Discussion Locked

Need a New Motherboard

0 helpful
17 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Wow, it's been a long time since I've been here.

Recently, my motherboard died. I'm in college, and I run my computer 24/7. I wake up, move the mouse, and wake it up every morning. One morning, though, it didn't wake up. I looked at it, and to my dismay, the CPU's fan was spinning WAY too slowly. I had a guy check it out, and my board is dead. The processor is a 2100+, and they run pretty hot, so I'm guessing it's fried too, but I didn't want to spend the extra money to have him check that, too.

My problem is this. My current dead board is an AOpen AK77-333. I want to upgrade to a good solid, stable board, without paying huge amounts of money for it. I talked to a few friends, and they recommended the Asus A7N8X board.

Should I rather upgrade to another AOpen? Like the AK77-600N? Or something similar? The guy that checked out my computer said that if I got a board with a Via chipset in it, then I wouldn't have to reinstall Windows. I'd really rather not reinstall Windows, so ... should I go with a Via chipset board? Or is this guy incorrect?

17 replies

by jschein

A7N8X - Deluxe - Great board and I would go with it. This board from ASUS is one of their best. Not only that, the onboard chipset has a heatsink instead of a fan cooler (which fail after about a year). Plus it's ready for anything as far as upgrades. Newegg.com has them listed for 70 USD if I recall.

by cg it

I like the MSI K7N2 Delta mainboard. Has the nForce2 chipset. Different models have different add on stuff. Some have Serial ATA onboard Video, Onboard LAN, Onboard sound.

If you change out your mainboard, even if it's a VIA chipset based, unless it's the exact same board, it's best to reinstall the O/S and all the drivers.
Here's a link to MSI's web site http://www.msicomputer.com

by thechas

Which version of Windows are you running?

If W2K or XP, you might have to start over unless you replace the board with one that uses the same VIA chip-set.

If Windows 98 or Me, you can boot into safe mode and run regedit to delete the hardware information in the enum key.

AS to whether or not you need the N-force chip-set depends on how you use your PC.
If you run a lot of games or other strenuous applications, you may want the extra power of the N-Force.

If all you do is web surf and word processing, any quality motherboard will do the job.

Chas

by etherealraven

I'm running WinXP Pro. If I put in a board with the Via chipset, will i NOT have to reinstall Windows OR reformat my hard drive?

And if I put in a board that has a different chipset (non-Via) will I have to reinstall Windows? Or reformat.

by thechas

Running XP Pro, there is a VERY good chance that unless you install the exact same make and model motherboard that you WILL need to re-install Windows.

There are tools that can help you move a hard drive with Windows XP installed on it to different hardware. However, ALL of these tools require that you prepare for the move before shutting down the PC for the last time. Since your motherboard died, you do not have this option.

Bottom line, IMHO, whatever newer motherboard you install, you have a 70 percent chance that you will have to re-install Windows. If you choose a motherboard that uses a different VIA chip-set, your odds improve to 60 percent.
If you choose a different motherboard that uses the same VIA chip-set as is on your existing board, your odds improve to 30 percent.

1 idea based on how Microsoft used to recommend changing motherboards would be to start over fresh with a new hard drive.
Then, "restore" from the old hard drive.
The old hard drive could then be used as an extra hard drive.

Chas

by thechas

Got your message.

No, if your system does not boot up with the new motherboard, you don't have to format the hard drive.

If you have problems, all you need to do is set the boot sequence to boot from your CD drive and run setup from the XP CD.

Just make sure that you install Windows to the SAME folder that it was originally installed to.
(C:\Windows)

When you re-install XP, XP wipes out your old installation. So, the registry and ALL Windows Updates are removed.

You will need to re-install your applications.

I would pick the motherboard that you like best. Cross your fingers and hope for the best when you boot up the first time.
Who knows, you might be one of the lucky ones who has no problems with a system upgrade.

Best of luck,
Chas

by csmith

If you do not want to reload Windows, consider this.
The motherboard is not bad.
When the CPU burns out because of CPU fan failure, the motherboard does not normally fail.
The motherboard normally fails when there is a lightning strike or power surge, or the voltage regulator in the power supply fails.
If the board is bad, more troubleshooting is required to find the cause, or the new motherboard you install will also go out.
Regards, Chris

by etherealraven

The motherboard IS bad. A transistor blew, and it's burnt in one spot. There's a brown discoloration right next to the _blown_ transistor.

by wlbowers

The Asus is a great choice. I ran one ror a year till I upgraded my system to a 64bit. Still I went with an Asus K8V Deluxe.

Reloading depends on whether the chipsets are close enough. By staying with via you have a fair chance.

If you are running 2000 or XP you will know as soon as you try to boot. If it's not compatable you will get a boot error.

You can do an inplace upgrade on 2000 and XP by booting from the cd.

Depending on how old your system is you might want to upgrade the power supply.

Lots of good information at this site.

http://www.anandtech.com

Good Luck Lee

by csmith

The motherboard normally fails when there is a lightning strike or power surge, or the voltage regulator in the power supply fails.
How old is your surge supressor?
Remember, this PC is never really "OFF".
If the board is bad, more troubleshooting is required to find the cause, or the new motherboard you install will also go out.
Obviously, the cheapest solution is to buy the same board, used. Ebay?
Regards, Chris

This discussion is closed to new replies.