had not added spyware download on purpose.

Disadvantage would be that at least one PC in the world running the subscribing anti-spyware would have to have had the spyware downloaded onto it.

Anti-virus / anti-spyware orgs/ companies could run networks of 'honey-pot' automatically browsing PCs that would both automatically browse websites via search engines and browse to verify reported spyware sites before adding to a 'do not browse to this site' list.

by dr dij

brightmail and several other subscription services do exactly this (spam honeypots).

not all spam sells something, others are virus and phishing; so not buying wont keep these from coming.

by jshee42

As long as there are users to keep messing up their computers, you can come out ahead in the long run. I charge $80 a pop for removing spyware off of people's computers. Sometimes it takes me an hour, sometimes 3, but all I usually do is install Spybot S&D, Ad Aware and do a SFC on Windows and then repair IE. That solved 99.44% of all the users problems. As long as they can surf the internet afterwards and Spybot is blocking sites, I'm a happy camper knowing that one more computer is clean and free of Spyware.

by jamessutton

Damn right !!!!

This sort of thing was done with snail mail where junk mail was sent back to its origin for the sender to Pay for postage. As pointed out if enough people will join in then it can be very effective. I'm in

by kawa29

I completly agree with you.
I'm sure that if they start receiving bills they will may be think twice.....

by g.brown

But I spose it depends how much you been smokin, it could be anything. Hey, why not a tulip. There we go - problem solved.

It's no longer a DOS its a Mc68000ATTACK lol.

Well, I don't KNOW but reading your opinin on it you have obviously been affected by whatever you were infected by at some stage, it was a comment.

Lol, no I don't work for Lycos, if I did, I wouldn't be shouting about a supposed attempted illegal activity, which ended up in them "apparently" being reversed DDOS'ed themselves. The site was down for a few days. So if you want to go and try it yourself, sure, be my guest.

If anyone does have any ideas, they would be interesting. What you have suggested is a DOS, with a popup message (a la spyware itself) pot calling a kettle black.

by lachlann562

Has anyone tried using adblock to filter out these spyware? After you work on it for a bit its pretty easy to block most advertisements, I wonder if there is a way to upload a adblock list to other computers (probably is just haven't tried). Adblock seems to block all traffice from a specific source not just filter it out after its been installed, if we were able to determine which websites these came from the adblock might be able to block the traffic.

Just a thought.

by dfacer

A great idea - so let's sue. Now WHO do we sue...under what law? Who do we serve papers to? Which jurisdiction?
Spyware software developers know that there are no answers to these questions yet, and know that they have to be "caught in the act" before they can be prosecuted. Yes, they are infringing on our privacy - unasked.....but sending them a bill is only asking to be targeted. Hoping you will be paid is like hoping to win back-to-back lotto's.

by ianm777

I like jereg's idea.. However these organisations are paying money to web sites to distribute their stupid spyware which contributes ti the economy of the internet as a whole. Kinda "Catch22"! So maybe it would not be a good idea to get rid of them?

by edjcox

The principle sounds right. But what in practice will happen if you sue or if you bill.

Personally sueing or billing the spamware company for damages or time spent in cleanup or other countermeasure efforts forced upon you will only be effective if you win or if you can bring the billing to legal channels and win your case.

I am all for this avenue as a means of deterrence but I feel that without credible cases and credible precedent all this banter is for not.

We need a landmark case filed at the lowest levels and won and all apeals exhausted with fines and settlement paid and done.

EJ Cox
Sanatoga, PA

by black_eyed_pea

On March 9th, the House Energy and Commerce Committee approved H.R. 29, the SPY ACT, with a unanimous, bipartisan vote of 43-0. You see, they appear to be doing something to combat the problem. It matters not a bit. This is just a symbolic, toothless gesture like the CAN SPAM Act of 2003. Can any of us testify with a straight face that the CAN SPAM Act has worked???

