Discussion Locked

Looking 4 best surround-sound receiver

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I am looking for owner's comments on how they rate their surround sound receiver. I am looking at the top-of-the line models from Yamaha, Denon, and Onkyo. Are you happy with your results. What bells and whistles do you find that you never use, and which ones you couldn't live without, and why?

If you have time, and are rating your system a 10, please identify the components that make up your home theatre.

Thanks

5 replies

by thechas

I do not presently have a surround sound receiver.
My comments come from a past life as a service tech in the high end audio business.
Of the 3, I would rank Denon #1. Yamaha #2. And Onkyo a close #3.

Denon gets first rank for product and sonic quality and for avoiding gimmicks.
Yamaha gets second because they are 2 quick to introduce gimmick features, and do not match the sonic qualities of Denons amplifiers.
Onkyo comes in third. While they have unparalled quality and support, they fall behind in sonic quality.

That said, I have been considering a Yamaha surround sound receiver myself. Why, they offer the lowest cost units that still have a phono input. I do not need the extra amplifier power that comes with the higher end Denon models that have the phono input.

The phono input aside though, to my ears, the Denon sounds better than the comparable Yamaha unit.
Also, where I live, the Denon dealer is head and shoulders above the other dealers in every measure of a retailer.

My system has an older Denon preamp, a Harmon Kardon amp, Kef Ref. 101 speakers, a Denon tuner,
Denon cassette deck, Denon turntable with Denon moving coil cartridge, a Pioneer DVD player (choosen for features), and an assortment of high quality interconnects.

I am amased at what I need to spend to match the sonic performance of what I have.

by the gardener

i have 30+ yrs experiance with Hi-Fi reproduction and system design/integration. the single most important feature is a remote with center and rear volume adjustments and other adjustable perameters so that you can make (tweek) them from your seatedposition. second should be power (watts output) concideration which is dependand on room size and speaker efficiency (?dbspl@1w@1m)
my room dimention is 14.5' x 16.5'and i have an elcheapo OPTIMUS STAV-3770 with 50Wx5@8ohms and i run 12 pairs of speakers off of it at around a 4ohm load per channel so althou it may be 179.00 reciever it works quite well (and for 2 years now)concidering i have its outputs loaded below what its rated for and it does bother the rest of the house if i have it on.
main channels are optimus 12" 3way (no port), 6" polks with tweeters, 3" Morell dome midranges with tweeters sitting atop those in old boston acoustics A40 boxes (with crossovers i had to fabricate), rear (which i added a 150Hz bass filter onto so that the rear channels have less bass content) are a pair of DCM 6" with horn tweeters and on top of those are optimus 5" with linauam tweeters, and center is a pair of optimus (now with an RCA tag) 5" with linauam tweeters.
system is more than adequate for the bedroom and i have a nakamichi 20W reciever and nak speakers for the computer with video/audio output to the vcr which feeds the reciever and i can watch my pc's dvd player through the system aswell as record the cable antenna signal through the pc onto a hard drive.
the only thing the reciever lacks is a 5.1 input source or s-video, i have s-video output capability from the monitor card (wired to the video input of the vcr) but only 2 channel audio which im thinking about upgradingto 5.1 so i can completely eliminate the reciever and just use an outboard 6 channel amp sourced from the pc's soundcard.

This discussion is closed to new replies.