Discussion Locked

Lawyers promote subterfuge of H1-B process in seminars

0 helpful
37 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This article has video of lawyers telling companies how to bypass H1B requirements.
They claim it is legal.

http://www.computerworld.com/action/article.do?command=viewArticleBasic&articleId=9025268&intsrc=hm_list

http://www.informationweek.com/news/showArticle.jhtml;jsessionid=QWZAGIJZW3A0WQSNDLPCKHSCJUNN2JVN?articleID=199905192

Still telling openly in seminars how to fake out the law sounds not just scummy but illegal to me. No wonder we get those lawyer jokes.

37 replies

by jdclyde

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UhLBSLLIhUs

So, how many of you know an IT professional that is unemployed or underemployed?

I do not think there is a shortage, as I know several people right now that would LOVE to be able to find work.

This is all about people that are willing to work for less.

by big ole jack

She's a sellout to the same middle class people she claims to represent by giving jobs away to low cost foreign labor. There is no shortage of skilled labor here, just a shortage of companies that see IT as an integral part of their corporations instead of another thorn in the side expense that has to be undermined with low pay.

by techexec2

.
I completely agree with everything in your post, except one important thing: You really shouldn't try to hang the H-1B problem on Hillary. Hillary is not the problem, nor is she the solution. Both Republicans and Democrats favor H-1Bs (1). I don't think there is a solution.

In the 1990s: The Republican-controlled Congress wrote and passed the H-1B bills and Democratic President Clinton signed them into law.

In the 2000s: The Republican-controlled Congress wrote and passed the H-1B bills and Republican President Bush signed them into law.

The constituency of American IT worker voters is a tiny drop in the voter bucket. All other Americans [u]benefit[/u] in some way from the inexpensive H-1B workers. That's why politicians from both parties support H-1Bs.

American IT workers are never going to have what they used to have ever again. They are a "special interest" (in Bush's words) and are being sacrificed for the benefit of everyone else. It doesn't matter much who wins control of the government in 2008 with respect to this.

-------------------------------------------

(1) Bush and Gore advocate increasing the H-1B visa cap (2000 presidential race)

[i]"...Both Bush and Gore favor legislation that would raise this year's cap of 115,000 workers to 200,000 and would extend that increase for the next several years..."[/i] --- CNET article

[i]"...the Clinton-Gore administration is standing in the way of continued economic growth...I urge the Clinton-Gore administration to put the public's interests ahead of union bosses and special interests who oppose legal immigration...."[/i] --- Bush on the campaign trail in 2000

http://news.com.com/Bush,+Gore+wrestle+for+new-economy+voters/2100-1023_3-245260.html

by big ole jack

Perhaps the guy was actually right in his rantings about Indians and H1-B visas. I'm not claiming to defend him in any way, but maybe he knew something about this that we didn't and was simply expressing his outrage through other means. Perhaps those applying for H1-Bs' know about these illegal schemes and are taking full advantage of it to undermine the American workforce. Is it time for us IT pros to unionize and start busting kneecaps like the Teamsters do?

by jdclyde

I did not say she was "the" problem, just that she does support increasing this.

Just getting my feet wet on this issue, so I wonder where Rudy stands on this? So far, he seems like my pick out of the bunch.

by big ole jack

Since foreign guest workers have no loyalty towards the USA, they should be overly scrutinized and run through extensive background checks to determine if they pose a national security risk or are prone to run off with trademark secrets or intellectual property. I'm not saying that U.S. citizens are innocent of this, but foreign labor is more prone to engage in such crimes because they think they'll get away with it as soon as they leave the country.

by big ole jack

They solicit me all the time and want to know if I am interested in new opportunities and what my salary requirements and visa status is. Mind you, I have my own company.

My answers are as follows:

Yes I am interested. Let me know who the client is so that I can solicit them directly through my firm and offer them real quality service..not outsourced crappy foreign labor.

My salary requirement: $250/hr for my professional consulting services.

My visa status: Platinum card member since 2001 with a $50,000 credit limit.

