Discussion Locked

Is anyone else tired of spyware?

0 helpful
395 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

395 replies

by mcecen

Absolutely agree with billing the companies for time spent cleaning their resource hogging, system cripling junkware/spyware. If the state governments can claim monies from tobacco companies for treating patients harm done by their product(s, why not individuals or the businesses claim money from spyware companies for time spent on cleaning their junk.

Mike C.
New Jersey

by joe90fluke

It is time for the governements to put on their pants.
I think if us the Networks Managers we put a lot of pressure on the governements and force them to write a law in that sense: It would be a criminal act to install a software or to make any changes on a remote computer without the agreement of the computer user/owner.

They should pursue these companies that wrote all the Data Mining engines and the spywares after the law passes. They should persue as well the virus writters and raise examplary punishement for the firsts ones they would catch, so the rest
of the community who write the adverse code will have to think twice before creating a new virus.

Radical? YES !! When you want to eradicate something as bad as that you don't have the choice, you have to be radical.

So, for that purpose governments be radical !!

by acantu

Jereg,

It really depends on who you work for. At my workplace we have resticted, WinXP, the users on their desktop computers. This has cut down to zero the time spent cleaning up spyware; because they can't download anything!

We have a computer notebook program for students and they are constantly downloading junk off the net and scrogging their notebooks. What we do is re-image their notebooks which takes 45min and we do not back-up their files! Therefore, it takes only a couple of times and they learn their lesson.

Trying to bill these off shore spammers will get nowhere. It would have to go to court if you wanted to succeed and who has the time or money.

An email Spam filter and restricted accounts is the way to go.

by mcornejo_1

Re-imaging a students system is great but still somewhat time consuming (45 minutes). For student computers we use an excellent program called Deep Freeze (http://www.faronics.com/html/deepfreeze.asp). Once you have the image you want you "Freeze" it. After that, every time the system is rebooted it is taken back to that original image automatically. When the system is setup properly the first time you don't have to worry about it until you find something you want to add then, with the administrator password you set up you, "Thaw" it, install the additions and "Freeze" it again. It provides an "unfrozen" extra drive for files like docs that need to be saved but wont allow any new programs to stay on the system. There are a number of things I can write about in here but you're better off checking out the website yourself. Good luck with the continuous war on spyware.

by acantu

Mike,

We use deep freeze in the labs but it would be a real battle if we were to put it on the notebooks.

When we started the notebook program spyware was almost non-existant, therefore no forethought about using deep freeze, but having to retro the program now would cause the students to have a fit not to mention cost. And we can't restrict them because of the constant need to load class related software.

My next solution is to start charging the repeat offendors. I'm currently working on this proposal to push up the ladder.
Thanks for the tip!

by talkin

I read your article and solution, my belief is that prevention rather than a cure is the answer.
Xp sp 2 goes a long way to halt pop ups.
Spysweeper (by webroot) an excellent program, prevents future hijacking of 'your' home page, and regular scanning removes all known adware/spyware.
This program like antivirus programs are only good as if you update definitions daily/ biweekly. Spysweeper starts up when you boot your computer so it is monitoring all the time.

And finally computer users must realize that when 'they' accept a download/install, 'they' must know EXACTLY what 'they' are downloading first, before they accept. This by far will prevent future problems. When In Doubt Leave Out.
Only download/install from known companies.
Use Google, type in the name of the download and type in the word spyware after it and read.
PREVENTION IS BETTER THAN THE CURE.

by g.brown

This is getting hilarious, and I think it's gonna be my last post on this subject as there are just too many people who don't bother to think and just repeat some old MS tosh.

Wouldn't you class google as Adware/Spyware?

http://www.google-watch.org/bigbro.html
Quote:
"The nine points we raised in connection with this nomination necessarily focused on privacy issues:

1. Google's immortal cookie:
Google was the first search engine to use a cookie that expires in 2038. This was at a time when federal websites were prohibited from using persistent cookies altogether. Now it's years later, and immortal cookies are commonplace among search engines; Google set the standard because no one bothered to challenge them. This cookie places a unique ID number on your hard disk. Anytime you land on a Google page, you get a Google cookie if you don't already have one. If you have one, they read and record your unique ID number.

2. Google records everything they can:
For all searches they record the cookie ID, your Internet IP address, the time and date, your search terms, and your browser configuration. Increasingly, Google is customizing results based on your IP number. This is referred to in the industry as "IP delivery based on geolocation."

3. Google retains all data indefinitely:
Google has no data retention policies. There is evidence that they are able to easily access all the user information they collect and save.

4. Google won't say why they need this data:
Inquiries to Google about their privacy policies are ignored. When the New York Times (2002-11-28) asked Sergey Brin about whether Google ever gets subpoenaed for this information, he had no comment.

5. Google hires spooks:
Matt Cutts, a key Google engineer, used to work for the National Security Agency. Google wants to hire more people with security clearances, so that they can peddle their corporate assets to the spooks in Washington.

6. Google's toolbar is spyware:
With the advanced features enabled, Google's free toolbar for Explorer phones home with every page you surf, and yes, it reads your cookie too. Their privacy policy confesses this, but that's only because Alexa lost a class-action lawsuit when their toolbar did the same thing, and their privacy policy failed to explain this. Worse yet, Google's toolbar updates to new versions quietly, and without asking. This means that if you have the toolbar installed, Google essentially has complete access to your hard disk every time you connect to Google (which is many times a day). Most software vendors, and even Microsoft, ask if you'd like an updated version. But not Google. Any software that updates automatically presents a massive security risk.