Greg Walden, a Republic Rep. from Oregon who cosponsored H.R. 29, made this absurd statement: ?Our legislation gives consumers back their privacy and puts them in charge of what gets into their computers by making these invasive and destructive practices illegal.? Au contrair, mon frere! It will NOT give consumers back their privacy because it is inherently flawed! As I stated in an earlier post, the United States government cannot impose domestic legislation abroad.

Despite my greatest hopes, the American court system, Congress, the Federal Trade Commission, the Department of Homeland Security, and other federal entities will fail miserably in this endeavor.

I'm a proud American, but I'm also a pragmatist. The government will enact law, punish a few unlucky offenders, and months later everyone will realize the effort bore no long term effect.

ANTISPWARE LEGISLATION NEWS:

http://www.govtrack.us/congress/bill.xpd?bill=h109-29
http://www.bend.com/news/ar_view.php?ar_id=21655

by jordoncomp

Sue the little creeps for the time it takes to put thinggs in order. If an ISP knowingly sponsers such parties then they too should bear part of the blame.

by malo_piny

Consider time spent, economic opportunities lost and likely theft of your secrets, then we need to have these guys fixed.

by malo_piny

Consider time spent, economic opportunities lost and likely theft of your secrets, then we need to have these guys fixed.

I am yet to get a better way to prevent spyware from spreading to machines on my Internet. Firefox works at times, but not always.

by black_eyed_pea

Money gained from advertising is not the only thing that motivates the offenders to write spyware. Theft is equally effective.

When a keylogger is deposited onto an unsuspecting user's PC via drive-by-download or when they are tricked into visiting a phishing site, that user could be in for a world of hurt without spending a dime. For people still using modems, automated porn dialers can quickly soak them for a butt-load of money.

I've personally seen these things happen and can witness that the frequency of these occurences are steadily increasing.

by ebjsa001

I think that jereg has a very good idea. However, the only "bug", would be trying to trace back to where the spyware and for that matter, any virii (plural for virus), are coming from. I am personally tired of having a number of programs on my system(s), that are necessary to try to clean out all of the spyware. Another thing, is if the spyware is coming from Europe or from the Middle and Fast East, how are you going to make the penalties stick? If it possible to charge the people putting the spyware on our computers, I am all for it.

by adrianne2

Why not? Why not pass a law requiring people sending un-solicited mail to pay for the time of recepients to read/remove/sterilize their mail. After all, if you call me on the phone from WorldsEnd, Zimbabyou, you have to pay for the call. So why not pay for their use of my computer? If they don't pay, have the law require that if over 500 people they spammed are unpaid, the goes out of business or to jail.

by techlisa

I don't have time to go through all the posts right now, so forgive me if I'm being redundant. Unfortunately, the users need to JUST SAY NO! to the little "helpful" programs they keep installing. When they accept the EULA, they give your right to bill the company for your time-away! By accepting the EULA they say they understand that they are installing a program that is designed to wreak havoc on a system. (Some EULA's hide this fact in mumbo-jumbo, but many are very straightforward, if only they were read!)

Again, it is a matter of user training. It's too bad a license is not required for computing-with a minimal proficiency required before being issued. (Not really practical since potential threats keep finding new ways in-impossible to cover everything, especially things currently unknown!)

by wrangler1948

I'm all for it. I for one am tired of cleaning out spy/ad ware. And I'm tired of trying to find software to combat the problem.
Let's bill them.

by mike

Think about it.....you are on your pc and the net doing some work and without your knowledge a malicious program leeches it's way into your box and installs itself in your hard drive, all without your knowledge amd with you granting permission for the owner of the program to install itself. Just getting into the box itself is hacking, installing a malicious program is hacking with the intent to disable the owners equipment. Thats what this spyware does, if you don't act swiftly, it can bring a system to a grinding halt in many flavors.....The companies that design and distribute these programs should all be held on hacking and other various charges.