Any more questions?

by big ole jack

and see how loud they scream to have an IT person onsite to fix the problem of them not being able to surf the web or get their emails. It's unfortunate that the sh-t has to hit the fan first in many organizations before IT is viewed as an integral part of the business instead of a cost center. Perhaps we need to "accidentally" take down the system to gain the respect and appreciation we deserve as IT professionals.

by inkling

I was discussing the need for required user training with one of our salespeople.

Their reply was that they don't have time for that kind of stuff. They are already too busy.

My reply was to ask how much free time they would have if the entire system crashed because some ignorant user downloaded something they weren't supposed to.

Have fun taking those orders without your pocket pcs. If they think they're busy now...I wonder how they would do with pen and paper.

by jdclyde

to become more efficient and save time.

Yeah, I hear this all the time, as one of my many hats is in-house trainer. The only one that has EVERYONE trained is the lady in charge of marketing. She hires someone, they spend a day with me before they get their equipment.

by jdclyde

The servers crash more often, so the admin can save the day on a regular basis. Of course they don't tell the users they fix it by rebootting the server..... :0

But this does make them more visible, where for a *nix server, you load it and forget about it until it is time for a patch or upgrade.

by big ole jack

written by mediocre programmers that cause the servers to crash. One can make Unix and Linux servers crash as well by running poorly written code on them. No OS is truly immune to crashing, but Windows has gotten a bad rap due to its prominence and market visibility. Trust me, I've sold and built many custom configured servers and none of them have crashed. The only time I would see a crash was when a customer was poking around on one and installed some custom written code that hasn't been fully tested to run properly on the given OS and hardware.

by techexec2

.
Isn't this a white collar version of a bunch of prison inmates getting together to compare notes about how to get away with street crimes?

Thanks for posting this, Dr. Dij! It gives a rare clear view of how bad the weasel infestation is. I am not surprised or shocked by this at all. It just gives me ammunition for the next time I discuss this with the H-1B fraud naysayers.

This video is just the tip of the iceberg as far as I'm concerned. "Fraudulent H-1B visa program" is an oxymoron.

Do we assail the lawyers? Or, do we assail the corporations who game the system and the Federal government that makes it possible, and lets them get away with it? Lawyers are the vultures alright. But, the kill was made by the Lion.

by jdclyde

we "assail" BOTH the lawyers AND the corporations.

Anyone that participates is guilty of AT LEAST accessory to the crime, and yes, it is a crime.

by jdclyde

when it is modular, say there is an issue with the dns, just hop that service, instead of having the whole system be taken down by one application. It IS a flaw in the OS that ALLOWS an application to take it down.

But that of course is for another discussion. I will leave it as "Perception is reality". :D

by jdclyde

was when he made it a racial thing specifically against the Indian immigrants. Looking at this, the majority are from there, but that doesn't mean we should hate people from India. It would seem that he did. It wasn't being apposed to H1-B's that got him, it was being a card carrying modern day IT-KKK.

If he could have remained professional about it and left out the personal commentary about the race and stayed on issue, then instead of getting eggs thrown at him, he could have enlightened some of us maybe.

by techexec2

.
[b][i]"...Is it time for us IT pros to unionize and start busting kneecaps like the Teamsters do?..."[/i][/b]

No and maybe. :^0

Unions are defangled big cats in this age of globalization. All they can really do now is make a lot of noise (roars and screams). Look what concessions the unions are making with Delphi and GM! Can you IMAGINE the unions making such concessions 20 years ago? If the unions hold fast, the ENTIRE Delphi operation will move offshore. Unions are defangled big cats.

Unions cannot help IT workers much (or any other workers for that matter these days). Unions are out on their ear just like American workers are. But, that part about breaking kneecaps sounds interesting! :^0

[b][i]"...Perhaps those applying for H1-Bs' know about these illegal schemes and are taking full advantage of it to undermine the American workforce..."[/i][/b]

As the video shows, it is much much worse than that. These bastards are organized. And, there is a "pipeline" from Bangalore to the United States. There are many people involved in getting those cheap Indian workers into the U.S. The individual Indians are not doing this all on their own. They are not even the "bad guys". They are just squirrels trying to get a nut, just like all of the rest of us. Nearly every major American tech company has a huge workforce in India. The process often starts there.

