Discussion Locked

MAC vs PC in the Creative Community

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Assumed: we agree that the cost of supporting multiple platforms in significantly greater than supporting single platform.

Method: please set aside your bias and respond specifically to the technical advantages (if they exist).

Question: Given that the applications will run in either environment, is there any technical advantage to running Photoshop, Quark Xpress and the like on a MAC rather than an Intel based PC. Is this a marketing issue or do real advantages exist for these apps in the MAC world?

9 replies

by dcosgrove

Hi,
this is kind of a tough question. I will attempt minimal bias. First of all, I primarily work on and with PCs, so if I have a bias it will be in that direction. I used to feel that Macs had better memory management and higher quality in general. Memory management is key in graphics applications. I do believe that now many pc technologies exist that bring them closer to the performance of macs. There are two reasons I use mainly Pcs at this point in time. If you look at the new Imacs and some of the other mac stuff, you'll notice a sharp decline in some of that quality. Next, look at the cost of replacement parts and the availability of peripherals. Also, look for qualified mac people in your area, if you do need help, will you be able to find it? I could go on but space is limited, so thats my synopsis and two cents.

by stillatit

This is an issue which changes drastically over time.

Many programs, such as Quark and Photoshop work very closely between the two platforms, and aside from the minor keystroke differences have no significant differences. This was not always the case, and may change between versions.

Historically color matching on large monitors was poor for PC's. This may have improved since I last looked.

A MAJOR problem historically has been fonts. Since the output houses have been Mac-based, fonts have historically been PostScript fonts. If you are on a Mac, you send the fonts with the job on your Syquest or similar disk, the output shop uses your fonts, and everything works. When you are on a PC, and using Truetype fonts, it can get ugly if the output shop cannot handle Truetype and substitutes their own PostScript fonts. All your line endings change just slightly, making your clean right edge of text blocks ragged.

(If your output shop can handle Truetype, this is not an issue. Somecan, others cannot.)

If you have your own imagesetter, some RIP's work better than others with PC's.

There are also real format differences between the view portions of some graphic formats when you change from Mac to PC.

Strong recommendation -- ask the people at the facility you use for imagesetting what formats they accept, and whether or not they have trouble with PC-based files, and if so, what.

Good luck.

by tbradley

I can only answer this via second hand information, but our Director of Technology also teaches night courses at USA. They use quark and photoshop on Macs at USA, and he is exclusively PC while at the district.

Having worked both sides of the fence for over 12 years, Quark and Photoshop, while they tout themselves as being PC compatible, do not perform with the same reliability, ease of use, nor does the output compare.

The code is not the same, and to make these
software packages PC compatible required some extensive "re-work". The Apps are written specifically for MACS, and the compatibility comes in via "reverse engineering".

A little research could turn up the same
"hardware" incompatibilties between Intel, AMD, and CYRIX chips in the PC world.

by jpt

Our office runs both Mac and PCs and I also had to make this type of a decision. What I found out are the following:
1 Adobe products were made primarily for the Mac computers.
2 Quark was made primarily for the Mac computers.
3 The interfacealthough very similar to the PC is better managed in the Mac environment.
4 Outsourcing your jobs for prints, you'll find the majority of places run Mac computers, and like one of the previous answers dealing with Postscript vs Truetype.

I loveworking on PCs and wish I could do away with all my Macs in my office (would make my life easier) but in reality I feel the Mac computers offer a greater advantage to both the novice and experienced user with ease of use and understaning.

As muchas I hate to admit it but your probably better off with the Mac, unless price becomes an issue. Mac computers are more expensive than PCs and the support is not always readily available in your area.

Good Luck with your decision.

This discussion is closed to new replies.