Discussion Locked

Music Goes to Hell: The Long Fall of DRM

0 helpful
18 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

"[i]Yahoo! Music Store has announced that it?s shutting the doors on its DRM-laden music superstore. Somewhere Freddy Mercury is screaming 'Another One Bites the Dust?' at 128 kilobits per second. Despite short-term annoyances to burned customers, the joy to music fans is this era of Digital Rights Management is waning like a bad hangover.

It was only 2005 when we first heard the details of the PlaysForSure DRM scheme used by Yahoo! Music and others. Microsoft's Media Player 10 DRM (PlaysForSure) was licensed to various music services (including Yahoo! Music) and to nearly any portable music player manufacturer.

The plan's purpose was to topple iPod and iTunes absolute dominance in online music. In 2005 only 4 percent of music was purchased online, but it was a significant growth from the year before. Up to 70-percent of the total online music market belonged to Apple.[/i]"

[i]"Change is in the air and DRM is quietly disappearing from the digital audio market. To many progressive consumers burned by the fall of PlaysForSure, DRM may have looked like a reality to which we'd all have to reluctantly agree. The market had other ideas."[/i]

more...http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_rights_management

Buh-bye DRM.

18 replies

by boxfiddler Hot topic

I'm fairly certain the Martians have been waiting for yodeling to be so controlled that it's not worth the trouble it takes to acquire. They'd like to move here.

by the scummy one

I thought the most recent one was Apple/iTunes that announced DRM free versions.
I love it, I gotta pay extra to convert my songs to drm free versions, or I may lose the ability to play them in the future :0

Gee, lucky I already converted them to cd format and mp3 format. Now I dont gotta re-purchase my purchased items.

by jackofalltech

It was a flowchart that explained why you SHOULD (tongue in cheek) pirate music. Sorry, I can't post a link, I'm at work and they frown on visiting sites like that. Just search for xkcd, then search the archives.

by w2ktechman

however it is not my scene. Buying used cd's usually (or new but on sale) seems to be working fine for me. Especially with the availability of converters.

by jck

If making sure music was not pirated was such a big issue, why didn't the music industry encode CD audio (and later their internet audio) with data that IDed it?

Then if a person has a file with no discernable ID in the bit pile, you know it's pirated.

End of story. QED.

Guess they were not smart enough to figure that one out.

by oz_media

Many people think that DRM was for protection against pirating, but it wasn't.

DRM was implemented by the companies lookign to sell music online, it allowed restricted licence to play a song that you've paid for.

DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) was designed to protect against piracy, though miserably so as it cannot be put into law in most countries outside of America that seek to protect citizens rights over the music companies.

by jck

on Audio CDs (at some point) to try and prevent piracy?

I just remember something being tried...and it failed.

I still think the best way that the music industry could end piracy is the same way Microsoft could: lower their prices.

I can buy 500 blank CDs for about $.02-.03 a piece. That's $10-15.

I can send my 500 CDs to a duplication firm and have them press my software for about $.30 a copy. That's $150.

or

I can buy my own duplicator that burns 20 CDs at a time. That's about $3,000. Gives me ROI once I run off ~4000 CDs.

Then, I can get the jewel cases for about $.20 a piece. that's $100 more.

I can have printed covers in tri-fold, color glossy for about $.80-1.00 a piece depending on quality and what not.

or

I can pay the disk printer for jewel cases with the printing done for about $1.25 incl. cd, case, cover, etc.

So most bands get anywhere from $.20 a CD to upward of $1.50.

Now consider you have storage, transport, etc., costing another $1 per CD.

that's about what? $3-4 total?

Why does a record label sell a CD for $14-20?

Isn't that price gouging?

2-3 times cost isn't enough profit?

I wouldn't mind so much paying $10-15 for a CD if I knew the music artists were getting $5-10 of it. But, I've heard horror stories of them getting $.50 per CD for a 4 person group to split, then having to pay back the label for "expenses" and end up in debt to them.

Sad.

by oz_media

Once FLAC is available as a standard format for stand alone and car audio players, it will be huge, but FLAC has become an audiophiles format now, only people really into audio seem to use it, that's why the bst quality music is usually available for download in FLAC format, but not much else.

by oz_media

DRM music was distributed at lower cost that normal CD's. DRM disks did not have the familar CD logo on the disk either as they did not play in most people's stand alone players, they are just PC CDROM's.

As for CD costs, that's a good idea of applicable costs but yoru numbers are not realistic for mass production of CD's.

Firdt of all there is teh recordign stuiod time, which can run upwards of $300.00/hr. Then you have teh inistial Producers and Engineers, again a few hundred an hour (which is why most disks these days have poor engineering and production to keep costs down.
The master is then provided at a one-time lump cost.

Then you have copy writers, graphic designers and focus groups who consider and revamp yor cover art, ,enter lyrics into teh booklet, the legal disclaimers etc.

Then there is actual production costs, while you can get a few hundred disks duped locally pretty cheap, when it comes to pressing music, inserting a booklet into the jewel case, printing the disk label itself, then shrink wrappign teh disks, you are lookign at anywhere fro $3.50 - over $5.00 per disk.

If you have FAIR deal, not one of those US (we own everything contracts0 the band will get $3-$5 a disk, sold at $16.99 and up.

So now you have a finished, packaged CD, but you have to get placement in record stores, the tricky part.

This is where Payola used ot come into play, "hey I'll throw you $1500.00 + tickets to the superbowl, make sure my disk is in the front end of the store beside the bulk-end displays". As payola is supposedly illegal these days, the shmoozing and grovelling is much more muted but still exists.

Online presence in music store websites also costs money, they don't advertise your disk on their website for free. Plus they get a cut of all disks sold, $2.00 approximately average.

In the end, nobody makes a lot of money of the disk, you make money from the tour, the merchandise, the endorsements etc.

The bigger it gets, the lowr per disk costs are, however there are more and more people to cut in on each one.

by jackofalltech

That's what I do. There's a shop near me (it would have been called a head shop years ago) that sells and trades used CDs. I bought a 3 CD set of the Best of the Allman Brothers for $5.00!

The first thing I do is rip the CD to my HD then put the CD away in a dark cabinet.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

if Mr. Obama thought about the Region 1/Region 2 thing when he gave those. Having been touted as a tech savvy dude, I'd have thought he'd would have. Maybe he did it on purpose?
'Bout time that kind of thing made news from a different perspective.
Thanks. :D

This discussion is closed to new replies.