by jthamilton6

To bill companies delivering spyware to my computer is an interesting idea--not that it would bring compensation for my time lost in rooting out the junk, but that it might at least force those companies to lose their time rooting out my return junk. A junk for a junk, if you will.

by blackjack9000

as a Fellow Techie jereq i 110% AGREEE with your address to this Annnoying and Dangerous problem. Why not Bill "these" company's for our long hours of work. Many people who are not tech savvy don't understand what "we" techs go through when spyware crashes & disrupts their systems. Everyday we hear of people saying that their system is down becuase of potential Spyware & Adware problems. I say bill'em; bill the Bastards once and for all. Like the old saying goes all's well that ends well. so lets do it. Come on fellow techies lets unite together and end this Chaos, get back control of the IT world we once had.

by tkinler

Yes, please! Starting a list of known executables and folders can go a long way in the corporate world.

by isocyanates

i agree!! i am so tired of removing this crap! mostly from customers computers! these spam and spyware a**holes, owe me quite a bit of money! i think we should bill them and put them into collections, just like the credit card and cell phone a**holes do to us!!

by stuart_at_oz

Firefox doesn't handle some website very well, so you would have to have IE available for those web site that Firefox doesn't render very well - but then you have to educate DAU's (dumb arse users) how to use Firefox, AND when they need to swap to IE to view a web page properly, AND then explain to them (again & again) why they have to use two browsers (why can't I just use IE????).

Some people have as much ability with computers as I have artistic ability (ie - none!) :-)

Stu

by emeralddruid

I have two antivirus programs on this machine. It seems that todays viruses are smarter than they used to be.

They seem to morph when running a scan. The 1st scanner doesn't see them but the second program zaps them as they morph to avoid detection by the 1st scanner.

by black_eyed_pea

Yes, I have noticed it. We have licensed Symantec Antivirus Corporate on our network, but some of the viruses and Trojans are sneaking right past the newest version with the most recent definitions. When I find an infection, I run AVG, NOD, Trend Micro's House Call, and Panda Antivirus. I have found pests with each of them.

Even then, how can you be sure you caught everything? With serious infections, I have to resort to the undesirable reinstallation of XP.

Keeping more than one antivirus app resident is not always a good idea because they aren't always copascetic with one another. Plus, you have the drag on your CPU time.

I used to preach Symantec products, but I relinquished the habit when I saw how much slipped by it. I'm not so sure any other product is much better these days.

by paquettep

If you hit them in the Wallet the US Spyware vendors will just move overseas out of the reach of the long arm of the law. How can we really fix the problem or prevent our users who fold their arms and play brain dead.

by tkinler

Can you post a copy of what the text file says? Having a file like that on each computer at least gives you a starting point for any legal action you might take in the future.

by stan20

"Use of this computer implies acceptence of the following terms:

1. CPU time, memory and disk storage are considered by the owner of this computer to be valuable resources. The owner may, at his sole discretion, hold any user liable for any charges that user may incur at the following rates:
CPU Time - $1000/hour or any part of an hour"

.....etc (I just made up rates for different resources, higher than any sane person would agree to pay)

"2. Failure to read these terms does not absolve any user from these terms.

3. Time spent removing unwanted software and/or files will be billed at a rate of $250/hour.

4. Payment is due at the time at the time the usage occurs.

5. Any and all legal meaans of collection will be pursued."

-------------------------
This is not aimed at any legitimate uses, ads, etc. Its aimed at those companies that install crap on my network without my knowledge or consent. Some of the newer adware actually opens backdoors into your system, so that their content can be sent later. I think there is evidence that malicious hackers, etc. have found ways to use that to really damage systems.

by jakester

Here's my nickels worth on this subject.

I too agree with jereg's idea to hit them back where it hurts. And only by legal means would this put the brakes to those spammers.

Everyone participating could be running a software where one could identify and capture the source address of these adwares and spywares.

Many of these *wares also use other participating websites...etc, to spread and infest your computers. I'm not a lawyer, but in my books, the one holding the bag is as guilty as the one that stole the money that's in the bag.