7. Google's cache copy is illegal:
Judging from Ninth Circuit precedent on the application of U.S. copyright laws to the Internet, Google's cache copy appears to be illegal. The only way a webmaster can avoid having his site cached on Google is to put a "noarchive" meta in the header of every page on his site. Surfers like the cache, but webmasters don't. Many webmasters have deleted questionable material from their sites, only to discover later that the problem pages live merrily on in Google's cache. The cache copy should be "opt-in" for webmasters, not "opt-out."

8. Google is not your friend:
By now Google enjoys a 75 percent monopoly for all external referrals to most websites. Webmasters cannot avoid seeking Google's approval these days, assuming they want to increase traffic to their site. If they try to take advantage of some of the known weaknesses in Google's semi-secret algorithms, they may find themselves penalized by Google, and their traffic disappears. There are no detailed, published standards issued by Google, and there is no appeal process for penalized sites. Google is completely unaccountable. Most of the time Google doesn't even answer email from webmasters.

9. Google is a privacy time bomb:
With 200 million searches per day, most from outside the U.S., Google amounts to a privacy disaster waiting to happen. Those newly-commissioned data-mining bureaucrats in Washington can only dream about the sort of slick efficiency that Google has already achieved. "

by talkin

Your response to google and the information you provided is alarming, and I was not aware.

I have noticed that when I do a Trace on an email sender, I notice 9 out of 10 emails go through a US military address, I have often wondered why.

I clean infected computers, and when I find a situation that I am puzzled on, I go to google and do research.
I would be grateful if you would let me know if you have a better web site that I can do my research on. thanking you in advance. t_alkin@

by compguy

All of the examples I have seen of this supposed "flaw" are situations where the user goes to a web site with Firefox, is presented with a warning asking whether or not to allow a Java applet to run, and then the malware is installed by the Java applet.

This has ABSOLUTELY NOTHING to do with Firefox. Firefox correctly presents you with a warning asking whether or not you want the Java code to run. Once you've allowed the JRE to run the code, Firefox is out of the picture.

In this case, it's a user issue. If a popup comes up and asks if you trust the software from "Integrated Search Technologies," it's your own darn fault if you allow the applet to be installed.

by g.brown

That's the only one I've seen too.

You see in FF you get the option not to install - in IE you don't. Unless you're up on your security then this is the inherent problem with IE.

Why do you think that they're bringing out IE7?

I figure that what MS was trying to do was to wait until they release their next OS and only ship it with that.

But now that Mozilla/FF is getting many more users, MS have decided to do something about it.

Do you think that if FF wasn't available they would have bothered?

I don't think so, it would be like the firewall etc that you can't get for windows 2000, only XP.

If they had it their way, you'd have to upgrade to the next OS to get this.

Call me cynical but it's plain as the nose on my face.

by g.brown

I wish I'd have brought that up earlier ... but I blocked it quite a while ago, and it didn't even come to mind.

Another reason why I like FireFox :)

Now ... if all these "clever" people start sueing TechRepublic wouldn't that be funny.

I doub't they'll get to the real issue, which is buggy, insecure software.

Do you really think these people would try and sue MS, or TR, they know they'd lose. That's why they're gonna pick on the smaller companies rather than the larger ones, it's a bit poor really aint it. Especially for supposedly technical people. They seem more like lawyers than they do techies.

by eriksblues

Just finished reading all these posts. Nice idea but unrealistic in terms of being able to collect.Read the post about the advisory committee, had me laughing in frustration. Have done complete reinstalls...reactive with Microsoft and all other software vendors that require it...fun stuff. IE is not going to disappear....how many consumers buy it everyday with their new computer? Why not fight fire with fire ... write a program that puts data miners back to the system that invades yours? That way you collect info on the perps! In-house net is closed, no internet and utilized for graphics production. All email and internet access comes through another system set up for that, and have used all the products mentioned in these posts. Spyware still manages to get through, but on a very limited basis. Hitting them in the wallet sounds good....but I don't have the time to wait on collecting. How long does it take an insurance company to fight off a claim they don't want to pay? Fight fire with fire...ping them back!

by breadtrk

My network is a government network. Like the thread starter has stated, Firefox breaks my applications so it is simply not an option.

I'm all for spamming the spammers, but ANY reply to them just verifies your address and they sell it to all of their spamming and spyware buddies.

by bajarip

A definitive technique engine needs to be set up to do this with minimal effort. But then again, the 'scabbers' will latch onto in too.
PB

by clarolh

Spyware is terrible. But if you think of it. Spyware is the reason most computer techs have jobs. I'd jus let it be and stay on the defense. If anyone should fight it. It should be the end-user themselves.

by awfernald

If we get people from all over the country submitting claims at the same time, then the companies will end up having to be in court on or about the same day in multiple locations, thus requiring a lot more resources.

by ripvan

Have the government study this? Get real. As long as the people who do this grease the right palms, you will get NOTHING.

Listen to the arguments already. Most claim that the customers are presented with a screen to which they must agree to the installation of whatever innocuous trash they are luring the "customer" with, PLUS the rights to install whatever garbage the scavengers want to install at any time. (This, obviously, does not cover the "drive-by" installations.) Still, many of the self-righteous jackals DO have the law on their side.