[b]As for "Why Me Worry?"[/b]

Correct. He was not wrong about the H-1Bs. He wasn't even completely wrong about Indians. They are not all as well qualified as they are said to be or as many of them think they are. WMW used a lot of racist insults and epithets that were completely unnecessary and unacceptable. That is where he crossed the line, many times, and even more so after being warned about it.

Arrogance and pride is built into Indian culture. They are actually told they are getting these jobs because they are better than the Americans they are displacing, they are internalizing it, and they are repeating it. And, it is complete crap. It's just another one of the lies being told in this sordid global scam that helps the bitter drink go down easier for everyone involved. "I got the job because I'm better at it". Bullsh*t!

The bottom line is that highly educated qualified [u]American[/u] tech workers are being displaced because they MUST earn a living [u]IN AMERICA[/u]. The [u]median[/u] price of a home in the heart of California's Silicon Valley is $750,000. You and your family cannot afford one, or keep one, if you are paid like they pay those young Indian workers on H-1Bs. The hiring American corporations don't care (and lie about it). The American government doesn't care (and lies about it). The Indian outsourcing companies don't care (and lie about it). The Indian H-1B workers don't care (and lie about it). Of course, all of this lack of concern brings out the best in me as a human being.

by ontheropes

TechExec? What is there about you and your posts? Is it the ring of truth I wonder? Maybe so. Sometimes you just tick me off too. :0 :)

I believe you're right about the Union thing and it's demise. The Unions day has come and gone and speaking as a good citizen of the United States and former Union worker manager I'll say good riddance. MY people were in a UAW-style Union and let me tell you, there were some BIG, (read that HUGE) boys under my guidance and direction. I called some of them Sir. You know why? They told me to.

Truthfully, they deserved politeness and manners. Many were and are veterans from virtually every conflict or war since WWII. They know the real meaning of work, faith, honesty, diligence and patriotism. I learned as much, if not more, from them as they learned from me and I was tuned into all of the latest and greatest hogwash. I say that I never have/had an original idea but it's all just a combination of the ideas and words from the doods with the dirt under their fingernails and the ones with the manicured hands and prissy white starched shirts and Loony Tunes and silk ties. (That latter was me BTW, tho' I did my own nails. Aren't they pretty.)

So, I say, the Unions day is done and good riddance? Sure!!! I think that Unions encouraged people to let someone else do their thinking for them. My men were PERFECTLY capable of thinking for themselves. I wanted to reward the best of them with more moola moola, time-off for vacation and what have you but I couldn't because the best were in the same category as the worst of them.

I know for a FACT that the owner of the Fortune 500 company where I worked felt EXACTLY the same way. I ought to know. That SOB was the one who hired me and also my direct report. He was my farking boss if somebody doesn't quite ?get? that yet. I spent far too much time with him and the various Veeps, GM's and upper-echelon types we had every place you can imagine. (There too :0 )

What should we, as a country, do about ?it?. Take back ownership of the country from those clownish boys and girls in D.C. and at the local levels who've forgotten that this is a country of ?WE THE PEOPLE? not them and their special interest groups. Get the lobbyists out of the lobby and let REAL folk in. I MIGHT HAVE SOMETHING I WANT TO SAY TO MY REPRESENTATIVES IN PERSON and I can't when there are a bunch of self-serving lobbyists with fistfulls of cash vying for my rep's attention. He/she is distracted from ME THE PEOPLE and turns towards self-serving behavior because it's a human trait for a lot of folks. If no one seems to care why not? They are so distracted that they can't even see that idjits like me DO care.

(Big sigh). We need help to get this country back on track. I'd say let's ask the fine citizens of Japan to help us design a business and education model that will work for all of us, them included. Let's use the thinking power of all of the worlds people to come up with solutions that will benefit everyone world-wide. What a concept huh? Smaller government and more control of where your dollar and mine is spent. Feed the starving nations instead of bombing them. Put shoes on their feet. By God I've got a pair of boots right here for a bigfooted man from any nation on Earth who would accept them and not try to steal them but would respect my right to have a steenking pair of boots.

