With a re imaged drive there is no possibility of the repairer ever being put in a difficult position of having to report one or more of their customers for Illegal Activity. Once the Data is gone it's gone and never to be seen again so you can not report what is never seen can you?
That covers both the Owner and the Repairer weather you like it or not but it's true.
So if you are working on any level of Secure System you would never have returned the HDD as it's possible to recover data off the empty platters if you have the time & inclination to do so. So it's possible to recover all your data and still have a working OS as well. But the main problem here is that you should never have let your Data out of your Hands.
Here once a HDD enters this place it never leaves the place as a working HDD, just in bits when it's decommissioned, even then the platters are headed straight to a furnace to be melted down any guesses why it is so?
The current going rate to recover everything that has ever been written to any HDD is about $450,00.00 here is my bill and you need to pay it before the NB is returned. My guess is that you will not accept the NB as that is way more than the cost of several new Ruggerised NB that are far better than the system that you bought.
Now I build my own computers and my own NB's as well so I don't deal with any of the Big OEM Companies but I do know that they all advise and warn you of the possibility of a re image and they tell you to save your data before returning the machine. I believe that this also comes with the packaging as well so you really have no recourse to anything as you where warned.
The last NB that I sold was returned 5 days after delivery with the screen going to the basic Display after 30 minutes of running and you needed to turn it off let it cool down and the start up again before you could change the screen resolutions. The cause some incompatible software was installed which caused the problem. Without removing this software there was no possibility of repairing the NB and it would have been returned exactly the same as it arrived with no solution. That is Unacceptable to me. If you where willing to cover the cost of a HDD you should have removed it and sent in a letter asking HP to supply a new HDD at your expense. Most people are unwilling to accept this however as they mistakenly think that they have paid a lot of money for the NB and they expect it to work no matter what they do to it.
If your backup failed that speaks volumes of your backup software not anything of HP service arraignments. Personally I never fully trust any Backup Software and I always copy the data across to a HDD as I've seen way too many failed Backups over the years and know better than to ever fully trust them again and certainly I never ever trust any Backup performed by M$ backup software. I can almost guarantee that it will fail at some point.
[i]I specifically included a note that the hard disk was not to be reimaged. I would have rather incurred the cost than have to reproduce the work[/i]
First thing is that you didn't make any mention of this but none the less why should HP believe you? They can waste hours attempting to get something to work only to find out that the problem is some installed software that the end user has installed. This is a Paid For Repair buy I've never seen these repairs actually charged for as it's not worth the hassles involved.
[i]because HP enforces the MS agreement, I feel that releasing an OS that corrupts network data when synchronizing is the fault of HP as well as MS.[/i]
No actually this is your fault. If you didn't ask for a M$ OS to be installed at some point it wouldn't be an issue would it? Though to be fair M$ does produce second rate software that has no right to be used in any business.
[i]it is a crime, at least on a federal level, to alter or destroy data without authorization[/i]
It's also a crime to be in possession of Kiddy Porn and HP in this case are not wanting to be in a position of being forced to report you and then being sued for following the Law. While you may not personally be interested in this many are so HP has to cover themselves in every eventuality.
[i]the HP tech notes state that the issue was reproducible in bios. Therefore, no reimaging was required.[/i]
I had exactly the same comments made to me with a NB that was recently returned but it was still a Software Related issue. So what why should any System Builder spend their money finding out that they have been provided wrong advice and then need to fix the system to the standard that they require? After all if you didn't want the system fixed you would never have returned it would you?
[i]HP offered to purchase the machine back. Of course, they wont pay what I paid[/i]
Sounds like a great idea as you will not be happy with this machine and they will never repair it so you will be happy so you are better off without it.
[i]after a week and a half setting the computer back up, I took two backups. One was with the backup software I use and the other with the Vista Business/Ultimate backup. I tested both, they are good[/i]
Why spend so long setting up a Appliance? After all those is what these are sold as and are specifically sold as turn on and go now without any need to setup. If you want something different you need to come to someone like me who will custom build a machine for you and not give you an off the shelf machine that you need to constantly change to suit your needs.
[i]the post itself indicates that it is possible and feasible, at a minimal cost, to recover the data without spending more time than it takes to reimage the hard disk. The program I use can do a bare metal restore in about an hour for 30+ gigs of data and programs[/i]
Yes it's possible but then again it's possible to recover every bit of Data that has ever been recorded to any Magnetic Storage Device but who's going to pay for this? I get $160.00 per hour base line so who pays my Labour? I would guess that you wouldn't be happy doing this particularly on a new machine that has just broken as you expect it to work right?
The bottom line was that you agreed to purchase a machine with a suspect OS installed and accept any short comings of that OS so you need to live with it. If you want something reliable you would never consider a Experimental OS and Software Load. Remember that Vista was only released on January 30 so it's only seven months old and still way too new to be considered as Reliable.
When you agree to get onto the Bleeding Edge you should expect to carry the can for poorly developed software and expect it to break. If you don't accept this you would never have bought a computer loaded with Vista of any form.
Col