And you want people who (for the most part) cannot operate a computer as well as your dumbest user to make legislation on this matter? No offense, but instead of billing the companies or coming up with some "strategy", you would be better off taking up a collection among people who are pissed off, and bribing some key players in government. It is faster, more direct and MUCH more effective. (Sorry, it is Monday and the subject is government. No optimism...)

by steve

Bill the MF'ers. They cause more problems than ever and they think they are real cool with that shit. I am sick and tired of what they do and all to make a buck. Its time to turn the tables on these "DUDES"
Bill them for the time and hassles that they create.

by jotom102000

I think they should be lined up and shot.Thats my opinion.But we all know that wont happen so yes i think they should be charged an inflated rate.What buisness is it of theres of where i go or who i visit.Its invasion of privacey period and that is against federal law and the constitution.I say jump on the wagon for a class action suit involving these companies and the feds to force them into action.Its simple hit them in there pockets afterall they are hitting us in ours.Board of directors do not like to lose cash and niether do we.

by seeker532

It's probably just my computer but something is screwing up Firefox and I don't have much free time to research through websites and faqs to find the answer. With that last "big" upgrade my right click went bye-bye. I could still highlight and edit, copy and paste something I wanted to keep for reference. Last week I upgraded several extensions and now my highlight went bye-bye and also select-all. I am forced to open IE to save anything.
Firefox has gone backwardsd for me. I don't see how it can hope to compete with IE the way it's going.
Now I gotta figure out how to make IE my default again. I gotta go. Spent too much time on this.

by deathtoliberalism

You probably are using mouse gestures extension - this will cause your right-click to be disabled until you press ctrl or shift. You probably are also using auto copy extension - upon hightlighting, it copies the text to clipboard, and then removes the highlighting. In some ways Internet explorer has just dumbed us down. These are things you chose to install, don't blame it on Firefox. Configure or remove them.

by g.brown

I bet you've probably downloaded Auto Copy without bothering to read what it does.

Well, it's great, when you highlight something it automatically copies it to clipboard and then deselects it (like trillian).

Don't worry, it got me confused for a bit when I first used it, but I use it all the time now, as all I need to do is highlight, it just removes 2 extra steps ... copy and deselect :)

Check the bottom right of your screen for something that says "Auto Copy ENABLED".

If you don't like it .. disable it.

Or just uninstall all the plugins you downloaded if you don't unerstand how they work.

Tools -> Extensions -> Uninstall what you don't like.

by rc1

Since you do not know how to reset IE as your default browser, you are incapable of understanding the dangers of using IE and the advantages and disadvantages of each product.

I have not used iE for last 3 years, I use both Opera (for speed, security) and Firefox (ease of use, security).

I have spent far to much time removing trojans brought in under MS's security free (as in no security) activex. My desktop belongs to me, I paid for it and I will not surrender control to MS and its licensees.

by cptnemo2

I would be in favor of a class-action suit against the marketers of adware and pop-ups. We sue tobacco companies don't we...

by cagedmonkey

I agree the MS Anti-spyware is a fairly decent product for a beta version. I like many other admins can't wait till there's a enterprise version so I don't have to visit each desktop to deploy this sucker.

I would not put it past MS to eventually bundle this into a service pack.

We generally deploy our desktops with Spybot and MS Anti-spyware now. The combo of the 2 seems to catch most of the stuff.

Personally I would rather be doing more productive admin stuff than having to deal with this crap, but such is the vein of following the MS route for employment.

by teacherbb

I found that MS Antispyware was causing the cpu to freeze if I had Norton's running. In fact, I did not realize MS antispyware was installed until my cpu's started freezing. I disabled Norton's and it stopped. So who do we trust?

by go_figure

I work in User Services for a university, we do desktop support. Most of our trouble tickets are for spyware these days, particularly the ones that create network connections like new.net and ones that run persistently, like wintools and marketscore. These stop our clients from using SCTBanner and running normal programs. The lost hours to these spyware is unimagineable. We are not the only university having these problems. Someone should start a class action lawsuit against all the spyware makers and stop this nonsense. I wouldn't buy anything from any business that causes popups, popunders, or installs spyware on my machine anyway and am convincing others that they shouldn't either. The going rate for working on a computer in this area is $75 an hour, regardless of the problem, so until individuals become intolerant of having to pay to have their computers cleaned there won't be a solution.

by mr_breeze

I like the idea of billing them... the big question is will they pay. I believe we need the operating system designers to get involved. We also need need Yes or No button before allowing them to install their slimy Software on our PCs.

by carlos.garcia.marcano

I don't know if the proposed measure will work in every case (not all spam comes from the US or countries where that is a felony), bet something is for sure, the only way to have spamers (and other internet pests) to retreat is hit them in their pockets, like class action sue by affected personal or enterprise users of Internet.