I could go on (or off) more at length... Maybe I will later. This is just crap I thought of while cleaning my GMC pickup truck. I like American made products, no matter what company makes them. I prefer American owned manufacturers but... American manufacturers need to get their CRAP together. It's NEVER TOO LATE unless YOU GIVE UP! NEVER GIVE UP!!!

That's it for me now. Me need trail-coffee and my trucks not up to MY standards, yet!

BTW-I never met an Indian (from Inja) that I didn't like but I s'pose they're out there. At risk of over-simplication I'll just say that they seem to be like me but their cultural differences could use some work from what I've seen on the ground in New Delhi and Balabgarh. (sp-sue me)

by jamesrl

And mean those from India, as opposed to native Americans/Canadians.

Like citizens of every other nation, there are good ones and bad ones, kind ones and evil ones. Smart ones and dumb ones.

I've met quite a few. I've worked on political campaigns for them and with them(my area has quite a few Members of Parliament of Indian birth/decent). I've worked with them in business. I've met them at church.

India is quite diverse. There are tensions between Sikhs, Muslims and the Hindhu majority. There are tensions within those communities as well. Some of that has spilled into Canada as well.

James

by locrian_lyric

Thanks to my union, I got to spend several years job hopping, losing everything and nearly ending it all.

A friend of mine, under the same union wasn't so lucky.

They are WORSE than management in many instances.

by big ole jack

Because they have their own self interests in mind and are being duped like a bunch of dumb sheep by large corporations into thinking there aren't skilled IT workers here in the USA. I like Rudy, his style, and how he cleaned up NYC of all the vagrants and smut when he was mayor. I'd like to see where he stands on this entire H1-B debacle and if he truly has the good ole American in mind. Well, he did throw the sympathy money back at the Saudi Arabian Sheik right after 9/11 and that right there shows pride in the man and that money can't replace over 3000 lost lives. We'll just have to wait and see.

by jdclyde

the bleeding hearts where screaming their outrage.

He did what had to be done, and NY City is a better place for it.

This was all before 911 and the global spotlight was put on him, so it isn't an act.

This country needs some tough love right now to clean it up, just like NY City did. I have not made up my mind, as we don't even know if he will make it past the primaries, but he is the strongest person running from either party.

The front runners for the Dems are weasels that are going to do great harm to this country if they get in office. Not intentionally, but you can have good people with bad ideas. (exclude Hillary from that though, because nothing has ever shown her to be a "good person")

by locrian_lyric

Without naming names, this US newspaper has recently come to the attention of Rupert Murdoch...

Said paper's view of IT was/is "All IT does is spend money".

They're learning a lesson now....

by captbilly1eye

I'm flippin' the lever for Rudy... that is [b]IF[/b] he gets the nomination. That's gonna be the toughest battle. The amount of feathers ruffled by McCain and the 'non-party' lines of Rudy may mean that Romney gets the nod. Thompson does look interesting, tho.

Hillary makes my skin crawl and hair stand on end (what little I have left) and I find it too difficult to imagine an Obama-nation.

Anyway... The H1-B issue isn't going to be resolved by the politicians... at least not in the foreseeable future.

I don't have an answer other than making it my personal point not to aid and abet those that abuse the system.

by ontheropes

I do recall a few Indians that ticked me off after giving it some thought. There were/are, supposedly, a beggar class who'd maim their own children to elicit sympathy and a buck. It paid in spades to wear wrap-around sunglasses for the taxi ride. It pisses me off to think they feel they have to do that to survive.

I think that something's wrong with the "big picture".

by big ole jack

Why Me Worry was ranting about Indians and had his account terminated here, although he went overboard with his racially charged rants, but I can see how Indians would have ticked him off. I too have my own opinions of them, but I'd rather not share them here because they aren't very politically correct.

by locrian_lyric

Suffice it to say, that in HIS opinion, the latest crop we've been getting have been the washouts that couldn't make it at home.

(This man has more money than G_D and his own security force at home)

by techexec2

.
JamesRL is on solid ground. What got WMW into trouble was the racial insults and epithets. That sort of thing is unacceptable, and rightly so. Discussing Indian culture or politics or social issues or immigration or H-1Bs or problems with outsourcing companies in India or some such is perfectly legitimate.

This discussion is closed to new replies.