This log would then be filed and sent to an online server where these *ware entries would be stored onto a database. A legal copmplaint and warning letter would then be emailed to those spammers and participating websites, on behalf of those members.

The spammers would be made responsible to supply and/or provide instructions to remove those *wares from one's computer.

Should the spamming persist after a specified period of time as addressed in the complaint, the members could then file a lawsuit against those spammers and their participating websites.

Dammages and $$$ could be determined by the number of *wares each members captured.

There might be enough in the lawsuit pot to hire legal representation to pursue this all the way to the courts.

by kwgoad

I think hitting them with a bill would make an impact, but if you find one of them and make an example out of them like the IRS it would change their thinking. A slap on the hand doesn't intimidate people any more. People are setting around so cushy happy because they've got the liberal judges making things easy on them - not to mention the immoral, Homo-loving "Supreme? Court who are managing to pull this country into a pit called hell. We need more people who will do what is needed to straighten things out.

by sww

Spyware relies on things like "Active-X" in order to turn IE into a gateway to hell. Firefox doesn't use active-x, so it's immune to those types of exploits. Also, IE is tightly woven into Windows - an integral element of it, in fact. There are thousands of known and yet undiscovered pathways into your OS. Firefox doesn't. It's that simple. None of the PC's in our organization which use Firefox have a problem. None.
I'd love a movie where the superhero hunts down spy-jackers & spammers and gives them each a violent, painful death. Pass the popcorn.

by ckarmadillo

Yes I would love to particapate. Just let me know what I can do. Send emails to anyone-but you would need to give me the emails to send them to. Thank you for asking me to particapate.

by pbrownlee

We should insist as consumers, that an operating system be lock down tight with Browsers for the Web. Before it is marketed or purchased.
If you look at all the patches for supposedly ready for market O.S.s by M$ then you take into account the recalcetrent attitudes of the Anti Virus people. That Spyware is not a Virrus and other malware is just some other Company's problem.
As a consumer I just don't see why, when I buy an O.S., that I have to go and buy several more third party software programs from other vendors to protect my system and it's information from malware that is probably being spread around by the very same programmers and third party vendors.
M$ better get this fixed as it is the strongest reason to look elsewhere next time I need an O.S.

by fettered

I foresee the value of such an endeavor as adding to validation of or legal justification of a class action suite against a specific spam king to establish a precedence.

by myzeuz2001

I think billing them would be a start, but, what if that ad was a spoof..? and there isn't really a company that with that name, or what's worst someone eventually made an ad who has the same name of a real company, what would happen then is that billing them would be a small start on figuring out which is which.

Even you had the chance to capture their IP or any trace route figures on their computer, it would not be easy...

the idea is good, and we all need to contribute a lot of them, learn from them as they learn from us, we're on the defense side, which they learn from our mistakes... but if we could not possibly advertise what our plans, then i think we could compile our ideas and execute them without them knowing... i think it would be a fairly good start.

by dragonlen

H%^* did this question become some advertisement for firefox. I thought the idea was brilliant right up until the first reply shot right to a firefox promo by obvious fans. You are right. Maybe taking the owners of these sites to small claims court will make them wake up and think twice. As far as firefox a good program but not the solution, plain and simple!

by gunnar klevedal

In what way does spyware differ from malware like worms, trojans and viruses?

I have worked in a locked down environment, with ordinary user rights for several years. We get patches and virus definitions over the network, and the firewall is transparent to us. Our messaging system blocks executable attachments.

I will start with internet at home this summer, but I have to resize the partitions on my new PC first, and create some new ones.

Likewise I'd like to study the options of IE6SP1, and see what I can block.

I also have to install SP2 of WinXPh

Tribute to John Socha, beacon in the mist

by black_eyed_pea

Perform a Google search for "Spyware FAQ". You'll find out everything you ever wanted to know about malware . . . which is a catchall term for the pests you mentioned. I've also heard the terms crapware and trashware.