Meanwhile, lets keep fighting by reporting to abuse@domain.com of the ISP providers, using tools to blockthem out, be careful with Sites that ask for our e-mail addresses in orther for us to get information. Avoid using distribution lists and/or forwarding outside of the Intranet, and, if necessary, use bcc.

by starderup

It costs you money to remove this junk. Who should foot the bill? The victim or the perp?
It is like a car, that after you use it, suddenly, it drives itself 50 miles away and parks in front of a fire hydrant and gets towed.
You have to search for it, go get it, and you are denied the use of it until you jump through all the hoops.
Spyware/Spammers are getting away with criminal use of your computer until we get tough with them.

by sean_n

I have read many of the posts here and the ideas go from each end of the specturm (I particularly like the cutting off of the fingers myself) but with most of this garbage created and distributed from outside the US until we have a global solution and department that takes care of it. Sadly to say we all know it will never end. One of the posts linked in an article about how the former Gator exec who is now on the homeland security board, that scares me. What is one of the ebiggest producers of this garrbage who is being sued left and right and was able to get so many users to put that peice of crap on thier systems(I know I found it on mine once and I never signed up for any of it)doing on the board of protecting Our privacy with homeland security? Lets face he knows how to get information from the vast majority of non savvy users.

I will start ramble here into a political and conspiracy theorist rant but isnt that what this board is for. Hearing eachothers opinion, concerns and feeling about what and how security and usages of our time and money is spent when it comes to our companies systems and our own personal ones.

There are many programs that go thru and clean the systems and they will get better with time, but will always be a race with the bad guys winning until things like some of the ideas in the posts are put in place and realy followed thru with. But, without it being done on a global scale where each country is held accountable, especialy the ones that allow this to happen with out checks then this problem will never end. We may be able to stop it in the US, in the UK and Canada. But the real offenders are not even based in these countries, and when they are stopped here they will just move to a country that will not hold them accountable.

So to do this we need the entire global user community to band togather. I am sure there are 10s of thousands that are willing in each and every place in the world with a PC and a Browser that keeps getting jacked. And the long list of crap that Adware and Spyware keeps cleaning off thier systems.

But maybe I am just thinking big brother is the one hosting all this so they know exactly what we are doing when we are doing it and why.

by dnickason

I could use the extra income. I could probably retire from the extra income as a matter of fact. I however think a bit more maliciously. I would like a way to reply to them with spyware from about 200 other companies that send it out. Spread the happiness

by starderup

By cutting off their digits...
Funny, but I don't know....
Like the joke:
What do you call someone in the Middle East with no arms?
A repeat offender....

by jaytmoon

The only way to slow down or stop these schmucks is to create laws that encompase global use standards (perhaps through the UN). OK, within the US, the Congress COULD TRY to create laws making the removal of this junk a billable service and the covert installation of the same a privacy violation (FBI rules apply there). The problem there lies within the legislative branch itself (they have no clue whats going on), and if they try to make some laws, the fools will likely water it down anyway.

by starderup

many users need to be able to install software, so it isn't a complete answer.
SA's can block some of the sites using access lists, and SP2's firewall plus other anti spyware utilities in combination might reduce the problem temporarily, but the bottom line is, someone is trying to use the computer and connection YOU are paying for to make money for themselves.
This is no different than the telephone solicitors using YOUR phone and YOUR phone account to call you during dinner to sell you something you don't want.
Don't buy anything you see as a result of a pop-up ad or SPAM, first of all, and secondly, make those responsible for the problem bear the cost.

by deathtoliberalism

Nobody said that.
The parent of my post was insinuating that SPAM has nothing to do with SPYWARE. They are closely tied.

by starderup

IE can be surgically removed from Window$, but the best way is to dump all M$ entirely.
I don't use it unless I am forced to, and that is only because of my job.
I can't say too much bad about M$. If it weren't for supporting their crummy software, I'd be out of a job.

by oldtechie

I've found that bigfix provides the updates in a timely manner, lets you vet and install the ones that you want, and ignore those you don't. www.bigfix.com, and, it's a freebie! They also offer enterprise solutions.

by mcornejo_1

Acantu,

Thanks for the "caveat" regarding the notebooks. We too utilize Deep Freeze in our labs but recently purchased notebooks for a kind of "Virtual Classroom" scenario that our Chancellor decided to try. We are starting with a small number to see how well it works but haven't come to a final decision on the various software we will need currently and in the future. Your information gives us something else to consider. Thanks again!

by bbarlo01

Great idea, as far as I'm concerned spyware is no different than someone painting graffiti on your front door. It's destuction of personal property.

Babarlow

by starderup

But you have to configure it manually.
XP is very much like W2K. They made some things easier, and of course, made it look as different as they could (otherwise, why spend $200 for an upgrade?), but under the hood, the improvements were largely inconsequential.

by bpist

First of all you can bash Microsoft if you like that is not the real problem. You can suggest Firefox but that is not a 100% fix all solution. The problem is these slimey rats that are just plain con artists and crooks. They need to pay for thier actions. How do you educate users on every way they can be fooled into installing trash on thier system. Especially when it changes daily. I have even verified that some infections come through the regular banner ads that appear in your browsers or pushed out by visiting a sites home page. I would love to see them pay. I would go so far as to have a lawyer who wants to make some cash start a class action suit against these people. I am sure there is one out there somewhere. I have spent numerous hours repairing corporate, education and home users computers because of this. I have also been infected on my own even when using multiple vendors products that claim to block or clean this. As for Microsoft's Antispyware ( formerly Giant) it does not work on WIndows 98 which there are still has many users.

by starderup

The tactic they use of embedding consent into a small type disclaimer buried in a EULA could be used by us legitimate users as well.
If you install any software on my computer, you agree to my Terms of Service, which include ridiculously high rates.
I like it.

