Discussion Locked

Need to swap hard drive in Raid 5 array

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
We have an HP Netserver LC200 running Microsoft SQL Server 7.0 on it. It has 5 9GB Hard drives. 2 drives are Raid 1 mirrored and 3 drives are at Raid Level 5 in an array. One of the 3 drives in the array needs to be replaced. Normally this wouldbe easy to swap with another 9 GB, but we need to swap with an 18GB drive. I need to do this without losing any data. Rebuild the drive and restore all data. I need a solid plan of action. Anybody with an expert opinion???

5 replies

by gmscne

You will lose the extra space over the 9GB.
Has the raid software determined that the drive is bad? If so then the array has probably rebuilt the data from the parity info on the other two drives. You should remove the failed drive from the array in the software first, then remove it physically and replace it with whatever. Then you will need to add the replacement to the array in software and allow some time for it to rebuild.

by bdrysdale

The drive is not bad. We are running out of space on it. That's why we are replacing it with an 18gB drive. Which is why it will not work to simply remove it from the array and rebuild it because the system will then rebuild an 18 gig drive as a 9 gig and we will not get the extra space we need.

by grbeckmeyer

This will not work. All drives in a raid5 array must be the same size. Older controllers required identical drives. Most new controllers don't need identical drives, but the smallest drive will determine the size of the array. So if you try to use 2 9GB drives and one 18GB, you will be wasting 9GB of space on the bigger drive.

by bdrysdale

My fault for not clarifying. We will be switching all three 9GB to 18GB drives. And will need to restore all data to these drives.

This discussion is closed to new replies.