Basically, the spyware encompasses a whole range of software that has unwanted effects on your computer . . . one of which is to spy on you.

Viruses simply replicate themselves; that is the delineating factor.

A Trojan is a destructive program that masquerades as a benign application. In the pure sense of the term, it does not replicate.

You didn't mention parasites, worms, keyloggers, dialers, snakes, adware, or hijackers - all of these have been referred to as spyware. I won't argue the point. They are all pests that need to be eradicated.

Here are some typical symptoms of spyware:

1. Your usual homepage is changed and you have no idea why.
2. An unexpected toolbar appears in Internet Explorer and you don't know how it got there.
3. New shortcuts appear on your desktop or your task bar, or even your system tray that you didn't put there.
4. New entries appear in your Favorites folder that you didn't put there.
5. Your computer starts acting sluggish and slow (this could be from a number of reasons however).
6.Excessive popup windows that you are unable to stop or close.
7. Excessive CPU usage. Each bit of malware has its own program, and, thus uses resources.
8. Every time you perform a search, you are redirected to the same unusual, unknown website
9. There is a new program, in the add/remove section of your Control Panel
10. Your antivirus is mysteriously turned off.
13. You are unable to access any of these: Task Manager, regedit, MSConfig. They just pop up, and disappear.

by rw.griffin

I think your idea is great, but how would you set it up for all the junk companies which I have to clean off!

by amvx86

Jereg,

I have been an IT professional since i was about the age of 17. I know what the risks are for spyware, i know what these scum do and how they propagate. Unfortunately, only a fraction of users know how to properly protect themselves against such scumware.

I myself spend hours upon hours a day cleaning garbage out of clients computers. If that's not enough, at the end of the week my cell inbox is blown up yet again, for complaints of spyware. Not only does this create more work, it also puts my credibility in doubt, whereas the customers think i don't properly handle the job.

I have written an article based on IE hardening, which could also be applied across to Mozilla, Netscape, Firefox and the like. The problem lays on the end-users (mostly). Because most end-users appreciate the simple things (playing online games) activex controls and java scripts can prompt to download garbage that is not needed.

In essence, i would begin to just harden the browser that the client is using. A little sacrifice never hurt anyone. As for your proposal to actually "bill" these companies probably wont stand to well. Most websites if you read their "terms and conditions" blatantly state that they will be adding garbage to your system. It's like the End-User License Agreements. No one ever reads them. On top of which, if you never collect your money, you will have to hire an attorney to probably go after them. Which, the attorney may reply to you "Do you have proof that company X has done this to your system?" Which also causes a greater loss of time, filling out paper work and creating an abuse report.

My advise to you, and to the other IT professionals out there (who run windows) Microsoft has created a nice little tool, hit up: http://support.microsoft.com and search for "Spyware Beta." Or just "Spyware." See what pops up. If you have trouble getting the application, e-mail me. I will be glad to send it over.

by tkinler

This is a great starting point. If we all used a similar file and followed up by actually billing and filing lawsuits or mechanics leins, and posting the companies names in a public forum... etc.

I am thinking about a website that tracks the names and addresses of companies that produce these programs, as well as the companies that buy them. Anybody interested?

by doyle

I'm with you jereg. @$50/hr, and most spyware takes @ least 1 hr time to remove, would pad my pocket book well. Been on one computer for four days, 3hrs day getting rid of all I could find on about:blank which sets IExplorer to their home page.
At end of each day, computer ran clean with same result that when I got back to work next day, the problem beat me there.
Would not have to worry about gas prices with this kind of extra income.
put me on the list for billing.
thanks for asking,
jthedo

by mikercol

I not quite sure what your comment about IE or MS has to do with my post?

You are right elimination of spyware and associated spam would reduce bandwidth loads. I doubt it could be done without a significant expenditure of time and money for someone.