by mc68000

Many of you said "hit 'em where it hurts - in the pocketbook" and I agree with all that, but I like the alien who said "lets fight fire with fire". That's the only way to smoke out these detestable sneaks. But not with DDOS attacks, which will cripple the ISP's and gobble up all the bandwidth. I say one of you geniuses out there build a little "back at ya" program that detects, denies and warns the scum___s with something like "NO ADMITTANCE! DO NOT ENTER - BAD DOG! YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED. ENTER AGAIN AT YOUR OWN RISK! IGNORE THIS WARNING AND YOU WILL GO DOWN!!! Then if their stupid enought to try again an attack program of some sort goes out and takes 'em out. Come on already! I know we're at least as smart as they are. Of course we'll need to make sure we're armored to the teeth before we proceed with our offensive, or rather defensive. But, admit it people, this is WAR!! War on our very time and money. Not to mention the emotional and psychlogical pain and suffering (You think I'm kidding, don't ya? Well just look at this thread, I'd say there's alot of pain and suffering going on. Wouldn't you??) We can't do this by billing the snots. They're like any coward, the hide and snipe. I say we have a right to defend ourselves in any way possible! Any takers??

by g.brown

I think that the problem here is people who think they are technically savvy, but in reality.....

Lycos tried it a while ago...... old news.

They've taken it down now.

"A spokesman for Lycos in Germany told The Register he believed that the tool could generate 3.4MB in traffic on a daily basis. When 10m screensavers are downloaded and used, the numbers quickly add up, to 33TB of 'useless' IP traffic. Seems Lycos may hurt not just spammers."

But no, please, go ahead, after all, if you get prosecuted for DDOS attack then that just means the internet will be faster for everyone else :)

by starderup

I just hope not everybody follows your lead.
Being a PC Tech in a Microsoft world is like being an auto mechanic in a Yugo world.
Job Security Deluxe.

by catfish182

ok maybe getting the money isnt the point. but these cats are slippery so the question is would it be a fake company or a real one. how much time would you put into it before saying this isnt worth it. spammer dont just have one route to find them. they are usally have something shady going on.

by mikercol

If you want to try to stop the creation/distribution of spyware the only effective method will have to involve the internet governing bodies. 5000 state, provincial, federal ... laws/lawsuits will never accomplish the task. There will always be some banana or icicle republic out there that won't play along.

The internet governing bodies could set up criteria for pulling IP's. In order to protect their business ISPs would then be the enforcers and the cost of providing services would go up to some degree in order cover costs.

There will always be some moving targets, but if they are constantly forced to pull up stakes we may be able to make the cost prohibitive for them to do "Business".

If you think world governments can do the job better spend your time/dime on defenses. They are all incompetent or corrupt.

by g.brown

Yeah, brilliant, if ISP's stopped IE or MS from accessing the internet then there'd be a lot less adware/spyware.

Instead of making the net more expensive for me and all other people who could be botehred to do a little research, it would speed it up (that spyware takes a lot of bandwith, and i'm on contended adsl).

by edward18

I'm dead serious about billing the spyware companies back for there illicit miss-deeds. Only I charge 125 per hour for spyware/virus removal. I move much faster than most though. We should build a billing system and watch these companies either disappear or re-emerge in a few weeks under a new name. What happened to truth in advertising? I saw a tomato sauce that stated " True Italian recipe" Only to find corn syrup and high fructose corn syrup on the list of ingredients.
So i guess the computer industry isn't the only one filled with FUD!

by g.brown

I'm sorry to dissapoint you but that's not going to stop spam!!

Email addresses can be harvested in many other ways too.

People posting their addresses in the internet.

Major sites being compromised.

Incorrect newsgroup postings.

The list goes on and on.......

So what. Do you want to ban email too?

Why not just ban the internet .. you won't get any adware/spam then.

You see your comments do not make sense.

I could just use a simple phrase like you do "cause and effect" to make a mockery of just about anything.

I wish someone had thought of a way to stop spam ... oh yeah I forgot .. they have ... it's called Anti Spam programs!!

Just like in the real world you need a firewall. You also need good Spam filters.

But I suppose that means you actually have to use your brain and download one.

Oh, and BTW, where do you get your statement from that "SPAM is one of the major end results of spyware" I suppose you actually just made that up!!

by andeanderson

As tempting as that sounds, it would end up costing us more in the long run.

One Judge in California has already sided with one of these companies and issued a Cease-And-Desist order for similar lawsuits. It appeared that an Associate Website was responsible for the illicit installation, not the spyware author.

We can only try to protect our systems as well as we can until the Congressional Leaders get as fed up with it as they did with SPAM. Then, maybe in a few years, we would see a similar legislation for Spyware.

Of course, if you try to use the same tactics against the Spyware authors, as they use to get their spyware installed on your systems, they have attorneys ready to sue you. LOL

by dotxen

Great idea mate.

With the ?ound to the $ollar running at 1.85 to 1.90, why not bill the low-life in ?ounds?

Trouble is, it's unlikely that enough people would bother.

My own opinion is to report them to MI5 or CIA as a terrorist cell operating against the financial interests of the Uk and USA. That way we get permanent relief.

The answer is the SAS. Or am I being a trifle harsh?

by g.brown

Upgrade or Security Patch?

I know what I'd argue, and I definetly know what they'd argue. Jeez, i'm sure that if it was possible they'd charge you for each update available.

Actually, I suppose you could really say that XP is just a slight update of win2k.

The features could be implemented if MS wanted, but they'd prefer more of your money. And it sounds like you're way to willing to just throw it around.

by rick1056

While I agree that they should be accountable for the Tech time (man-hours) wasted by their malicious spyware and business techniques. Isn't billing them just another waste of time because as we all know they won't pay or stop without some enforceable laws and fines levied against them. The cost of billing, postage and invoice production is really another expense and a waste of resources, that could be used to effectively make a real effort to get some laws passed in Washington.

by edeldoug

I'll reply to your idea of billing the offenders in a second. First and foremost, however, are the steps you can take to protect yourself.

1) Download (free) and install Spyware Blaster on all the PCs. Will block a LOT (not all) of this stuff from ever getting on the machines.

2) Download & install (free) Spybot Search & Destroy on all the PCs. Use the advanced configuration to turn on scheduled scans to run weekly.

Download (free) and install Microsoft AntiSpy (formerly Giant) to all PCs and configure for autoupdate, realtime protection, and daily scans.

3) Purchase Pest Patrol Corporate, and install to an administrative machine (admin's PC or a server) to run scans enterprise wide and provide realtime protection.

This should keep your systems pretty clean.

As to billing the offenders: Forget it. They'll just ignore you, and they have an army of lawyers if you try to pursue collection! If you think you're wasting time on spyware now, just try to actually collect on your bill!

On the other hand - send your anecdotal nightmare stories regarding spyware to your local congressman and senators demanding that they criminalize the placing of any executable code on someone's PC without the user's expressed knowledge and consent.

by fdohle

Let's just have the authorities make this activity illegal - implicate all parties - site owners as well as ISP's who host the sites.

Think about it - If there was someone spying in your windows in your home - you could call the cops and have the creep arrested. Whether the creep is casing your place to rob it - or he's just a peeping Tom - our courts would easily dish out a sentence. It's no different with spyware - espicially since most of it has malicious intent - either sending info back for "Identity theft" or wasting your time by hijacking your browser. Let's stop fooling around and fix the issue at the source.

by g.brown

Nice one, I hadn't heard about that.

Just had a quick hunt for it.

Brilliant, it seems like they've got a free home user edition.

Think I'll play with it when MS can be bothered to release their latest patches/upgrades or whatever you want to call em ;) seeing as they didn't bother this month.

Here's the link for others...

http://www.bigfix.com/download/download.html

by darkpawn5

I am in agreement with jereg!!!

I actually found one entitled DealHelper.com
I found their website, got their IP address and did a 24-48 hour D.O.S. to their site, as it had a business PC problemmatic for that length of time so I figured the old good for goose, good for the gander idea. I think it is an excellent idea to bill them for services rendered.

by mshatswell

Since the spyware jerks did not actually ask me to perform the removal of their software I think the burden is still on myself and/or my customers. I am willing to submit bills for my time if it will help slow this down.

by drumit

Jereg,
I agree with your sentiments 110%. However, I wonder how you would implement it. Do Spammers provide a billing address? I think this may be a good idea but practical implementation is still a question. How do you prove they owe you the money?
DrumIT

by bootp

I HATE spammers and I LIKE this idea. To actually make it work, "we" need a class action lawsuit to collect on our billings.

So, I propose that we all send a bill for spyware removal. Then some attorney who also hates spam can tie them up in court for a few years.

.... anyone recall the civil action that WON against OJ ??? Nothing like a few $$$ being extracted from someone's wallet to get their attention.

While "we victims" are at it, "we" need a leader - someone to contact the perpetrators and connect with the legal profession. Any takers???

I say - bury them with and in the legal system.

by mrwelch98

What About the Advertisers or the people actually purchacing our private data?

As I recall, it is illeagal in most parts of the world to recieve "stolen goods". Hitting the advertisers with liable suits would likely have better results.

If no one buys the info...the incentive to pursue info for profit should decrease.

Michael Welch

by william.halvorson

The problem with billing them is that there are hundreds of different people/sites writing these pop-ups into their code, and even if we did all send them bills, they would not be enforcable by law. They would have only succeeded in wasting more of our time in sending them bills. Even a class action suit would be problematic as it would require somebody identifying all the culprits behind the popups, though I guess if we just targeted the companies that were named in all the popups it would be a good start.

For short term goals, I had a recent problem with pop-ups, and using spybot, adaware and a few other downloaded tools did nothing for me. Then I saw StopZilla, and installed it for a 15 day trial period. It immediately stopped my pop-ups, and since the trial period ended and I uninstalled it I have still been pop-up free. Whatever it did really cleaned up my PC.

by deathtoliberalism

Thanks for re-answering the question. That is half-reanswering the question. See the above post by me for the full explanation.

by g.brown

Gator is adware that collects and transmits information about a user's Web activity. Its goal is to gather demographic information and generate a profile of the user's interests for targeted advertisements. Gator may log and transmit URLs that the user visits, partially identifying information such as the user's first name and zip code, and information about the configuration and installed software on the user's machine. Gator also tracks the sites that a user visits, so that it can display its targeted ads at the moment that specific words appear on the user's screen. Gator is also known as OfferCompanion, Trickler, or GAIN.