If your thinking is, the savings in bandwidth use would offset the cost of producing that savings, I would be very suprised if that proved to be true.

by jclulow

Why submit a bill you know they will not pay... Simply fight fire with fire....An eye for an eye, a spam for a spam, a hack attack for a hack attack... They can't'spam you if they are denied service through the same tactics they imploy... I say to all the programmers, tech support people and tech guru's, find the spammers and hackers and beat em at their own game...They are only as smart at blocking as their programmers are, but no one is as smart as all of us, soooo... Charge!!! and let them know we are out there and tired of them and will fight fire with fire...Create a generic popup and spyware that can be down loaded and sent to each spammer by each one of us, the same message from all of us so they KNOW that we have targeted them for reprisal...Let them know that they are on the hit list of EVERY company tech out there and that their company and / or service has been noted as a disreputable company and that this will affect their bottom line $$.

Develop a list of advertisers and companies that spam people and companies, supply this to the appropriate government agencies on a regular basis until they get tired of receiving our complaints and then just maybe, they will do something about the legalities of spamming.

Develop a program that can be installed on company and home computers that will automatically capture, list, then notify the government of the spammers.

Walk loudly and carry a gargantuan stick, eventually the government will here us!!

by g.brown

OK, where do you get your figures from?

Why is it that all you seem to be doing is blaming other people...

And I thought most spam originated from the US.

Check your figures before you start blaming other countries:

http://www.spamhaus.org/statistics.lasso

Quote:

1 United States 2459
2 China 644
3 South Korea 380
4 Brazil 178
5 Russia 174
6 Taiwan 146
7 Canada 132
8 Japan 130
9 Argentina 98
10 United Kingdom 94

IT professionals should tell the REALITY, not SCAREMONGER with half-truths.

by mwradio

At this time Michigan Legislature is attempting to craft a law against spyware and trojans. Lets hope it works and someone uses it against these bas*****!

by snafu-cf

If enough companies got together and filed a class action suit [shades of the Republicans,] most spy ware would probably stop with the first suit won. Bills will just be ignored.

by mdchrzanowski

Evidently there is no advantage to the powers that be to stop spam or spyware the way there is to stop music downloads.

Can you say re-election

by saintjohnhawke

I would say the difference between the two has more to do with the amount of pressure put on the 'powers that be' by the parties concerned.

If the userbase united and started harassing the government about spyware it's likely there would be more action on that front.

The liklihood of such a thing actually occuring to the same degree as the RIAA pressures is rather implausible though.

by fmcgowan

If so, the "answer" would seem to include bringing those IE specific legacy apps into standards compliance during routine maintenance. This would not be a quick fix; it would require a policy change in many organizations.

Even without spyware, you *may* want to make your apps comply with standards - real ones rather than the "de facto" kind the industry loves so well - to decrease your dependence on a single vendor.

by mwradio

You often already have that, but as I found out the hard way ONCE, Yes means Yes AND No means Yes when you click those buttons. My favorite no buttons? Ask before running Active-x and the good old Alt+F4, Works every time for me. Now if I could just teach ALL the users to do it! Ad-Mal-Spyware free for over a year now. By the way, I don't personally allow Alexa nor use IE (I'm spying on you) version 6. I stuck with 5.5. It works for me with a little help from Norton Anti-virus!

by mdchrzanowski

bank robbers, drug dealers, mercenaries, are all just doing their jobs. Jobs, by the way, intrude on society against it's will. 'Callin' it your job ole' hoss sure don't make it right" (thanks john)

by rforster

It is very time consuming running adaware, or worse cleaning the hard drive completly. I think also to bill these people. If I get ahold of an address to bill them at, I would be more than happy to send it to them.

by tlath1972

If you have no problem with spyware at your house then stay in your house because some of the world outside of your house is clueless. Whoever you are giving support issues for, you should give them a clue and let them know how you keep it out of your house. Otherwise you are just going keep feeling pity for yourself. It's not going to stop itself you need to find a solution not just an answer to a quick fix.

ruble ruble ruble time to get back to work