Gator can be installed on a user's computer in several ways. When a user installs one of several free software programs produced by Claria Corporation (the company that produces Gator), such as a free calendar application or a time synchronization client, the application installs Gator as well. Several peer-to-peer file-sharing clients, such as iMesh [8], Grokster [7], or Kazaa [9], are bundled with Gator. When visited, some Web sites will pop up advertisements on the client's browser that prompt the user to download software that contains Gator. Gator can run either as a DLL linked with the free software that carries it, or within a process of its own launched from an executable called gain.exe or cmesys.exe. Gator is capable of self-updating.

by chelsechune

I spend hours upon hours trying to keep my pc and mostly everyone I know clean if it's not one thing it's another...I think you have a n excellent idea. So then if I wanted to bill them could I just bill them as a consultant?

by pdouglas4294

I work for a California Government Entity. As such, we try to emphasize to the users the machine is not their personal machine and they are not supposed to be installing whatever they want. "What do mean, I don't have administrative rights to my computer!!!! I need to be able to screw it up royally anytime I want and then just need you to fix it."
As such, maybe the EULA argument could be countered by the user didn't have the proper authority to install it.
Also, I want to see if any of the California entities (State, County, DA, whatever) have the "huevos" to enforce the new law about installing Spyware on a computer.

TTFN
Paul

by eeehhhaaa

If somebody trespasses on your personal property, as in your computer with spyware, then sue them for the transgression! If they collect personal information about you or your habits, without your permission, then you got a case in Canada given new federal legislation (i.e., PIPEDA). Unfortunately, most freeware or shareware, use the benefit of their software as the carrot for their spyware. However, if no benefit and no permission, then sue!

by themessenger

The easiest thing that I have seen that works is to balance user abilities with Group Policy, User Rights, and Internet Filtering.
In group policy there is a software restriction policy. I have found that placing the 14 most prevelant spyware executables into the policy has stopped almost all of the spyware infections in our environment. We have only had 3 infections in 12 months across 3500 computers.
Our users also do not have admin rights, so most software will not install properly even if they get past policy.
We also use N2H2 to filter our user's internet access, blocking access to many of the sites that provide free screensavers and themes (which are where many infections come from).
The last peice of protection comes from the company pc policy that states that the user is not allowed to install freeware, shareware, or beta software on company computers.

Side note: I have only had to update the group policy list of executables twice in since we started using it. That makes it real easy to keep up with. You can also block the creation of certain folders, which lots of the "non-spyware" spyware uses for installation.

If you would like a list of the executables and folders that I am blocking, drop me a line. I'd love to help out fellow IT guys!

==============================
IBecause of the requests for information, I have started a new thread with help in it under the desktops discussions.

by jpo41

Why not take it a step further and consider this some kind of criminal offense, kind of like telemarketers calling without permission? It is a constant battle, and for a personal computer to be taken to its knees because of spyware is utterly ridiculous, especially considering when most users cannot clean their pc's.

by g.brown

format c:

:)

Or you could just use your brain and get some anti spyware and a decent browser. And don't just click OK to everything that comes up.

Great ... a non call list ... just post all your email addresses live onto the internet and it'll all magically stop. Wow, I wish someone had thought of that before.

errr, one problem though.

Wouldn't that actually give the people who you don't want to get your e-mail address your e-mail address?

by tmoreau

I'd be willing to tey the idea. I'm fed up with having to clean my system on a daily basis.

tom

by black_eyed_pea

I agree that Firefox is usually a viable alternative to IE. However, since not all webages are create equal, some "mission critical" sites do require IE. In addition, many IT professionals (especially government IT like me) can do nothing to change these requirements. So, the game continues and we must do whatever we can in our limited spheres of influence.

Given the constraints I just mentioned, there is still wiggle room. If your company has the cash and willingness to cooperate, WebSense is a great product.

In my opinion, a proactive organization will have the following:

1. A web/URL filter to block sites that host spyware, mobile malicious code, web-based email, and remote proxies. (Installation of P2P file sharing and IM clients are a leading cause of spyware.)
2. A solution that will allow administrators to block the download of certain file types.
3. A solution to block specific ports used by spyware related apps like IM and P2P.
4. Methods to detect and block spyware on each client workstation.
5. Methods to remove spyware that did not get blocked.
6. Acceptable use policies for enterprise network and email.
7. End user education.

An organization can configure a secure stack, including a firewall, cache proxy, and web/URL filter to accomplish the first three objectives. Websense is worth investigating as a URL/Web filter. Websense claims their product is the only one that blocks incoming and back-channel transmission of spyware.

Check out these URLs:
http://www.websense.com/products/resources/wp/EmergingThreats_Spyware.pdf

http://www.websense.com/products/about/PG/

by mc68000

I said NOT another DDOS. Something new. I don't know what. Something that runs right back up the pipe to them as soon as their trying to deliver their payload and stops them in their tracks. If your statement "I think that the problem here is people who think they are technically savvy, but in reality....." is meant to mean me, then I say you don't even know how to use an ellipsis! It's three dots dude. Not five, not two, three. And just because you can't think outside the box doesn't mean everyone can't. But lets save the insults for the real antagonists here. I don't pretend to know how to write the "The buck stops here code" that I'm trying to promote. I'm not a hacker or a security geek (simile?) But I know many of TechRepublics aliens are. Again, I say, any takers??

by montgomery gator

The term "Sleazy Lawyer" is not an oxmoron, but is a redundant phrase. Oxymorons are self-contradictory phrases like "Non-Dairy Creamer".

by slowfred

How about doing the samething they did with the national no call list fo the phone system. Start a spyware do not send list and get the Feds,state and local goverments to sponser such a bill.
Thanks,
Fred

by bigbobsanders

If they fail to pay your bill, turn them over for collection and report them to the three credit bureaus. These reports will damage them more than suing the bums.

by decimumaximus

I like it
Publish a list of addresses to send the bill I have plenty of spyware removal cases a week.
Xain

by wendygoerl

This could be a case of "the bad guy gone good" (like the hacker they hire as a security consultant)--only time will tell.

by wendygoerl

Maybe that will stop the companies that care about their reputation. But good luck actually getting a bill to some fly-by-night that will come out of the woodwork to fill the void the legitimate companies leave behind. FBN gets too much heat, they fold up, your bill comes back "undeliverable," and, in a week or two, they've reinvented themselves and are spamming you again.
For a while, I was getting spam from "fs8@m01" I told them to cut it out, filed an abuse against them, they eventually complied--and I started getting spam from "fs8@m02" Tell me this ain't the same outfit?

by ibillybibilly

I suppose my suggestion of a DDOS on spyware/adware servers would put us in the category of virus senders, but these f^$%ers really boil my blood.

A few molitov cocktails?? Who's with me?!!

by pmwpaul

The problem with spam, adware or spyware is that somebody somewhere buys something.

As long as people continue to buy stuff, people will continue to try to sell it.

People in China will continue to try to sell chinese jelly beans to everybody as long as people in Kansas, Paris and Boliva buy them.

To address spam issues: For business domains, how about an email honeypot?
This would be for unsoliticed emails and anything that goes to the honeypot would be blocked from actual emails. And you could send 10,000 replies every day for ten days. That would keep people away from your domain.

For pop-ups, have a plug-in that identifies when FireFox blocks a pop-up, sends the info to your firewall and automatically blocks that site's ip for 30 days.

If everybody used a browser that wouldn't allow the user to visit a site with a pop-up, sites would stop using pop-ups.

Can anybody write the email honeypot component?

by john_galt9

I would love to know if there is a law that would allow billing and could include telemarketers that ignore the "I don't want what you are selling list!" Jokes aside, just HOW d you track them down? I'm thinking, it would be 'turn about is fair play' by send them one of over 2000 virus, worms, and trojans I have collected on Zip's. (grin)

by gktravis

My biggest beef with all the spyware (and viruses) is that is now common accepted practice to have to run software to combat it. Software which sits in memory, sits running on the pc waiting to 'catch' something. All this 'necessary' [and completely acceptable] software eats up precious cpu and memory cycles. I now have to buy a bigger machine just so I can use my machine. Webroot's spyware software is great, but it cripples the computer. Microsofts is a little better. But I know when I turn off all my AV and Spyware and pop-up blockers [after unplugging my CAT5 cable, of course], my computer screams in speed, just like the days of yore (a few years ago).

That's what I really hate about the world we're in now. We need a bigger internet, now that we've filled the old one up wiht junk (re: spam).

by itdood

Take the easiest path. Plug the holes:

XP SP2
Deploy Firefox
Send bigger orgs through a decent Proxy like BlueCoat

by ak norm

A few of us have had the germ of a good idea. Spyware companies exist because other companies pay lots of money to them for the data they mine. Remove the financial incentive, and the business dries up.
1. Find and publish the names of companies using Spyware companies (Verizon, T-Mobile & some national banks for a start) Have them published in major news sources -magazines, newscasts, etc.
2. Boycott these companies' products, and encourage others to do the same.
3. Bill these companies (the data buyers) for the "costs" mentioned in other posts on this topic. Go through the process, lett'em refuse to pay, then formally report them to the credit bureaus - don't forget Dun & Bradstreet.
4. When they find their credit ratings slipping, and sales slipping, and bad publicity popping up, they'll start thinking twice about spending money with spies.
5. Whenever you run anti-spyware programs on your systems, and you find & remove infestations, save a copy of the report to a file on your computer. Send a copy of the file, with an estimate of lost productive time, and cost of repair, to your State AND Federal congressmen. 50 computers means 50 messages. Once a week meand 200 messages a month. (For this example) These people are too complacent about this topic, they don't come in contact with the consequences enough.
6. Once a month, print out all of the reports, and mail them to the same people via USPS. Now they have both their email and regular mail systems clogged with their constituents making them aware of the size & intensity of the problem.
It's called raising their awareness level.
In a cover letter going with the printouts (same one every month - change the date), ask them when they are going to take action against the problem.

And for God's sake, tell them to get that guy from Claria off the Homeland Security post!!!!

It's all about the money.

by 7november

What they are doing with the spy ware they put into our computers costs us more then it does them..and to just recover from their tactics.. it's alot of our time and our money that gets lost.. since the FTC and the FCC cannot see that.. cause they wish not to..we ought to petition and ammend for those who do put spy ware in..you will be charged a hefty fee for it's removal..

by 7november

What they are doing with the spy ware they put into our computers costs us more then it does them..and to just recover from their tactics.. it's alot of our time and our money that gets lost.. since the FTC and the FCC cannot see that.. cause they wish not to..we ought to petition and ammend for those who do put spy ware in..you will be charged a hefty fee for it's removal..